Originally posted by EmeraldGladiators:
This is what I never understood about the mandates. Why must 'new' Legionnaires be forced on the buying public? If established characters are loved why replace them with newbies?
As with so many things, I see two sides;
On the one hand, a writer signs up for a job to write a book called the 'Legion of Super-Heroes,' he darn skippy should be planning on writing about the characters that fans of the Legion of Super-Heroes have known and loved for decades, and not just making up a bunch of new characters and sidelining the old ones (see, Liefield, Rob, taking over a book called 'New Mutants' and replacing four of the five characters with his own lame creations in the first month...).
On the other hand, every writer has favorite characters and concepts to explore, and characters and concepts that just don't 'speak' to them. Given a choice between reading a re-characterized version of a beloved character, that has gone through all sorts of changes to be more relatable for the writer who didn't get any inspiration from their original characterization and having that writer admit that 'Character X does nothing for me' and just writing them off-stage for a few years, and focusing on the characters that *do* speak to them, I think I'd rather have a writer focus on a pre-existing Legionnaire that they *do* 'grok,' than have a writer who never liked a character totally change them to suit their own personal aesthetic. (Jim Lee's redesign of armored British fashion model into an Asian ninja / acrobat springs to mind. How freaking hard would it have been for Wolverine to run into an *actual* Asian ninja with a psychic knife, who had nothing to do with Betsy Braddock?)
I can see where adding new characters can be a breath of fresh air, and I can also see where, at times, fans-become-writers, and drag everything back to the way they remembered stuff from their childhood, even if it means resurrecting Barry Allen or whatever.
Given a choice between someone coming along and replacing half the Legion with new characters, or someone dragging the Legion backwards and trying to recapture some previous era, I'm in the 'six of one, half-dozen of the other camp.'
One part of me loves new characters and concepts, fast and furious. Another part of me loves the continuity-porn of backwards-looking writers like Kurt Busiek.
In a team this big, new characters, IMO, should be added in small doses. There's already a *ton* of characterization that needs to happen, in a deconstructionist era where it takes 10 pages to tell two panels worth of story. The addition of a half-dozen new Legionnaires in a single year is just crazy, IMO, and slows down the pace of the actual story-telling, as so much more space (ideally) needs to be devoted to character beats.