I know I'm a little early...but isn't the Flash always early? At the very least, he is never late. Joking aside, I am posting this early because I need serious help collecting more characters for this game. I was surprised by the small number of repeating characters I found on the Internet and my memory. I glanced at a small encyclopedia at the library (not the huge one, like a smaller one) and that was not helpful. I am sending out a general plea for any and all knowledge of Flash villains.

If I can't get at least 100 names, I might consolidate Flash's Idol with other traditionally "B-List" heroes (such as Green Arrow and Green Lantern). If it comes to that, I will rename the thread appropriately. We will probably experience a similar problem if/when we get to Superman/Wonder Woman (with the LSV Idol coming after this one, don''t worry).

Dr. Alchemy
Abra Kadabra
Heatwave
Captain Cold
Captain Cold (New 52)
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)
Golden Glider
Professor Zoom
Captain Boomerang
Captain Boomerang II
Weather Wizard
Magenta
Trickster I
Trickster II
Mirror Master
Mirror Master II
Rainbow Raider
Cobalt Blue
The Shade
The Turtle (Golden Age)
The Gambler
Gorilla Grodd
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Thinker (Modern Age)
Blacksmith
Chillbaine
Borther Grimm
Atom Smasher (Golden Age)
The Alchemist
Colonel Computron
The Eel (Golden Age)
Mr.Element I
Mr.Element II
Eradicator
Double Down
The Combine
Girder
The Rival
Inerita
Last Resort
Pied Piper
Peel-a-Boo
Murmur
The Molder( Elongated Man villain) <-- I'll drop him from the list if/when we get 100 pure Flash villains
Rag Doll
The Top
Urtumi
The Viper
White Lightning
Tar Pit
Ring master
Speed Demon
Plunder
Kilg%re
Clive Yorkin
Goldface
Mazdan
The Thorn
Star Sapphire
Gregor Gregorovich
Christina Alexandrova
Boleslav Uminski
Alexander Petrov
Savitar
Black Flash
Razer
Fallout
Cicada
Rudolph West
Griffin
Mob Rule
Baroness Blitzkrieg
Zyklon
Folded Man
Weather Wizard (New 52)
Heat Wave (New 52)
Glider (New 52)
Chunk
Spin
Edward
The Anti Monitor
Changeling
Brain
Steve Palmer
Vandal Savage
Katmos
Replicant
President Thaddeus Thawne
The Suit
Mr. Frost
Wildside (Team Turmoil)
Rumble (Team Turmoil)
Caliber (Team Turmoil)
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Big Sir
Saber-Tooth
Psykon
Commander Cold
Mirror Monarch
Heatstroke
Top (Renegade Version)
Trixster
Weather Warlock

How about the Rogues? Captain Cold, Captain Boomerang, Golden Glider, Weather Wizard, Heat Wave...

And the Red Trinity of speeddters. Or was it Blue ztrinity

Abra Kadabra

Prof Zoom

Inertia

Thank you IB, I copy-pasted from the wrong line! I still only have 51 total though.

How many appearances did Abra Kadabra have? I also remember leaving off one or two people who were basically the same villain with a new codename.

This source says he appeared in 97 stories. I am not a Flash reader but I do know he was one of the more prominent Flash villains as well.

The Blue Trinity can also be added. There were 3 of them, and they appeared in at least 10 issues.

There's Mazdan, who only had a couple of appearances, but is kind of significant because he appeared in Showcase #4.

Also, The Thorn, perhaps more famous these days as the mother of Jade and Obsidian, but she started out as a Flash villain.

I only know a handful ...

Alexander Petrov - who worked in the police lab and used Dr. Alchemy's equipment to kill people, including Ashley Zolomon (during Geoff Johns' run)

Savitar - Mark Waid's run - a speedster cult leader

Black Flash - who was supposed to be a big heavy and is now in the TV show

Star Sapphire - NOT the GL one - she was an otherdimensional queen who fought Jay Garrick twice to take over the world

Razer - who wore a frictionless suit to commit crimes - he ended up working for a computer company during Wally's era

Fallout - the villain used as a battery for Iron Heights

Griffin - a friend of Barry's who got superpowers but aged quickly. Ended up battling it out with Impulse

Mob Rule - from the new 52

There's also the speedster villains that Jay fought with the JSA and All-Star Squadron - Baroness Blitzkrieg and Zyklon

I'll have a peek at the weekend Emily.

Chunk started off as a villain. If you have Pied Piper, you should have him.

It's Peek-a-Boo BTW, although Peel-a-Boo sounds like a great Cobalt Kid villain!

More here: http://www.hyperborea.org/flash/villains.html

Kilg%re, Clive Yorkin & Goldface should certainly be there.

Wow, what a nice turn out so far! I'm going to be adding names to the list in small chunks, so if you don't see your suggestions right away, please be patient.

Myg: Please provide number of appearances if possible for the ones you listed (with the exception of Star Sapphire).

Invisible Brainiac: Should the Blue Trinity be listed as a group or individual members?

I recommend listing the Trinity as individuals.i know the female at least has appeared alone.

I'd include Turtle-Man in addition to Turtle. Their Golden and Silver Age appearances didn't differentiate them too much, but the Modern era did quite a bit to rectify that fact.

They have been added to the list. I had to double-check the female's patronym because it bothered me; it's more common to see Alexandovna. Gregorovich and Alexandrova aren't exactly last name; they usually denote who your father is. Tsarivich was the son of the Tsar.

I guess the creator either didn't research well enough, or decided to ignore the real world practice.

I'm reminded of Ice from JLA, whose given name is Tora Olafsdottir (daughter of Olaf). That type of patronymic naming system is used in Iceland, but Ice was said to be from Norway.

Sure, Emily. I can try ...

Alexander Petrov - 5 issues

Savitar - 14 issues

Black Flash - 6 issues

Razer - 4 issues

Fallout - 15 issues

Griffin - 6 issues

Mob Rule - 9 issues

Baroness Blitzkrieg - 6 issues

Zyklon - 1 (maybe 2?) issues

What about the Spirit King, who used Jay to murder Mr. Terrific?

Jay also fought Sieur Satan once or twice in the Golden Age and again in the All-Star Squadron

Also, Vandal Savage was considered a mostly-Flash villain for much of Wally's run (and clearly fought Jay several times)

Cicada was pretty significant in the early parts of Johns' run.

Rudolph West was a Manhunter agent back in Millenium.

EDIT: You can probably make the case that the "new 52" version of Captain Cold is significantly different from Pre-Flashpoint (including having meta-human powers).

Myg: I'll add them all to the list. If anyone objects to Zyklon's inclusion, let me know...by the way what year was that character created? It's one of those names that feels really on the nose knowing what zyklon is.

General Question: If/When we do a JLA/JSA Villains Idol, should be include or exclude those that appeared in other Idols?

I don't want to include Vandal Savage until this issue is addressed and discussed.

Dave: I'll add the New 52 Version of Captain Cold and the other two you listed.

Zyklon debuted in All-Star Squadron in 1985.

I think Savage has appeared in equal prominence as a Flash and JSA villain (He's appeared lots of other places as well, but I'd say Flash and JSA are the most frequent). I have no problem with him on both lists.

Yeah I agree. I think there's bound to be people who pop up on multiple lists due to their publication histories.

The Shade, Fiddler and Thinker could just as easily be considered JSA foes. The Shade can also be a hero under a certain star.

Other villains:
Folded Man
Weather Wizard (New 52)
Heat Wave (New 52)
Glider (New 52)

The list is being updated with Dave's new suggestions. If anyone has a negative opinion in regards to having characters on multiple lists, please speak now.

Nopes, it's the best way.

Alright, I will add Vandal Savage to the list. I'll get the current villain count by Sunday night, if we have around 100, the game will start on Monday.

Three More:

Chunk
Spin
Edwar

I have updated the list and we only have 80 characters. Should we look into combining with other "B-Listers" or proceed with what we have? I will go with whatever the majority wants.

I'm always of the opinion that more is better when building an Idol list. Majority of the entries will be eliminated in the first few rounds anyway, and it can be very hard to add new characters to the list in the middle of a game.


That said, if we can't think of any more to add, might as well continue.

Anti Monitor
Changeling, The
Brain
Steve Palmer

Katmos, apparently a one-shot villain, but one of Barry Allen's first.

Since it seems we would rather try to add more villains as opposed to combining this game with other franchises, I am going to keep the start up going another week. If by some miracle we reach 100 characters soon, I will begin immediately. Otherwise, we'll start with whatever we have in a week from this posting.

More villains:

Replicant
President Thaddeus Thawne
The Suit
Mr. Frost
Wildside (Team Turmoil)
Rumble (Team Turmoil)
Caliber (Team Turmoil)
Miasma (Team Turmoil)

Big Sir
Saber-Tooth
Psykon


The Renegades:

Commander Cold
Mirror Monarch
Heatstroke
Top (Renegade Version)
Trixster
Weather Warlock

Great Job everyone! In the interest of time, if there are multiple versions of the character, vote for the version listed. If there are other versions not currently listed, they will be added to the next round if relevant.

These rules have been adapted from the Rules for Justice League Idol per the permission of Invisible Brainiac.

Official Flash Rogues Idol Rules

The concept of an Idol game is that players get to vote for their favorite characters, instead of voting for the characters they most want off the list. This is based on overall popularity, and has nothing to do with stats.

Players have to rank their faves. The higher the rank, the more points a character gets. So your rank 1 might get 10 points, but rank 2 only gets 8, and so on.

Flash Museum Rules

1) Each round will last about 48 hours. I will try to end each round at the same time, but this won't always be possible because of other circumstances. I will push dates when there is a major holiday coming up.
2) I'll vote at the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) I don't actively encourage editing of votes; it's a smart tactic but may be unfair for those who don't get to log on as often. However, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, that poster will be notified by PM immediately. If the poster cannot correct his/her votes before the end of the round, he/she will get a makeup point next round - a +15 bonus. This only applies to instances where I made the error, and not where the poster made an error.
5) Points will be given based on your ranking. The higher you rank a character on your list, the more points that character will get (e.g. Rank 1 gets 10 points, Rank 2 gets 9 points...) Point distributions will change per round.
6) Exception to the above will be the first 1-2 rounds of the game, which trim the list down considerably. Each vote will count as one point, and characters below a certain point threshold get eliminated.

7) Because several characters have multiple versions,please specify which character you are voting for.

Abra Kadabra
Alexander Petrov
Atom Smasher (Golden Age)
Baroness Blitzkrieg
Big Sir
Black Flash
Blacksmith
Boleslav Uminski
Borther Grimm
Brain
Caliber (Team Turmoil)
Captain Boomerang
Captain Boomerang II
Captain Cold
Captain Cold (New 52)
Changeling
Chillbaine
Christina Alexandrova
Chunk
Cicada
Clive Yorkin
Cobalt Blue
Colonel Computron
Commander Cold
Double Down
Dr. Alchemy
Edward
Eradicator
Fallout
Folded Man
Girder
Glider (New 52)
Golden Glider
Goldface
Gorilla Grodd
Gregor Gregorovich
Griffin
Heat Wave (New 52)
Heatstroke
Heatwave
Inerita
Katmos
Kilg%re
Last Resort
Magenta
Mazdan
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Mirror Master
Mirror Master II
Mirror Monarch
Mob Rule
Mr. Frost
Mr.Element I
Mr.Element II
Murmur
Peel-a-Boo
Pied Piper
Plunder
President Thaddeus Thawne
Professor Zoom
Psykon
Rag Doll
Rainbow Raider
Razer
Replicant
Ring master
Rudolph West
Rumble (Team Turmoil)
Saber-Tooth
Savitar
Speed Demon
Spin
Star Sapphire
Steve Palmer
Tar Pit
The Alchemist
The Anti Monitor
The Combine
The Eel (Golden Age)
The Gambler
The Rival
The Shade
The Suit
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Thinker (Modern Age)
The Thorn
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
The Viper
Top (Renegade Version)
Trickster I
Trickster II
Trixster
Urtumi
Vandal Savage
Weather Warlock
Weather Wizard
Weather Wizard (New 52)
White Lightning
Wildside (Team Turmoil)
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)
Zyklon

Abra Kadabra 1
Alexander Petrov 1
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 1
Baroness Blitzkrieg 0
Big Sir 0
Black Flash 0
Blacksmith 1
Boleslav Uminski 1
Brother Grimm 0
Brain 0
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 0
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 1
Captain Cold (New 52) 1
Changeling 0
Chillbaine 0
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 0
Cicada 1
Clive Yorkin 0
Cobalt Blue 1
Colonel Computron 0
Commander Cold 1
Double Down 0
Dr. Alchemy 1
Edward 0
Eradicator 1
Fallout 0
Folded Man 0
Girder 0
Glider (New 52) 1
Golden Glider 1
Goldface 0
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gregor Gregorovich 1
Griffin 0
Heat Wave (New 52) 1
Heatstroke 1
Heatwave 1
Inerita 1
Katmos 0
Kilg%re 1
Last Resort 0
Magenta 1
Mazdan 0
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 0
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 1
Mirror Monarch 1
Mob Rule 0
Mr. Frost 0
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 1
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 1
Plunder 1
President Thaddeus Thawne 0
Professor Zoom 1
Psykon 0
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 1
Razer 0
Replicant 0
Ring master 0
Rudolph West 0
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 0
Saber-Tooth 0
Savitar 1
Speed Demon 0
Spin 0
Star Sapphire 0
Steve Palmer 0
Tar Pit 0
The Alchemist 1
The Anti Monitor 1
The Combine 0
The Eel (Golden Age) 0
The Gambler 1
The Rival 0
The Shade 1
The Suit 0
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Thinker (Modern Age) 0
The Thorn 0
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
The Viper 0
Top (Renegade Version) 0
Trickster I 1
Trickster II 1
Trixster 0
Urtumi 0
Vandal Savage 1
Weather Warlock 0
Weather Wizard 1
Weather Wizard (New 52) 1
White Lightning 0
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 0
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 1
Zyklon 0

Abra Kadabra...1
Alexander Petrov...0
Atom Smasher (Golden Age)...0
Baroness Blitzkrieg...1
Big Sir...1
Black Flash...0
Blacksmith...0
Boleslav Uminski...1
Borther Grimm...0
Brain...0
Caliber (Team Turmoil)...0
Captain Boomerang...0
Captain Boomerang II...0
Captain Cold...0
Captain Cold (New 52)...0
Changeling...1
Chillbaine...0
Christina Alexandrova...1
Chunk...1
Cicada...0
Clive Yorkin...1
Cobalt Blue...0
Colonel Computron...1
Commander Cold...0
Double Down...0
Dr. Alchemy...1
Edward...0
Eradicator...1
Fallout...0
Folded Man...0
Girder...0
Glider (New 52)...0
Golden Glider...1
Goldface...0
Gorilla Grodd...0
Gregor Gregorovich...1
Griffin...0
Heat Wave (New 52)...0
Heatstroke...0
Heatwave...0
Inertia...0
Katmos...1
Kilg%re...1
Last Resort...0
Magenta...1
Mazdan...1
Miasma (Team Turmoil)...0
Mirror Master...1
Mirror Master II...0
Mirror Monarch...0
Mob Rule...0
Mr. Frost...0
Mr.Element I...1
Mr.Element II...0
Murmur...0
Peek-a-Boo...0
Pied Piper...1
Plunder...0
President Thaddeus Thawne...0
Professor Zoom...1
Psykon...1
Rag Doll...0
Rainbow Raider...1
Razer...0
Replicant...0
Ring Master...1
Rudolph West...1
Rumble (Team Turmoil)...0
Saber-Tooth...1
Savitar...0
Speed Demon...0
Spin...0
Star Sapphire...0
Steve Palmer...1
Tar Pit...0
The Alchemist...0
The Anti Monitor...1
The Combine...0
The Eel (Golden Age)...1
The Gambler...1
The Rival...1
The Shade...0
The Suit...0
The Thinker (Golden Age)...1
The Thinker (Modern Age)...1
The Thorn...1
The Top...1
The Turtle (Golden Age)...1
The Viper...1
Top (Renegade Version)...0
Trickster I...1
Trickster II...0
Trixster...0
Urtumi...1
Vandal Savage...0
Weather Warlock...0
Weather Wizard...1
Weather Wizard (New 52)...0
White Lightning...0
Wildside (Team Turmoil)...0
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)...0
Zyklon...1

Abra Kadabra 1
Alexander Petrov 0
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 0
Baroness Blitzkrieg 0
Big Sir 1
Black Flash 1
Blacksmith 1
Boleslav Uminski 0
Borther Grimm 1
Brain 1
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 1
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 1
Captain Cold (New 52) 0
Changeling 0
Chillbaine 1
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 1
Cicada 1
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 1
Colonel Computron 1
Commander Cold 0
Double Down 1
Dr. Alchemy 1
Edward 0
Eradicator 1
Fallout 1
Folded Man 1
Girder 1
Glider (New 52) 0
Golden Glider 1
Goldface 1
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gregor Gregorovich 0
Griffin 0
Heat Wave (New 52) 0
Heatstroke 0
Heatwave 1
Inerita 1
Katmos 0
Kilg%re 1
Last Resort 0
Magenta 1
Mazdan 0
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 1
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 1
Mirror Monarch 0
Mob Rule 0
Mr. Frost 0
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 1
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 1
Plunder 1
President Thaddeus Thawne 0
Professor Zoom 1
Psykon 0
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 1
Razer 0
Replicant 1
Ring master 0
Rudolph West 1
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 1
Saber-Tooth 1
Savitar 1
Speed Demon 1
Spin 0
Star Sapphire 0
Steve Palmer 0
Tar Pit 1
The Alchemist 1
The Anti Monitor 0
The Combine 0
The Eel (Golden Age) 0
The Gambler 1
The Rival 1
The Shade 1
The Suit 0
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Thinker (Modern Age) 1
The Thorn 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
The Viper 0
Top (Renegade Version) 0
Trickster I 1
Trickster II 1
Trixster 0
Urtumi 0
Vandal Savage 1
Weather Warlock 0
Weather Wizard 1
Weather Wizard (New 52) 0
White Lightning 0
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 1
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 1
Zyklon 0

Abra Kadabra 1
Alexander Petrov 0
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 0
Baroness Blitzkrieg 1
Big Sir 0
Black Flash 0
Blacksmith 1
Boleslav Uminski 0
Borther Grimm 0
Brain 1
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 0
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 1
Captain Cold (New 52) 0
Changeling 0
Chillbaine 0
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 1
Cicada 1
Clive Yorkin 0
Cobalt Blue 0
Colonel Computron 1
Commander Cold 0
Double Down 1
Dr. Alchemy 1
Edward 0
Eradicator 0
Fallout 0
Folded Man 1
Girder 1
Glider (New 52) 0
Golden Glider 1
Goldface 0
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gregor Gregorovich 0
Griffin 0
Heat Wave (New 52) 0
Heatstroke 1
Heatwave 1
Inertia 0
Katmos 0
Kilg%re 1
Last Resort 0
Magenta 1
Mazdan 0
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 0
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 1
Mirror Monarch 0
Mob Rule 1
Mr. Frost 0
Mr.Element I 0
Mr.Element II 1
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 1
Plunder 1
President Thaddeus Thawne 0
Professor Zoom 1
Psykon 0
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 1
Razer 0
Replicant 0
Ring master 0
Rudolph West 0
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 0
Saber-Tooth 0
Savitar 1
Speed Demon 0
Spin 1
Star Sapphire 0
Steve Palmer 0
Tar Pit 1
The Alchemist 0
The Anti Monitor 1
The Combine 0
The Eel (Golden Age) 0
The Gambler 1
The Rival 1
The Shade 1
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Thinker (Modern Age) 1
The Thorn 0
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
The Viper 0
Top (Renegade Version) 0
Trickster I 1
Trickster II 1
Trixster 0
Urtumi 0
Vandal Savage 1
Weather Warlock 0
Weather Wizard 1
Weather Wizard (New 52) 0
White Lightning 0
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 0
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 1
Zyklon 0

Blank means 0

Abra Kadabra 1
Alexander Petrov
Atom Smasher (Golden Age)
Baroness Blitzkrieg
Big Sir 1
Black Flash
Blacksmith
Boleslav Uminski
Borther Grimm
Brain
Caliber (Team Turmoil)
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 1
Captain Cold (New 52)
Changeling
Chillbaine
Christina Alexandrova
Chunk
Cicada
Clive Yorkin
Cobalt Blue
Colonel Computron
Commander Cold
Double Down 1
Dr. Alchemy 1
Edward
Eradicator
Fallout
Folded Man
Girder
Glider (New 52)
Golden Glider
Goldface
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gregor Gregorovich
Griffin
Heat Wave (New 52)
Heatstroke
Heatwave
Inerita
Katmos
Kilg%re
Last Resort
Magenta 1
Mazdan
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 1
Mirror Monarch
Mob Rule
Mr. Frost
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II
Murmur
Peel-a-Boo
Pied Piper 1
Plunder
President Thaddeus Thawne
Professor Zoom
Psykon
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 1
Razer
Replicant
Ring master
Rudolph West
Rumble (Team Turmoil)
Saber-Tooth
Savitar
Speed Demon
Spin
Star Sapphire 1
Steve Palmer
Tar Pit
The Alchemist 1
The Anti Monitor 1
The Combine
The Eel (Golden Age)
The Gambler
The Rival
The Shade 1
The Suit
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Thinker (Modern Age)
The Thorn
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
The Viper
Top (Renegade Version)
Trickster I 1
Trickster II 1
Trixster
Urtumi
Vandal Savage
Weather Warlock
Weather Wizard 1
Weather Wizard (New 52)
White Lightning
Wildside (Team Turmoil)
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)
Zyklon

Abra Kadabra 1
Alexander Petrov 0
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 0
Baroness Blitzkrieg 0
Big Sir 1
Black Flash 1
Blacksmith 0
Boleslav Uminski 0
Borther Grimm 0
Brain 1
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 0
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 0
Captain Cold 1
Captain Cold (New 52) 0
Changeling 1
Chillbaine 0
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 1
Cicada 0
Clive Yorkin 0
Cobalt Blue 1
Colonel Computron 1
Commander Cold 0
Double Down 0
Dr. Alchemy 1
Edward 0
Eradicator 1
Fallout 0
Folded Man 0
Girder 0
Glider (New 52) 0
Golden Glider 1
Goldface 1
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gregor Gregorovich 0
Griffin 0
Heat Wave (New 52) 0
Heatstroke 0
Heatwave 1
Inerita 0
Katmos 0
Kilg%re 1
Last Resort 0
Magenta 1
Mazdan 0
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 0
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 1
Mirror Monarch 0
Mob Rule 0
Mr. Frost 0
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 1
Murmur 0
Peel-a-Boo 0
Pied Piper 1
Plunder 0
President Thaddeus Thawne 0
Professor Zoom 1
Psykon 0
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 1
Razer 0
Replicant 0
Ring master 0
Rudolph West 0
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 0
Saber-Tooth 0
Savitar 1
Speed Demon 1
Spin 0
Star Sapphire 1
Steve Palmer 1
Tar Pit 0
The Alchemist 1
The Anti Monitor 1
The Combine 0
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 1
The Rival 1
The Shade 1
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Thinker (Modern Age) 1
The Thorn 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
The Viper 0
Top (Renegade Version) 0
Trickster I 1
Trickster II 0
Trixster 0
Urtumi 0
Vandal Savage 1
Weather Warlock 0
Weather Wizard 1
Weather Wizard (New 52) 0
White Lightning 0
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 0
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 0
Zyklon 0

Votes will be tallied tomorrow on account of the Superbowl, giving 24 hours for any last minute votes.

These are the characters eliminated from the tournament:

Edward 0
Griffin 0
Last Resort 0
Mr. Frost 0
President Thaddeus Thawne 0
Razer 0
The Combine 0
Top (Renegade Version) 0
Trixster 0
Weather Warlock 0
White Lightning 0

I'll begin the next round tomorrow, in case there are any last minute entries. I want to avoid adding characters mid-game like I did last time.

No one I'll miss, or that I've read for that matter.

I have heard of one or two, but I know nothing about them besides their code names.

I voted for a few of those characters. Did my entry get missed?

I probably typed or skipped one number and it effected the whole chain of your entries. It would be easier for me if you just copy-paste the ones that should have one points, and I will edit the above post. I'm busy with roleplays on other sites right now.

Eliminated characters I had votes for:

Borther Grimm 1
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 1
Chillbaine 1
Fallout 1
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 1
Replicant 1
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 1
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 1

Round Two aka I will try to be more awake when I calculate these ones. We will move on to a scale for the round after this. I will probably make a list of all the scales we did for the preliminary rounds in the Bat-Villain Idol and have the players (that means you) vote in a Straw Poll for which one we should use for this game.

This is what straw poll is if anyone is wondering: http://www.strawpoll.me/

Abra Kadabra
Alexander Petrov
Atom Smasher (Golden Age)
Baroness Blitzkrieg
Big Sir
Black Flash
Blacksmith
Boleslav Uminski
Brain
Brother Grimm
Caliber (Team Turmoil)
Captain Boomerang
Captain Boomerang II
Captain Cold
Captain Cold (New 52)
Changeling
Chillbaine
Christina Alexandrova
Chunk
Cicada
Clive Yorkin
Cobalt Blue
Colonel Computron
Commander Cold
Double Down
Dr. Alchemy
Eradicator
Fallout
Folded Man
Girder
Glider (New 52)
Golden Glider
Goldface
Gorilla Grodd
Gregor Gregorovich
Heat Wave (New 52)
Heatstroke
Heatwave
Inerita
Katmos
Kilg%re
Magenta
Mazdan
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Mirror Master
Mirror Master II
Mirror Monarch
Mob Rule
Mr.Element I
Mr.Element II
Murmur
Peek-a-Boo
Pied Piper
Plunder
Professor Zoom
Psykon
Rag Doll
Rainbow Raider
Replicant
Ring master
Rudolph West
Rumble (Team Turmoil)
Saber-Tooth
Savitar
Speed Demon
Spin
Star Sapphire
Steve Palmer
Tar Pit
The Alchemist
The Anti Monitor
The Eel (Golden Age)
The Gambler
The Rival
The Shade
The Suit
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Thinker (Modern Age)
The Thorn
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
The Viper
Trickster I
Trickster II
Urtumi
Vandal Savage
Weather Wizard
Weather Wizard (New 52)
Wildside (Team Turmoil)
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)
Zyklon

Abra Kadabra 1
Alexander Petrov 1
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 0
Baroness Blitzkrieg 0
Big Sir 1
Black Flash 1
Blacksmith 0
Boleslav Uminski 0
Brain 1
Brother Grimm 0
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 0
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 0
Captain Cold 1
Captain Cold (New 52) 0
Changeling 1
Chillbaine 0
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 1
Cicada 0
Clive Yorkin 0
Cobalt Blue 1
Colonel Computron 1
Commander Cold 0
Double Down 0
Dr. Alchemy 1
Eradicator 1
Fallout 0
Folded Man 0
Girder 0
Glider (New 52) 0
Golden Glider 1
Goldface 1
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gregor Gregorovich 1
Heat Wave (New 52) 0
Heatstroke 0
Heatwave 1
Inerita 0
Katmos 0
Kilg%re 1
Magenta 1
Mazdan 0
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 0
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 1
Mirror Monarch 0
Mob Rule 0
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 1
Murmur 0
Peek-a-Boo 0
Pied Piper 1
Plunder 0
Professor Zoom 1
Psykon 0
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 1
Replicant 0
Ring master 0
Rudolph West 0
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 0
Saber-Tooth 0
Savitar 1
Speed Demon 1
Spin 0
Star Sapphire 1
Steve Palmer 1
Tar Pit 0
The Alchemist 0
The Anti Monitor 1
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 1
The Rival 1
The Shade 1
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Thinker (Modern Age) 1
The Thorn 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
The Viper 0
Trickster I 1
Trickster II 0
Urtumi 0
Vandal Savage 1
Weather Wizard 1
Weather Wizard (New 52) 0
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 0
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 0
Zyklon 0

Abra Kadabra 1
Alexander Petrov 1
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 1
Baroness Blitzkrieg 0
Big Sir 0
Black Flash 0
Blacksmith 1
Boleslav Uminski 1
Brain 0
Brother Grimm 0
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 0
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 1
Captain Cold (New 52) 1
Changeling 0
Chillbaine 0
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 0
Cicada 1
Clive Yorkin 0
Cobalt Blue 1
Colonel Computron 0
Commander Cold 1
Double Down 0
Dr. Alchemy 1
Eradicator 1
Fallout 0
Folded Man 0
Girder 1
Glider (New 52) 1
Golden Glider 1
Goldface 0
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gregor Gregorovich 1
Heat Wave (New 52) 1
Heatstroke 1
Heatwave 1
Inerita 1
Katmos 0
Kilg%re 0
Magenta 1
Mazdan 0
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 0
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 1
Mirror Monarch 1
Mob Rule 0
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 1
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 1
Plunder 1
Professor Zoom 1
Psykon0
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 0
Replicant 0
Ring master 0
Rudolph West 0
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 0
Saber-Tooth 0
Savitar 1
Speed Demon 0 <-- (There is a B or C-List Spider-Man villain with the same name, I wonder if DC knows that)
Spin- 0
Star Sapphire 1
Steve Palmer 0
Tar Pit 1
The Alchemist 1
The Anti Monitor 0
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 1
The Rival 0
The Shade 1
The Suit 0
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Thinker (Modern Age) 0
The Thorn 0
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
The Viper 0
Trickster I 1
Trickster II 1
Urtumi 0
Vandal Savage 1
Weather Wizard 1
Weather Wizard (New 52) 1
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 0
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 1
Zyklon 0

Thanks Emily. I have no preference for any one scale. One thing I did learn (as discussed with Reboot), is that ideally the gap between points increases as you go up the scale. Example,

1st - 100 (+30)
2nd - 70 (+20)
3rd - 50 (+10)
4th - 40 (+5)
5th - 35

Blank means "zero"

Abra Kadabra 1
Alexander Petrov
Atom Smasher (Golden Age)
Baroness Blitzkrieg 1
Big Sir 1
Black Flash
Blacksmith
Boleslav Uminski
Brain
Brother Grimm
Caliber (Team Turmoil)
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 1
Captain Cold (New 52) 1
Changeling
Chillbaine
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 1
Cicada
Clive Yorkin
Cobalt Blue
Colonel Computron
Commander Cold
Double Down 1
Dr. Alchemy 1
Eradicator 1
Fallout
Folded Man
Girder
Glider (New 52)
Golden Glider 1
Goldface 1
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gregor Gregorovich
Heat Wave (New 52)
Heatstroke 1
Heatwave
Inerita 1
Katmos
Kilg%re 1
Magenta 1
Mazdan
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 1
Mirror Monarch
Mob Rule
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 1
Murmur
Peek-a-Boo
Pied Piper 1
Plunder
Professor Zoom 1
Psykon
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 1
Replicant
Ring master
Rudolph West
Rumble (Team Turmoil)
Saber-Tooth
Savitar
Speed Demon
Spin
Star Sapphire 1
Steve Palmer
Tar Pit 1
The Alchemist
The Anti Monitor 1
The Eel (Golden Age)
The Gambler
The Rival
The Shade 1
The Suit
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Thinker (Modern Age)
The Thorn
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
The Viper
Trickster I 1
Trickster II 1
Urtumi
Vandal Savage
Weather Wizard 1
Weather Wizard (New 52)
Wildside (Team Turmoil)
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)
Zyklon

Abra Kadabra 1
Alexander Petrov 0
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 1
Baroness Blitzkrieg 1
Big Sir 1
Black Flash 0
Blacksmith 1
Boleslav Uminski 0
Brain 1
Brother Grimm 0
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 0
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 1
Captain Cold (New 52) 0
Changeling 0
Chillbaine 0
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 1
Cicada 0
Clive Yorkin 0
Cobalt Blue 0
Colonel Computron 1
Commander Cold 0
Double Down 1
Dr. Alchemy 1
Eradicator 0
Fallout 0
Folded Man 1
Girder 1
Glider (New 52) 0
Golden Glider 1
Goldface 0
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gregor Gregorovich 0
Heat Wave (New 52) 0
Heatstroke 0
Heatwave 1
Inertia 0
Katmos 0
Kilg%re 0
Magenta 1
Mazdan 0
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 0
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 1
Mirror Monarch 0
Mob Rule 1
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 0
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 0
Pied Piper 1
Plunder 0
Professor Zoom 0
Psykon 0
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 1
Replicant 0
Ring master 0
Rudolph West 0
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 0
Saber-Tooth 0
Savitar 1
Speed Demon 0
Spin 0
Star Sapphire 0
Steve Palmer 0
Tar Pit 1
The Alchemist 0
The Anti Monitor 1
The Eel (Golden Age) 0
The Gambler 1
The Rival 1
The Shade 1
The Suit 0
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Thinker (Modern Age) 1
The Thorn 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
The Viper 0
Trickster I 1
Trickster II 0
Urtumi 0
Vandal Savage 1
Weather Wizard 1
Weather Wizard (New 52) 0
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 0
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 0
Zyklon 0

Abra Kadabra...1
Alexander Petrov...0
Atom Smasher (Golden Age)...0
Baroness Blitzkrieg...1
Big Sir...1
Black Flash...0
Blacksmith...0
Boleslav Uminski...1
Borther Grimm...0
Brain...0
Caliber (Team Turmoil)...0
Captain Boomerang...0
Captain Boomerang II...0
Captain Cold...0
Captain Cold (New 52)...0
Changeling...0
Chillbaine...0
Christina Alexandrova...1
Chunk...1
Cicada...0
Clive Yorkin...1
Cobalt Blue...0
Colonel Computron...1
Commander Cold...0
Double Down...0
Dr. Alchemy...1
Eradicator...1
Fallout...0
Folded Man...0
Girder...0
Glider (New 52)...0
Golden Glider...1
Goldface...0
Gorilla Grodd...0
Gregor Gregorovich...1
Heat Wave (New 52)...0
Heatstroke...0
Heatwave...0
Inertia...0
Katmos...1
Kilg%re...1
Magenta...1
Mazdan...1
Miasma (Team Turmoil)...0
Mirror Master...1
Mirror Master II...0
Mirror Monarch...0
Mob Rule...0
Mr.Element I...1
Mr.Element II...0
Murmur...0
Peek-a-Boo...0
Pied Piper...1
Plunder...0
Professor Zoom...1
Psykon...1
Rag Doll...0
Rainbow Raider...1
Replicant...0
Ring Master...1
Rudolph West...0
Rumble (Team Turmoil)...0
Saber-Tooth...1
Savitar...0
Speed Demon...0
Spin...0
Star Sapphire...0
Steve Palmer...1
Tar Pit...0
The Alchemist...0
The Anti Monitor...1
The Eel (Golden Age)...1
The Gambler...1
The Rival...1
The Shade...0
The Suit...0
The Thinker (Golden Age)...1
The Thinker (Modern Age)...1
The Thorn...1
The Top...1
The Turtle (Golden Age)...1
The Viper...1
Trickster I...1
Trickster II...0
Urtumi...1
Vandal Savage...0
Weather Wizard...1
Weather Wizard (New 52)...0
Wildside (Team Turmoil)...0
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)...0
Zyklon...1

Abra Kadabra 1
Alexander Petrov 0
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 0
Baroness Blitzkrieg 0
Big Sir 1
Black Flash 1
Blacksmith 1
Boleslav Uminski 0
Brain 0
Brother Grimm 1
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 1
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 1
Captain Cold (New 52) 0
Changeling 0
Chillbaine 1
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 1
Cicada 1
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 1
Colonel Computron 1
Commander Cold 0
Double Down 1
Dr. Alchemy 1
Eradicator 0
Fallout 1
Folded Man 0
Girder 1
Glider (New 52) 0
Golden Glider 1
Goldface 1
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gregor Gregorovich 0
Heat Wave (New 52) 0
Heatstroke 0
Heatwave 1
Inerita 0
Katmos 0
Kilg%re 1
Magenta 1
Mazdan 0
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 1
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 1
Mirror Monarch 0
Mob Rule 0
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 0
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 1
Plunder 1
Professor Zoom 1
Psykon 0
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 1
Replicant 1
Ring master 0
Rudolph West 1
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 1
Saber-Tooth 1
Savitar 1
Speed Demon 1
Spin 0
Star Sapphire 0
Steve Palmer 0
Tar Pit 1
The Alchemist 1
The Anti Monitor 0
The Eel (Golden Age) 0
The Gambler 1
The Rival 1
The Shade 1
The Suit 0
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Thinker (Modern Age) 1
The Thorn 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
The Viper 0
Trickster I 1
Trickster II 1
Urtumi 0
Vandal Savage 1
Weather Wizard 1
Weather Wizard (New 52) 0
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 1
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 1
Zyklon 0

So, we have really unexpected results. Only one character, Spin, received 0 votes. The number of characters with 1 vote is 25, and I think that is too many to be eliminated in one round. So I think it would only be right to do a run-off round of 1s and 0s for the bottom 25. Everyone who is not in the list and is not named Spin is safe

Brother Grimm
Caliber (Team Turmoil)
Changeling
Chillbaine
Commander Cold
Fallout
Folded Man
Glider (New 52)
Heat Wave (New 52)
Katmos
Mazdan
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Mirror Monarch
Mob Rule
Psykon
Replicant
Ring master
Rudolph West
Rumble (Team Turmoil)
The Suit
The Viper
Urtumi
Weather Wizard (New 52)
Wildside (Team Turmoil)
Zyklon

Please also vote in the Straw Poll: http://strawpoll.me/6793604

Brother Grimm 1
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 0
Changeling 0
Chillbaine 1
Commander Cold 0
Fallout 1
Folded Man 0
Glider (New 52) 0
Heat Wave (New 52) 0
Katmos 0
Mazdan 0
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 1
Mirror Monarch 0
Mob Rule 0
Psykon 0
Replicant 1
Ring master 0
Rudolph West 1
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 1
The Suit 0
The Viper 0
Urtumi 0
Weather Wizard (New 52) 0
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 1
Zyklon 0

I have no idea what the Straw Poll was asking so just voted '75' because it was in the middle.

1 point for:

Ring Master

0 points for (everyone else):

Brother Grimm
Caliber (Team Turmoil)
Changeling
Chillbaine
Commander Cold
Fallout
Folded Man
Glider (New 52)
Heat Wave (New 52)
Katmos
Mazdan
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Mirror Monarch
Mob Rule
Psykon
Replicant
Rudolph West
Rumble (Team Turmoil)
The Suit
The Viper
Urtumi
Weather Wizard (New 52)
Wildside (Team Turmoil)
Zyklon

1 for:

Brother Grimm
Chillbaine
Mob Rule
Replicant
The Suit


Btw I found out that there are 4 Chillblaines! I don't think we need to differentiate them though, now that we are a couple of rounds into the game.

Brother Grimm 0
Caliber (Team Turmoil) 0
Changeling 0
Chillbaine 0
Commander Cold 0
Fallout 0
Folded Man 1
Glider (New 52) 0
Heat Wave (New 52) 0
Katmos 0
Mazdan 0
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 0
Mirror Monarch 0
Mob Rule 1
Psykon 0
Replicant 0
Ring master 0
Rudolph West 0
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 0
The Suit 0
The Viper 0
Urtumi 0
Weather Wizard (New 52) 0
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 0
Zyklon 0

1s for
Changeling
Fallout
Folded Man
Rudolph West
The Suit

0s for the rest

It was supposed to be by 7's but I apparently forgot about grammar when I made the poll.

Oh, I hadn't even noticed the grammatical error. I thought they were all '5's at the end. haha

I meant, I don't get what the scale refers to. Is it the number of characters we lose each round?

Yes, they use a different font (they try to look like handwriting I suppose). Straw Poll is widely used in chatroom games and Twitch channels, so you would think someone else would have the same problem and they would adjust the fond.

The scale refers to how we vote for the characters.

Example
10 <- Lowest
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100 <- Highest

The scale effects how many characters we lose per round. As Invisible Brainiac was saying, the longer the scale the more space in points there are between characters.

So I somehow forgot to vote , but I don't want anyone to think I'm voting based on others and therefore manipulating the game in some fashion, so I will just skip this round. My thoughts may be as fast as the Flash.

Results of Last Round:

Brother Grimm 2
Chillbaine 2
Fallout 2
Folded Man 2
Mob Rule 2
Rudolph West 2
The Suit 2
Changeling 1
Miasma 1
Psykon 1
Ring master 1
Replicant 1
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 1

All of these are eliminated:

Caliber 0
Commander Cold 0
Glider 0
Heat Wave (New 52) 0
Katmos 0
Mazdan 0
Rumble (Team Turmoil) 0
The Viper 0
Urtumi 0
Weather Wizard (New 52) 0
Zyklon 0

Scale Business

The results of the straw poll indicate a tie between 10's and 7's:
http://strawpoll.me/6793604/r

I flip a coin to break the tie; Heads is 10's and Tails is 7's.

Result is Heads, Scale is by 10's.
Top 80
Abra Kadabra
Alexander Petrov
Atom Smasher (Golden Age)
Baroness Blitzkrieg
Big Sir
Black Flash
Blacksmith
Boleslav Uminski
Brain
Brother Grimm
Captain Boomerang
Captain Boomerang II
Captain Cold
Captain Cold (New 52)
Changeling
Chillbaine
Christina Alexandrova
Chunk
Cicada
Clive Yorkin
Cobalt Blue
Colonel Computron
Double Down
Dr. Alchemy
Eradicator
Fallout
Folded Man
Girder
Golden Glider
Goldface
Gorilla Grodd
Gregor Gregorovich
Heatstroke
Heatwave
Inerita
Kilg%re
Magenta
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Mirror Master
Mirror Master II
Mirror Monarch
Mob Rule
Mr.Element I
Mr.Element II
Murmur
Peek-a-Boo
Pied Piper
Plunder
Professor Zoom
Psykon
Rag Doll
Rainbow Raider
Replicant
Ring master
Rudolph West
Saber-Tooth
Savitar
Speed Demon
Star Sapphire
Steve Palmer
Tar Pit
The Alchemist
The Anti Monitor
The Eel (Golden Age)
The Gambler
The Rival
The Shade
The Suit
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Thinker (Modern Age)
The Thorn
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
Trickster I
Trickster II
Vandal Savage
Weather Wizard
Wildside (Team Turmoil)
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)

Abra Kadabra 10
Alexander Petrov 5
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 1
Baroness Blitzkrieg 1
Big Sir 1
Black Flash 1
Blacksmith 7
Boleslav Uminski 8
Brain 1
Brother Grimm 1
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 10
Captain Cold 10
Captain Cold (New 52) 70
Changeling 10
Chillbaine 10
Christina Alexandrova 10
Chunk 1
Cicada 7
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 10
Colonel Computron 1
Double Down 1
Dr. Alchemy 50
Eradicator 10
Fallout 1
Folded Man 1
Girder 10
Golden Glider 10
Goldface 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Gregor Gregorovich 8
Heatstroke 5
Heatwave 100
Inerita 3
Kilg%re 6
Magenta 10
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 10
Mirror Master 10
Mirror Master II 10
Mirror Monarch 5
Mob Rule 1
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 1
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 10
Pied Piper 4
Plunder 9
Professor Zoom 10
Psykon 1
Rag Doll 3
Rainbow Raider 1
Replicant 1
Ring master 1
Rudolph West 1
Saber-Tooth 1
Savitar 9
Speed Demon 1
Star Sapphire 4
Steve Palmer 1
Tar Pit 8
The Alchemist 2
The Anti Monitor 3
The Eel (Golden Age) 10
The Gambler 10
The Rival 10
The Shade 10
The Suit 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Thinker (Modern Age) 1
The Thorn 4
The Top 9
The Turtle (Golden Age) 10
Trickster I 10
Trickster II 10
Vandal Savage 2
Weather Wizard 10
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 1
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 6

1 point for:

Abra Kadabra
Baroness Blitzkrieg
Big Sir
Blacksmith
Brother Grimm
Captain Boomerang
Captain Boomerang II
Captain Cold
Chillbaine
Christina Alexandrova
Chunk
Cicada
Double Down
Dr. Alchemy
Eradicator
Fallout
Folded Man
Goldface
Gorilla Grodd
Heatwave
Inerita
Magenta
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Mirror Master
Mirror Master II
Mob Rule
Mr.Element I
Mr.Element II
Murmur
Peek-a-Boo
Pied Piper
Professor Zoom
Rag Doll
Rainbow Raider
Replicant
Ring master
Rudolph West
Star Sapphire
Tar Pit
The Anti Monitor
The Shade
The Suit
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
Trickster I
Trickster II
Weather Wizard

I kind of goofed on my first vote, IB, I edited it once I realized what I did. Should I just convert all your 1s to 10s?

Oh is that what we were aupposed to do. Yes please Emily. Thanks.

Abra Kadabra 9
Alexander Petrov 1
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 1
Baroness Blitzkrieg 1
Big Sir 4
Black Flash 9
Blacksmith 8
Boleslav Uminski 1
Brain 1
Brother Grimm 5
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 7
Captain Cold 10
Captain Cold (New 52) 3
Changeling 1
Chillbaine 1
Christina Alexandrova 4
Chunk 6
Cicada 5
Clive Yorkin 10
Cobalt Blue 6
Colonel Computron 7
Double Down 5
Dr. Alchemy 8
Eradicator 3
Fallout 6
Folded Man 1
Girder 7
Golden Glider 7
Goldface 7
Gorilla Grodd 8
Gregor Gregorovich 1
Heatstroke 1
Heatwave 9
Inerita 5
Kilg%re 6
Magenta 9
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 6
Mirror Master 10
Mirror Master II 10
Mirror Monarch 1
Mob Rule 1
Mr.Element I 8
Mr.Element II 8
Murmur 7
Peek-a-Boo 8
Pied Piper 8
Plunder 5
Professor Zoom 9
Psykon 1
Rag Doll 8
Rainbow Raider 6
Replicant 4
Ring master 1
Rudolph West 7
Saber-Tooth 7
Savitar 5
Speed Demon 8
Star Sapphire 1
Steve Palmer 1
Tar Pit 8
The Alchemist 8
The Anti Monitor 1
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 1
The Rival 9
The Shade 3
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 8
The Thinker (Modern Age) 10
The Thorn 3
The Top 7
The Turtle (Golden Age) 8
Trickster I 10
Trickster II 7
Vandal Savage 9
Weather Wizard 9
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 6
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 7

Abra Kadabra...10
Alexander Petrov...5
Atom Smasher (Golden Age)...1
Baroness Blitzkrieg...1
Big Sir...10
Black Flash...1
Blacksmith...1
Boleslav Uminski...5
Brain...1
Brother Grimm...1
Captain Boomerang...1
Captain Boomerang II...1
Captain Cold...1
Captain Cold (New 52)...1
Changeling...1
Chillbaine...1
Christina Alexandrova...5
Chunk...5
Cicada...1
Clive Yorkin...10
Cobalt Blue...1
Colonel Computron...10
Double Down...1
Dr. Alchemy...10
Eradicator...10
Fallout...1
Folded Man...1
Girder...1
Golden Glider...10
Goldface...1
Gorilla Grodd...1
Gregor Gregorovich...5
Heatstroke...1
Heatwave...1
Inerita...1
Kilg%re...5
Magenta...10
Miasma (Team Turmoil)...1
Mirror Master...10
Mirror Master II...1
Mirror Monarch...1
Mob Rule...1
Mr.Element I...10
Mr.Element II...1
Murmur...1
Peek-a-Boo...1
Pied Piper...10
Plunder...1
Professor Zoom...10
Psykon...5
Rag Doll...1
Rainbow Raider...10
Replicant...1
Ring Master...10
Rudolph West...5
Saber-Tooth...10
Savitar...1
Speed Demon...1
Star Sapphire...1
Steve Palmer...1
Tar Pit...1
The Alchemist...1
The Anti Monitor...5
The Eel (Golden Age)...1
The Gambler...5
The Rival...5
The Shade...5
The Suit...5
The Thinker (Golden Age)...5
The Thinker (Modern Age)...5
The Thorn...5
The Top...10
The Turtle (Golden Age)...1
Trickster I...10
Trickster II...1
Vandal Savage...1
Weather Wizard...10
Wildside (Team Turmoil)...1
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)...1

Abra Kadabra 7
Alexander Petrov 1
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 4
Baroness Blitzkrieg 6
Big Sir 5
Black Flash 3
Blacksmith 6
Boleslav Uminski 1
Brain 1
Brother Grimm 1
Captain Boomerang 9
Captain Boomerang II 6
Captain Cold 10
Captain Cold (New 52) 1
Changeling 1
Chillbaine 1
Christina Alexandrova 3
Chunk 4
Cicada 6
Clive Yorkin 2
Cobalt Blue 2
Colonel Computron 7
Double Down 9
Dr. Alchemy 9
Eradicator 1
Fallout 5
Folded Man 7
Girder 5
Golden Glider 7
Goldface 4
Gorilla Grodd 9
Gregor Gregorovich 1
Heatstroke 5
Heatwave 10
Inerita 6
Kilg%re 6
Magenta 8
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 1
Mirror Master 5
Mirror Master II 10
Mirror Monarch 1
Mob Rule 6
Mr.Element I 8
Mr.Element II 7
Murmur 8
Peek-a-Boo 9
Pied Piper 10
Plunder 5
Professor Zoom 5
Psykon 1
Rag Doll 10
Rainbow Raider 10
Replicant 1
Ring master 1
Rudolph West 1
Saber-Tooth 1
Savitar 6
Speed Demon 3
Star Sapphire 1
Steve Palmer 1
Tar Pit 7
The Alchemist 4
The Anti Monitor 6
The Eel (Golden Age) 7
The Gambler 10
The Rival 6
The Shade 10
The Suit 4
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Thinker (Modern Age) 4
The Thorn 6
The Top 9
The Turtle (Golden Age) 9
Trickster I 9
Trickster II 5
Vandal Savage 9
Weather Wizard 9
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 1
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 6

Abra Kadabra 8
Alexander Petrov 4
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 1
Baroness Blitzkrieg 1
Big Sir 6
Black Flash 2
Blacksmith 1
Boleslav Uminski 1
Brain 4
Brother Grimm 1
Captain Boomerang 8
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 8
Captain Cold (New 52) 1
Changeling 4
Chillbaine 1
Christina Alexandrova 4
Chunk 6
Cicada 1
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 2
Colonel Computron 4
Double Down 1
Dr. Alchemy 8
Eradicator 6
Fallout 2
Folded Man 2
Girder 1
Golden Glider 4
Goldface 4
Gorilla Grodd 8
Gregor Gregorovich 4
Heatstroke 1
Heatwave 6
Inerita 1
Kilg%re 6
Magenta 6
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 1
Mirror Master 8
Mirror Master II 6
Mirror Monarch 1
Mob Rule 1
Mr.Element I 6
Mr.Element II 6
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 6
Plunder 1
Professor Zoom 6
Psykon 1
Rag Doll 8
Rainbow Raider 6
Replicant 2
Ring master 1
Rudolph West 4
Saber-Tooth 1
Savitar 2
Speed Demon 4
Star Sapphire 6
Steve Palmer 2
Tar Pit 1
The Alchemist 1
The Anti Monitor 4
The Eel (Golden Age) 2
The Gambler 6
The Rival 2
The Shade 6
The Suit 4
The Thinker (Golden Age) 8
The Thinker (Modern Age) 6
The Thorn 6
The Top 4
The Turtle (Golden Age) 8
Trickster I 6
Trickster II 4
Vandal Savage 6
Weather Wizard 6
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 1
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 4

I had to make a tough call an eliminate everyone that received less than 20 points. Funny results to say the least (sorry for the bad pun):

Trickster I 55 100%
Abra Kadabra 54 98%
Weather Wizard 54 98%
Mirror Master 53 96%
Dr. Alchemy 50 91%
Professor Zoom 50 91%
Captain Cold 49 89%
The Top 49 89%
Captain Boomerang 48 87%
Magenta 48 87%
Pied Piper 48 87%
Mirror Master II 47 85%
The Turtle (Golden Age) 46 84%
The Shade 44 80%
Mr.Element I 43 78%
Rainbow Raider 43 78%
Gorilla Grodd 42 76%
The Thinker (Golden Age) 42 76%
Heatwave 41 75%
Rag Doll 40 73%
Eradicator 39 71%
Golden Glider 39 71%
Peek-a-Boo 39 71%
Trickster II 37 67%
Big Sir 36 65%
Christina Alexandrova 36 65%
Captain Boomerang II 35 64%
Clive Yorkin 35 64%
Tar Pit 35 64%
Double Down 34 62%
The Suit 34 62%
Mr.Element II 33 60%
The Gambler 33 60%
The Rival 33 60%
Chunk 32 58%
Goldface 31 56%
Inerita 31 56%
Cicada 30 55%
Kilg%re 30 55%
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 29 53%
The Anti Monitor 29 53%
Girder 28 51%
Murmur 28 51%
Rudolph West 28 51%
Vandal Savage 28 51%
Colonel Computron 27 49%
The Thinker (Modern Age) 27 49%
Boleslav Uminski 26 47%
Fallout 26 47%
Folded Man 25 45%
The Thorn 25 45%
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 25 45%
Blacksmith 24 47%
Chillbaine 24 47%
Cobalt Blue 24 47%
Ring master 24 47%
Savitar 24 47%
Star Sapphire 23 42%
Plunder 22 40%
The Eel (Golden Age) 22 40%

Close to Elimination

Saber-Tooth 21 38%
Baroness Blitzkrieg 20 36%
Mob Rule 20 36%

The Eliminated
Brother Grimm 19 35%
Heatstroke 19 35%
Replicant 19 35%
Changeling 18 33%
Speed Demon 18 33%
Alexander Petrov 17 31%
Captain Cold (New 52) 17 31%
Gregor Gregorovich 17 31%
The Alchemist 17 31%
Black Flash 16 29%
Wildside (Team Turmoil) 14 24%
Mirror Monarch 10 18%
Psykon 10 18%
Atom Smasher (Golden Age) 9 16%
Brain 9 16%
Steve Palmer 7 13%

The only ones I thought would have done better were Speed McGee (Speed Demon) and the Black Flash. Also interesting that Zoom is in the lower half of the list.

I too was surprised by the Black Flash's early elimination. And how poorly Vandal Savage is doing.

I usually get away unscathed in the first few rounds, but there were a few here I gave points to that didn't make the cut.

I'll add my surprise about Speed Demon going. I thought that initial Wally West run was decent.

From what I saw of the Changeling, he looked to be a forerunner of Gar Logan.

I personally don't know the DC Speed Demon, it just rubbed me wrong because there is a Spider-Man villain with the same name. It just seemed cheap to my eyes.

Oh, the next round. I will just borrow the Cosmic Treadmill and go back a few days, and it will be like this delay never happened.

Top 64

Abra Kadabra
Baroness Blitzkrieg
Big Sir
Blacksmith
Boleslav Uminski
Captain Boomerang
Captain Boomerang II
Captain Cold
Chillbaine
Christina Alexandrova
Chunk
Cicada
Clive Yorkin
Cobalt Blue
Colonel Computron
Double Down
Dr. Alchemy
Eradicator
Fallout
Folded Man
Girder
Golden Glider
Goldface
Gorilla Grodd
Heatwave
Inerita
Kilg%re
Magenta
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Mirror Master
Mirror Master II
Mob Rule
Mr.Element I
Mr.Element II
Murmur
Peek-a-Boo
Pied Piper
Plunder
Professor Zoom
Rag Doll
Rainbow Raider
Ring master
Rudolph West
Saber-Tooth
Savitar
Star Sapphire
Tar Pit
The Anti Monitor
The Eel (Golden Age)
The Gambler
The Rival
The Shade
The Suit
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Thinker (Modern Age)
The Thorn
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
Trickster I
Trickster II
Vandal Savage
Weather Wizard
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)

Abra Kadabra 6
Baroness Blitzkrieg 1
Big Sir 1
Blacksmith 10
Boleslav Uminski 8
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 10
Captain Cold 10
Chillbaine 1
Christina Alexandrova 10
Chunk 1
Cicada 7
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 10
Colonel Computron 1
Double Down 1
Dr. Alchemy 10
Eradicator 7
Fallout 1
Folded Man 1
Girder 10
Golden Glider 10
Goldface 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Heatwave 10
Inerita 5
Kilg%re 8
Magenta 10
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 1
Mirror Master 10
Mirror Master II 10
Mob Rule 1
Mr.Element I 5
Mr.Element II 5
Murmur 10
Peek-a-Boo 9
Pied Piper 7
Plunder 8
Professor Zoom 10
Rag Doll 6
Rainbow Raider 1
Ring master 1
Rudolph West 1
Saber-Tooth 1
Savitar 9
Star Sapphire 1
Tar Pit 10
The Anti Monitor 3
The Eel (Golden Age) 10
The Gambler 10
The Rival 10
The Shade 10
The Suit 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Thinker (Modern Age) 10
The Thorn 1
The Top 5
The Turtle (Golden Age) 10
Trickster I 10
Trickster II 10
Vandal Savage 2
Weather Wizard 10
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 10

Abra Kadabra...10
Baroness Blitzkrieg...1
Big Sir...10
Blacksmith...1
Boleslav Uminski...5
Captain Boomerang...1
Captain Boomerang II...1
Captain Cold...1
Chillbaine...1
Christina Alexandrova...5
Chunk...5
Cicada...1
Clive Yorkin...10
Cobalt Blue...1
Colonel Computron...10
Double Down...1
Dr. Alchemy...10
Eradicator...10
Fallout...1
Folded Man...1
Girder...1
Golden Glider...10
Goldface...1
Gorilla Grodd...1
Heatwave...1
Inertia...1
Kilg%re...5
Magenta...10
Miasma (Team Turmoil)...1
Mirror Master...10
Mirror Master II...1
Mob Rule...1
Mr.Element I...10
Mr.Element II...1
Murmur...1
Peek-a-Boo...1
Pied Piper...10
Plunder...1
Professor Zoom...10
Rag Doll...1
Rainbow Raider...10
Ring Master...10
Rudolph West...1
Saber-Tooth...10
Savitar...1
Star Sapphire...1
Tar Pit...1
The Anti Monitor...5
The Eel (Golden Age)...1
The Gambler...5
The Rival...5
The Shade...1
The Suit...1
The Thinker (Golden Age)...5
The Thinker (Modern Age)...1
The Thorn...1
The Top...10
The Turtle (Golden Age)...1
Trickster I...10
Trickster II...1
Vandal Savage...1
Weather Wizard...10
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)...1

Abra Kadabra 8
Baroness Blitzkrieg 1
Big Sir 6
Blacksmith 1
Boleslav Uminski 1
Captain Boomerang 8
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 8
Chillbaine 1
Christina Alexandrova 4
Chunk 6
Cicada 1
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 2
Colonel Computron 6
Double Down 1
Dr. Alchemy 8
Eradicator 6
Fallout 4
Folded Man 4
Girder 1
Golden Glider 6
Goldface 6
Gorilla Grodd 7
Heatwave 6
Inerita 1
Kilg%re 6
Magenta 8
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 1
Mirror Master 8
Mirror Master II 6
Mob Rule 1
Mr.Element I 6
Mr.Element II 6
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 6
Plunder 1
Professor Zoom 6
Rag Doll 8
Rainbow Raider 6
Ring master 1
Rudolph West 4
Saber-Tooth 1
Savitar 2
Star Sapphire 8
Tar Pit 1
The Anti Monitor 4
The Eel (Golden Age) 4
The Gambler 8
The Rival 2
The Shade 6
The Suit 4
The Thinker (Golden Age) 8
The Thinker (Modern Age) 8
The Thorn 8
The Top 6
The Turtle (Golden Age) 8
Trickster I 8
Trickster II 4
Vandal Savage 8
Weather Wizard 6
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 6

Abra Kadabra 6
Baroness Blitzkrieg 6
Big Sir 8
Blacksmith 9
Boleslav Uminski 1
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 10
Captain Cold 7
Chillbaine 1
Christina Alexandrova 4
Chunk 8
Cicada 5
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 2
Colonel Computron 7
Double Down 9
Dr. Alchemy 5
Eradicator 1
Fallout 3
Folded Man 8
Girder 6
Golden Glider 10
Goldface 5
Gorilla Grodd 5
Heatwave 9
Inerita 4
Kilg%re 4
Magenta 8
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 2
Mirror Master 6
Mirror Master II 9
Mob Rule 6
Mr.Element I 5
Mr.Element II 7
Murmur 8
Peek-a-Boo 6
Pied Piper 10
Plunder 3
Professor Zoom 5
Rag Doll 10
Rainbow Raider 9
Ring master 2
Rudolph West 1
Saber-Tooth 1
Savitar 6
Star Sapphire 1
Tar Pit 5
The Anti Monitor 5
The Eel (Golden Age) 8
The Gambler 9
The Rival 6
The Shade 10
The Suit 6
The Thinker (Golden Age) 9
The Thinker (Modern Age) 7
The Thorn 6
The Top 10
The Turtle (Golden Age) 10
Trickster I 10
Trickster II 2
Vandal Savage 5
Weather Wizard 9
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 1

Abra Kadabra 8
Baroness Blitzkrieg 1
Big Sir 7
Blacksmith 8
Boleslav Uminski 1
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 7
Captain Cold 10
Chillbaine 3
Christina Alexandrova 4
Chunk 7
Cicada 6
Clive Yorkin 10
Cobalt Blue 7
Colonel Computron 5
Double Down 6
Dr. Alchemy 8
Eradicator 4
Fallout 4
Folded Man 1
Girder 6
Golden Glider 8
Goldface 8
Gorilla Grodd 9
Heatwave 9
Inerita 5
Kilg%re 5
Magenta 9
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 8
Mirror Master 9
Mirror Master II 10
Mob Rule 1
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 6
Murmur 6
Peek-a-Boo 8
Pied Piper 7
Plunder 7
Professor Zoom 8
Rag Doll 8
Rainbow Raider 7
Ring master 1
Rudolph West 7
Saber-Tooth 5
Savitar 5
Star Sapphire 1
Tar Pit 8
The Anti Monitor 1
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 6
The Rival 9
The Shade 1
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 7
The Thinker (Modern Age) 9
The Thorn 3
The Top 8
The Turtle (Golden Age) 8
Trickster I 9
Trickster II 7
Vandal Savage 8
Weather Wizard 9
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 7

I never knew The Trickster I was this popular.

Trickster I 47 100%
Magenta 45 96%
Golden Glider 44 94%
Weather Wizard 44 94%
Mirror Master 43 91%
Dr. Alchemy 41 87%
Pied Piper 40 85%
Captain Boomerang 39 83%
Professor Zoom 39 83%
The Thinker (Golden Age)39 83%
The Top 39 83%
Abra Kadabra 38 81%
The Gambler 38 81%
The Turtle (Golden Age) 37 79%
Captain Cold 36 77%
Mirror Master II 36 77%
Heatwave 35 74%
The Thinker (Modern Age)35 74%
Rag Doll 33 70%
Rainbow Raider 33 70%
Big Sir 32 68%
Gorilla Grodd 32 68%
The Rival 32 68%
Blacksmith 29 62%
Captain Boomerang II 29 62%
Colonel Computron 29 62%
Murmur 29 62%
Eradicator 28 60%
Kilg%re 28 60%
Peek-a-Boo 28 60%
The Shade 28 60%
Christina Alexandrova 27 57%
Chunk 27 57%
Mr.Element I 27 57%
Clive Yorkin 26 55%
Mr.Element II 25 53%
Tar Pit 25 53%
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 25 53%
Girder 24 51%
The Eel (Golden Age) 24 51%
Trickster II 24 51%
Vandal Savage 24 51%


Close to Elimination
Cicada 23 49%
Savitar 23 49%
Cobalt Blue 22 47%
The Suit 22 47%
Goldface 21 44%
Plunder 20 43%
The Thorn 19 40%

Eliminated this Round
Double Down 18 38%
Saber-Tooth 18 38%
The Anti Monitor 18 38%
Boleslav Uminski 16 34%
Inerita 16 34%
Miasma (Team Turmoil) 16 34%
Folded Man 15 32%
Ring master 15 32%
Rudolph West 14 30%
Fallout 13 28%
Mob Rule 13 28%
Star Sapphire 12 26%
Baroness Blitzkrieg 10 21%
Chillbaine 7 15%

Thanks for reminding me about this round, Emily. Apologies for not being able to vote, it's hard to do so using my phone and I was out of the office most of the day.

Apart from thinking of the folded man as an ancestor of Ron Karr, no huge losses.

Double Down? Gone? But, but.. he looked so cool!

Top 50

Abra Kadabra
Big Sir
Blacksmith
Captain Boomerang
Captain Boomerang II
Captain Cold
Christina Alexandrova
Chunk
Cicada
Clive Yorkin
Cobalt Blue
Colonel Computron
Dr. Alchemy
Eradicator
Girder
Golden Glider
Goldface
Gorilla Grodd
Heatwave
Kilg%re
Magenta 45
Mirror Master
Mirror Master II
Mr.Element I
Mr.Element II
Murmur
Peek-a-Boo
Pied Piper
Plunder
Professor Zoom
Rag Doll
Rainbow Raider
Savitar
Tar Pit
The Eel (Golden Age)
The Gambler
The Rival
The Shade
The Suit
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Thinker (Modern Age)
The Thorn
Trickster I
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
Trickster II
Vandal Savage
Weather Wizard
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)

Abra Kadabra 5
Big Sir 1
Blacksmith 8
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 10
Captain Cold 10
Christina Alexandrova 8
Chunk 7
Cicada 8
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 8
Colonel Computron 1
Dr. Alchemy
Eradicator 7
Girder 8
Golden Glider 7
Goldface 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Heatwave 8
Kilg%re 7
Magenta 8
Mirror Master 10
Mirror Master II 10
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 1
Murmur 9
Peek-a-Boo 8
Pied Piper 7
Plunder 8
Professor Zoom 10
Rag Doll 8
Rainbow Raider 1
Savitar 8
Tar Pit 8
The Eel (Golden Age) 10
The Gambler 10
The Rival 10
The Shade 10
The Suit 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Thinker (Modern Age) 1
The Thorn 5
Trickster I 1
The Top 8
The Turtle (Golden Age) 10
Trickster II 6
Vandal Savage 1
Weather Wizard 8
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 6

Abra Kadabra 8
Big Sir 7
Blacksmith 8
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 7
Captain Cold 9
Christina Alexandrova 6
Chunk 7
Cicada 6
Clive Yorkin 10
Cobalt Blue 6
Colonel Computron 6
Dr. Alchemy 7
Eradicator 5
Girder 7
Golden Glider 8
Goldface 8
Gorilla Grodd 9
Heatwave 8
Kilg%re 5
Magenta 8
Mirror Master 8
Mirror Master II 9
Mr.Element I 5
Mr.Element II 5
Murmur 6
Peek-a-Boo 6
Pied Piper 6
Plunder 6
Professor Zoom 7
Rag Doll 8
Rainbow Raider 6
Savitar 3
Tar Pit 7
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 6
The Rival 8
The Shade 1
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 6
The Thinker (Modern Age) 8
The Thorn 1
Trickster I 6
The Top 7
The Turtle (Golden Age) 7
Trickster II 5
Vandal Savage 6
Weather Wizard 8
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 4

Abra Kadabra 10
Big Sir 10
Blacksmith 1
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 10
Captain Cold 10
Christina Alexandrova 10
Chunk 10
Cicada 1
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 1
Colonel Computron 1
Dr. Alchemy 10
Eradicator 1
Girder 1
Golden Glider 1
Goldface 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Heatwave 1
Kilg%re 10
Magenta 10
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 10
Mr.Element I 1
Mr.Element II 1
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 10
Pied Piper 10
Plunder 1
Professor Zoom 1
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 10
Savitar 1
Tar Pit 1
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 1
The Rival 1
The Shade 10
The Suit 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Thinker (Modern Age) 1
The Thorn 1
Trickster I 10
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 10
Trickster II 10
Vandal Savage 1
Weather Wizard 10
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 1

Abra Kadabra...10
Big Sir...10
Blacksmith...1
Captain Boomerang...1
Captain Boomerang II...1
Captain Cold...1
Christina Alexandrova...1
Chunk...1
Cicada...1
Clive Yorkin...10
Cobalt Blue...1
Colonel Computron...10
Dr. Alchemy...10
Eradicator...10
Girder...1
Golden Glider...10
Goldface...1
Gorilla Grodd...1
Heatwave...1
Kilg%re...1
Magenta...10
Mirror Master...10
Mirror Master II...1
Mr.Element I...10
Mr.Element II...1
Murmur...1
Peek-a-Boo...1
Pied Piper...10
Plunder...1
Professor Zoom...10
Rag Doll...1
Rainbow Raider...10
Savitar...1
Tar Pit...1
The Eel (Golden Age)...1
The Gambler...10
The Rival...1
The Shade...1
The Suit...1
The Thinker (Golden Age)...10
The Thinker (Modern Age)...1
The Thorn...1
Trickster I...10
The Top...10
The Turtle (Golden Age)...1
Trickster II...1
Vandal Savage...1
Weather Wizard...10
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)...1

Abra Kadabra 7
Big Sir 6
Blacksmith 7
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 7
Captain Cold 10
Christina Alexandrova 4
Chunk 5
Cicada 6
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 1
Colonel Computron 6
Dr. Alchemy 5
Eradicator 1
Girder 3
Golden Glider 9
Goldface 2
Gorilla Grodd 8
Heatwave 10
Kilg%re 4
Magenta 6
Mirror Master 7
Mirror Master II 10
Mr.Element I 2
Mr.Element II 5
Murmur 4
Peek-a-Boo 7
Pied Piper 8
Plunder 1
Professor Zoom 2
Rag Doll 10
Rainbow Raider 9
Savitar 5
Tar Pit 2
The Eel (Golden Age) 8
The Gambler 9
The Rival 4
The Shade 10
The Suit 2
The Thinker (Golden Age) 6
The Thinker (Modern Age) 1
The Thorn 1
Trickster I 9
The Top 10
The Turtle (Golden Age) 10
Trickster II 1
Vandal Savage 5
Weather Wizard 6
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 2

Abra Kadabra 8
Big Sir 6
Blacksmith 1
Captain Boomerang 8
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 8
Christina Alexandrova 8
Chunk 8
Cicada 1
Clive Yorkin 1
Cobalt Blue 2
Colonel Computron 8
Dr. Alchemy 8
Eradicator 8
Girder 1
Golden Glider 8
Goldface 8
Gorilla Grodd 8
Heatwave 8
Kilg%re 8
Magenta 8
Mirror Master 8
Mirror Master II 8
Mr.Element I 8
Mr.Element II 8
Murmur 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 8
Plunder 1
Professor Zoom 8
Rag Doll 8
Rainbow Raider 8
Savitar 4
Tar Pit 1
The Eel (Golden Age) 4
The Gambler 8
The Rival 2
The Shade 8
The Suit 8
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Thinker (Modern Age) 8
The Thorn 8
Trickster I 8
The Top 8
The Turtle (Golden Age) 8
Trickster II 1
Vandal Savage 10
Weather Wizard 8
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 6

I want to take this moment to wish Myg a Happy Birthday! If you don't have a thread in the Monitor Board, I will probably start one so others can wish you a happy birthday.

This game is Freejoin, so if anyone new is looking at the thread, feel free to vote in the next round.

The results this time around are simply forces of nature: Weather Wizard and Magenta tie for first place.

Magenta 50 100%
Weather Wizard 50 100%[/color]
[/color]Pied Piper 49 98%
Abra Kadabra 48 96%
Captain Cold 48 96%
Mirror Master II 48 96%
Gorilla Grodd 46 92%
The Gambler 46 92%
The Turtle (Golden Age) 46 92%
Mirror Master 44 88%
Trickster I 44 88%
The Top 44 88%
Big Sir 43 86%
Golden Glider 43 86%
The Thinker (Golden Age) 43 86%
Dr. Alchemy 42 84%
Rainbow Raider 41 82%
Captain Boomerang 40 80%
Professor Zoom 39 78%
Christina Alexandrova 37 74%
Chunk 37 74%
Captain Boomerang II 36 72%
Heatwave 36 72%
Kilg%re 35 70%
Rag Doll 34 68%
Peek-a-Boo 33 66%
The Shade 33 66%
Eradicator 32 64%
The Suit 32 64%
The Eel (Golden Age) 30 60%

Close to Elimination
Clive Yorkin 29 58%
Colonel Computron 27 54%
Mr.Element I 27 54%
Blacksmith 26 52%
Savitar 26 52%

Eliminated This Round
Trickster II 24 48%
Vandal Savage 24 48%
Cicada 22 44%
Murmur 22 44%
Girder 21 42%
Goldface 21 42%
Mr.Element II 21 42%
The Rival 21 42%
The Thinker (Modern Age) 20 40%
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman) 20 40%
Cobalt Blue 19 38%
Plunder 19 38%
The Thorn 17 34%
Tar Pit 14 28%

Thanks, Emily!

I'm impressed at the strong showing of Magenta and Pied Piper

A bit sad to see Murmur & Vandal Savage go

Too bad about the Modern Aged Thinker. He was a great villain in Suicide Squad.

I was also partial to the Rival, but he was always more of an interesting concept than an actual character.

Happy to see Magenta and Piper doing so well.

Really surprised to see Vandal Savage go. He's a top tier villain, who's an imoortal threat to the Titans, JSA and probably the JLA too. He was the most brutal of villains in Kingdom Come.

In the way that Deadshot did so well in the last Idol, I thought that the second Thinker would also do better. Not only a recurring antagonist n Firestorm, before he got powers, but a nasty sociopath over in Suicide Squad.

I like Vandal Savage but he's not who I think of when I think of Flash villains. He would get probably get more points from me in a JSA Villain Idol.

This is the same reason why I'll be turning on Magenta shortly. I've been giving her the highest points each round so far but that's mainly beacuse she's one of my favourite Titans characters.

I really didn't like it when they went down the crazy villain road with her in the Flash books, especially when Geoff Johns had her hanging out with all those murderers during his 'Rogue War' arc.

The Thinker and Goldface are other characters I associate more with other properties (JSA and Green Lantern respectively).

The post Crisis Flash relaunch had Savage as a major early villain. It was disappointing that more wasn't done with him at the time.

Just noticed this looking at the active topics screen.

In the short run (no pun intended), Savage didn't get enough face time, but in the long run he was at the top of his game in the superb 3-part arc running from Flash 48 to 50, written by Bill Loebs and drawn by Greg LaRocque, both at the top of their game as well. If you haven't read it, I highly recommend it.

Please join the game, it is a lot of fun. LSV Idol will start probably a month after this one is over, but after that I want to do a Marvel one (probably Spider-Villain) for the sake of my sanity. There tends to be more resources for Marvel characters (websites, books, official statistics) so it is easier for me to compile the data and host.

Top 35
Abra Kadabra
Big Sir
Blacksmith
Captain Boomerang
Captain Boomerang II
Captain Cold
Christina Alexandrova
Chunk
Clive Yorkin
Colonel Computron
Dr. Alchemy
Eradicator
Golden Glider
Gorilla Grodd
Heatwave
Kilg%re
Magenta
Mirror Master
Mirror Master II
Mr.Element I
Peek-a-Boo
Pied Piper
Professor Zoom
Rag Doll
Rainbow Raider
Savitar
The Eel (Golden Age)
The Gambler
The Shade
The Suit
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
Top 35
Trickster I
Weather Wizard

My Votes
Abra Kadabra 5
Big Sir 1
Blacksmith 10
Captain Boomerang 5
Captain Boomerang II 10
Captain Cold 10
Christina Alexandrova 5
Chunk 1
Clive Yorkin 1
Colonel Computron 1
Dr. Alchemy 1
Eradicator 1
Golden Glider 5
Gorilla Grodd 10
Heatwave 5
Kilg%re 1
Magenta 10
Mirror Master 10
Mirror Master II 10
Mr.Element I 1
Peek-a-Boo 5
Pied Piper 5
Professor Zoom 10
Rag Doll 5
Rainbow Raider 1
Savitar 5
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 10
The Shade 10
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Top 10
The Turtle (Golden Age) 10
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 10

I may just do that, Emily. Thank you.

And I apologize if it was inappropriate of me to make that post, it's just that I really love that Wally vs Vandal Savage story.

I don't mind the commentary at all; I usually give it more time between rounds on purpose if people are commenting. The most important thing is that people are having fun.

Thanks again, Emily.

I was just looking over the first few pages of the thread, including the rules. I'll join in tomorrow, when I'm less tired and have a clearer head.

Abra Kadabra 8
Big Sir 5
Blacksmith 8
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 7
Captain Cold 9
Christina Alexandrova 5
Chunk 8
Clive Yorkin 10
Colonel Computron 5
Dr. Alchemy 6
Eradicator 1
Golden Glider 5
Gorilla Grodd 8
Heatwave 7
Kilg%re 1
Magenta 7
Mirror Master 8
Mirror Master II 9
Mr.Element I 6
Peek-a-Boo 7
Pied Piper 7
Professor Zoom 7
Rag Doll 5
Rainbow Raider 4
Savitar 1
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 3
The Shade 2
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 3
The Top 8
The Turtle (Golden Age) 7
Trickster I 7
Weather Wizard 7

Alas, poor Clive Yorkin doesn't look long for this game. As a kid I found him so scary looking, more like something out of a horror comic than the Flash. And he was freaky in the books, not only was he deadly, he was a complete psychopath! And then he killed Iris! Later of course, it turns out he didn't, but 6-year old me still found him really terrifying.

Abra Kadabra 6
Big Sir 4
Blacksmith 5
Captain Boomerang 6
Captain Boomerang II 9
Captain Cold 7
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 2
Clive Yorkin 1
Colonel Computron 6
Dr. Alchemy 5
Eradicator 1
Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 4
Heatwave 6
Kilg%re 2
Magenta 7
Mirror Master 3
Mirror Master II 7
Mr.Element I 4
Peek-a-Boo 2
Pied Piper 6
Professor Zoom 1
Rag Doll 8
Rainbow Raider 8
Savitar 2
The Eel (Golden Age) 6
The Gambler 5
The Shade 10
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Top 10
The Turtle (Golden Age) 10
Trickster I 6
Weather Wizard 4

This.

Abra Kadabra 10
Big Sir 10
Blacksmith 1
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 10
Captain Cold 10
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 10
Clive Yorkin 1
Colonel Computron 1
Dr. Alchemy 1
Eradicator 1
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Heatwave 1
Kilg%re 1
Magenta 10
Mirror Master 10
Mirror Master II 10
Mr.Element I 1
Peek-a-Boo 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 1
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 10
Savitar 1
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 1
The Shade 10
The Suit 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 10

Thanks Fickles. I haven't read that one. My reading in that run stops in the early 20s and doesn't return until the 80s or even towards the 100 for a while.

Abra Kadabra 8
Big Sir 8
Blacksmith 1
Captain Boomerang 8
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 8
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 8
Clive Yorkin 1
Colonel Computron 8
Dr. Alchemy 8
Eradicator 8
Golden Glider 5
Gorilla Grodd 8
Heatwave 8
Kilg%re 8
Magenta 8
Mirror Master 8
Mirror Master II 8
Mr.Element I 5
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 5
Professor Zoom 8
Rag Doll 8
Rainbow Raider 5
Savitar 1
The Eel (Golden Age) 8
The Gambler 8
The Shade 8
The Suit 8
The Thinker (Golden Age) 8
The Top 5
The Turtle (Golden Age) 8
Trickster I 8
Weather Wizard 8

Abra Kadabra...10
Big Sir...10
Blacksmith...1
Captain Boomerang...1
Captain Boomerang II...1
Captain Cold...1
Christina Alexandrova...1
Chunk...1
Clive Yorkin...10
Colonel Computron...10
Dr. Alchemy...10
Eradicator...10
Golden Glider...10
Gorilla Grodd...1
Heatwave...1
Kilg%re...1
Magenta...10 (I just can't quit you, Frances)
Mirror Master...10
Mirror Master II...1
Mr.Element I...10
Peek-a-Boo...1
Pied Piper...10
Professor Zoom...10
Rag Doll...1
Rainbow Raider...10
Savitar...1
The Eel (Golden Age)...1
The Gambler...1
The Shade...1
The Suit...1
The Thinker (Golden Age)...1
The Top...10
The Turtle (Golden Age)...1
Trickster I...10
Weather Wizard...10

Okay, Emily, I'm officially in as of now, and I hope I did this right:

Top 35
Abra Kadabra 1
Big Sir 1
Blacksmith 1
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 1
Christina Alexandrova 10
Chunk 1
Clive Yorkin 1
Colonel Computron 1
Dr. Alchemy 1
Eradicator 1
Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 10
Heatwave 1
Kilg%re 10
Magenta 10
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 10
Mr.Element I 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 10
Rag Doll 1
Rainbow Raider 10
Savitar 10
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 1
The Shade 10
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 1

I'm not sure I understand how to vote but I'm giving it a shot! Please let me know if I need to edit anything...

Abra Kadabra 8
Big Sir 1
Blacksmith 1
Captain Boomerang 5
Captain Boomerang II 2
Captain Cold 10
Christina Alexandrova 1
Chunk 2
Clive Yorkin 1
Colonel Computron 1
Dr. Alchemy 3
Eradicator 2
Golden Glider 3
Gorilla Grodd 7
Heatwave 5
Kilg%re 10
Magenta 10
Mirror Master 3
Mirror Master II 10
Mr.Element I 1
Peek-a-Boo 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 10
Rag Doll 5
Rainbow Raider 2
Savitar 2
The Eel (Golden Age) 1
The Gambler 1
The Shade 7
The Suit 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Top 3
The Turtle (Golden Age) 2
Trickster I 8
Weather Wizard 7

Please edit the 0s. Please only use numbers from 1-10 for now. I can't accept the 0 votes because it will skew the data too much. Once we narrow the characters down further, we will end up changing the scale.

I suggest reposting instructions and scale every round to reduce confusion

Fixed! (I hope!) Honestly, I really wasn't sure if there was a total the numbers should add up to or if I could only do a certain number of high votes or what have you.

Due to the higher turn out, I am giving a warning as to when votes close tonight. Please post any last minute votes by 9:00 P.M Central Time today.

The winner is shining brightly in pink.

Top 35
Magenta 72 100%
Trickster I 69 96%
Mirror Master II65 90%
Pied Piper 63 88%
Gorilla Grodd 58 81%
The Shade 58 81%
Professor Zoom 57 79%
Weather Wizard 57 79%
Abra Kadabra 56 77%
Captain Cold 56 77%
Captain Boomerang 55 76%
Golden Glider 54 75%
Mirror Master 53 74%

Close to Elimination
Rainbow Raider 50 69%
The Top 48 67%
Captain Boomerang II 41 57%
Big Sir 40 56%
The Turtle (Golden Age) 40 56%
Peek-a-Boo 37 53%
Dr. Alchemy 35 49%
The Thinker (Golden Age) 35 49%

Eliminated This Round

Heatwave 34 47%
Kilg%re 34 47%
Rag Doll 34 47%
Chunk 33 46%
Colonel Computron 33 46%
The Gambler 30 42%
Eradicator 29 40%
Mr.Element I 29 40%
Blacksmith 28 39%
Clive Yorkin 26 35%
Christina Alexandrova 25 34%
The Suit 24 33%
Savitar 23 32%
The Eel (Golden Age) 20 28%

Next round will start tomorrow evening.

Aww, I like Kilg%re! Although I mostly know him from the JLU and it was pretty different, so I guess it's not that sad. I will admit I was pretty disappointed that Girder didn't make it too far. He was one of the first Rogues I thought of when I saw this thread and I'm definitely a fan.

I'll admit some of my fondness for Magenta comes from roleplaying her in my past life. I also adore the Pied Piper to pieces - he's probably one of my all-time favorite characters ever. I may like him more than Wally and some of you may recall Wally is my fave like whoa.

I thought the Suit was interesting.

I'm sad that the Chunk left, although I guess he's not really an out and out villain as of pre-Flashpoint. But still.

The suit reminded me of the old Justice League stories where they fought their costumes.

I liked Chunk's early appearances, but he wasn't really a villain for me, so I was going to reduce points for him sooner or later.

Kilg%re was also around at the same time as Chunk, so those issues have held up in my memory probably more than I thought they would.


That's something I can also say about Infantino art. I was never a great fan of it, but I can't imagine the Eradicator or Colonel Computron drawn by anyone else.

Rag Doll was great in the JLA/JSA crossovers, again in Starman and was he in a secret six sort of thing too? None of which are the Flash, so for me it was a matter of time before I gave him fewer points.

Yay! I'm so glad almost all my favorites with be there next round!

I do wish Christina Alexandrova had done better, though. I guess it had something to do with her becoming prominent in the transitional period between the end of Loebs' run and the beginning of Waid's.

We are probably going to end up doing a Wild Card Round soon, as we have reached a point where we have an odd number of remaining characters. I need even numbers so we have two characters left in the last round.

Top 21
Abra Kadabra
Big Sir
Captain Boomerang
Captain Boomerang II
Captain Cold
Dr. Alchemy
Golden Glider
Gorilla Grodd
Magenta
Mirror Master
Mirror Master II
Peek-a-Boo
Pied Piper
Professor Zoom
Rainbow Raider
The Shade
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
Trickster I
Weather Wizard

Scale is still 1-10 (1 being the least amount of points, and 10 the most).

Abra Kadabra 1
Big Sir 1
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 10
Captain Cold 10
Dr. Alchemy 1
Golden Glider 8
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 8
Mirror Master 5
Mirror Master II 10
Peek-a-Boo 10
Pied Piper 5
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 7
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Top 5
The Turtle (Golden Age) 8
Trickster I 5
Weather Wizard 7

Abra Kadabra 5
Big Sir 1
Captain Boomerang 3
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 9
Dr. Alchemy 3
Golden Glider 2
Gorilla Grodd 5
Magenta 10
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 10
Peek-a-Boo 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 8
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 7
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 6
Trickster I 7
Weather Wizard 4

Abra Kadabra 10
Big Sir 10
Captain Boomerang 1
Captain Boomerang II 10
Captain Cold 1
Dr. Alchemy 1
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 10
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 10
Peek-a-Boo 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 1
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 10

Where were all these Magenta fans in the Titans Idol?!?

Not that it will probably make much difference, but Top 20ish is about as far as I'm willing to support Frances considering I don't think of her a "Flash Villain". So it's going to be "1"s for you from now on, Frances. Sorry! I still love you!

Meanwhile, Rainbow Raider's pleasingly successful journey in this game so far seems like it's about to come to a sudden stop. A vote against the Rainbow Raider is a vote against love!

Abra Kadabra...10
Big Sir...10
Captain Boomerang...1
Captain Boomerang II...1
Captain Cold...1
Dr. Alchemy...10
Golden Glider...10
Gorilla Grodd...1
Magenta...1
Mirror Master...10
Mirror Master II...1
Peek-a-Boo...1
Pied Piper...10
Professor Zoom...10
Rainbow Raider...100
The Shade...1
The Thinker (Golden Age)...1
The Top...10
The Turtle (Golden Age)...1
Trickster I...10
Weather Wizard...10

To be fair, different pool of characters. Magenta was decently liked in Titans Idol but just eclipsed by others

Abra Kadabra 4
Big Sir 7
Captain Boomerang 5
Captain Boomerang II 8
Captain Cold 7
Dr. Alchemy 5
Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 6
Magenta 6
Mirror Master 4
Mirror Master II 6
Peek-a-Boo 6
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 2
Rainbow Raider 10
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 9
The Top 10
The Turtle (Golden Age) 9
Trickster I 7
Weather Wizard 3

Abra Kadabra 10
Big Sir 1
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 4
Dr. Alchemy 4
Golden Glider 2
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 1
Mirror Master 10
Mirror Master II 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 1
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 5
The Shade 5
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Top 2
The Turtle (Golden Age) 10
Trickster I 1
Weather Wizard 1

Abra Kadabra 5
Big Sir 1
Captain Boomerang 10
Captain Boomerang II 1
Captain Cold 5
Dr. Alchemy 3
Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 10
Mirror Master 1
Mirror Master II 10
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 10
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 5
The Top 5
The Turtle (Golden Age) 5
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 5

First, Magenta has a distinct advantage in this one because of the general lack of female villains in Flash. Of course there are the notable exceptions of the Golden and Modern Ages (which probably says something about the roles of women the 1940s and today, but that is for another thread). Second, she has really useful powers that can be a threat to Flash. Third, she has a tragic background in that she started out at least neutral.

All of those things are so true, Emily! I find her history with Wally particularly interesting, too. Like, if we did "Wally West Love Interest Idol" she'd rank high for me for the DRAMA of it all. So would Raven, actually....

I think you might enjoy this thread, Cali:

http://www.legionworld.net/forums/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=836993#Post836993

I find the Search function difficult to use on this site - could you please remind me how Frances fared in that game IB.

She placed 40 out of 188. Here's the thread, linked to the results summary.

She placed above Supergirl, Kid Devil, Speedy (Mia), among others.

Thanks IB. Such weird but interesting results in that game. Shame about the rigged winner.

Tsk, it is a shame that so many voters conspired to make a certain Titan dominate every round Blacula

Even back then, you were Time Trapping, Ibby

I did a pretty good job of it with Kinetix in Multiverse Legion Idol and Kole in the aforementioned Titans Idol, but people wised up to it when I tried with Doctor Light (Kimiyo) in JLIdol...

Kidding aside, my Idol games had very different mechanics (which Emily knows as she played in JLIdol). Below is a quote from my games:



I believe Kinetix and Kole won their respective Idols because:

a) I always kept them as #1 on my own votes, giving them a big number of points
b) they had just enough support from other voters.

Kinetix was the last Postboot character standing, so other Postboot fans naturally gravitated towards her, for example (8 votes vs. 6 for Preboot Imra and 5 for Preboot Val; having two Preboot characters in the final round led to the Preboot fans' votes being split!).

Kole beat Flamebird and Wally in Titans with 4 votes, to 3 each for the other two, so it was very close!

Emily's format is very different as you are not limited in how many characters you can vote for per round, nor is the point system as restrictive.

Sorry I have not calculated the results yet, I will try to get to it by tomorrow. I hope everyone is enjoying the LMB anniversary celebration. I'll see if Captain Cold can pick us up an ice cream cake for this thread.

The winner of this one is the musical Pied Piper. This makes me slightly happy as it reminds me how close I was to getting the Music Maestro onto the Bat-villain Idol. Maybe Pied Piper provided some inspiration to the writers?

Top 21 Results
Pied Piper 56 100%
Gorilla Grodd 52 93%
Professor Zoom 51 91%
The Shade 50 89%
Trickster I 50 89%
Mirror Master II 48 86%
Magenta 46 82%
Abra Kadabra 45 80%
Golden Glider 43 77%
The Turtle (Golden Age) 40 71%
Weather Wizard 40 71%
Peek-a-Boo 39 70%

Close to Being Eliminated
Rainbow Raider 38 68%
Captain Cold 37 66%
The Thinker (Golden Age) 37 66%
The Top 34 61%

Eliminated This Round
Captain Boomerang II 32 57%
Mirror Master 32 57%
Big Sir 31 55%
Captain Boomerang 31 55%
Dr. Alchemy 27 48%

As we are still miraculously at an even number or remaining character (16 total), next round will continue as the previous one. I expect to begin the next round tonight or tomorrow evening.

A bit surprised that we lost Mirror Master AND Captain Boomerang! And that Captain Cold was almost lost too. I always assumed THE Rogues would be topping this game.

Sad to see Big sir go, he was hilarious.

Happy that Piper is doing so well despite having more or less reformed. Also happy to see Grodd doing so well.

WOW the rogues got decimated. I'm also surprised.
Maybe I wasn't doing my diligence keeping them on the board? OR maybe we just aren't as enamored as Geoff Johns with them...

YAY for PIPER! Always an underused fave!

>whistles< I thought Mirror Master wouldn't be far off winning it. Boomerang, like so many others, I think I liked him best from Suicide Squad. But still very surprised to see him go out.

Of those that are left, I think Peekaboo is the only one I'm not familiar with.

Never actually read a story with Peek-a-boo in it either, but her profile makes her out to be quite a sympathetic character.

The next round's rules are the same as the previous one. I will begin a Wild Card Round as soon as we have an uneven number of remaining characters.

Top 16
Abra Kadabra
Captain Cold
Golden Glider
Gorilla Grodd
Magenta
Mirror Master II
Peek-a-Boo
Pied Piper
Professor Zoom
Rainbow Raider
The Shade
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
Trickster I
Weather Wizard

Abra Kadabra 5
Captain Cold 10
Golden Glider 5
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 8
Mirror Master II 5
Peek-a-Boo 8
Pied Piper 1
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 5
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Top 5
The Turtle (Golden Age) 5
Trickster I 1
Weather Wizard 7

Abra Kadabra 3
Captain Cold 1
Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 10
Mirror Master II 10
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 10
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 3
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 1

Abra Kadabra 10
Captain Cold 10
Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 1
Mirror Master II 10
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 8
The Shade 7
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Top 7
The Turtle (Golden Age) 7
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 10

Abra Kadabra 3
Captain Cold 8
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 7
Magenta 10
Mirror Master II 8
Peek-a-Boo 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 5
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 5
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 4
Trickster I 2
Weather Wizard 3

Abra Kadabra 1
Captain Cold 10
Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 1
Magenta 1
Mirror Master II 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 1
Rainbow Raider 10
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Top 10
The Turtle (Golden Age) 10
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 1

Abra Kadabra 1
Captain Cold 1
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 10
Mirror Master II 1
Peek-a-Boo 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 1
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 10

I'm sorry to see Mirror Master I go. I consider him the preeminent Barry Allen Flash villain and the most prominent of the pre-Crisis Rogues. I've never understood how such a major villain got such an unfitting, blink-and-you'll-miss-it death in Crisis.

Votes & Commentary:

Abra Kadabra...10 (Love an evil mustache.)
Captain Cold...1 (Same character archetype as Deadshot [for people who remember my criticism of him in 'Batman Villains Idol']. Not a fan).
Golden Glider...10 (For the longest time she was the ONLY female Flash villain. Loved her motivations too.)
Gorilla Grodd...1 (Respect him but he just doesn't excite me. Love Solovar and Gorilla City though.)
Magenta...1 (Not a Flash villain IMO.)
Mirror Master II...1 (I rarely prefer a legacy character to the original.)
Peek-a-Boo...1 (Never read her in anything. Very surprised she's still here. She seems fun though.)
Pied Piper...1 (I like him but I like others more.)
Professor Zoom...10 (Great costume and star of some great stories.)
Rainbow Raider...10 (What's not to love?!?)
The Shade...1 (Not a Flash villain IMO.)
The Thinker (Golden Age)...1 (Not a Flash villain IMO.)
The Top...10 (He intrigues me. Major character deaths were so rare pre-Crisis that I'm very fascinated by all those who did die.)
The Turtle (Golden Age)...1 (Not super familiar with this character.)
Trickster I...10 (Probably one of the least flashy Rogues, ironically. Has had some really good stories but none have them have been too famous. I like quiet achievers.)
Weather Wizard...10 (Amazing collar! I think he might have been one of the first Flash villains I read about too.)

Abra Kadabra 10
Captain Cold 8
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 1
Mirror Master II 1
Peek-a-Boo 1
Pied Piper 1
Professor Zoom 5
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 5
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Top 1
The Turtle (Golden Age) 1
Trickster I 1
Weather Wizard 1

As they say, apes sell more comics and Gorilla Grodd is no exception.

Gorilla Grodd 59 100%
Trickster I 54 92%
Pied Piper 53 90%
The Shade 53 90%
Professor Zoom 52 88%
Captain Cold 49 83%
Golden Glider 48 81%
Abra Kadabra 43 73%
Weather Wizard 43 73%
Magenta 42 71%
Rainbow Raider 42 71%

Almost Eliminated
Mirror Master II 37 63%
The Thinker (Golden Age) 37 63%
The Top 36 61%

Eliminated
Peek-a-Boo 33 56%
The Turtle (Golden Age) 30 51%


So we have a total of 14 characters remaining. I will admit to wishing it was uneven numbers so we could start the Wild Card Round.

Yay Grodd! Yay Piper!

Poor Peek-a-Boo, but then I think she would make a better supporting character than a full villain

I'm sure you've explained it at some point, Emily, but can I please ask how the percentage works?

I used to think that 100% meant that a character had gotten the maximum number of points, but that's obviously not the case.

Thanks.

I thought so too. Maybe it is the percentage of the total number of points players gave during the round.

^ I don't follow IB?

My guess is, Emily adds the total number of points each player gives..like if I gave 10 points each o 5 characters, my total is 50 points.

But then that would not make sense either...

I adopted the method that RexFactor Podcast uses to calculate their Reign scores; they divide the number of years by that of the longest living monarch ((at the time it was Queen Victoria). So, yes, 100% is the one with the most amount of points from that round. I divide the rest of the scores against the character who has the most points per round.

Here is how I do it:

1) I make a column for each player and write the points they voted for. If there are any errors, it probably comes from this process, because if I miss one number or enter one incorrectly, then the whole chain can be thrown off.

2) I AutoSum all the results (I use Excel).

3) I hide all the data I used to get the AutoSums.

4) I Filter the scores/characters from highest to lowest.

5) I copy and paste that to here and add all the colors.

Thanks Emily. That's an interesting calculation method and I'm still not sure I fully understand it, but that's probably more due to me being mathematically-challenged than anything to do with your explanation.

I like how this method takes into account how far away each character is from the one who got the most points. It is not just a straight ranking thing.

Thanks, Emily

You do an awesome job

Thank you all for your compliments and participation. I could not have done it without your help. I am happy with the turnout, and hope you will all be here when the LSV Idol starts in May. Then we are going to have a Spider-Villain Idol in the summer so I can keep my sanity...it is a lot easier to create Marvel-based games because they have more information available online.

I have decided that once we have less than 10 players, we will do a Wildcard Round irregardless if whether or not we have uneven numbers.

Top 14
Abra Kadabra
Captain Cold
Golden Glider
Gorilla Grodd
Magenta
Mirror Master II
Pied Piper
Professor Zoom
Rainbow Raider
The Shade
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Top
Trickster I
Weather Wizard

Abra Kadabra 1
Captain Cold 10
Golden Glider 5
Gorilla Grodd 5
Magenta 10
Mirror Master II 10
Pied Piper 5
Professor Zoom 8
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 3
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Top 3
Trickster I 5
Weather Wizard 7

Abra Kadabra 10
Captain Cold 10
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 1
Mirror Master II 1
Pied Piper 1
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Top 1
Trickster I 1
Weather Wizard 1

Abra Kadabra...10
Captain Cold...1
Golden Glider...10
Gorilla Grodd...1
Magenta...1
Mirror Master II...1
Pied Piper...1
Professor Zoom...10
Rainbow Raider...10
The Shade...1
The Thinker (Golden Age)...1
The Top...10
Trickster I...10
Weather Wizard...10

Abra Kadabra 4
Captain Cold 5
Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 4
Magenta 4
Mirror Master II 6
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 4
Rainbow Raider 10
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
The Top 10
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 5

These are a lot harder to differentiate between them because I like MOST of them... Argh!

Abra Kadabra 1
Captain Cold 1
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 10
Mirror Master II 1
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 1
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Top 1
Trickster I 1
Weather Wizard 10

Abra Kadabra 1
Captain Cold 1
Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 10
Mirror Master II 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 10
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
The Top 1
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 1

I am extending this round 24 hours due to illness. Please submit any last minute votes by tomorrow at 5:30 P.M Central Time.

Feel better soon, Emily.

Feel better, Em!

(Professor) Zooming well wishes to you Emily.

Get well soon Emily

The results are both golden and dark as The Shade won this round.

The Shade 44 100%
Professor Zoom 43 98%
Gorilla Grodd 40 91%
Golden Glider 37 84%
Pied Piper 37 84%
Trickster I 37 84%
Magenta 36 82%

Close to Elimination
Weather Wizard 34 77%
Rainbow Raider 33 75%
The Thinker (Golden Age) 33 75%

Eliminated this Round
Mirror Master II 29 66%
Captain Cold 28 64%
Abra Kadabra 27 61%
The Top 26 59%

Next round will begin later tonight or tomorrow morning. I am getting puzzled by the round even numbers.

Wow, I thought Captain Cold would do better. He often seemed like the foremost Rogue (and I thought his TV appearances would have helped0.

Still surprised at how well Golden Glider is doing!

Female characters seem to do well in idols.

* Obviously this isn't replicated in the wider world. Because that would mean readers are interested in female characters and >gasp< the books may attract a female audience.*

Cold, Kadabra, Mirror Master... it'll be a tough wild card round if we get one, just like last time.



*need an emoticon for dripping with sarcasm.

Last Round before the Wild Card Round. We will do Write-In Votes for the Wild Card Run, and I will explain the rules for that when the time comes.

Top 10
Golden Glider
Gorilla Grodd
Magenta
Pied Piper
Professor Zoom
Rainbow Raider
The Shade
The Thinker (Golden Age)
Trickster I
Weather Wizard

Golden Glider...10
Gorilla Grodd...1
Magenta...1
Pied Piper...1
Professor Zoom...10
Rainbow Raider...10
The Shade...1
The Thinker (Golden Age)...1
Trickster I...10
Weather Wizard...10

Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 9
Rainbow Raider 9
The Shade 8
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 5

Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 1
Rainbow Raider 10
The Shade 1
The Thinker (Golden Age) 1
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 1

Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 6
Magenta 1
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 5
Rainbow Raider 10
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 8
Trickster I 8
Weather Wizard 5

Jumping in here...

Golden Glider...5
Gorilla Grodd...10
Magenta...1
Pied Piper...1
Professor Zoom...10
Rainbow Raider...1
The Shade...2
The Thinker (Golden Age)...3
Trickster I...10
Weather Wizard...7

Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Magenta 1
Pied Piper 1
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 1
The Shade 10
The Thinker (Golden Age) 10
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 10

Sorry for the delay in tallying votes. I will try to tally votes tomorrow evening. In the meantime, start preparing for the Wild Card Round.

Wild Card Round Instructions
1. Read all the Submissions before yours so that you do not suggest the same character.
2. Write the name of the character you wish to enter into the Round. Please include the version of the character.
3. The list will be finalized within three days of when the Wild Card Round starts.

It may be too late to join, but I'll have fun voting regardless...

Golden Glider: 10
Gorilla Grodd: 10
Magenta: 2
Pied Piper: 9
Professor Zoom: 10
Rainbow Raider: 6
The Shade: 1
The Thinker (Golden Age): 1
Trickster I: 5
Weather Wizard: 7

I am delaying voting again by 24 hours because I was in the middle of tallying the votes. I am frustrated by the Excel spreadsheet and am in no mood to tally them again.

I'm sorry, I hope that wasn't b/c I posted right then, please disregard!

To be honest, I was having trouble before I got your submission. I forgot to copy and paste one of the characters onto the list, so I would have had to go back and manually calculate those anyways. If I wait a bit, I will calm down and be able to just copy and paste everything manually tomorrow.

Oh, I am truly sorry, that sucks, I know how maddening spreadsheets can be! I just found the game and got excited, and mis-read the date of your post about tallying votes the next evening (i.e., thought I had time). Good luck on compiling the submissions, and many thanks for doing it!

At least you got to join before the game ends, Rokk! I think we'll still have a few more rounds before the end.

Good to see you here Rokk! Did Emily vote in this round? Silly gadget on train making scrolling awkward...

I apologize for the delays.

Trickster I 63 100%
Gorilla Grodd 57 90%
Professor Zoom 55 87%
Weather Wizard 54 86%
Golden Glider 47 75%
Rainbow Raider 47 75%

Close to Elimination
Pied Piper 42 67%

Eliminated This Round
The Shade 33 52%
Magenta 26 41%
The Thinker (Golden Age) 25 40%


Does everyone understand the rules I posted for the Wild Card Round? Do you want me to re-post the list of all the characters that were eliminated or is that unnecessary? If I receive no messages by the time I go to bed (11:00 PM Central Time), I will start the Wild Card Round.

You will be able to nominate three characters, as three have been eliminated.

Noooooo Piper! So close!

We are losing the shades of gray villains too.

I recommend reposting the list and rules Emily, for greater clarity
.thanks for running this

Wild Card Round Instructions
1. Read all the Submissions before yours so that you do not suggest the same character.
2. Write the name of the characters you wish to enter into the Round. Please include the version of each of the characters.
3. The list will be finalized within three days of when the Wild Card Round starts.

**Added Instruction**

4. After list is posted, pick three from the overall list.

For Your Reference
Abra Kadabra
Alexander Petrov
Atom Smasher (Golden Age)
Baroness Blitzkrieg
Big Sir
Black Flash
Blacksmith
Boleslav Uminski
Borther Grimm
Brain
Caliber (Team Turmoil)
Captain Boomerang
Captain Boomerang II
Captain Cold
Captain Cold (New 52)
Changeling
Chillbaine
Christina Alexandrova
Chunk
Cicada
Clive Yorkin
Cobalt Blue
Colonel Computron
Commander Cold
Double Down
Dr. Alchemy
Edward
Eradicator
Fallout
Folded Man
Girder
Glider (New 52)
Goldface
Gregor Gregorovich
Griffin
Heat Wave (New 52)
Heatstroke
Heatwave
Inerita
Katmos
Kilg%re
Last Resort
Magenta
Mazdan
Miasma (Team Turmoil)
Mirror Master
Mirror Master II
Mirror Monarch
Mob Rule
Mr. Frost
Mr.Element I
Mr.Element II
Murmur
Peel-a-Boo
Plunder
President Thaddeus Thawne
Psykon
Rag Doll
Razer
Replicant
Ring master
Rudolph West
Rumble (Team Turmoil)
Saber-Tooth
Savitar
Speed Demon
Spin
Star Sapphire
Steve Palmer
Tar Pit
The Alchemist
The Anti Monitor
The Combine
The Eel (Golden Age)
The Gambler
The Rival
The Shade
The Suit
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Thinker (Modern Age)
The Thorn
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
The Viper
Top (Renegade Version)
Trickster II
Trixster
Urtumi
Vandal Savage
Weather Warlock
Weather Wizard (New 52)
White Lightning
Wildside (Team Turmoil)
Zoom (Hunter Zoloman)
Zyklon

Christina Alexandrovna
Mirror Master II
Vandal Savage

Abra Kadabra
Dr. Alchemy
Mirror Master I

Captain Boomerang
Captain Cold
Heatwave

Blacksmith
Rag Doll
The Eel (Golden Age)

The Shade
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Turtle (Golden Age)

I will post the list later tonight to give IB some more time. It is not like him to miss sessions.

Happy Birthday Fanfic Lady! I have Captain Cold pick you up an ice cream cake.

I will add mine now:

The Top
Plunder
Peek-A-Boo

Total List (Vote for three)
Abra Kadabra
Christina Alexandrovna
Blacksmith
Captain Boomerang
Captain Cold
Dr. Alchemy
Heatwave
Mirror Master I
Mirror Master II
Plunder
Peek-A-Boo
Rag Doll
The Eel (Golden Age)
The Shade
The Thinker (Golden Age)
The Top
The Turtle (Golden Age)
Vandal Savage

Rag Doll
The Top
The Shade

A question: do we have to vote for three different ones this time?



Thank you, Emily. I adore ice cream cakes.

No, you can always vote for the ones you suggested. If we get a lot of ties, I will use the Random Generator to chose the winner.

Okay. Thanks, Emily.

Christina Alexandrova
Mirror Master II
Vandal Savage

Captain Boomerang
Captain Cold
Mirror Master II

The Top
Dr. Alchemy
Abra Kadabra

Abra Kadabra
Peek-a-Boo
Mirror Master II

Thanks for sending me a message Emily! Could not think of anyone I really wanted to add in so I missed the earlier round.

Abra
Mirror Master I
Captain Cold

My votes:

The Top
Christina Alexandrova
Peek-A-Boo

The characters that got the most votes are Abra Kadabra, Mirror Master II, and the Top. They will be re-added back to the list of winners of the last normal round. The next round will start either tonight or tomorrow. Since it is already April, there will be no more Wild Card Rounds and any ties will be broken by Random Number Generators.

Yay! One of my choices made the cut!

I always preferred Evan McCulloch as Mirror Master to Sam Scudder as Mirror Master. He's such a bastard, but in a love-to-hate-him way IMO.

Final Ten

Abra Kadabra
Golden Glider
Gorilla Grodd
Mirror Master II
Pied Piper
Professor Zoom
Rainbow Raider
The Top
Trickster I
Weather Wizard

Scale is still 1-10.

Abra Kadabra 1
Golden Glider 9
Gorilla Grodd 9
Mirror Master II 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 9
Rainbow Raider 9
The Top 1
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 1

That's a pretty good top ten!

Abra Kadabra 5
Golden Glider 10
Gorilla Grodd 5
Mirror Master II 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 5
The Top 5
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 10

Abra Kadabra...10
Golden Glider...10
Gorilla Grodd...1
Mirror Master II...1
Pied Piper...1
Professor Zoom...10
Rainbow Raider...10
The Top...10
Trickster I...10
Weather Wizard...10

Abra Kadabra 10
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Mirror Master II 1
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 1
Rainbow Raider 10
The Top 1
Trickster I 1
Weather Wizard 10

Very cool crew of villains

Abra Kadabra 4
Golden Glider 9
Gorilla Grodd 5
Mirror Master II 5
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 3
Rainbow Raider 10
The Top 7
Trickster I 10
Weather Wizard 6

Abra Kadabra 10
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Mirror Master II 1
Pied Piper 1
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 1
The Top 1
Trickster I 1
Weather Wizard 1

I do want to note that it is interesting the the expected high score winners, like Joker and Captain Cold didn't make it to the Semi-Finals. I guess different tastes here than on other sites.

I want to apologize for all the delays. For the LSV Idol, I am going to get a co-host to cover for me when I am busy. If any of you are interested, please send me a PM ASAP. May is approaching quickly, and I want to stick to my timeline. LSV Idol will start exactly one month from when we finish this game, but the planning thread will probably be a week in advance.

Final Ten

Rainbow Raider 45 100%
Professor Zoom 43 96%
Pied Piper 42 93%
Trickster 42 93%
Abra Kadabra 40 89%
Golden Glider 40 89%
Gorilla Grodd 40 89%
Weather Wizard 38 84%

Eliminated this Round
Mirror Master II 28 62%
The Top 25 56%

The next round will begin tonight or tomorrow morning.

I think every Idol game that's been played on Legion World has had a slightly offbeat winner (except maybe the JLA one).

Legion Worlders tend to have non-mainstream tastes. It's probably what makes us Legion fans.

I agree. Titans Idol top 3 were Kole, Flamebird and Wally. Multiverse Legion Idol saw most Adventure Era Legionnaires eliminated before Top25.

I love these types of games on Legion World. So many surprises.

I've run Idols before, but your rules and format are quite different from mine, Emily. I don't mind the delays, though.

I also prefer running Hero Idols to Villain ones. I've been thinking of doing a Justice Society/All-Star Squadron Idol, in fact! (I just won't acronym it... JSA/ASS doesn't sound quite right...)

That would almost complete the super-teams with memberships big enough to warrant their own idols (LSH, Titans, JLA).

Ugh, I am late again! The next round starts now.

Final Eight
Abra Kadabra
Golden Glider
Gorilla Grodd
Pied Piper
Professor Zoom
Rainbow Raider
Trickster
Weather Wizard

My Votes:

Abra Kadabra 1
Golden Glider 2
Gorilla Grodd 5
Pied Piper 1
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 1
Trickster 3
Weather Wizard 10

Abra Kadabra 1
Golden Glider 9
Gorilla Grodd 8
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 7
Rainbow Raider 7
Trickster 10
Weather Wizard 6

Abra Kadabra 1
Golden Glider 9
Gorilla Grodd 6
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 4
Rainbow Raider 9
Trickster 10
Weather Wizard 3

Abra Kadabra 10
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Pied Piper 1
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 1
Trickster 1
Weather Wizard 1

Abra Kadabra 1
Golden Glider 5
Gorilla Grodd 5
Pied Piper 5
Professor Zoom 10
Rainbow Raider 1
Trickster 10
Weather Wizard 10

Abra Kadabra 1
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 10
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 1
Rainbow Raider 1
Trickster 1
Weather Wizard 1

Abra Kadabra...10
Golden Glider...10
Gorilla Grodd...1
Pied Piper...1
Professor Zoom...1
Rainbow Raider...10
Trickster...10
Weather Wizard...10

Abra Kadabra 4
Golden Glider 1
Gorilla Grodd 9
Pied Piper 10
Professor Zoom 8
Rainbow Raider 2
Trickster 7
Weather Wizard 6

Has anyone heard from Dave lately?

Also, any interest in a classic text based RPG?

I have seen Dave on Facebook. He seems to be doing fine, though it has been a week since he posted there. Would you like to PM him?

I enjoy a good text based RPG but it would depend on the time commitment

IB: I saw that he posted today, so I used the Shout Box. If that does not work, I will PM him tomorrow.

Myg: It would largely depend on setting. I'm thinking either 1) Generic Fantasy 2) Medieval Ages or 3) Marvel Universe.

I tried contacting Dave, but received no response, so I have to keep the game moving. I already have another possible delay as I will be out of town Friday-Saturday. I asked a Mod to substitute for me, so hopefully that will work out. We are almost to the Semi-Finals.

Apes do sell covers!

Gorilla Grodd 54 100%
Trickster 52 96%
Professor Zoom 51 94%
Pied Piper 48 89%
Weather Wizard 47 87%

Eliminated this Round
Golden Glider 38 70% <- I am pleasantly surprised how well she did.

Rainbow Raider 32 59%
Abra Kadabra 29 54%

Scale for Top 5 will be changed to 1-5. The Semi-Finals start either tonight or tomorrow evening.

<cry> Those results hurt. Three of my faves. On the plus side, Rainbow Raider lasted MUCH longer than I thought he would.

Oh Rainbow Raider, I had a soft spot for him.

The Rainbow Raider was the first supervillain to really take a stand for Pride flags everywhere

Gorilla Grodd 1
Trickster 5
Professor Zoom 5
Pied Piper 3
Weather Wizard 1

Semi-Finals Voting is in Session

My votes:

Gorilla Grodd 5
Trickster 2
Professor Zoom 5
Pied Piper 48 1
Weather Wizard 3

Gorilla Grodd 5
Trickster 1
Professor Zoom 5
Pied Piper 1
Weather Wizard 1

Low numbers for both Trickster and Pied Piper who both had their spells as almost good guys! Not villainy enough! Weather Wizard nabbed his brother's invention, so he's not in the same class (despite nice visual effects) as Grodd and Zoom.

Gorilla Grodd 3
Trickster 5
Professor Zoom 3
Pied Piper 4
Weather Wizard 1

Gorilla Grodd 5
Trickster 1
Professor Zoom 1
Pied Piper 5
Weather Wizard 1

Gorilla Grodd...1
Trickster...5
Professor Zoom...5
Pied Piper...1
Weather Wizard...5

Gorilla Grodd 3
Trickster 5
Professor Zoom 1
Pied Piper 4
Weather Wizard 2

The winner this round is Professor Zoom. Since there are only five characters yet, I am not going to bother with percents.

Professor Zoom 25
Gorilla Grodd 23
Trickster 24

Eliminated
Pied Piper 19
Weather Wizard 17

I asked thoth lad to substitute for me when I go on vacation later today. Please start the next round either later tonight or tomorrow.

Flash Rogues Idol Final Round!

You’ve voted to reduce the field to our three finalists. But who will win Flash Rogues Idol?

Give each of the finalists points between 1 and 3 and we’ll find out!

Flash Rogue Finalists

In alphabetical order…

Gorilla Grodd
Professor Zoom
Trickster

Gorilla Grodd 2
Professor Zoom 1
Trickster 3

Gorilla Grodd 2
Professor Zoom 1
Trickster 3

Gorilla Grodd 1
Professor Zoom 2
Trickster 3

Gorilla Grodd...1
Professor Zoom...3 (unless we're meant to rank them in between 1 & 3, in which case make it 2)
Trickster...3

Yes, you can have 1,2 or 3 when allocating points.

Aw bye Piper...

Gorilla Grodd 3
Professor Zoom 1
Trickster 1

Gorilla Grodd 3 - He's a genus level gorilla supervillain with telepathic powers and a background that includes aliens. He is everything cool about the Silver Age.

Professor Zoom 2 - science fiction, time travel and super villainy for Barry Allen's dark nemesis.

Trickster 1 - Lots of fun visual gimmicks, but his time doing heroic things loses him some points for me.

Final Round Update!

The Trickster maintains a slender lead, but it's been cut back by recent support for Grodd. Can The Trickster hold on? Close behind both is Professor Zoom. Can the man with super speed ever be ruled out of a race to the finish line?

It's certainly close enough that only a couple of posts will make a difference!

Silver/Bronze Age Gorilla Grodd was awesome. Unfortunately, the 90s/00s happened and Grodd, like other formerly awesome characters like Killer Croc, Killer Moth and The Shark, became monster-fied and seemed to be unpleasantly depicted eating people in every other appearance. That kind of portrayal ruined all of those characters for me.

Oh wow. Thanks, Blacula. I found the new "eat people" tactic a bit cheap and lurid, and my fondness for these characters dimmed. Glad I'm not alone.

I'm only familiar with Silver Age Grodd, not Modern. Sigh. They had to go ruin a good thing... Why would he need to eat people?!?!