Multiverse Legion Idol 2024! (We have a winner!!)

OPEN FOR DISCUSSION ON THE LIST OF LEGIONNAIRES!

Hey gang! So a while back, it was popular to play Survivor type games on the forums. We start with a list, and vote out folks we don't like.

I started to do the opposite with Idol type games - where we vote for those we DO like. I thought it would be more positive, and potentially give us more surprising results.

Which it kinda did.

We had Reboot Legion Idol, Triad, XS, Gates, Kinetix and Umbra were the top 5, while Cosmic Boy and Kid Quantum II (both fairly prominent, and having been leaders) were 26th and 27th.

Preboot Legion Idol White Witch, Bouncing Boy, Brainiac 5, Chemical King and Shrinking Violet were the top 5! Polar Boy and Nightwind were 6 and 7. Matter-Eater Lad made the top 10, Spider-Girl crept into 11, and Superboy only came out to #41!

then we had the first edition of Multiverse Legion Idol , where... gasp... Kinetix won... (most likely because she faced off against Preboot Saturn Girl and Preboot Karate Kid in the final, so naturally Reboot fans gravitated towards Zoe!

SW6 Dragonmage made it to 8th place, while many Preboot stalwarts like Cosmic Boy, Shrinking Violet and Sun Boy were eliminated in Round 3.

We've also had Titans Idol (where Kole beat Wally West and Flamebird in the final),

and Justice League Idol top 3 of Barry Allen, Black Canary and Hawkgirl/Hawkwoman

and a JSA Idol top 3 of Doctor Fate (Kent), original Huntress, and Ma Hunkle!

and a whole bunch of villain Idols run by Emily Sivana too!

anyway, enough about the background.

Idol Games typically run like this:

We have a few "elimination" rounds, where folks vote for a massive list of up to 100 characters. Characters who get at least 2 votes will move on to the next round.

Once the list is manageable enough, we begin with ranking. I'll ask folks to rank their top 5/10/15/20/25, and award points based on ranking. e.g., your #1 gets 50 points, #2 gets 40 points, and so on. The Top X-number of characters, based on total points, move on to the next round. And we keep going until we crown our winner - the last round always contains 3 folks.

We also usually have 1 or 2 resurrection rounds, where folks can vote for a number of eliminated characters to come back. (we've had some resurrected characters win big!) in Preboot Idol, Chemical King first got kicked out as 21, was brought back in the coming resurrection round, and ended up as #4 overall.

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 48 hours.
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing.

whew!

so for anyone interested, I'll open this thread with my initial list (taken from the last Multiverse Idol, and updated for recent appearances). As the first 1-3 rounds will be massive eliminations, I'm inclined to be very liberal in including folks!

this list covers the following realities:

Arrowverse
Arthurian Legion
Bendisboot
DC Animated Universe
Dead Earth
Glorithverse/5YL
JLA Trapped in Time
Legion 1 Million
Legion Animated Movie
Legion Toon (and Comic)
Preboot
Reboot
Retroboot
Smallville
Superboy's Legion
SW6
Threeboot
Young Justice

Here is the initial list - it is open for comments re are we missing any realities, or any Legionnaires? Are any code names confusing, and should I add some real names or other identifiers? Are the reality names clear, or should I clarify some?

list is organized alphabetically, by reality. please refer to the post above, for the list of realities represented.

Arrowverse

Brainiac 5
Chameleon
Dream Girl
Karate Kid
Lightning Lass
Mon-El
Saturn Girl
Toyman

Arthurian Legion

Alchemist
Andromeda
Brainiac 5
Chameleon
Computo
Cosmic Boy
Dragonmage
Dream Girl
Ferro
Infectious Lass
Inferno
Invisible Kid I
Invisible Kid II
Karate Kid I
Leviathan
Live Wire
Matter-Eater Lad
Nemesis Kid
Polar Boy
Saturn Girl
Shrinking Violet
Spark
Triad
Ultra Boy
Umbra

Bendisboot

Blok
Bouncing Boy
Brainiac 5
Chameleon Boy
Colossal Boy
Computo
Cosmic Boy
Dawnstar
Doctor Fate
Dream Girl
Element Lad
Entropy Kid
Ferro Lad
Gold Lantern
Invisible Kid
Karate Kid
Lightning Lad
Lightning Lass
Matter-Eater Lad
Mon-el
Monster Boy
Phantom Girl
Princess Projectra
Radius Lad
Saturn Girl
Shadow Lass
Shrinking Violet
Star Boy
Sun Boy
Superboy (Jon)
Timber Wolf
Triplicate Girl
Ultra Boy
White Witch
Wildfire
X-Ray Girl

DC Animated Universe

Andromeda
Bouncing Boy
Brainiac 5
Chameleon Boy
Cosmic Boy
Kid Quantum
Phantom Girl
Saturn Girl
Supergirl

Dead Earth

Argent
Graft
Lodestone
Magno Boy
Membrain
Metrox
Nervosa
Phase
Shape
Shift
Silverwing
Triad III
Triplicate
Wildfire

Glorithverse/5YL

Atmos
Bloodclaw
Bouncing Boy
Bounty entity
Brainiac 5
Calamity King
Chameleon Boy
Chlorophyll Kid
Color Kid
Colossal Boy
Cosmic Boy
Crystal Kid
Dawnstar
Dream Girl
Duo Damsel
Echo
Element Lad
Fire Lad
Firefist
Flederweb
Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
Infectious Lass
Invisible Kid II
Karate Kid II
Kono
Laurel Gand
Lightning Lad (Proty)
Lightning Lass
Matter-Eater Lad
Mon-el
Neon (Celeste Rockfish)
Nightwind
Polar Boy
Porcupine Pete
Queen Projectra
Reflecto
Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
Rond Vidar
Saturn Girl
Shadow Lass
Shrinking Violet
Spider-Girl
Star Boy
Stone Boy
Storm Boy
Sun Boy
Timber Wolf
Tyroc
Ultra Boy
Valor
Veilmist
Visi-Lad
White Witch
Wildfire

JLA Trapped in Time

Dawnstar
Karate Kid

Legion 1 Million

Brainiac 417
Cosmicbot
Implicate Girl
Superboy
The Chameleon
The Dreamer
The M'Onelves
The Umbra
Titangirl
Wildflame

Legion Animated Movie

Andromeda
Arm-Fall-Off-Boy
Atmos
Blok
Bouncing Boy
Brainiac 5
Catspaw
Chameleon Boy
Chemical King
Color Kid
Comet Queen
Cosmic Boy
Dawnstar
Dream Girl
Element Lad
Ferro Lad
Gates
Gold Lantern
Invisible Kid
Karate Kid
Kid Quantum II
Kinetix
Lightning Lad
Mon-El
Monstress
Phantom Girl
Polar Boy
Power Boy
Quislet
Saturn Girl
Sensor Girl
Shadow Lass
Star Boy
Stone Boy
Supergirl
Superman
Tellus
Timber Wolf
Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
Tyroc
Wildfire

Legion Toon (and Comic)

Blok
Bouncing Boy
Brainiac 5
Chameleon Boy
Chemical King
Chlorophyll Kid
Color Kid
Colossal Boy
Cosmic Boy
Dawnstar
Dream Girl
Element Lad
Ferro Lad
Infectious Lass
Invisible Kid
Karate Kid
Lightning Lad
Matter-Eater Lad
Nemesis Kid
Night Girl
Phantom Girl
Polar Boy
Porcupine Pete
Saturn Girl
Shrinking Violet
Star Boy
Stone Boy
Sun Boy
Superman
Superman X
Timber Wolf
Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
Tyroc
Ultra Boy
White Witch
XS

Preboot

Anti-Lad
Beppo
Blok
Bouncing Boy
Brainiac 5
Chameleon Boy
Chemical King
Colossal Boy
Comet
Command Kid
Cosmic Boy
Dawnstar
Dream Girl
Dynamo Boy
Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen)
Element Lad
Ferro Lad
Insect Queen (Lana Lang)
Invisible Kid I
Invisible Kid II
Karate Kid
Kid Psycho
Krypto
Light(ning) Lass
Lightning Lad
Magnetic Kid
Matter-Eater Lad
Mon-el
Nemesis Kid
Pete Ross
Phantom Girl
Polar Boy
Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
Proty II
Quislet
Rond Vidar
Saturn Girl
Shadow Lass
Shrinking Violet
Star Boy
Streaky
Sun Boy
Superboy
Supergirl
Tellus
Timber Wolf
Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
Tyroc
Ultra Boy
White Witch
Wildfire

Reboot

Andromeda
Apparition
Brainiac 5
Chameleon
Chuck Taine
Cosmic Boy
Dreamer
Element Lad
Ferro
Gates
Gear
Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
Invisible Kid
Karate Kid
Kid Quantum I
Kid Quantum II
Kinetix
Leviathan
Live Wire
Magno
M'Onel
Monstress
Saturn Girl
Sensor
Shikari
Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
Spark
Star Boy
Superboy (Kon-el)
Thunder
Timber Wolf
Triad
Ultra Boy
Umbra
Wildfire
XS

Retroboot

Black Witch
Blok
Bouncing Boy
Brainiac 5
Chameleon Boy
Chameleon Girl
Chemical Kid
Colossal Boy
Comet Queen
Cosmic Boy
Dawnstar
Dragonwing
Dream Girl
Duplicate Damsel
Earth-Man
Element Lad
Gates
Glorith
Harmonia Li
Invisible Kid II
Karate Kid
Lightning Lad
Lightning Lass
Matter-Eater Lad
Mon-el
Night Girl
Phantom Girl
Polar Boy
Quislet
Rond Vidar
Saturn Girl
Sensor Girl
Shadow Lass
Shrinking Violet
Star Boy
Sun Boy
Superman
Tellus
Timber Wolf
Tyroc
Ultra Boy
Wildfire

Smallville

Brainiac 5
Clark Kent
Cosmic Boy
Lightning Lad
Saturn Girl

Superboy's Legion

Bouncing Boy
Brainiac 5
Chameleon Boy
Colossal Boy
Cosmic Boy
Element Lad
Ferro Lad
Invisible Kid
Karate Kid
Light Lass
Lightning Lad
Phantom Girl
Saturn Girl
Sensor
Shadow Lass
Shrinking Violet
Star Boy
Sun Boy
Superboy
Ultra Boy

SW6

Alchemist
Andromeda
Apparition
Bouncing Boy
Brainiac 5
Catspaw
Chameleon Boy
Computo
Cosmic Boy
Dragonmage
Dream Girl
Ferro
Gossamer
Inferno
Invisible Kid
Karate Kid
Kid Quantum
Leviathan
Live Wire
Matter-Eater Lad
Princess Projectra
Saturn Girl
Shrinking Violet
Star Boy
Triad
Ultra Boy
Valor

Threeboot

Atom Girl
Brainiac 5
Chameleon
Colossal Boy/ Micro Lad
Cosmic Boy
Dream Boy
Dream Girl
Element Lad
Gazelle
Invisible Kid
Karate Kid
Light Lass
Lightning Lad
Mon-el
Night Girl
Phantom Girl
Princess Projectra
Saturn Girl
Shadow Lass
Sizzle
Star Boy
Sun Boy
Supergirl
Theena
Timber Wolf
Triplicate Girl
Turtle
Ultra Boy

Young Justice

Chameleon Boy
Phantom Girl
Saturn Girl

Wow! That's... a lot! Thanks for making this ginormous list!

Are Preboot and Retroboot more or less the same characters? Not sure if the changes to characterization, costumes and even powers, in some cases (Duplicate Damsel comes to mind, but also Tyroc) count sufficiently to be considered separate characters.

thanks, Set! most of the list was already there during the first edition

It's a really good Q, if Preboot and Retroboot should be merged or not. I think some, like Brainiac 5 and Lightning Lad, had fairly big differences Preboot and Retro - but enough to be different, I don't know. I'm happy to merge Preboot and Retro.

it's also Preboot and Glorithverse/5YL where I'm in doubt, TBH. Mon-El vs. Valor had super big differences, and of course Tenzil's personality 5YL was really different, but am not sure if that warrants having Preboot and Glorith separate (other than that: if we merge Preboot and Retroboot together, than how else would 5YL be represented?)

SW6 should definitely be split out, as they were a different team and different individuals.

so on the table: merging Preboot with Retroboot, and maybe merging 5YL in too!

I would definitely count those three as distinct (though "preboot" might not be the best name?) If anything I'd consider adding in the Adult Legion as an additional group, though it's arguable the we don't see enough of them to really get a feel for them as distinct individuals (especially since many known members never appear on panel in that version).

I suppose an alternative to merging Preboot/Retroboot/5YL would be just to only list the new/changed characters under Retroboot/5YL. Probably have some debate about which were changed.

Good point about Adult Legion. Although their appearances were limited they were in more comics than Arthurian Legion or Superboy's Legion. Still they were often cameos so perhaps harder to judge. Also not all of the appearances were consistent with each other. Not sure what to do there.

if we do keep all groups separate, I'd just list each Legionnaire - then we don't have to go through the exercise of determining which ones are different enough. in any case, the first 1-3 rounds are major elimination ones, so the list would be trimmed down pretty quickly.

Adult Legion - happy to add as a distinct group. I think we can just make one set of Legionnaires for that, no need to track down each distinct Adult Legion and make each separate.

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

I would definitely count those three as distinct (though "preboot" might not be the best name?)

If not Preboot, what name? Original? Pre-5YL?

Adult Legion, initial list:

Batman
Bouncing Man
Brainiac 5
Chemical King
Color King
Colossal Man
Cosmic Man
Dream Woman
Duo Damsel
Duplicate Boy
Element Man
Ferro Lad
Ferro Lad II
Karate King
Lex Luthor V
Light Lady
Lightning Man
Matter-Eater Man
Mxyzptlk V
Night Woman
Phantom Woman
Polar Man
Power Boy
Quantum Queen
Reflecto
Saturn Woman
Shadow Woman
Shrinking Violet
Star Man
Superman
Timber Wolf
Ultra Man
White Witch

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

I would definitely count those three as distinct (though "preboot" might not be the best name?)

If not Preboot, what name? Original? Pre-5YL?[/quote]

Definitely not "original", as that can be kind of contentious. The problem with "preboot" is that means "pre-Reboot", which should include 5YL, so "pre-5YL" is probably a better description. I would almost go for "pre-Crisis" or "Earth-One", but the problem with that is that much of the Baxter series occurs post-Crisis, and even though pre- and post-Crisis are separate realtities, the changes between those two probably aren't enough to warrant a separate listing. I don't know. Maybe I'm just overthinking it.

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

Definitely not "original", as that can be kind of contentious. The problem with "preboot" is that means "pre-Reboot", which should include 5YL, so "pre-5YL" is probably a better description. I would almost go for "pre-Crisis" or "Earth-One", but the problem with that is that much of the Baxter series occurs post-Crisis, and even though pre- and post-Crisis are separate realtities, the changes between those two probably aren't enough to warrant a separate listing. I don't know. Maybe I'm just overthinking it.

Classic? Golden/Silver Age?

Originally Posted by Set

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

Definitely not "original", as that can be kind of contentious. The problem with "preboot" is that means "pre-Reboot", which should include 5YL, so "pre-5YL" is probably a better description. I would almost go for "pre-Crisis" or "Earth-One", but the problem with that is that much of the Baxter series occurs post-Crisis, and even though pre- and post-Crisis are separate realtities, the changes between those two probably aren't enough to warrant a separate listing. I don't know. Maybe I'm just overthinking it.

Classic? Golden/Silver Age?

"Classic Legion." Like Classic Rock. I love it, and I'll second it. Good call, Set.

While I like the sound of classic, I think definition wise pre-5YL is the most precise. So I vote for that

Yeah, "classic" has a normative element to it, while I'd prefer something purely descriptive.

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

While I like the sound of classic, I think definition wise pre-5YL is the most precise. So I vote for that

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

Yeah, "classic" has a normative element to it, while I'd prefer something purely descriptive.

Fair enough, guys.

looks like we're agreed, thanks

I mean, if we're counting every version (and I mean all of them), what about Morrison's Action Comics Adult Legion - didn't that have mostly preboot-esque characters, but Snake-Sensor and Tasmia called "Umbra"?

Originally Posted by stile86

Good point about Adult Legion. Although their appearances were limited they were in more comics than Arthurian Legion or Superboy's Legion. Still they were often cameos so perhaps harder to judge. Also not all of the appearances were consistent with each other. Not sure what to do there.

I mean, if we're talking about cameos, the DCAU list gets squiffy. It appears to be based mostly on the postboot-like designs/lineup in the Superman episode (where characters like Andromeda & Kid Quantum were not only non-speaking, but appeared only in a still), but there was also the appearance from JLU that had more characters cameo (such as Timber Wolf & Blok), and a preboot-style aesthetic. Do you pare it down to only the characters who actually did stuff, or add all of them? [And did either version appear in tie-in comics?]

While it would be great if we make this list exhaustive, I'm going to cap it at "any other versions surfaced during the pre-game round of this thread"

As someone who has not been religiously following every appearance, I'm not in the best position to think of all of these.

this is also out of practicality - even if we list every single version ever, most will be eliminated in the first 3 rounds anyway. So I'd like to strike a balance between being complete, and being practical.

good point about the DCAU one. the list (which was built in the first Multiverse Legion Idol - so 2011 even!) indeed drew from that Superman episode. It can, and should, be expanded to include the JLU cameo. There was definitely one version that appeared in one issue of the JLU comic, which I think can be treated as same version.

for the Morrison's Action Comics Adult Legion, is that this group?

https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/m...ale-to-width-down/1000?cb=20190516035334

if so, I think they're different enough to warrant their own entry. But I will need help getting the full list, I'm struggling to find lists online.

So my proposals:

We get two "Adult Legion" listings. the current one is "Adult Legion (Adventure Era)".

the new one becomes "Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)", with initial membership listing of

Brainiac 5
Chameleon Man
Cosmic Man
Dream Woman
Lightning Man
Matter-Eater Man
Saturn Woman
Sensor
Umbra

and updated listing for the JLU-verse. Arrow and Lantern are there, because they were made Honorary members - as I've done through this list, confirmed Honorary and Reserve members get in. (I've also been a bit liberal in including Inferno (Sandy) on the Reboot list, even though she was never officially made even a Reservist, other than that one quote from Triad...)

Andromeda
Blok
Bouncing Boy
Brainiac 5
Chameleon Boy
Colossal Boy
Cosmic Boy
Douglas Nolan
Dream Girl
Ferro Lad
Green Arrow
Green Lantern (John Stewart)
Kid Quantum
Light Lass
Lightning Lad
Phantom Girl
Saturn Girl
Shadow Lass
Supergirl
Timber Wolf
Triad
Ultra Boy
Wildfire

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

for the Morrison's Action Comics Adult Legion, is that this group?

https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/m...le-to-width-down/1000?cb=20190516035334.

I don't... think so? That looks like Carlos Pacheco art. I'm getting a faint bell in the back of my brain suggesting that might have been an evil team from a Jeph Loeb Superman/Batman arc, but not any more details.

I did find these for the Morrison team:

Attached picture MorrisonLegion3.jpg

thanks, scrapping the earlier list - I'll treat those as the "original" Adult Legion. all the members in the Pacheco art are represented in the Morrison art too, anyway (I've added Chameleon Man there)

so... are the "younger" Legionnaires down below (Bouncing Boy, Brainiac 5, etc.) supposed to be part of this Adult Legion too? right now, I've only listed the members from the first 3 screenshots.

Chameleon
Cosmic Man
Lightning Man
Saturn Woman
Sensor
Shrinking Violet
Superman
Umbra
Wildfire

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

so... are the "younger" Legionnaires down below (Bouncing Boy, Brainiac 5, etc.) supposed to be part of this Adult Legion too?

Whether they survived to the Universo-dominated "present" is open, I think, but it's a flashback to that version before things Got Bad.

thanks, that means they should go in there, too. I wonder if we need to rename their reality, right now I've got them as Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)...

I'll leave discussions open until Friday, then we can begin on a Saturday. thanks to all

ok gang, thanks for all your comments and input in shaping this list! now, let's have at it!

We start with 508 (!!!) entries on the list. Whoops! Please vote for any from 1 to 150 of the list below. Any Legionnaire that gets at least 2 votes, moves on to the next round!

so to vote, just submit a list of your picks: minimum of 1, maximum of 150. and please copy-paste the list/wording exactly as below, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 48 hours (so, around this time on January 8)
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing.

Realities covered - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)
Adult Legion (Adventure Era)
Arrowverse
Arthurian Legion
Bendisboot
DC Animated (JLU-verse)
Dead Earth
JLA Trapped in Time
Legion 1 Million
Legion Animated Movie
Legion Toon (and Comic)
Pre-5YL
Reboot
Retroboot
Smallville
Superboy's Legion
SW6
Threeboot
Young Justice

The List for Round 1 - Realities are listed alphabetically; then Legionnaires are listed alphabetically within reality. Confirmed Reserve and Honorary Legionnaires are also included.

(5YL) Atmos
(5YL) Bloodclaw
(5YL) Bouncing Boy
(5YL) Bounty entity
(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Calamity King
(5YL) Chameleon Boy
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid
(5YL) Color Kid
(5YL) Colossal Boy
(5YL) Cosmic Boy
(5YL) Crystal Kid
(5YL) Dawnstar
(5YL) Dream Girl
(5YL) Duo Damsel
(5YL) Echo
(5YL) Element Lad
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Firefist
(5YL) Flederweb
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Invisible Kid II
(5YL) Karate Kid II
(5YL) Kono
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty)
(5YL) Lightning Lass
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Mon-el
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish)
(5YL) Nightwind
(5YL) Polar Boy
(5YL) Porcupine Pete
(5YL) Queen Projectra
(5YL) Reflecto
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Rond Vidar
(5YL) Saturn Girl
(5YL) Shadow Lass
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Star Boy
(5YL) Stone Boy
(5YL) Storm Boy
(5YL) Sun Boy
(5YL) Timber Wolf
(5YL) Tyroc
(5YL) Ultra Boy
(5YL) Valor
(5YL) Veilmist
(5YL) Visi-Lad
(5YL) White Witch
(5YL) Wildfire

(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Bouncing Boy
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Brainiac 5
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Chameleon
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Colossal Boy
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Cosmic Man
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Lightning Man
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Saturn Woman
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Sensor
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Shrinking Violet
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Superman
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Ultra Boy
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Umbra
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Wildfire

(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Batman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Bouncing Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chameleon Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chemical King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Color King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Colossal Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Cosmic Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Dream Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duo Damsel
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Element Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Karate King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Light Lady
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Matter-Eater Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Night Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Phantom Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Polar Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shrinking Violet
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Star Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Timber Wolf
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ultra Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) White Witch

(Arrowverse) Brainiac 5
(Arrowverse) Chameleon
(Arrowverse) Dream Girl
(Arrowverse) Karate Kid
(Arrowverse) Lightning Lass
(Arrowverse) Mon-El
(Arrowverse) Saturn Girl
(Arrowverse) Toyman

(Arthurian Legion) Alchemist
(Arthurian Legion) Andromeda
(Arthurian Legion) Brainiac 5
(Arthurian Legion) Chameleon
(Arthurian Legion) Computo
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Dragonmage
(Arthurian Legion) Dream Girl
(Arthurian Legion) Ferro
(Arthurian Legion) Infectious Lass
(Arthurian Legion) Inferno
(Arthurian Legion) Invisible Kid I
(Arthurian Legion) Invisible Kid II
(Arthurian Legion) Karate Kid I
(Arthurian Legion) Leviathan
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire
(Arthurian Legion) Matter-Eater Lad
(Arthurian Legion) Nemesis Kid
(Arthurian Legion) Polar Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl
(Arthurian Legion) Shrinking Violet
(Arthurian Legion) Spark
(Arthurian Legion) Triad
(Arthurian Legion) Ultra Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Umbra

(Bendisboot) Blok
(Bendisboot) Bouncing Boy
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5
(Bendisboot) Chameleon Boy
(Bendisboot) Colossal Boy
(Bendisboot) Computo
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy
(Bendisboot) Dawnstar
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate
(Bendisboot) Dream Girl
(Bendisboot) Element Lad
(Bendisboot) Entropy Kid
(Bendisboot) Ferro Lad
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern
(Bendisboot) Invisible Kid
(Bendisboot) Karate Kid
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass
(Bendisboot) Matter-Eater Lad
(Bendisboot) Mon-el
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy
(Bendisboot) Phantom Girl
(Bendisboot) Princess Projectra
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl
(Bendisboot) Shadow Lass
(Bendisboot) Shrinking Violet
(Bendisboot) Star Boy
(Bendisboot) Sun Boy
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon)
(Bendisboot) Timber Wolf
(Bendisboot) Triplicate Girl
(Bendisboot) Ultra Boy
(Bendisboot) White Witch
(Bendisboot) Wildfire
(Bendisboot) X-Ray Girl

(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Andromeda
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Blok
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Bouncing Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Brainiac 5
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Chameleon Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Colossal Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Cosmic Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Douglas Nolan
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Dream Girl
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Ferro Lad
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Green Arrow
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Green Lantern (John Stewart)
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Kid Quantum
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Light Lass
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Lightning Lad
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Phantom Girl
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Saturn Girl
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Shadow Lass
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Timber Wolf
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Triad
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Ultra Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Wildfire

(Dead Earth) Argent
(Dead Earth) Graft
(Dead Earth) Lodestone
(Dead Earth) Magno Boy
(Dead Earth) Membrain
(Dead Earth) Metrox
(Dead Earth) Nervosa
(Dead Earth) Phase
(Dead Earth) Shape
(Dead Earth) Shift
(Dead Earth) Silverwing
(Dead Earth) Triad III
(Dead Earth) Triplicate
(Dead Earth) Wildfire

(JLA Trapped in Time) Dawnstar
(JLA Trapped in Time) Karate Kid

(Legion 1 Million) Brainiac 417
(Legion 1 Million) Cosmicbot
(Legion 1 Million) Implicate Girl
(Legion 1 Million) Superboy
(Legion 1 Million) The Chameleon
(Legion 1 Million) The Dreamer
(Legion 1 Million) The M'Onelves
(Legion 1 Million) The Umbra
(Legion 1 Million) Titangirl
(Legion 1 Million) Wildflame

(Legion Animated Movie) Andromeda
(Legion Animated Movie) Arm-Fall-Off-Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Atmos
(Legion Animated Movie) Blok
(Legion Animated Movie) Bouncing Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Brainiac 5
(Legion Animated Movie) Catspaw
(Legion Animated Movie) Chameleon Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Chemical King
(Legion Animated Movie) Color Kid
(Legion Animated Movie) Comet Queen
(Legion Animated Movie) Cosmic Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Dawnstar
(Legion Animated Movie) Dream Girl
(Legion Animated Movie) Element Lad
(Legion Animated Movie) Ferro Lad
(Legion Animated Movie) Gates
(Legion Animated Movie) Gold Lantern
(Legion Animated Movie) Invisible Kid
(Legion Animated Movie) Karate Kid
(Legion Animated Movie) Kid Quantum II
(Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix
(Legion Animated Movie) Lightning Lad
(Legion Animated Movie) Mon-El
(Legion Animated Movie) Monstress
(Legion Animated Movie) Phantom Girl
(Legion Animated Movie) Polar Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Power Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Quislet
(Legion Animated Movie) Saturn Girl
(Legion Animated Movie) Sensor Girl
(Legion Animated Movie) Shadow Lass
(Legion Animated Movie) Star Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Stone Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Supergirl
(Legion Animated Movie) Superman
(Legion Animated Movie) Tellus
(Legion Animated Movie) Timber Wolf
(Legion Animated Movie) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Legion Animated Movie) Tyroc
(Legion Animated Movie) Wildfire

(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Blok
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chameleon Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chemical King
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chlorophyll Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Color Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Colossal Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Cosmic Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dawnstar
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dream Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Element Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Ferro Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Infectious Lass
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Invisible Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Karate Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Matter-Eater Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Night Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Phantom Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Polar Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Porcupine Pete
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Saturn Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Star Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Stone Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Sun Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman X
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Timber Wolf
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Tyroc
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Ultra Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) White Witch
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) XS

(Pre-5YL) Anti-Lad
(Pre-5YL) Beppo
(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
(Pre-5YL) Comet
(Pre-5YL) Command Kid
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Dynamo Boy
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen)
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang)
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho
(Pre-5YL) Krypto
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid
(Pre-5YL) Pete Ross
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Proty II
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Streaky
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire

(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Element Lad
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Leviathan
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Magno
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) Wildfire
(Reboot) XS

(Retroboot) Black Witch
(Retroboot) Blok
(Retroboot) Bouncing Boy
(Retroboot) Brainiac 5
(Retroboot) Chameleon Boy
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
(Retroboot) Chemical Kid
(Retroboot) Colossal Boy
(Retroboot) Comet Queen
(Retroboot) Cosmic Boy
(Retroboot) Dawnstar
(Retroboot) Dragonwing
(Retroboot) Dream Girl
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
(Retroboot) Earth-Man
(Retroboot) Element Lad
(Retroboot) Gates
(Retroboot) Glorith
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li
(Retroboot) Invisible Kid II
(Retroboot) Karate Kid
(Retroboot) Lightning Lad
(Retroboot) Lightning Lass
(Retroboot) Matter-Eater Lad
(Retroboot) Mon-el
(Retroboot) Night Girl
(Retroboot) Phantom Girl
(Retroboot) Polar Boy
(Retroboot) Quislet
(Retroboot) Rond Vidar
(Retroboot) Saturn Girl
(Retroboot) Sensor Girl
(Retroboot) Shadow Lass
(Retroboot) Shrinking Violet
(Retroboot) Star Boy
(Retroboot) Sun Boy
(Retroboot) Superman
(Retroboot) Tellus
(Retroboot) Timber Wolf
(Retroboot) Tyroc
(Retroboot) Ultra Boy
(Retroboot) Wildfire

(Smallville) Brainiac 5
(Smallville) Clark Kent
(Smallville) Cosmic Boy
(Smallville) Lightning Lad
(Smallville) Saturn Girl

(Superboy's Legion) Bouncing Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Brainiac 5
(Superboy's Legion) Chameleon Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Colossal Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Element Lad
(Superboy's Legion) Ferro Lad
(Superboy's Legion) Invisible Kid
(Superboy's Legion) Karate Kid
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
(Superboy's Legion) Lightning Lad
(Superboy's Legion) Phantom Girl
(Superboy's Legion) Saturn Girl
(Superboy's Legion) Sensor
(Superboy's Legion) Shadow Lass
(Superboy's Legion) Shrinking Violet
(Superboy's Legion) Star Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Sun Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Superboy
(Superboy's Legion) Ultra Boy

(SW6) Alchemist
(SW6) Andromeda
(SW6) Apparition
(SW6) Bouncing Boy
(SW6) Brainiac 5
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Chameleon Boy
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Cosmic Boy
(SW6) Dragonmage
(SW6) Dream Girl
(SW6) Ferro
(SW6) Gossamer
(SW6) Inferno
(SW6) Invisible Kid
(SW6) Karate Kid
(SW6) Kid Quantum
(SW6) Leviathan
(SW6) Live Wire
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad
(SW6) Princess Projectra
(SW6) Saturn Girl
(SW6) Shrinking Violet
(SW6) Star Boy
(SW6) Triad
(SW6) Ultra Boy
(SW6) Valor

(Threeboot) Atom Girl
(Threeboot) Brainiac 5
(Threeboot) Chameleon
(Threeboot) Colossal Boy/ Micro Lad
(Threeboot) Cosmic Boy
(Threeboot) Dream Boy
(Threeboot) Dream Girl
(Threeboot) Element Lad
(Threeboot) Gazelle
(Threeboot) Invisible Kid
(Threeboot) Karate Kid
(Threeboot) Light Lass
(Threeboot) Lightning Lad
(Threeboot) Mon-el
(Threeboot) Night Girl
(Threeboot) Phantom Girl
(Threeboot) Princess Projectra
(Threeboot) Saturn Girl
(Threeboot) Shadow Lass
(Threeboot) Sizzle
(Threeboot) Star Boy
(Threeboot) Sun Boy
(Threeboot) Supergirl
(Threeboot) Theena
(Threeboot) Timber Wolf
(Threeboot) Triplicate Girl
(Threeboot) Turtle
(Threeboot) Ultra Boy

(Young Justice) Chameleon Boy
(Young Justice) Phantom Girl
(Young Justice) Saturn Girl

*Round ends around this time, January 8th!!*

and here's my votes: 89 Legionnaires!

(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Invisible Kid II
(5YL) Kono
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Nightwind
(5YL) Polar Boy
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Veilmist
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl
(Legion Animated Movie) Brainiac 5
(Legion Animated Movie) Chemical King
(Legion Animated Movie) Dawnstar
(Legion Animated Movie) Invisible Kid
(Legion Animated Movie) Phantom Girl
(Legion Animated Movie) Shadow Lass
(Legion Animated Movie) Supergirl
(Legion Animated Movie) Superman
(Legion Animated Movie) Timber Wolf
(Legion Animated Movie) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chameleon Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Colossal Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dream Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Infectious Lass
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Karate Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Matter-Eater Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Phantom Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Saturn Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Star Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Stone Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Sun Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Timber Wolf
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Element Lad
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Leviathan
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Magno
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) Wildfire
(Reboot) XS
(Retroboot) Gates
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
(SW6) Alchemist
(SW6) Valor

(5YL) Bloodclaw
(5YL) Color Kid
(5YL) Crystal Kid
(5YL) Echo
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Firefist
(5YL) Flederweb
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Invisible Kid II
(5YL) Karate Kid II
(5YL) Kono
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty)
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish)
(5YL) Nightwind
(5YL) Polar Boy
(5YL) Porcupine Pete
(5YL) Queen Projectra
(5YL) Reflecto
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Rond Vidar
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Stone Boy
(5YL) Tyroc
(5YL) Valor
(5YL) Veilmist
(5YL) Visi-Lad
(5YL) White Witch

(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Cosmic Man
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Lightning Man
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Saturn Woman
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Sensor
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Umbra

(Arthurian Legion) Alchemist
(Arthurian Legion) Brainiac 5
(Arthurian Legion) Chameleon
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Dragonmage
(Arthurian Legion) Ferro
(Arthurian Legion) Inferno
(Arthurian Legion) Leviathan
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire
(Arthurian Legion) Matter-Eater Lad
(Arthurian Legion) Polar Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl
(Arthurian Legion) Shrinking Violet
(Arthurian Legion) Triad
(Arthurian Legion) Ultra Boy

(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Bouncing Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Chameleon Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Cosmic Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Kid Quantum
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Saturn Girl
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl

(Dead Earth) Argent
(Dead Earth) Lodestone
(Dead Earth) Magno Boy
(Dead Earth) Membrain
(Dead Earth) Silverwing
(Dead Earth) Triad III
(Dead Earth) Triplicate
(Dead Earth) Wildfire

(Legion 1 Million) Brainiac 417
(Legion 1 Million) Cosmicbot
(Legion 1 Million) Implicate Girl
(Legion 1 Million) Superboy
(Legion 1 Million) The Chameleon
(Legion 1 Million) The Dreamer
(Legion 1 Million) The M'Onelves
(Legion 1 Million) The Umbra
(Legion 1 Million) Wildflame

(Legion Animated Movie) Arm-Fall-Off-Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Comet Queen
(Legion Animated Movie) Gates
(Legion Animated Movie) Kid Quantum II
(Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix
(Legion Animated Movie) Monstress

(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chlorophyll Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Night Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman X

(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid
(Pre-5YL) Proty II
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Tellus

(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Element Lad
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Leviathan
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Magno
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) Wildfire
(Reboot) XS

(Superboy's Legion) Bouncing Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Brainiac 5
(Superboy's Legion) Chameleon Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Colossal Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Element Lad
(Superboy's Legion) Ferro Lad
(Superboy's Legion) Invisible Kid
(Superboy's Legion) Karate Kid
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
(Superboy's Legion) Lightning Lad
(Superboy's Legion) Phantom Girl
(Superboy's Legion) Saturn Girl
(Superboy's Legion) Sensor
(Superboy's Legion) Shadow Lass
(Superboy's Legion) Shrinking Violet
(Superboy's Legion) Star Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Sun Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Superboy
(Superboy's Legion) Ultra Boy

(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Dragonmage
(SW6) Kid Quantum
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad

Thanks for doing this Ibby. I nearly missed it, thanks to the hols. Whew!

Crumbs. Tough choices, even to get to 150...

(5YL) Bouncing Boy
(5YL) Bounty entity
(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Calamity King
(5YL) Chameleon Boy
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid
(5YL) Color Kid
(5YL) Colossal Boy
(5YL) Cosmic Boy
(5YL) Duo Damsel
(5YL) Element Lad
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Flederweb
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Invisible Kid II
(5YL) Kono
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty)
(5YL) Lightning Lass
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Mon-el
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish)
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Shadow Lass
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Stone Boy
(5YL) Sun Boy
(5YL) Timber Wolf
(5YL) Tyroc
(5YL) Ultra Boy
(5YL) Valor
(5YL) Veilmist
(5YL) White Witch
(5YL) Wildfire
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Batman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Cosmic Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Dream Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duo Damsel
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Element Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Karate King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Light Lady
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Night Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Phantom Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Polar Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Star Man
(Bendisboot) Computo
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy
(Bendisboot) Dawnstar
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass
(Bendisboot) Mon-el
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl
(Bendisboot) Timber Wolf
(Bendisboot) Triplicate Girl
(Pre-5YL) Beppo
(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
(Pre-5YL) Comet
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen)
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang)
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho
(Pre-5YL) Krypto
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Pete Ross
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Proty II
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Streaky
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) XS
(Retroboot) Bouncing Boy
(Retroboot) Brainiac 5
(Retroboot) Chameleon Boy
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
(Retroboot) Chemical Kid
(Retroboot) Comet Queen
(Retroboot) Dragonwing
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
(Retroboot) Glorith
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li
(Retroboot) Lightning Lad
(Retroboot) Lightning Lass
(Retroboot) Mon-el
(Retroboot) Night Girl
(Retroboot) Shrinking Violet
(Retroboot) Ultra Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Kid Quantum
(Threeboot) Atom Girl
(Threeboot) Dream Girl
(Threeboot) Light Lass
(Threeboot) Phantom Girl
(Threeboot) Supergirl
(Threeboot) Theena
(Threeboot) Triplicate Girl

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Chameleon Boy
(5YL) Cosmic Boy
(5YL) Dawnstar
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(5YL) Stone Boy
(5YL) Timber Wolf
(5YL) Ultra Boy
(5YL) Wildfire
14

(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
6

(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl
3

(Bendisboot) Blok
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5
(Bendisboot) Chameleon Boy
(Bendisboot) Computo
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon)
10

(Dead Earth) Wildfire
1

(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire
29

(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) XS
21

(Retroboot) Black Witch
(Retroboot) Blok
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
(Retroboot) Dawnstar
(Retroboot) Dragonwing
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
(Retroboot) Gates
(Retroboot) Glorith
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li
(Retroboot) Phantom Girl
(Retroboot) Saturn Girl
(Retroboot) Star Boy
(Retroboot) Superman
(Retroboot) Tellus
(Retroboot) Timber Wolf
(Retroboot) Tyroc
(Retroboot) Ultra Boy
(Retroboot) Wildfire
18

(SW6) Alchemist
(SW6) Andromeda
(SW6) Apparition
(SW6) Brainiac 5
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Cosmic Boy
(SW6) Dragonmage
(SW6) Ferro
(SW6) Invisible Kid
(SW6) Live Wire
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad
(SW6) Saturn Girl
(SW6) Shrinking Violet
(SW6) Triad
(SW6) Ultra Boy
(SW6) Valor
17

(Threeboot) Chameleon
(Threeboot) Dream Girl
(Threeboot) Invisible Kid
(Threeboot) Karate Kid
(Threeboot) Light Lass
(Threeboot) Lightning Lad
(Threeboot) Mon-el
(Threeboot) Phantom Girl
(Threeboot) Saturn Girl
(Threeboot) Shadow Lass
(Threeboot) Sun Boy
(Threeboot) Supergirl
(Threeboot) Theena
(Threeboot) Triplicate Girl
14

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Thanks for doing this Ibby. I nearly missed it, thanks to the hols. Whew!
l

my pleasure, thothy, and glad you're here!

thanks too, to Reboot and Stile.

I'll extend it for a few hours, I was hoping for a few more votes - I'll send a PM to the others who've commented on this thread thus far, just in case the opening of the round was missed

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Thanks for doing this Ibby. I nearly missed it, thanks to the hols. Whew!
l

my pleasure, thothy, and glad you're here!

thanks too, to Reboot and Stile.

I'll extend it for a few hours, I was hoping for a few more votes - I'll send a PM to the others who've commented on this thread thus far, just in case the opening of the round was missed

Thanks Ibby. Going through the list (trying my bestest not to cut Kinetix, while cackling) it's clear how many tricky decisions you had to make on the various character iterations.

Maybe I should have slipped in a few more Kinetix versions ...

We're at 4 voters now, which is rather few for an Idol game. I've sent a few PMs, some Facebook messages, and cross-advertised to a couple of other threads, so I will give it a day longer to see if we got more votes. no more than that though; even if we're only 4, the game should continue for us 4

Not a problem giving people some extra time. As mentioned, I nearly missed it, and I'd seen one of the first posts, so I knew it was going live. Ramping up into the new year...

Sorry, I didn't realize this had started.

(5YL) Atmos
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid
(5YL) Color Kid
(5YL) Crystal Kid
(5YL) Echo
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Flederweb
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Karate Kid II
(5YL) Kono
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish)
(5YL) Nightwind
(5YL) Porcupine Pete
(5YL) Reflecto
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Veilmist
(5YL) Visi-Lad

(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen

(Bendisboot) Blok
(Bendisboot) Bouncing Boy
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5
(Bendisboot) Chameleon Boy
(Bendisboot) Colossal Boy
(Bendisboot) Computo
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy
(Bendisboot) Dawnstar
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate
(Bendisboot) Dream Girl
(Bendisboot) Element Lad
(Bendisboot) Entropy Kid
(Bendisboot) Ferro Lad
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern
(Bendisboot) Invisible Kid
(Bendisboot) Karate Kid
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass
(Bendisboot) Matter-Eater Lad
(Bendisboot) Mon-el
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy
(Bendisboot) Phantom Girl
(Bendisboot) Princess Projectra
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl
(Bendisboot) Shadow Lass
(Bendisboot) Shrinking Violet
(Bendisboot) Star Boy
(Bendisboot) Sun Boy
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon)
(Bendisboot) Timber Wolf
(Bendisboot) Triplicate Girl
(Bendisboot) Ultra Boy
(Bendisboot) White Witch
(Bendisboot) Wildfire
(Bendisboot) X-Ray Girl

(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid

(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Dynamo Boy
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen)
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang)
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire

(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Element Lad
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Leviathan
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Magno
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) Wildfire
(Reboot) XS

(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
(Retroboot) Comet Queen
(Retroboot) Dragonwing
(Retroboot) Night Girl

(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Dragonmage

(Threeboot) Gazelle
(Threeboot) Sizzle
(Threeboot) Turtle

OK I think I'm doing this right - Sorry I'm late!

(Arthurian Legion) Triad
(Arthurian Legion) Triad
(Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix
(Legion Animated Movie) Dawnstar
(Legion Animated Movie) Mon-El
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) XS
(Retroboot) Earth-Man
(Retroboot) Lightning Lad
(Retroboot) Lightning Lass
(Retroboot) Saturn Girl
(Retroboot) Shrinking Violet
(Threeboot) Atom Girl
(Young Justice) Chameleon Boy
(Young Justice) Phantom Girl
(Young Justice) Saturn Girl

thanks, thothy!

and welcome, Nighty and GL! (no sorries needed, just glad you're both here!)

I'll try to get to this in a few hours. Super-busy the past few days.

thanks, EDE. I was about to close this, but I'll keep it open overnight.

timely too, as I have some sudden family drama to deal with... and I just sprained my ankle. ugh!

going to take some R&R tonight.

and from here on out, each round will be 3 days, rather than 2...

Oh no! Hope you feel better soon!

Get better soon Ibby. Remember to focus on The Speed Force to help along that sprained ankle.

This looks like a job for... Refecto!

thanks GL, thothy, EDE!

where are the healers when you need one...

maybe GL's version of Kinetix can speed up my healing

or Kent Shakespeare can give me some TLC

(5YL) Calamity King
(5YL) Echo
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Reflecto
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Veilmist
(5YL) Visi-Lad
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Bouncing Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chameleon Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chemical King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Color King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Colossal Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Cosmic Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Dream Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duo Damsel
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Element Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Karate King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Light Lady
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Matter-Eater Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Night Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Phantom Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Polar Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shrinking Violet
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Star Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Timber Wolf
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ultra Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) White Witch
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Matter-Eater Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid
(Pre-5YL) Beppo
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
(Pre-5YL) Comet
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen)
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang)
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho
(Pre-5YL) Krypto
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid
(Pre-5YL) Pete Ross
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Proty II
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Streaky
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Element Lad
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Leviathan
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Magno
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) Wildfire
(Reboot) XS
(Retroboot) Glorith
(Superboy's Legion) Star Boy
(SW6) Andromeda
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Dragonmage
(SW6) Kid Quantum
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad
(Threeboot) Gazelle
(Threeboot) Theena

ok, am holed up in my room while my sprained ankle heals, so am ending the round now! results up shortly

thanks to all who voted!!!

Hey, all,

I'm going to be busy for the foreseeable future, too busy to participate in this game. But I will still be checking in at Legion World every day, and I hope that you have lots of fun in this thread.

Feel better soon, Ibby, and thanks for the invite.

thank you Annfie, appreciate it tons! hope life isn't too hectic for you

what's interesting is, a number of voters had 149 on their list - just 1 shy of the max of 150

(I double-checked that I copy=-pasted the lists correctly too!)

also, GL, you had Arthurian Triad twice on your list - I assume it's just a typo

so I've given her 1 point from your vote

RESULTS TIME!!! End of Round 1!

thanks to all 7 voters for chiming in! and here we go...

with a unanimous vote from all 7: perhaps these Legionnaires also benefit from not having many counterparts?

(Reboot) Gates - 7
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - 7
(Reboot) Kinetix - 7
(Reboot) XS - 7

With 6 of 7 voters:

(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad - 6
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - 6
(Reboot) Chameleon - 6
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - 6
(Reboot) Monstress - 6
(Reboot) Saturn Girl - 6
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - 6
(Reboot) Spark - 6
(Reboot) Thunder - 6
(Reboot) Triad - 6

A whole bunch getting 5/7 votes:

(5YL) Infectious Lass - 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand - 5
(5YL) Spider-Girl - 5
(5YL) Veilmist - 5
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - 5
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy - 5
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King - 5
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl - 5
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad - 5
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass - 5
(Pre-5YL) Quislet - 5
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - 5
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet - 5
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy - 5
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - 5
(Pre-5YL) White Witch - 5
(Reboot) Andromeda - 5
(Reboot) Apparition - 5
(Reboot) Chuck Taine - 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy - 5
(Reboot) Ferro - 5
(Reboot) Gear - 5
(Reboot) Live Wire - 5
(Reboot) M'Onel - 5
(Reboot) Ultra Boy - 5
(SW6) Catspaw - 5
(SW6) Computo - 5

And with 4/7 votes:

(5YL) Fire Lad - 4
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare) - 4
(5YL) Kono - 4
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 4
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan) - 4
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II - 4
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid - 4
(Pre-5YL) Blok - 4
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy - 4
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar - 4
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad - 4
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II - 4
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - 4
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid - 4
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el - 4
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - 4
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - 4
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl - 4
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar - 4
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass - 4
(Pre-5YL) Superboy - 4
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - 4
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 4
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy - 4
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire - 4
(Reboot) Dreamer - 4
(Reboot) Element Lad - 4
(Reboot) Karate Kid - 4
(Reboot) Leviathan - 4
(Reboot) Magno - 4
(Reboot) Sensor - 4
(Reboot) Shikari - 4
(Reboot) Star Boy - 4
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el) - 4
(Reboot) Timber Wolf - 4
(Reboot) Umbra - 4
(Reboot) Wildfire - 4
(SW6) Dragonmage - 4

With 3/7 votes:

(5YL) Color Kid - 3
(5YL) Echo - 3
(5YL) Flederweb - 3
(5YL) Invisible Kid II - 3
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish) - 3
(5YL) Nightwind - 3
(5YL) Reflecto - 3
(5YL) Stone Boy - 3
(5YL) Visi-Lad - 3
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5 - 3
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V - 3
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man - 3
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V - 3
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen - 3
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman - 3
(Bendisboot) Computo - 3
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad - 3
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass - 3
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy - 3
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl - 3
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy - 3
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy - 3
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen) - 3
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang) - 3
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I - 3
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho - 3
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 3
(Pre-5YL) Proty II - 3
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy - 3
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - 3
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc - 3
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson) - 3
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I - 3
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl - 3
(Retroboot) Dragonwing - 3
(Retroboot) Glorith - 3
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass - 3
(SW6) Kid Quantum - 3
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad - 3
(Threeboot) Theena - 3

And finally, just coming in above the cut off, still safe with 2/7 votes:

(5YL) Brainiac 5 - 2
(5YL) Calamity King - 2
(5YL) Chameleon Boy - 2
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid - 2
(5YL) Cosmic Boy - 2
(5YL) Crystal Kid - 2
(5YL) Karate Kid II - 2
(5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty) - 2
(5YL) Polar Boy - 2
(5YL) Porcupine Pete - 2
(5YL) Shrinking Violet - 2
(5YL) Timber Wolf - 2
(5YL) Tyroc - 2
(5YL) Ultra Boy - 2
(5YL) Valor - 2
(5YL) White Witch - 2
(5YL) Wildfire - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Cosmic Man - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Dream Woman - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duo Damsel - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Element Man - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Karate King - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Light Lady - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Night Woman - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Phantom Woman - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Polar Man - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Star Man - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman - 2
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy - 2
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire - 2
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl - 2
(Arthurian Legion) Triad - 2
(Bendisboot) Blok - 2
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5 - 2
(Bendisboot) Chameleon Boy - 2
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy - 2
(Bendisboot) Dawnstar - 2
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate - 2
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern - 2
(Bendisboot) Mon-el - 2
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad - 2
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon) - 2
(Bendisboot) Timber Wolf - 2
(Bendisboot) Triplicate Girl - 2
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl - 2
(Dead Earth) Wildfire - 2
(Legion Animated Movie) Dawnstar - 2
(Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix - 2
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5 - 2
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad - 2
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Matter-Eater Lad - 2
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet - 2
(Pre-5YL) Beppo - 2
(Pre-5YL) Comet - 2
(Pre-5YL) Krypto - 2
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid - 2
(Pre-5YL) Pete Ross - 2
(Pre-5YL) Streaky - 2
(Retroboot) Comet Queen - 2
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel - 2
(Retroboot) Gates - 2
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li - 2
(Retroboot) Lightning Lad - 2
(Retroboot) Lightning Lass - 2
(Retroboot) Night Girl - 2
(Retroboot) Saturn Girl - 2
(Retroboot) Shrinking Violet - 2
(Retroboot) Ultra Boy - 2
(Superboy's Legion) Star Boy - 2
(SW6) Alchemist - 2
(SW6) Andromeda - 2
(SW6) Valor - 2
(Threeboot) Atom Girl - 2
(Threeboot) Dream Girl - 2
(Threeboot) Gazelle - 2
(Threeboot) Light Lass - 2
(Threeboot) Phantom Girl - 2
(Threeboot) Supergirl - 2
(Threeboot) Triplicate Girl - 2

ELIMINATIONS - sorry for those who got 1 vote:

(5YL) Atmos - 1
(5YL) Bloodclaw - 1
(5YL) Bouncing Boy - 1
(5YL) Bounty entity - 1
(5YL) Colossal Boy - 1
(5YL) Dawnstar - 1
(5YL) Duo Damsel - 1
(5YL) Element Lad - 1
(5YL) Firefist - 1
(5YL) Lightning Lass - 1
(5YL) Mon-el - 1
(5YL) Queen Projectra - 1
(5YL) Rond Vidar - 1
(5YL) Shadow Lass - 1
(5YL) Sun Boy - 1
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Cosmic Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Lightning Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Saturn Woman - 1
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Sensor - 1
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Umbra - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Batman - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Bouncing Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chameleon Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chemical King - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Color King - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Colossal Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Matter-Eater Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shrinking Violet - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Timber Wolf - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ultra Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) White Witch - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Alchemist - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Brainiac 5 - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Chameleon - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Dragonmage - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Ferro - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Inferno - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Leviathan - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Matter-Eater Lad - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Polar Boy - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Shrinking Violet - 1
(Arthurian Legion) Ultra Boy - 1
(Bendisboot) Bouncing Boy - 1
(Bendisboot) Colossal Boy - 1
(Bendisboot) Dream Girl - 1
(Bendisboot) Element Lad - 1
(Bendisboot) Entropy Kid - 1
(Bendisboot) Ferro Lad - 1
(Bendisboot) Invisible Kid - 1
(Bendisboot) Karate Kid - 1
(Bendisboot) Matter-Eater Lad - 1
(Bendisboot) Phantom Girl - 1
(Bendisboot) Princess Projectra - 1
(Bendisboot) Shadow Lass - 1
(Bendisboot) Shrinking Violet - 1
(Bendisboot) Star Boy - 1
(Bendisboot) Sun Boy - 1
(Bendisboot) Ultra Boy - 1
(Bendisboot) White Witch - 1
(Bendisboot) Wildfire - 1
(Bendisboot) X-Ray Girl - 1
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Bouncing Boy - 1
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Chameleon Boy - 1
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Cosmic Boy - 1
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Kid Quantum - 1
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Saturn Girl - 1
(Dead Earth) Argent - 1
(Dead Earth) Lodestone - 1
(Dead Earth) Magno Boy - 1
(Dead Earth) Membrain - 1
(Dead Earth) Silverwing - 1
(Dead Earth) Triad III - 1
(Dead Earth) Triplicate - 1
(Legion 1 Million) Brainiac 417 - 1
(Legion 1 Million) Cosmicbot - 1
(Legion 1 Million) Implicate Girl - 1
(Legion 1 Million) Superboy - 1
(Legion 1 Million) The Chameleon - 1
(Legion 1 Million) The Dreamer - 1
(Legion 1 Million) The M'Onelves - 1
(Legion 1 Million) The Umbra - 1
(Legion 1 Million) Wildflame - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Arm-Fall-Off-Boy - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Brainiac 5 - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Chemical King - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Comet Queen - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Gates - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Invisible Kid - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Kid Quantum II - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Mon-El - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Monstress - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Phantom Girl - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Shadow Lass - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Supergirl - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Superman - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Timber Wolf - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chameleon Boy - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chlorophyll Kid - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Colossal Boy - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dream Girl - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Infectious Lass - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Karate Kid - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Night Girl - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Phantom Girl - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Saturn Girl - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Star Boy - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Stone Boy - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Sun Boy - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman X - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Timber Wolf - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 1
(Pre-5YL) Dynamo Boy - 1
(Retroboot) Black Witch - 1
(Retroboot) Blok - 1
(Retroboot) Bouncing Boy - 1
(Retroboot) Brainiac 5 - 1
(Retroboot) Chameleon Boy - 1
(Retroboot) Chemical Kid - 1
(Retroboot) Dawnstar - 1
(Retroboot) Earth-Man - 1
(Retroboot) Mon-el - 1
(Retroboot) Phantom Girl - 1
(Retroboot) Star Boy - 1
(Retroboot) Superman - 1
(Retroboot) Tellus - 1
(Retroboot) Timber Wolf - 1
(Retroboot) Tyroc - 1
(Retroboot) Wildfire - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Bouncing Boy - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Brainiac 5 - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Chameleon Boy - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Colossal Boy - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Cosmic Boy - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Element Lad - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Ferro Lad - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Invisible Kid - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Karate Kid - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Lightning Lad - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Phantom Girl - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Saturn Girl - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Sensor - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Shadow Lass - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Shrinking Violet - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Sun Boy - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Superboy - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Ultra Boy - 1
(SW6) Apparition - 1
(SW6) Brainiac 5 - 1
(SW6) Cosmic Boy - 1
(SW6) Ferro - 1
(SW6) Invisible Kid - 1
(SW6) Live Wire - 1
(SW6) Saturn Girl - 1
(SW6) Shrinking Violet - 1
(SW6) Triad - 1
(SW6) Ultra Boy - 1
(Threeboot) Chameleon - 1
(Threeboot) Invisible Kid - 1
(Threeboot) Karate Kid - 1
(Threeboot) Lightning Lad - 1
(Threeboot) Mon-el - 1
(Threeboot) Saturn Girl - 1
(Threeboot) Shadow Lass - 1
(Threeboot) Sizzle - 1
(Threeboot) Sun Boy - 1
(Threeboot) Turtle - 1
(Young Justice) Chameleon Boy - 1
(Young Justice) Phantom Girl - 1
(Young Justice) Saturn Girl - 1

and the bottom of the bottom: those who got no votes at all!

(5YL) Dream Girl - 0
(5YL) Saturn Girl - 0
(5YL) Star Boy - 0
(5YL) Storm Boy - 0
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Bouncing Boy - 0
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Brainiac 5 - 0
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Chameleon - 0
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Colossal Boy - 0
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Shrinking Violet - 0
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Superman - 0
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Ultra Boy - 0
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Wildfire - 0
(Arrowverse) Brainiac 5 - 0
(Arrowverse) Chameleon - 0
(Arrowverse) Dream Girl - 0
(Arrowverse) Karate Kid - 0
(Arrowverse) Lightning Lass - 0
(Arrowverse) Mon-El - 0
(Arrowverse) Saturn Girl - 0
(Arrowverse) Toyman - 0
(Arthurian Legion) Andromeda - 0
(Arthurian Legion) Computo - 0
(Arthurian Legion) Dream Girl - 0
(Arthurian Legion) Infectious Lass - 0
(Arthurian Legion) Invisible Kid I - 0
(Arthurian Legion) Invisible Kid II - 0
(Arthurian Legion) Karate Kid I - 0
(Arthurian Legion) Nemesis Kid - 0
(Arthurian Legion) Spark - 0
(Arthurian Legion) Umbra - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Andromeda - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Blok - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Brainiac 5 - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Colossal Boy - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Douglas Nolan - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Dream Girl - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Ferro Lad - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Green Arrow - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Green Lantern (John Stewart) - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Light Lass - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Lightning Lad - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Phantom Girl - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Shadow Lass - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Timber Wolf - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Triad - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Ultra Boy - 0
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Wildfire - 0
(Dead Earth) Graft - 0
(Dead Earth) Metrox - 0
(Dead Earth) Nervosa - 0
(Dead Earth) Phase - 0
(Dead Earth) Shape - 0
(Dead Earth) Shift - 0
(JLA Trapped in Time) Dawnstar - 0
(JLA Trapped in Time) Karate Kid - 0
(Legion 1 Million) Titangirl - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Andromeda - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Atmos - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Blok - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Bouncing Boy - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Catspaw - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Chameleon Boy - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Color Kid - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Cosmic Boy - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Dream Girl - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Element Lad - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Ferro Lad - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Gold Lantern - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Karate Kid - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Lightning Lad - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Polar Boy - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Power Boy - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Quislet - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Saturn Girl - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Sensor Girl - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Star Boy - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Stone Boy - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Tellus - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Tyroc - 0
(Legion Animated Movie) Wildfire - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Blok - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chemical King - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Color Kid - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Cosmic Boy - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dawnstar - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Element Lad - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Ferro Lad - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Invisible Kid - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Polar Boy - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Porcupine Pete - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Tyroc - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Ultra Boy - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) White Witch - 0
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) XS - 0
(Pre-5YL) Anti-Lad - 0
(Pre-5YL) Command Kid - 0
(Retroboot) Colossal Boy - 0
(Retroboot) Cosmic Boy - 0
(Retroboot) Dream Girl - 0
(Retroboot) Element Lad - 0
(Retroboot) Invisible Kid II - 0
(Retroboot) Karate Kid - 0
(Retroboot) Matter-Eater Lad - 0
(Retroboot) Polar Boy - 0
(Retroboot) Quislet - 0
(Retroboot) Rond Vidar - 0
(Retroboot) Sensor Girl - 0
(Retroboot) Shadow Lass - 0
(Retroboot) Sun Boy - 0
(Smallville) Brainiac 5 - 0
(Smallville) Clark Kent - 0
(Smallville) Cosmic Boy - 0
(Smallville) Lightning Lad - 0
(Smallville) Saturn Girl - 0
(SW6) Bouncing Boy - 0
(SW6) Chameleon Boy - 0
(SW6) Dream Girl - 0
(SW6) Gossamer - 0
(SW6) Inferno - 0
(SW6) Karate Kid - 0
(SW6) Leviathan - 0
(SW6) Princess Projectra - 0
(SW6) Star Boy - 0
(Threeboot) Brainiac 5 - 0
(Threeboot) Colossal Boy/ Micro Lad - 0
(Threeboot) Cosmic Boy - 0
(Threeboot) Dream Boy - 0
(Threeboot) Element Lad - 0
(Threeboot) Night Girl - 0
(Threeboot) Princess Projectra - 0
(Threeboot) Star Boy - 0
(Threeboot) Timber Wolf - 0
(Threeboot) Ultra Boy - 0

we say goodbye to 304 Legionnaires, leaving us with 204! We lost about 60% of the list!

the following realities are completely removed from the game (many of the live action/animated ones):

Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)
Arrowverse
JLA Trapped in Time
Legion 1 Million
Smallville
Young Justice

Next round will be up shortly!

Round 2 begins!

Though we eliminated 304 Legionnaires last round, we still have 204. So let's do another mass elimination!

to vote, just submit a list of your picks: minimum of 1, maximum of 75. Anyone getting at least 3 votes will move on to the next round!

and please copy-paste the list/wording exactly as below, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours (so, around this time on January 13)
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Adult Legion (Adventure Era)
Arthurian Legion
Bendisboot
DC Animated (JLU-verse)
Dead Earth
Legion Animated Movie
Legion Toon (and Comic)
Pre-5YL
Reboot
Retroboot
Superboy's Legion
SW6
Threeboot

The List for Round 2 - Realities are listed alphabetically; then Legionnaires are listed alphabetically within reality. Confirmed Reserve and Honorary Legionnaires are also included.

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Calamity King
(5YL) Chameleon Boy
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid
(5YL) Color Kid
(5YL) Cosmic Boy
(5YL) Crystal Kid
(5YL) Echo
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Flederweb
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Invisible Kid II
(5YL) Karate Kid II
(5YL) Kono
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty)
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish)
(5YL) Nightwind
(5YL) Polar Boy
(5YL) Porcupine Pete
(5YL) Reflecto
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Stone Boy
(5YL) Timber Wolf
(5YL) Tyroc
(5YL) Ultra Boy
(5YL) Valor
(5YL) Veilmist
(5YL) Visi-Lad
(5YL) White Witch
(5YL) Wildfire
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Cosmic Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Dream Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duo Damsel
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Element Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Karate King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Light Lady
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Night Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Phantom Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Polar Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Star Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl
(Arthurian Legion) Triad
(Bendisboot) Blok
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5
(Bendisboot) Chameleon Boy
(Bendisboot) Computo
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy
(Bendisboot) Dawnstar
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass
(Bendisboot) Mon-el
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon)
(Bendisboot) Timber Wolf
(Bendisboot) Triplicate Girl
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Legion Animated Movie) Dawnstar
(Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Matter-Eater Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Beppo
(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
(Pre-5YL) Comet
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen)
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang)
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho
(Pre-5YL) Krypto
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid
(Pre-5YL) Pete Ross
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Proty II
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Streaky
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Element Lad
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Leviathan
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Magno
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) Wildfire
(Reboot) XS
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
(Retroboot) Comet Queen
(Retroboot) Dragonwing
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
(Retroboot) Gates
(Retroboot) Glorith
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li
(Retroboot) Lightning Lad
(Retroboot) Lightning Lass
(Retroboot) Night Girl
(Retroboot) Saturn Girl
(Retroboot) Shrinking Violet
(Retroboot) Ultra Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
(Superboy's Legion) Star Boy
(SW6) Alchemist
(SW6) Andromeda
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Dragonmage
(SW6) Kid Quantum
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad
(SW6) Valor
(Threeboot) Atom Girl
(Threeboot) Dream Girl
(Threeboot) Gazelle
(Threeboot) Light Lass
(Threeboot) Phantom Girl
(Threeboot) Supergirl
(Threeboot) Theena
(Threeboot) Triplicate Girl

*Round ends around this time, January 13th!!*

Here is my 75!

Wow, was tougher to do this than I thought!

(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Invisible Kid II
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Polar Boy
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Valor
(5YL) Veilmist
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Krypto
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Element Lad
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Leviathan
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Magno
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) Wildfire
(Reboot) XS
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
(Retroboot) Gates
(Retroboot) Night Girl
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
(SW6) Alchemist
(SW6) Andromeda
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Dragonmage
(SW6) Valor
(Threeboot) Dream Girl
(Threeboot) Light Lass
(Threeboot) Supergirl
(Threeboot) Theena

(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid
(5YL) Color Kid
(5YL) Crystal Kid
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Karate Kid II
(5YL) Porcupine Pete
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Stone Boy
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5
(Bendisboot) Computo
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy
(Bendisboot) Dawnstar
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon)
(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) XS
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
(Retroboot) Night Girl
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Dragonmage
(SW6) Kid Quantum

(5YL) Calamity King
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Veilmist
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Cosmic Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Dream Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duo Damsel
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Element Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Karate King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Light Lady
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Night Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Phantom Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Polar Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Star Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad
(Pre-5YL) Beppo
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Comet
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen)
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang)
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho
(Pre-5YL) Krypto
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid
(Pre-5YL) Pete Ross
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Proty II
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Streaky
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Retroboot) Glorith
(SW6) Catspaw
(Threeboot) Theena

Okay, here's my next round

(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl
(Arthurian Legion) Triad
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl
(Legion Animated Movie) Dawnstar
(Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) XS
(Retroboot) Lightning Lad
(Retroboot) Lightning Lass
(Retroboot) Night Girl
(Retroboot) Saturn Girl
(Retroboot) Shrinking Violet
(SW6) Andromeda
(Threeboot) Atom Girl
(Threeboot) Dream Girl
(Threeboot) Theena
(Threeboot) Triplicate Girl

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Cosmic Boy
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(5YL) Timber Wolf
(5YL) Tyroc
(5YL) Ultra Boy
(5YL) White Witch
(5YL) Wildfire
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl
(Bendisboot) Blok
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5
(Bendisboot) Computo
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon)
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) XS
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
(Retroboot) Gates
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li
(Retroboot) Saturn Girl
(SW6) Alchemist
(SW6) Andromeda
(SW6) Computo
(Threeboot) Supergirl
(Threeboot) Theena
(Threeboot) Triplicate Girl

(Hope your ankle gets better soon)

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Calamity King
(5YL) Chameleon Boy
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid
(5YL) Crystal Kid
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Echo
(5YL) Flederweb
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Kono
(5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty)
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish)
(5YL) Nightwind
(5YL) Reflecto
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Stone Boy
(5YL) Tyroc
(5YL) Valor
(5YL) Visi-Lad
(5YL) Veilmist
(5YL) White Witch
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl
(Arthurian Legion) Triad
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Matter-Eater Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Element Lad
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Leviathan
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Magno
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) Wildfire
(Reboot) XS
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
(Superboy's Legion) Star Boy
(SW6) Alchemist
(SW6) Andromeda
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Dragonmage
(SW6) Kid Quantum
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad
(SW6) Valor

Originally Posted by stile86

(Hope your ankle gets better soon)

thanks, stile

(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II

(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Reboot) Triad

(5YL) Infectious Lass

(5YL) Spider-Girl

(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy

(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl

(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass

(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gear
(SW6) Computo

(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy

(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Umbra
(SW6) Dragonmage

(5YL) Color Kid
(5YL) Echo

(5YL) Nightwind
(5YL) Reflecto
(5YL) Stone Boy
(5YL) Visi-Lad

(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy

(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)

(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
(Retroboot) Dragonwing
(Retroboot) Glorith
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass

(Threeboot) Theena

(5YL) Crystal Kid
(5YL) Karate Kid II
(5YL) Tyroc

(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet

(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
(Retroboot) Night Girl
(Threeboot) Gazelle
(Threeboot) Light Lass

Should be 67 ish votes

I count 66, so you're good!

Crumbs! Lost a fav already.

More tough choices, and potential fav carnage ahead for Round 2.

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid
(5YL) Color Kid
(5YL) Cosmic Boy
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Kono
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty)
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish)
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Stone Boy
(5YL) Timber Wolf
(5YL) Ultra Boy
(5YL) White Witch
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
(Bendisboot) Computo
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass
(Pre-5YL) Beppo
(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
(Pre-5YL) Comet
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen)
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang)
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Krypto
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Proty II
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Streaky
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire
(Retroboot) Comet Queen
(Retroboot) Dragonwing
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li
(Retroboot) Lightning Lass
(Retroboot) Night Girl
(Retroboot) Shrinking Violet
(Retroboot) Ultra Boy
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Kid Quantum

yeah, these games typically see a lot of carnage in rounds 1-3... and actually, through the game! tough choices for all of us ahead, for sure!

we have 8 voters now (everyone from Round 1 + Set), so I'm ending the round and starting the tally! dun dun duuuun!!!

RESULTS TIME!!! End of Round 2!

As a reminder: anyone getting 3 or more votes is safe!

With 8 voters doing the selecting....

no unanimous votes this time! not unexpected, as we could vote for fewer this time!

With 6/8 of votes: a mainly female list, plus pre-5YL Garth and Gates!

(5YL) Infectious Lass - 6
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar - 6
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl - 6
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass - 6
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad - 6
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - 6
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 6
(Pre-5YL) White Witch - 6
(Reboot) Gates - 6
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - 6
(Reboot) Kinetix - 6
(SW6) Computo - 6

with 5/8 votes: we're seeing a lot of Legionnaires here who have few (or no!) alternative universe counterparts!

(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - 5
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 5
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - 5
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - 5
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - 5
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl - 5
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet - 5
(Pre-5YL) Superboy - 5
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - 5
(Reboot) Monstress - 5
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el) - 5
(Reboot) Triad - 5
(Reboot) XS - 5
(Retroboot) Night Girl - 5
(Threeboot) Theena - 5

Up next, a massive number of Legionnaires with 4/8 votes:

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 4
(5YL) Spider-Girl - 4
(5YL) Stone Boy - 4
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy - 4
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy - 4
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad - 4
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II - 4
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el - 4
(Pre-5YL) Quislet - 4
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar - 4
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass - 4
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy - 4
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy - 4
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - 4
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - 4
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc - 4
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy - 4
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire - 4
(Reboot) Andromeda - 4
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - 4
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy - 4
(Reboot) Dreamer - 4
(Reboot) Ferro - 4
(Reboot) Gear - 4
(Reboot) Live Wire - 4
(Reboot) Saturn Girl - 4
(Reboot) Shikari - 4
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - 4
(Reboot) Thunder - 4
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel - 4
(SW6) Andromeda - 4
(SW6) Catspaw - 4
(SW6) Dragonmage - 4

and finally, coming in just at the cut-off with 3/8:

(5YL) Brainiac 5 - 3
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid - 3
(5YL) Color Kid - 3
(5YL) Crystal Kid - 3
(5YL) Fire Lad - 3
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare) - 3
(5YL) Laurel Gand - 3
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan) - 3
(5YL) Shrinking Violet - 3
(5YL) Tyroc - 3
(5YL) Veilmist - 3
(5YL) White Witch - 3
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman - 3
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy - 3
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire - 3
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl - 3
(Bendisboot) Computo - 3
(Dead Earth) Wildfire - 3
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy - 3
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5 - 3
(Pre-5YL) Blok - 3
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King - 3
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy - 3
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad - 3
(Pre-5YL) Krypto - 3
(Reboot) Apparition - 3
(Reboot) Chameleon - 3
(Reboot) Chuck Taine - 3
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson) - 3
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - 3
(Reboot) Karate Kid - 3
(Reboot) M'Onel - 3
(Reboot) Sensor - 3
(Reboot) Spark - 3
(Reboot) Star Boy - 3
(Reboot) Ultra Boy - 3
(Reboot) Umbra - 3
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl - 3
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass - 3
(SW6) Alchemist - 3
(SW6) Kid Quantum - 3

ELIMINATIONS - just missing the cut off with 2/8: we also lose quite a few Legionnaires with no counterparts, but also a few Legionnaires with (whom I thought might be more popular!)

(5YL) Calamity King - 2
(5YL) Cosmic Boy - 2
(5YL) Echo - 2
(5YL) Karate Kid II - 2
(5YL) Kono - 2
(5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty) - 2
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish) - 2
(5YL) Nightwind - 2
(5YL) Reflecto - 2
(5YL) Timber Wolf - 2
(5YL) Ultra Boy - 2
(5YL) Valor - 2
(5YL) Visi-Lad - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5 - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V - 2
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman - 2
(Arthurian Legion) Triad - 2
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5 - 2
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy - 2
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern - 2
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy - 2
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad - 2
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl - 2
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon) - 2
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl - 2
(Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix - 2
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad - 2
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid - 2
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet - 2
(Pre-5YL) Beppo - 2
(Pre-5YL) Comet - 2
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen) - 2
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang) - 2
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I - 2
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho - 2
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 2
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid - 2
(Pre-5YL) Proty II - 2
(Pre-5YL) Streaky - 2
(Reboot) Element Lad - 2
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I - 2
(Reboot) Leviathan - 2
(Reboot) Magno - 2
(Reboot) Timber Wolf - 2
(Reboot) Wildfire - 2
(Retroboot) Dragonwing - 2
(Retroboot) Gates - 2
(Retroboot) Glorith - 2
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li - 2
(Retroboot) Lightning Lass - 2
(Retroboot) Saturn Girl - 2
(Retroboot) Shrinking Violet - 2
(SW6) Valor - 2
(Threeboot) Dream Girl - 2
(Threeboot) Light Lass - 2
(Threeboot) Supergirl - 2
(Threeboot) Triplicate Girl - 2

With 1/8 votes, we also sya goodbye to:

(5YL) Chameleon Boy - 1
(5YL) Flederweb - 1
(5YL) Invisible Kid II - 1
(5YL) Polar Boy - 1
(5YL) Porcupine Pete - 1
(5YL) Wildfire - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Cosmic Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Dream Woman - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duo Damsel - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Element Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Karate King - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Light Lady - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Night Woman - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Phantom Woman - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Polar Man - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman - 1
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Star Man - 1
(Bendisboot) Blok - 1
(Bendisboot) Dawnstar - 1
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate - 1
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad - 1
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass - 1
(Legion Animated Movie) Dawnstar - 1
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Matter-Eater Lad - 1
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid - 1
(Pre-5YL) Pete Ross - 1
(Retroboot) Comet Queen - 1
(Retroboot) Lightning Lad - 1
(Retroboot) Ultra Boy - 1
(Superboy's Legion) Star Boy - 1
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad - 1
(Threeboot) Atom Girl - 1
(Threeboot) Gazelle - 1

and closing out the round, with zero votes are:

(Bendisboot) Chameleon Boy - 0
(Bendisboot) Mon-el - 0
(Bendisboot) Timber Wolf - 0
(Bendisboot) Triplicate Girl - 0
(Threeboot) Phantom Girl - 0

We lose 103 more Legionnaires from the list, bringing us to 101 Legionnaires!

The following realities lose their last representatives this round:

DC Animated (JLU-verse)
Legion Animated Movie

While the following realities are left with one lone representative:

Adult Legion (Adventure Era)
Bendisboot
Dead Earth
Superboy's Legion
Threeboot

thanks again all for voting - next round will be up soon!

Round 3 begins!

We're down to 101, let's move to pick our Top 75!

And I'm going to make it harder (and hopefully more interesting) for everyone - this time we're going to RANK our favorites! That's right, list your top picks from 1-30.

Points will be distributed as follows - they are intentionally skewed so that a higher ranking gives a much higher number of points!

Points are awarded as follows:

Rank - Points
1 - 600
2 - 500
3 - 400
4 - 350
5 - 300
6 - 250
7 - 200
8 - 170
9 - 150
10 - 120
11 - 110
12 - 100
13 - 90
14 - 80
15 - 70
16 - 60
17 - 50
18 - 45
19 - 40
20 - 35
21 - 30
22 - 25
23 - 20
24 - 15
25 - 12
26 - 9
27 - 7
28 - 5
29 - 3
30 - 1

The Top 75 vote-getters get through, meaning we will lose 26 Legionnaires.

and please copy-paste the list/wording exactly as below, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours (so, around this time on January 16, though I will be in the office then, so this will end a bit later!)
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Adult Legion (Adventure Era)
Arthurian Legion
Bendisboot
Dead Earth
Legion Toon (and Comic)
Pre-5YL
Reboot
Retroboot
Superboy's Legion
SW6
Threeboot

Round 3 list!

Realities are listed alphabetically; then Legionnaires are listed alphabetically within reality.

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid
(5YL) Color Kid
(5YL) Crystal Kid
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(5YL) Spider-Girl
(5YL) Stone Boy
(5YL) Tyroc
(5YL) Veilmist
(5YL) White Witch
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl
(Bendisboot) Computo
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Krypto
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) XS
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
(Retroboot) Night Girl
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
(SW6) Alchemist
(SW6) Andromeda
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Dragonmage
(SW6) Kid Quantum
(Threeboot) Theena

*Round ends around this time +6 hours, Tuesday, January 16th!! (I will be in the office then, so will end around my dinner time here in Amsterdam!*

This was tough!

1 - (Reboot) Kinetix
2 - (Reboot) Gates
3 - (Reboot) Brainiac 5
4 - (Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
5 - (Reboot) Live Wire
6 - (Reboot) Apparition
7 - (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
8 - (Reboot) XS
9 - (Reboot) Chameleon
10 - (Reboot) Monstress
11 - (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
12 - (Reboot) Chuck Taine
13 - (Reboot) Saturn Girl
14 - (Reboot) Shikari
15 - (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
16 - (Reboot) Umbra
17 - (Reboot) Gear
18 - (Reboot) Dreamer
19 - (Reboot) Karate Kid
20 - (Reboot) Invisible Kid
21 - (Reboot) Spark
22 - (Reboot) Triad
23 - (Reboot) M'Onel
24 - (Reboot) Sensor
25 - (Reboot) Star Boy
26 - (5YL) Infectious Lass
27 - (Reboot) Ultra Boy
28 - (Reboot) Ferro
29 - (Reboot) Andromeda
30 - (Reboot) Thunder

I'll vote later, but I find it interesting and kinda funny that Dead Earth Wildfire made it through, but postboot Wildfire didn't

yeah, talk about a one-hit wonder re Dead Earth Wildfire

A couple more favs, and a number I'd have liked to have done really well now >sniff< gone.

Trying to get the remainder down to 30, never mind allocating points is tough going, just as you say Ibbs.

1. (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
2. (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
3. (5YL) Infectious Lass
4. (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
5. (Pre-5YL) Superboy
6. (Threeboot) Theena
7. (Pre-5YL) Krypto
8. (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
9. (5YL) Veilmist
10. (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
11. (Pre-5YL) Supergirl
12. (Pre-5YL) Quislet
13. (Reboot) Invisible Kid
14. (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
15. (Reboot) Kinetix
16. (Reboot) XS
17. (Pre-5YL) Star Boy
18. (Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
19. (SW6) Catspaw
20. (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
21. (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
22. (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
23. (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
24. (Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
25. (SW6) Andromeda
26. (Pre-5YL) Chemical King
27. (Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
28. (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
29. (5YL) Stone Boy
30. (Reboot) Thunder

Originally Posted by thoth lad

A couple more favs, and a number I'd have liked to have done really well now >sniff< gone.

Trying to get the remainder down to 30, never mind allocating points is tough going, just as you say Ibbs.

indeed, I think we're al in the same boat thothy, not easy!

out of curiosity, who are the top of the top faves of yours who've been eliminated?

also: nice eclectic list, EDE!

Ok, a stack rank of 30... this'll be hard...

Easier in that it helped get rid of a lot of entries, but still not easy to rank.

1 (Reboot) Kinetix
2 (Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
3 (5YL) Shrinking Violet
4 (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
5 (Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
6 (Reboot) Gates
7 (Reboot) Monstress
8 (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
9 (Reboot) XS
10 (Reboot) Triad
11 (Reboot) Spark
12 (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
13 (Reboot) Saturn Girl
14 (Threeboot) Theena
15 (Reboot) Live Wire
16 (Reboot) M'Onel
17 (Reboot) Sensor
18 (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
19 (Reboot) Dreamer
20 (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
21 (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
22 (Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
23 (Reboot) Andromeda
24 (Reboot) Chuck Taine
25 (Reboot) Brainiac 5
26 (Reboot) Chameleon
27 (Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
28 (Pre-5YL) Element Lad
29 (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
30 (Pre-5YL) Blok

1 - (Dead Earth) Wildfire
2 - (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
3 - (5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
4 - (5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
5 - (5YL) Brainiac 5
6 - (Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
7 - (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
8 - (5YL) Laurel Gand
9 - (5YL) Shrinking Violet
10 - (Pre-5YL) White Witch
11 - (Pre-5YL) Tellus
12 - (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
13 - (Pre-5YL) Quislet
14 - (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
15 - (Reboot) Kinetix
16 - (Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
17 - (Pre-5YL) Blok
18 - (Reboot) XS
19 - (SW6) Computo
20 - (Reboot) Andromeda
21 - (Reboot) Ferro
22 - (Reboot) Gates
23 - (Threeboot) Theena
24 - (Pre-5YL) Wildfire
25 - (Pre-5YL) Supergirl
26 - (Reboot) Triad
27 - (Pre-5YL) Superboy
28 - (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
29 - (Reboot) Brainiac 5
30 - (Reboot) Invisible Kid

Very tough - and the ranking, with the huge difference in points between the top 10 and the bottom 10!

1) (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
2) (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
3) (SW6) Dragonmage
4) (Pre-5YL) Tellus
5) (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
6) (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
7) (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
8) (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
9) (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
10) (Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
11) (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
12) (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
13) (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
14) (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
15) (SW6) Computo
16) (Threeboot) Theena
17) (Retroboot) Night Girl
18) (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
19) (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
20) (Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
21) (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
22) (Reboot) Umbra
23) (5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
24) (5YL) Crystal Kid
25) (5YL) Spider-Girl
26) (Pre-5YL) Element Lad
27) (Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
28) (Pre-5YL) Star Boy
29) (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
30) (Superboy's Legion) Light Lass

Welcome to the difficulty of the Idol games, gang

I think thothy, GL and stile are first-timers at the LW Idol ways of voting, whereas Reboot, Nighty, Set and EDE have been through this before

I also find it interesting and cool, how some of us would have multiple entries for different versions of a Legionnaire (e.g., pre-5YL Vi + Reboot Vi), where others stick to one version per Legionnaire.

I believe at least a couple on my list benefited from my preferred version being eliminated, and so my choosing close-enough counterparts!

So many of my favorites are those unique to one reality or at least with few counterparts.

I think I got 3 entries and 30 seconds into the remaining list yesterday, trying to weigh up points.
I abandoned that to just try and select my Knights of the 30.
Losing the final 2 or 3 to get to the 30 proved a tough one.
I've not been reading much Leigon recently, so going through the list reminded me, once again, just how much so many characters have given to the book. It made dropping some harder.
There's space between the different 'boots for some characters. Some stand out more in one than in anoother. Sometimes, that's just a particular story. It's interesting to see if that splits points, allowing characters unique to a 'boot to come through.

Originally Posted by Ibby

out of curiosity, who are the top of the top faves of yours who've been eliminated?

Not telling in case that character still has a version left in there.

Well, not telling yet...

1 - (Pre-5YL) Supergirl
2 - (5YL) Laurel Gand
3 - (5YL) Infectious Lass
4 - (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
5 - (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
6 - (5YL) Brainiac 5
7 - (Pre-5YL) Mon-el
8 - (5YL) Shrinking Violet
9 - (Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
10 - (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
11 - (Pre-5YL) Krypto
12 - (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
13 - (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
14 - (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
15 - (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
16 - (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
17 - (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
18 - (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
19 - (Pre-5YL) Blok
20 - (Pre-5YL) Wildfire
21 - (Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
22 - (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
23 - (Pre-5YL) Superboy
24 - (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
25 - (5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
26 - (Pre-5YL) White Witch
27 - (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
28 - (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
29 - (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
30 - (Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

I believe at least a couple on my list benefited from my preferred version being eliminated, and so my choosing close-enough counterparts!

So many of my favorites are those unique to one reality or at least with few counterparts.

I think Legionnaires with multiple counterparts definitely have a handicap, by potentially splitting the vote between their counterparts! Will be curious to see if multiple counterparts of certain Legionnaires will battle it out in later rounds!

Originally Posted by thoth lad

I've not been reading much Leigon recently, so going through the list reminded me, once again, just how much so many characters have given to the book. It made dropping some harder.

Originally Posted by Ibby

out of curiosity, who are the top of the top faves of yours who've been eliminated?

Not telling in case that character still has a version left in there.

Well, not telling yet...

fair enough

And indeed, one reason I love these types of games, is the walk down memory lane!

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

I believe at least a couple on my list benefited from my preferred version being eliminated, and so my choosing close-enough counterparts!

So many of my favorites are those unique to one reality or at least with few counterparts.

I think Legionnaires with multiple counterparts definitely have a handicap, by potentially splitting the vote between their counterparts! Will be curious to see if multiple counterparts of certain Legionnaires will battle it out in later rounds!

I've not had to pitch versions agaisnt each other for points yet. I was susprised that 5YG Jo went out so early. That was a character who was key to a number of the TMK arcs. Perhaps voters felt it was too many arcs, and voted him down as all these years later, they are still sick of his panel hogging.

Well, so much for my resistance in not blabbing on characters I thought would do well. That lasted five minutes.

The thing with the Legion for me, is that there are so many characters with something to offer. So, they are all sort of favs in their own way. Except Earth Man, who is the exception proving the rule.

I find up to now, I've been able to get on pretty well - I've had some drop out from the original cullings, but a lot are still there. So far its been easy to just hit reset to what the current list is.

5YG Jo was definitely one of the eliminations that raised an eyebrow of surprise from me!

I’ve lost a few Legionnaires that I quite like, but *touch wood* none of my super top faves yet.

As a fanfic writer, I admit to wincing a bit with the elimination of Nightwind - but that’s not the Nightwind I write, so…

I like Nightwind too. Then I realised the extent of her 5YG on panel membership, and she had to go.
I'm looking forward to any commentary on why character's are top faves for posters. That was a really enjoyable part of other idols.

With Nightwind, I always liked the idea of her as a Legionnaire. Really wish she had more screen time. Gail Simone gave her some great moments in the Reboot. I thought Nightwind did pretty well in her first couple of appearances, even knocking Wildfire for a loop. was not convinced that she wasn't ready for the team.

Infectious Lass is one of my top picks, for how useful she was 5YL (and for the Reboot, the Gail Simone story). Taking Universo out, figuring something out to stop zombies...

and of course, Kinetix is still my top one pick - her origin always fascinated me, searching for power in order to "not be useless" and to help people. her friendship with Vi was great, and I'm glad they had her turn her back on power - finally - later in the Reboot.

as for Polar Boy, I respect and admire him for coming up with the idea to form the Subs . he was not out for glory, he genuinely wanted to do good. and he kept at it until joining the Legion. he didn't have an easy time... I also respect him for bringing Brainiac 5 to trial, whatever his personal feelings, he did want to uphold the constitution.

many of my other faves also had good growth arcs. Reboot Vi, fighting back against the Emerald Eye and becoming more confident.
Reboot Tinya, dealing with her overbearing mother (can sympathize with her parental issues).
Reboot Garth, slowly maturing, and also having to deal with understanding that his beloved older brother was just rotten.
XS, growing out of her initial panic with her first mission...
Kid Q II, from hothead to Legion leader...
Reboot Brainy, slowly learning how to make friends... same for Gates, and Gates always had hilarious one-liners, but underneath that, Gates really cared about his fellow sentient.

Originally Posted by thoth lad

I'm looking forward to any commentary on why character's are top faves for posters. That was a really enjoyable part of other idols.

and agree,. would really enjoy discussion from everyone

1 - (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
2 - (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
3 - (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
4 - (Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
5 - (Pre-5YL) Tyroc
6 - (Pre-5YL) Star Boy
7 - (Pre-5YL) Mon-el
8 - (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
9 - (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
10 - (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
11 - (Pre-5YL) Supergirl
12 - (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
13 - (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
14 - (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
15 - (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
16 - (Pre-5YL) Wildfire
17 - (Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
18 - (Pre-5YL) Chemical King
19 - (Pre-5YL) Element Lad
20 - (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
21 - (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
22 - (Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
23 - (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
24 - (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
25 - (Pre-5YL) Superboy
26 - (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
27 - (Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
28 - (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
29 - (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
30 - (Pre-5YL) White Witch

1 - (Reboot) Shikari
2 - (Reboot) Spark
3 - (Reboot) Triad
4 - (Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
5 - (Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
6 - (Reboot) Thunder
7 - (SW6) Kid Quantum
8 - (Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
9 - (Reboot) Ultra Boy
10 - (Reboot) Star Boy
11 - (Reboot) Ferro
12 - (Reboot) Karate Kid
13 - (SW6) Catspaw
14 - (Reboot) Gear
15 - (Reboot) Andromeda
16 - (Reboot) Sensor
17 - (Reboot) M'Onel
18 - (Reboot) Umbra
19 - (Reboot) Dreamer
20 - (Reboot) Gates
21 - (Reboot) Invisible Kid
22 - (Reboot) Brainiac 5
23 - (Reboot) XS
24 - (Reboot) Saturn Girl
25 - (SW6) Computo
26 - (Reboot) Chameleon
27 - (Reboot) Chuck Taine
28 - (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
29 - (Reboot) Apparition
30 - (Reboot) Live Wire

I see all 8 "regular" voters have voted, and I am delayed from leaving home due to trains not working, so I will start tallying now!

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

I believe at least a couple on my list benefited from my preferred version being eliminated, and so my choosing close-enough counterparts!

So many of my favorites are those unique to one reality or at least with few counterparts.

I think Legionnaires with multiple counterparts definitely have a handicap, by potentially splitting the vote between their counterparts! Will be curious to see if multiple counterparts of certain Legionnaires will battle it out in later rounds!

Yeah, this round, the only ones from multiple boots I've been going for have been Ayla (Superboy's Legion Light Lass was so different, with her light powers), Tasmia (Umbra from the Reboot with her darkforce powers) and Triplicate Girl from the Reboot, who had a distinctive personality and role compared to 'classic' Luornu.

But in the end, I'll be probably pruning them for single-worlders like Tellus, Kid Quantum 2 and Dragonmage (if they make it to the next round).

update: trains started again, am halfway through tallying. will head to the office, and aim to finish this during my lunch break!

RESULTS TIME!!! End of Round 3!!

We choose our Top 75 from the 101 remaining, so 26 are going home...

With 8 voters doing the selecting....

here is the ranking, from highest to lowest!

Reboot (Kinetix) gets propelled to the top, with two 1st rank votes! While 5YL Matter-Eater Lad gets one Rank 1 and one Rank 4, and Reboot Violet gets a rank 2 and a rank 4.

And 5YL Infectious Lass, despite her relatively short actual tenure, places quite highly... and Dead Earth Wildfire only got 1 vote, but a Rank 1, so flies to safety!

1 ) (Reboot) Kinetix - 1340
2 ) (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad 950
3 ) (Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II 910
4 ) (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 895
5 ) (Reboot) Kid Quantum II 875
6 ) (Pre-5YL) Supergirl 832
7 ) (Reboot) Gates 810
8 ) (5YL) Infectious Lass 809
9 ) (5YL) Shrinking Violet 720
10 ) (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy 710
11 ) (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel 695
12 ) (Reboot) Shikari 680
13 ) (5YL) Laurel Gand 670
14 ) (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid 650
15 ) (Reboot) Spark 640
16 ) (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass 633
17 ) (Dead Earth) Wildfire 600
18 ) (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy 600
19 ) (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass 555
20 ) (Reboot) Triad 554
21 ) (5YL) Brainiac 5 550
22 ) (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl 510
23 ) (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl 483
24 ) (Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet 482
25 ) (Pre-5YL) Tellus 460
26 ) (Reboot) XS 445
27 ) (Reboot) Brainiac 5 440
28 ) (5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare) 412
29 ) (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy 411
30 ) (Threeboot) Theena 410
31 ) (Pre-5YL) Mon-el 400
32 ) (SW6) Dragonmage 400
33 ) (Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad 396
34 ) (Reboot) Live Wire 371
35 ) (5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan) 370
36 ) (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy 350
37 ) (Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el) 350
38 ) (Pre-5YL) Superboy 339
39 ) (Reboot) Monstress 320
40 ) (Pre-5YL) Krypto 310
41 ) (Pre-5YL) Star Boy 305
42 ) (Pre-5YL) Tyroc 300
43 ) (Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson) 300
44 ) (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy 280
45 ) (Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II 257
46 ) (Reboot) Apparition 253
47 ) (Reboot) Thunder 252
48 ) (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl 243
49 ) (Reboot) Cosmic Boy 230
50 ) (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar 218
51 ) (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy 215
52 ) (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl 210
53 ) (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf 205
54 ) (SW6) Kid Quantum 200
55 ) (Reboot) Saturn Girl 195
56 ) (Pre-5YL) Quislet 190
57 ) (Superboy's Legion) Light Lass 171
58 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5 170
59 ) (Reboot) Chameleon 168
60 ) (Reboot) Ultra Boy 157
61 ) (Reboot) Invisible Kid 156
62 ) (5YL) Veilmist 150
63 ) (Reboot) Ferro 145
64 ) (Reboot) Karate Kid 140
65 ) (Reboot) Star Boy 132
66 ) (Pre-5YL) White Witch 130
67 ) (Reboot) Gear 130
68 ) (Reboot) M'Onel 130
69 ) (Reboot) Umbra 130
70 ) (SW6) Catspaw 130
71 ) (Reboot) Andromeda 128
72 ) (Reboot) Dreamer 125
73 ) (Reboot) Sensor 125
74 ) (Reboot) Chuck Taine 122
75 ) (SW6) Computo 122

And our bottom 26, all going home...

Superman and Retroboot Duplicate Damsel just miss safety by 2 points each!

76 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman 120
77 ) (Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel 120
78 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy 115
79 ) (Pre-5YL) Wildfire 110
80 ) (Pre-5YL) Blok 91
81 ) (Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy 87
82 ) (Pre-5YL) Chemical King 54
83 ) (Pre-5YL) Element Lad 54
84 ) (Retroboot) Night Girl 50
85 ) (Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad 47
86 ) (Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar 35
87 ) (5YL) Crystal Kid 15
88 ) (5YL) Spider-Girl 12
89 ) (SW6) Andromeda 12
90 ) (5YL) Stone Boy 3
91 ) (5YL) Chlorophyll Kid 0
92 ) (5YL) Color Kid 0
93 ) (5YL) Fire Lad 0
94 ) (5YL) Tyroc 0
95 ) (5YL) White Witch 0
96 ) (Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy 0
97 ) (Arthurian Legion) Live Wire 0
98 ) (Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl 0
99 ) (Bendisboot) Computo 0
100 ) (Retroboot) Chameleon Girl 0
101 ) (SW6) Alchemist 0

Lots of surprises here. I'm mainly surprised at pre-5YL Wildfire, Cham, Element Lad, Lightning Lad, White Witch and Blok all going home fairly early... quite a few zero votes too!

The following realities lose their last representatives this round:

Arthurian Legion (Cos, Garth and Imra)
Bendisboot (Computo)
Retroboot (Duplicate Damsel, Chameleon Girl and Night Girl!)

thanks again, all, for voting - next round will be up shortly!

Round 4 begins!

We're down to 75, let's pick our Top 50!

This time, list your top picks from 1-25.

Points will be distributed as follows - they are intentionally skewed so that a higher ranking gives a much higher number of points!

Rank - Points
1 - 520
2 - 420
3 - 330
4 - 270
5 - 230
6 - 190
7 - 170
8 - 150
9 - 130
10 - 115
11 - 100
12 - 90
13 - 80
14 - 70
15 - 60
16 - 50
17 - 40
18 - 30
19 - 25
20 - 20
21 - 15
22 - 10
23 - 7
24 - 4
25 - 1

The Top 50 vote-getters get through, meaning we will lose 25 Legionnaires.

and please copy-paste the list/wording exactly as below, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

House Rules - including a rule I missed stating earlier, on how to break ties! (this has been in place in past Idols)

1) Each round will last about 72 hours (so, around this time on January 16, though I will be in the office then, so this will end a bit later!)
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Dead Earth
Legion Toon (and Comic)
Pre-5YL
Reboot
Superboy's Legion
SW6
Threeboot

Round 4 list!

Realities are listed alphabetically; then Legionnaires are listed alphabetically within reality.

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(5YL) Veilmist
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Krypto
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) White Witch
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) XS
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Computo
(SW6) Dragonmage
(SW6) Kid Quantum
(Threeboot) Theena

*Round ends around this time +6 hours, Friday, January 19th!! (most likely after dinner - I'm expecting a very busy day at work!)

Some observations while I'm thinking of my votes:

1) Brainiac 5 has 4 different versions still on the list! while Ayla and Salu both have 3 each! (it was tough to count, as I can only pivot by code name... I had to scroll up and down...). we have a number of Legionnaires with 2 versions left on the list.

2) Among the Adventure-Era stalwarts with multiple versions, Element Lad has been completely eliminated from the list.

3) For Live Wire and Chameleon and Lyle Norg, only the Reboot counterparts are left on the list!

4) while for Colossal Boy, only the pre-5YL version remains.

5) We still have quite a few "unique" Legionnaires, with no/ few multiversal counterparts, on the list - Kinetix, XS, Gates, Kid Quantum II, Gear, Monstress, Theena, Infectious Lass, Polar Boy, Tellus, Thunder, Veilmist, Krypto, Quislet, Devlin, Kent Shakespeare, Sandy-Inferno, Catspaw, Computo, Dragonmage...

6) conversely, we've lost many who don't have any/many counterparts: last round we lost Blok, Chemical King, Crystal Kid, Spider-Girl, Veilmist, Chameleon Girl, Rond Vidar, and most of the original Subs (Fire Lad, Color Kid, Chlorophyll Kid, Stone Boy, Night Girl)... (not listing more from earlier rounds, as there are too many to list)

6) and the sole Wildfire left on the list... is the Dead Earth version!

7) the only non-comic book Legionnaire left is Toon Brainiac 5!

8) Krypto is the only remaining Super-Pet on the list.

That Dead Earth Wildfire really sticks out.

Round 3 thoughts:-

Originally Posted by Ibby

Lots of surprises here. I'm mainly surprised at pre-5YL Wildfire, Cham, Element Lad, Lightning Lad, White Witch and Blok all going home fairly early... quite a few zero votes too!

Wildfire - Perhaps even within 'boots we have eras, with the early Bronze Age not coming out too well, posted between the Adventure era and Levitz Mk2. Something boosted by the 5YG focus on the Adventure era characters, and the bronze age characters being punted off to Legion Lost in v6/7. Dawny is the most popular, while Blok has joined Wildfire here.

Going by reader sentiment, Drake certainly looked to have been popular, a more aggressive action-first character with A-lister powers. But it's just as likely in these things, that voters were squeezed by having to make other choices, especially multiples of the same character.
Or they just thought he was an argumentative joik. He did provide a counterpoint to more conservative characters, joining frequent nemesis Lightning Lad in being eliminated this round. And was the guy pushing for the Academy students. Only for Polar Boy, Sensor Girl and off the street Quislet to get in, along with Nepotism Lad.

By the time I started reading, Garth had retired, and back issues showed him resigning as leader. So, not an awful lot for me to pin some popularity on for me. Even in the Adventure issues, his better arcs were him not as himself (Starfinger) or dead, with people trying to bring him back.

Jan had awesome powers that had to be constantly downplayed, not least by giving him a more passive personality. Regular deputy leader, but not one I was ever routing for.

Blok got introduced among a number of writers. It took a while for him to develop a personality and place in the team, and I thought his relationship with Timberwolf and Mysa would have kept him around a bit longer.

Pre-5YG Mysa is still around. But Mysa’s arc in 5YG was just one of many with a clear, if controversial, narrative start to it, but which didn’t pay off as it should have done.

A bit surprised at Cham going out. A mainstay across the boots, head of the espionage squad, stories of lost loves and issues with him finding out about his father. The latter not one of my favs, and his reboot version is still there. A version where they had the chance to get a little deeper into the character. Already out 5YG Cham started strongly, but ended up trading presidential duties for a traumatised planet over a squash game. So, not many points there.

Duplicate Damsel Definitely caught between versions for me. I’d have given more had I not felt I had to give more to another version.

Superman would have got more points, had we not all become suspicious of all that pipe smoking in the Adult Legion’s future. Suspicions that the Legion’s biggest foe turned out to be Big Tobacco

I definitely think that some of these early eliminations, would have done better at a Survivor-type game, where people vote off whom they DON'T like. some of these certainly are well-liked; just that, are they MORE well-liked than others?

certainly, being in someone's (or multiple ones') top 5s gives a great boost to safety. but being in a lot of Rank 21-30s... was not as helpful

thanks folks, keep the discussion coming - that's one of my fave parts of these games!

re Jan... well, Reboot Jan for me was a bit soured by him becoming the Progenitor. Threeboot Jan... I didn't like the big reduction in his powers. and Pre-5YL Jan... was a bit too snarky and judgmental for me, at times. I will always remember him a) ending a call with Nura right after she - nicely - said she would enjoy leading with him as Deputy; b) him snarking at both Brin and Imra after that whole asteroid debacle (I always felt that Brin and Imra were being unfairly maligned, heavens, all we saw was them hugging each other in the face of a very difficult and potentially deadly situation); and c) his wink-wink-nudge-nudge moment on that Sun-Eater factory world, when Jo messed up and Cham didn't. whispering to Cham "at least SOME of us remember that it's not what powers you have, but how you use them". I always felt like, well, Jan sure is being catty!

my fave "mainstream" Jan is probably the SW6 one, actually. he was a very nice guy!

(I have similar negative thoughts about some still on the list, but I'd rather save those comments for later!)

I wonder if Superman would have done better, had Superboy not also been on the list.

Duplicate Damsel - while I did like the power upgrade, the Reboot and Pre-5YL (esp. Adventure Era) versions tug a my heartstrings more. what with the Reboot's trauma growing up, and the pre-5YL's trauma losing one-third of her (belatedly explored), or that Shooter story where she cried her heart out re Superboy being oblivious to her crush.

trying not to overthink this... but was interrupted by, you know, actual work

in any case...

1 - (Reboot) Kinetix
2 - (Reboot) Gates
3 - (Reboot) Brainiac 5
4 - (Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
5 - (Reboot) Chameleon
6 - (Reboot) Monstress
7 - (Reboot) Gear
8 - (Reboot) XS
9 - (Reboot) Live Wire
10 - (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
11 - (Reboot) Apparition
12 - (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
13 - (Reboot) Shikari
14 - (Reboot) Umbra
15 - (Reboot) Saturn Girl
16 - (Reboot) Dreamer
17 - (Reboot) Spark
18 - (Reboot) Triad
19 - (Reboot) Karate Kid
20 - (5YL) Infectious Lass
21 - (Reboot) M'Onel
22 - (Reboot) Invisible Kid
23 - (Reboot) Chuck Taine
24 - (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
25 - (Reboot) Cosmic Boy

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

re Jan... well, Reboot Jan for me was a bit soured by him becoming the Progenitor. Threeboot Jan... I didn't like the big reduction in his powers. and Pre-5YL Jan... was a bit too snarky and judgmental for me, at times. I will always remember him a) ending a call with Nura right after she - nicely - said she would enjoy leading with him as Deputy; b) him snarking at both Brin and Imra after that whole asteroid debacle (I always felt that Brin and Imra were being unfairly maligned, heavens, all we saw was them hugging each other in the face of a very difficult and potentially deadly situation); and c) his wink-wink-nudge-nudge moment on that Sun-Eater factory world, when Jo messed up and Cham didn't. whispering to Cham "at least SOME of us remember that it's not what powers you have, but how you use them". I always felt like, well, Jan sure is being catty!

my fave "mainstream" Jan is probably the SW6 one, actually. he was a very nice guy!

I wonder if Superman would have done better, had Superboy not also been on the list.

Duplicate Damsel - while I did like the power upgrade, the Reboot and Pre-5YL (esp. Adventure Era) versions tug a my heartstrings more. what with the Reboot's trauma growing up, and the pre-5YL's trauma losing one-third of her (belatedly explored), or that Shooter story where she cried her heart out re Superboy being oblivious to her crush.

Pre-5YG Jan. Good points. When he did lose some of his quietness, he came across as a snark. While not endearing, I quite like the complexity it gives the character. The world is full of people who are quiet happy to be seen as a bit more spiritual, or quietly confident, but are actually far less than they appear. Pretty much all of Jan's 5YG spirituallity was really all about him. And then there's the Progenitor. It's hard to imagine how such an incident would have affected anyone. But at the core of Jan, there were always those little seeds...

Superman might have got more points, but he's either Adult Legion or used by DC because they were opposed to the legal case on the character. Mind you, Superman did tell Supergirl about the Legion, when the Legion's children came to recruit her...oh wait...

yeah, and my main qualm about Jan as a snark is, in these cases he didn't seem quite justified. I would like him more if his snark were directed at the "right" situations, if that makes sense.

In these cases, he just seemed overly petty. and with the Jo example, as the leader, I would have preferred a direct telling-off.

of course, this did serve to give Jan a different characterization - as you rightly say, it made him complex. it was certainly an interesting personality trait. (and indeed, just not one that endeared him to me

)

Yeah Jan has had a lot of focus over multiple eras and is a really interesting character - but somehow is just not as appealing to me as others.

Originally Posted by Gaseous Lad

That Dead Earth Wildfire really sticks out.

I confess. I'm the culprit.
DE Wildfire may only have appeared in a single issue but wow, what he did there, centuries after centuries maintaining the dream while everyone he knew was long gone, and in the end succeeding not only in creating a new Legion but bringing the galaxy back together. That's why he gets such a strong vote from me.

Superman - this one hurt. As most of you know I am a Superman fan, but this is a Legion list and in that context there are just quite a few more interesting and appealing Legionnaires.

I think perhaps the unique legionnaires (those that only appear in one version) have an advantage in that they stand out because of their difference, and nobody wants to lose that uniqueness.

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

I presume this means that - apart from a tie - points are not cumulative from round to round, but only specific to that round (otherwise the leaders would quickly zoom to the stratosphere with the point skew!)

It will be interesting to compare people's votes especially since this round is only 5 less than last round.

Ibby, I see your top 4 didn't change but then the next few get shaken up a bit. Gear climbs 10 positions! What did he give you between the two rounds, hey? Must have been something to annoy you about Cosmic Boy - bottom rung! Then you keep in 5YL Infectious Lass and add back 5YL Matter-Eater Lad that means you lose some more precious Reboot characters. Hard choices for sure, but losing Andromeda (well she is only there for the first and last years I guess) and Thunder (such an interesting late addition) and Ferro (I guess he started well with his new 20th Century and Final Night origin but not so much after that). Just kidding. This selection stuff is really tricky.

Oh and I wonder if Theena will survive this round? Not that likely but she was a very interesting and appealing Threeboot addition - and another unique character.

Oops. I was thinking Theena was at the bottom, but that was actually SW6 Computo, another very interesting unique character - who will be very lucky to survive the next round.

For better or worse here we go ...

1 - (Dead Earth) Wildfire
2 - (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
3 - (5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
4 - (5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
5 - (5YL) Brainiac 5
6 - (Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
7 - (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
8 - (5YL) Laurel Gand
9 - (5YL) Shrinking Violet
10 - (Pre-5YL) White Witch
11 - (Pre-5YL) Tellus
12 - (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
13 - (Pre-5YL) Quislet
14 - (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
15 - (Reboot) Kinetix
16 - (Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
17 - (Reboot) XS
18 - (SW6) Computo
19 - (Reboot) Triad
20 - (Reboot) Andromeda
21 - (Reboot) Ferro
22 - (Reboot) Gates
23 - (Threeboot) Theena
24 - (Reboot) Brainiac 5
25 - (Reboot) Invisible Kid

1) (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
2) (Pre-5YL) Tellus
3) (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
3) (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
4) (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
5) (Threeboot) Theena
6) (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
7) (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
8) (Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
9) (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
10) (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
11) (Reboot) Ferro
12) (SW6) Computo
13) (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
14) (5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
15) (Reboot) Gear
16) (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
17) (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
18) (Reboot) Monstress
19) (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
20) (Pre-5YL) Mon-el
21) (Reboot) Shikari
22) (Reboot) Umbra
23) (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
24) (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
25) (Reboot) Triad

I sometimes worry a bit about being too preferential to the 'boot I grew up with, and then my top 25 includes 8 characters from the Reboot and 1 each from 5YL, SW6 and the Threeboot, so I guess I'm not totally in the bag for 'my team!' So fickle!

(Some are just no contest. Reboot Ferro and Invisible Lyle, for instance, got more recent use and development than the 'classic' versions did, so it's kind of a no-brainer to lean more towards their later versions, than the classic versions that have been gone for so long.)

Originally Posted by stile86

Y

Originally Posted by Gaseous Lad

That Dead Earth Wildfire really sticks out.

I confess. I'm the culprit.
DE Wildfire may only have appeared in a single issue but wow, what he did there, centuries after centuries maintaining the dream while everyone he knew was long gone, and in the end succeeding not only in creating a new Legion but bringing the galaxy back together. That's why he gets such a strong vote from me.

I think perhaps the unique legionnaires (those that only appear in one version) have an advantage in that they stand out because of their difference, and nobody wants to lose that uniqueness.

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

I presume this means that - apart from a tie - points are not cumulative from round to round, but only specific to that round (otherwise the leaders would quickly zoom to the stratosphere with the point skew!)

thanks for your endorsement of Dead Earth Wildfire, stile. I already thought this might be why! TBH, I would vote for DE Wildfire if only he had more screen time, and thus, emotional attachment from me. As it is, I would be sad to see him go, it's just that I'm not attached enough to him to rank him above those on my list!

Same for Superboy's Legion Light Lass, I do like her unique twist on Ayla's powers - but other than that, she had such little screen time so I'm not so attached to her!

I agree about the uniqueness factor, I do think it can be an advantage! (not for all, as we've lost several unique ones!) but it can avoid vote-splitting.

stile, you are correct re cumulative points - they exist only to break ties, and they will also come to play in a mechanic that will become clear later for a couple of rounds. other than that, they are NOT cumulative from round to round - else the leaders will become untouchable, and that wouldn't be a fun game anymore, if the leaders are absolutely safe from danger

Originally Posted by stile86

It will be interesting to compare people's votes especially since this round is only 5 less than last round.

Ibby, I see your top 4 didn't change but then the next few get shaken up a bit. Gear climbs 10 positions! What did he give you between the two rounds, hey? Must have been something to annoy you about Cosmic Boy - bottom rung! Then you keep in 5YL Infectious Lass and add back 5YL Matter-Eater Lad that means you lose some more precious Reboot characters. Hard choices for sure, but losing Andromeda (well she is only there for the first and last years I guess) and Thunder (such an interesting late addition) and Ferro (I guess he started well with his new 20th Century and Final Night origin but not so much after that). Just kidding. This selection stuff is really tricky.

nice observing, stile. I'll add another observation - two voters didn't lose any of their top 30, which means these voters have to cut 5 from their list. as for the rest, everyone lost from 2 to 7 of their list.

Gear climbed because I saw that he was fairly low in points last round - just a gamble to keep him safer this round. Cosmic Boy, was simply the one I liked most among the remaining Legionnaires I considered for the list - and as this game shows, 1 point can make a difference

I like Drura and Tenzil a lot, and while I am a very big Reboot fan, I had to gamble that other voters would keep other Reboot heroes safe

but let's say, I am more willing to lose some than others !

re Set's comment, I worry sometimes too! but I grew up with the Reboot, so in most cases I simply prefer the Reboot version for the attachment!

if it were about "best
" version, my answer mioght be different!

1. (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
2. (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
3. (5YL) Infectious Lass
4. (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
5. (Pre-5YL) Superboy
6. (Threeboot) Theena
7. (Pre-5YL) Krypto
8. (5YL) Veilmist
9. (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
10. (Pre-5YL) Supergirl
11. (Pre-5YL) Quislet
12. (Reboot) Invisible Kid
13. (Reboot) Kinetix
14. (Reboot) XS
15. (Pre-5YL) Star Boy
16. (Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
17. (SW6) Catspaw
18. (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
19. (5YL) Laurel Gand
20. (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
21. (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
22. (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
23. (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
24. (Reboot) Thunder
25. (SW6) Kid Quantum

1 - (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
2 - (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
3 - (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
4 - (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
5 - (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
6 - (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
7 - (Pre-5YL) Tyroc
8 - (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
9 - (Pre-5YL) Star Boy
10 - (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
11 - (Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
12 - (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
13 - (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
14 - (Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
15 - (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
16 - (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
17 - (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
18 - (Pre-5YL) Mon-el
19 - (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
20 - (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
21 - (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
22 - (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
23 - (Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
24 - (Pre-5YL) Supergirl
25 - (Pre-5YL) Superboy

That was quite a bit quicker this round. I guess with the change in format in place and some idea of scoring in mind, it was easier to go through. As stile said, only 5 of a difference to cut. Cutting Number 26 was tough though.

DE Wildfire kept that Legion flame alive for centuries, and it's nice to see him stand out, showing those Legion traits of selflessness and duty.
I agree with stile on Adult Supes too. Just not Legiony enough, regardless of what DC would like me to believe for copyright reasons.

I see I'm still splitting my points among some with multiples left. Points that would have otherwise gone to other boots.
I quite liked seeing Thunder appear. I think it was an Alan Davis cover that caught my eye. But in the end, it's a Super-family inspired team for me. Sad to not give some points, but a touch like Adult Supes. LW fav Theena would be another one to get points, had they not been used elsewhere.

This round, I'm relying on previous round results keeping some favs onboard, while I give a boost to one or two others. Hopefully, it won't come back to bite me.

1 - (Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
2 - (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
3 - (5YL) Laurel Gand
4 - (Pre-5YL) Supergirl
5 - (5YL) Shrinking Violet
6 - (Pre-5YL) Mon-el
7 - (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
8 - (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
9 - (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
10 - (Pre-5YL) White Witch
11 - (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
12 - (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
13 - (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
14 - (5YL) Infectious Lass
15 - (5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
16 - (Pre-5YL) Krypto
17 - (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
18 - (5YL) Brainiac 5
19 - (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
20 - (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
21 - (Pre-5YL) Superboy
22 - (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
23 - (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
24 - (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
25 - (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl

This was more challenging in some ways to determine the rankings.

(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) XS
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Sensor
(Threeboot) Theena
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad

Originally Posted by Set

1) (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
2) (Pre-5YL) Tellus
3) (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
3) (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl

You realise you're trying to have 26 votes because of that double-third, right?

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Originally Posted by stile86

Originally Posted by Gaseous Lad

That Dead Earth Wildfire really sticks out.

I confess. I'm the culprit.
DE Wildfire may only have appeared in a single issue but wow, what he did there, centuries after centuries maintaining the dream while everyone he knew was long gone, and in the end succeeding not only in creating a new Legion but bringing the galaxy back together. That's why he gets such a strong vote from me.

thanks for your endorsement of Dead Earth Wildfire, stile. I already thought this might be why! TBH, I would vote for DE Wildfire if only he had more screen time, and thus, emotional attachment from me. As it is, I would be sad to see him go, it's just that I'm not attached enough to him to rank him above those on my list!

Well, the Wildflame from One Million is played as DE Wildfire much, much later, whether or not it's technically the same version or not.

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Same for Superboy's Legion Light Lass, I do like her unique twist on Ayla's powers - but other than that, she had such little screen time so I'm not so attached to her!

Eh, I voted for her mostly as the last SL representative, if I'm honest, rather than because of her herself.

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

nice observing, stile. I'll add another observation - two voters didn't lose any of their top 30, which means these voters have to cut 5 from their list. as for the rest, everyone lost from 2 to 7 of their list.

I mean, I'm definitely voting To Save at the moment. If this was a blind "single round, list your top 30" scenario, that would NOT have been my list!

LW Election Tyrant report...

Set has two entries at number 3!

Let's go over to our special election correspondant...

thoth lad: What do you think should be the action taken here, Mr Vidar.
Mr Vidar: By my monocle, the whole election should be null and void, with the winner being my favourite.
thoth lad: My favourite? That's very kind of you Mr Vidar.
Mr Vidar: No, I meant...
thoth Lad: We're out if time Mr Vidar, it's back to the studio where I'll announce my favourite shortly...

...and there you have it. The bells of democracy ring out over Metropolis, even though the whole thing is normally just decided by a computer, who may or may not be Computo...

Originally Posted by Reboot

I mean, I'm definitely voting To Save at the moment. If this was a blind "single round, list your top 30" scenario, that would NOT have been my list!

I figured as much

and thanks for the real-time audit, Reboot, thothy. I missed that completely

Set, if you'd like to edit your list, please go ahead - otherwise I'll take the top 25, and just cut #26

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Set, if you'd like to edit your list, please go ahead - otherwise I'll take the top 25, and just cut #26

Yeah, just cut 26 Triad, my bad!

1) (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
2) (Pre-5YL) Tellus
3) (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
4) (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
5) (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
6) (Threeboot) Theena
7) (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
8) (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
9) (Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
10) (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
11) (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
12) (Reboot) Ferro
13) (SW6) Computo
14) (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
15) (5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
16) (Reboot) Gear
17) (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
18) (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
19) (Reboot) Monstress
20) (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
21) (Pre-5YL) Mon-el
22) (Reboot) Shikari
23) (Reboot) Umbra
24) (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
25) (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar

And my super-secret evil identity is wringing his tentacles and cursing Reboot's name for foiling his ballot-box-stuffing scheme!

thanks for confirming

Reboot is the Election Hero!

I assumed it was Projectra using her illusion powers to sneak onto the list!

Originally Posted by Set

And my super-secret evil identity is wringing his tentacles and cursing Reboot's name for foiling his ballot-box-stuffing scheme!

I thought Set was your super secret evil identity!

1 - (Reboot) Triad
2 - (Reboot) Umbra
3 - (Reboot) Sensor
4 - (Reboot) M'Onel
5 - (Reboot) Andromeda
6 - (Reboot) Shikari
7 - (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
8 - (Reboot) Invisible Kid
9 - (Reboot) Saturn Girl
10 - (Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
11 - (Reboot) Apparition
12 - (Reboot) Gear
13 - (Reboot) Live Wire
14 - (Reboot) Chameleon
15 - (Reboot) Star Boy
16 - (Reboot) Ultra Boy
17 - (Reboot) Karate Kid
18 - (Reboot) Ferro
19 - (Reboot) Thunder
20 - (Reboot) Dreamer
21 - (Reboot) Chuck Taine
22 - (Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
23 - (Reboot) Spark
24 - (Reboot) Gates
25 - (Reboot) Brainiac 5

ok, have a bit of a gap at work so will try to close the round, as all 8 "regular" voters have voted.

well, work was going too swimmingly, and now I'm bombarded. tallying will have to wait...

Tally-ho!

and restarting! Tally-ho and all that!

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Originally Posted by Set

And my super-secret evil identity is wringing his tentacles and cursing Reboot's name for foiling his ballot-box-stuffing scheme!

I thought Set was your super secret evil identity!

Under the obvious mustachio-twirling 'tie people to train tracks and cackle' evil, a more subtle Machiavellian evil lurks. It's evil all the way down.

RESULTS TIME!!! End of Round 3!!

We went from Top 75 to Top 50, so we're losing 25 this round...

With 8 voters doing the selecting....

here is the ranking, from highest to lowest!

Still a strong showing from several Reboot Legionnaires, 3 relatively "unique" and one who is a version of an Adventure Era stalwart! Then we have a bunch of pre-5YL's and a couple of 5YL's making the rest of the top 10 - including the relatively "unique" Polar Boy!

1 ) (Reboot) Kinetix - 1080
2 ) (Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - 840
3 ) (Reboot) Gates - 764
4 ) (Reboot) Kid Quantum II - 750
5 ) (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 730
6 ) (Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet - 720
7 ) (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - 610
8 ) (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 605
9 ) (Reboot) Triad - 575
10 ) (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy - 555
11 ) (5YL) Shrinking Violet - 530
12 ) (Dead Earth) Wildfire - 520
13 ) (Pre-5YL) Tellus - 520
14 ) (5YL) Laurel Gand - 509
15 ) (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl - 504
16 ) (Reboot) Umbra - 497
17 ) (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl - 495
18 ) (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy - 490
19 ) (Reboot) Monstress - 485
20 ) (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass - 470
21 ) (Reboot) XS - 450
22 ) (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - 440
23 ) (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 437
24 ) (5YL) Infectious Lass - 420
25 ) (Threeboot) Theena - 412
26 ) (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - 411
27 ) (Pre-5YL) Supergirl - 396
28 ) (5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare) - 390
29 ) (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass - 385
30 ) (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar - 381
31 ) (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - 360
32 ) (Reboot) Sensor - 360
33 ) (Reboot) Brainiac 5 - 335
34 ) (5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan) - 330
35 ) (Reboot) M'Onel - 325
36 ) (Reboot) Gear - 310
37 ) (Reboot) Live Wire - 300
38 ) (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - 300
39 ) (Reboot) Chameleon - 300
40 ) (Reboot) Saturn Girl - 290
41 ) (Reboot) Shikari - 280
42 ) (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - 280
43 ) (Reboot) Spark - 277
44 ) (Reboot) Cosmic Boy - 261
45 ) (5YL) Brainiac 5 - 260
46 ) (Pre-5YL) Superboy - 256
47 ) (Reboot) Invisible Kid - 251
48 ) (Reboot) Andromeda - 250
49 ) (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy - 249
50 ) (Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el) - 245

Cut-off to safety!

and going home this round, ranks 51-75...

51 ) (Pre-5YL) Mon-el - 235
52 ) (Pre-5YL) White Witch - 230
53 ) (Pre-5YL) Krypto - 220
54 ) (Pre-5YL) Star Boy - 205
55 ) (Reboot) Apparition - 200
56 ) (Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II - 197
57 ) (Pre-5YL) Quislet - 180
58 ) (Pre-5YL) Tyroc - 170
59 ) (Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad - 150
60 ) (5YL) Veilmist - 150
61 ) (Reboot) Ferro - 135
62 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5 - 130
63 ) (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy - 117
64 ) (Reboot) Karate Kid - 115
65 ) (SW6) Computo - 110
66 ) (Reboot) Dreamer - 70
67 ) (Reboot) Star Boy - 60
68 ) (Reboot) Ultra Boy - 50
69 ) (SW6) Catspaw - 40
70 ) (Reboot) Thunder - 29
71 ) (Reboot) Chuck Taine - 22
72 ) (Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson) - 10
73 ) (SW6) Kid Quantum - 1
74 ) (SW6) Dragonmage - 0
75 ) (Superboy's Legion) Light Lass - 0

Several pre-5YL folks and several Reboot folks say bye! and we also lose the last representatives of 3 realities:

SW6 (Catspaw, Computo, Dragonmage, Kid Quantum)
Superboy's Legion (Light Lass)
Legion Toon (and Comic) Brainiac 5

We also lose:

1) the last two versions of Star Boy and Ferro (Lad)
2) the last version of White Witch, Invisible Kid II, Quislet, Tyroc, Colossal Boy, Computo, Dragonmage, Catspaw, Kid Quantum I, Thunder, Sandy Anderson, Veilmist

Star Boy and Colossal Boy stand out, as being Adventure era stalwarts from the beginning

thanks again, all, for voting - next round will be up shortly!

Originally Posted by Set

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Originally Posted by Set

And my super-secret evil identity is wringing his tentacles and cursing Reboot's name for foiling his ballot-box-stuffing scheme!

I thought Set was your super secret evil identity!

Under the obvious mustachio-twirling 'tie people to train tracks and cackle' evil, a more subtle Machiavellian evil lurks. It's evil all the way down.

Perhaps Set will be the winner of our Legion VIllain Idol game

Round 5 begins!

hey, it's a weekend, let's shake it up a bit... hah! (nah, the timing just went well... but this was planned, as those who played last Idol may remember!)

and a special thanks in advance to Reboot, who helped me (more than a decade ago) figure out the coming rules for this round.

So, from Top 50, let's begin to build our... Top 30?

But we will build our top 30 in 3 phases.

Phase 1/Round 5 - We will choose the first 10 of our Top 30. These 10 will get a special bonus for the next few rounds.

Phase 2/Round 6 - The remaining 40 (of the Top 50) will duke it out - via ranking again, just like we've been doing recently. and 15 of these will move on to the Top 30. (that gives us 10 + 15 = 25). (these Legionnaires don't get a special bonus, as doing so would be too much of a hurdle for the Legionnaires coming back in...

Phase 3/Round 7 - 5 eliminated Legionnaires get a second chance, via comic book resurrection, and progress on to finish our top 30. (exact mechanics to be announced

)

Round 5 rules -

Everyone has up to 1000 points to distribute however they wish. I will count votes less than 1000, but will not allow votes greater than 1000.

Example allowable votes (using non-Legion characters):

Example 1:

1000 points - Scarlet Witch

Example 2:

500 points - Jean Grey
250 points - Monica Rambeau
250 points - Jubilee

Example 3:

100 points - Kimiyo Hoshi
100 points - Power Girl
200 points - Wonder Woman
200 points - Hal Jordan
300 points - Ted Kord
100 points - Maya

you get the drift. someone can even give 20 points to each of the 50 characters on the list. as long as the total is max of 1000.

What is the special bonus? for the next few rounds, Legionnaires selected this way will get a starting bonus of +10% of their total accumulated points in the game so far! This bonus is to encourage taking risks and thinking carefully about our votes. After all, this round is a "lose nothing, but potentially gain big" round - Legionnaires not selected here, still have next round to make the Top 30. But Legionnaires who do get selected here, get a bit of a safety cushion (and potentially allow their fans to switch around their votes a bit and save other faves!)

*This bonus will only apply until we reach our Top 10, after which all bets are off.

One request when voting - please still copy-paste the list/wording exactly as below, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours (so, around this time on January 22nd Monday, though I have a homeowners meeting (ugh humble bragger) so it may end a bit later!)
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Dead Earth
Pre-5YL
Reboot
Threeboot

Round 5 list!

Realities are listed alphabetically; then Legionnaires are listed alphabetically within reality.

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) XS
(Threeboot) Theena

(Round ends, around this time on January 22nd Monday, though I have a homeowners meeting (ugh humble bragger) so it may end a bit later!)

Some more observations while I'm mulling over my votes...

Threeboot and Dead Earth hang on with 1 rep each: Theena and Wildfire!

I find it interesting that Theena, who is unique, gets more love than, say, Spider-Girl, Veilmist, Nightwind, Tyroc, Quislet... though maybe not so surprising, Theena had a cool personality and shtick. And I think her being a sort-of Legionnaire, but not part of the "main" team, helps!

Most of the Reboot Legionnaires eliminated last round DO have counterparts in other versions, except Sandy and Thunder. Most of the pre-5YL ones did also have counterparts.

Brainiac 5 and Violet both still have 3 versions on the list.

Having two versions still: Laurel Gand, Tasmia Mallor, Luornu Durgo, Ayla Ranzz, Cosmic Boy, Saturn Girl.

Depending on how you count them - Projectra and Sensor are also still both on the list.

Single versions left:

Pre-5YL: Polar Boy, Chuck Taine, Dawnstar, Nura Nal, Karate Kid, Dirk Morgna, Kal-El, Kara, Tellus, Timber Wolf, Tinya Wazzo, Ultra Boy

Reboot: Kinetix, Gates, XS, Kid Quantum II, Garth Ranzz, Gear, Chameleon, Lyle Norg, Lar Gand, Kon-El, Shikari

5YL: Matter-Eater Lad, Kent Shakespeare, Devlin O'Ryan, Infectious Lass,

Dead Earth: Wildfire

Theeboot: Theena

Well, lost a bunch of Reboot heroes last round. though it WAS becoming unsustainable to keep all of them safe, not enough places on the voting list... I'm the most bummed about losing Apparition.

I did like Dreamer and her boosted precognition, but find pre-5YL Nura Nal to also have a very appealing personality. similarly, I can live with preboot Val making it over Reboot Val. I much prefer Reboot Tinya to her Preboot counterpart though, ditto Cham and Lyle and Lar Gand and Garth.

among the Legionnaires with 2-3 versions left, I similarly generally have my clear preferences

well anyway, voting time... how do I want to use my points...

ok, for me it's a mix of voting for my faves, and hoping others will bring my other faves forward...

so points below do not necessarily represent my ranking of faves.

(Reboot) Kinetix 300
(Reboot) Chameleon 200
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 100
(Reboot) Live Wire 100
(Reboot) Monstress 100
(Reboot) Gates 50
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II 50
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II 50
(Reboot) XS 50

Ah thanks for posting your vote - I was scratching my head a bit. So we are doing it this way for the next three rounds?

Also I'm ok with the loss of Tinya. It's like she got vaporized, but there's still two more of her out there.

happy to! and nope, this is for this round - next round will be normal ranking...

and the resurrection round will be... heh

ah but remember, two of the Tinyas merged

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Well, lost a bunch of Reboot heroes last round. though it WAS becoming unsustainable to keep all of them safe, not enough places on the voting list... I'm the most bummed about losing Apparition.

Yeah, there's going to be carnage shortly on the postbooters, I think.

It basically came down to saving M'Onel or Apparition for me. Neither are spectacular favourites of mine, but the hero-formerly-known-as-Valor shaded it basically because other people were putting votes toward him.

sounds like a logical choice!

yeah, and also with the postbooters... though there are many I'd be happy to see win, there's also the "well, I like these ones, but not THAT much" thinking...

Yeah I'm already there a couple rounds ago with those thoughts.

Still, I'm happy to see them doing so well overall!

for sure! the top 50 has just about equal numbers of Pre-5YL and Reboot Legionnaires

also: we lost White Witch last round - she actually won Preboot Legion Idol, nearly 20 years ago!

https://www.legionworld.net/forums/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=807409&page=6

I don't think I'm much good at this strategic voting but let's try -

(Dead Earth) Wildfire - 300
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 200
(5YL) Brainiac 5 - 200
(5YL) Shrinking Violet - 100
(5YL) Laurel Gand - 100
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - 50
(Reboot) XS - 50

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad-- 350
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel-- 150
(5YL) Infectious Lass--150
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy--100
(Pre-5YL) Superboy--100
(Threeboot) Theena--100
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl--50

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

(5YL) Veilmist--50

hi EDE, Veilmist was sadly eliminated last round! would you like to change your vote?

also: I think someone changed the thread title for me, many thanks

(Pre-5YL) Tellus - 250
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass - 200
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - 150
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - 100
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl - 100
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy - 100
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - 100

I had like 8 Rebooters, 1 Threebooter and 1 5YL (and 6 more pre-5YL!) on my 'short list' but there's just so many points to go around! Ooh, the pain!

Can I vote to resurrect Silverwing, the Mon'elves, Dynamo Boy and Size Lad, just to be difficult?

Resurrection is coming next time Set

and do I guess correctly, that you’ve dropped most of the Rebooters from your list cause you’re expecting others to vote for em?

Also for Stile: what’s your take on pre 5YL versus 5YL Brainy? How do they differ for you? Cause I see you’re voting for both

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Resurrection is coming next time Set

and do I guess correctly, that you’ve dropped most of the Rebooters from your list cause you’re expecting others to vote for em?

Nah, just want to hoard mah points and put them on folk like Tellus that I don't expect to get much love. Still, Kid Quantum 2 is one of my absolute faves from the Reboot, so she squeaked in over even pre-boot characters I love like Ayla and Mon and Brin.

Not got round (see what I did there) to checking out the next set of voting rules. But some thoughts on Round 4

(Pre-5YL) Mon-el - I'd noticed he was low in points a round or two back, so thought I'd put some points in there. Surprised that such a mainstay of the team was out so early. Superboy's big brother, the 1000 year exile, the failing anti-lead serum, the Trapper fight and generally bravery and idealism.
(Pre-5YL) White Witch - Her takedown of the Khund warrior stands out as someone who Levitz put rules around, but who could still be made to be unexpectedly powerful. Points for her friendship with Blok, interesting complexity in her quitting over Brainy's use of the Infinite Man
(Pre-5YL) Krypto - A little sad to see the last of the Super Pets go. A nod to a more whimsical era, while also being played completely straight and therefore being a very effective unit.

(Pre-5YL) Tyroc - Reading some of those storeis back, there was a lot of potential with the character.

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Also for Stile: what’s your take on pre 5YL versus 5YL Brainy? How do they differ for you? Cause I see you’re voting for both

Like many of the 5YL characters, Brainy was a good possible continuation of the character from Pre-5YL. At first there was a lot of the stand-back coldness that had entered towards the end of Baxter Volume 3, but even within that we quickly saw the heart within that cared and counted them as friends. I thought he continued to be a fun character and an important part of the team, but the most of his character development was shown through his interactions with Laurel or mentions of her. You got the impressions that him setting himself apart was connected to their separation, but whether it was the cause or result or a combination was never clear.

Anyway I enjoyed this portrayal as I did the pre-5YL original version. Seeing the two together via SW6 was also fun and emphasised the differences and changes. They stood apart for me from the other portrayals in Reboot, Threeboot (yuck), even Retroboot, and so on where I felt more like I was reading the story of his ancestor Vril Dox II with the manipulation and anti-social outlook. Reboot B5 had his good moments but it wasn't the same character I appreciated before.

With the 5YL era now in some limbo of continuity it makes sense to have both groups of legionnaires listed in the polls but to me they are much the same character, whom I like and appreciate so they both get points.

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Not got round (see what I did there) to checking out the next set of voting rules. But some thoughts on Round 4

(Pre-5YL) Mon-el - I'd noticed he was low in points a round or two back, so thought I'd put some points in there. Surprised that such a mainstay of the team was out so early. Superboy's big brother, the 1000 year exile, the failing anti-lead serum, the Trapper fight and generally bravery and idealism.
(Pre-5YL) White Witch - Her takedown of the Khund warrior stands out as someone who Levitz put rules around, but who could still be made to be unexpectedly powerful. Points for her friendship with Blok, interesting complexity in her quitting over Brainy's use of the Infinite Man
(Pre-5YL) Krypto - A little sad to see the last of the Super Pets go. A nod to a more whimsical era, while also being played completely straight and therefore being a very effective unit.

(Pre-5YL) Tyroc - Reading some of those storeis back, there was a lot of potential with the character.

I agree that Mon-El in some ways deserves more. Certainly a hero but as time went on he seemed more and more shown as one of two personalities, either stoic strong-jawed hero, or slightly neurotic PTSD suffering whiner. Neither of those descriptions are really fair, both exaggerations, and investigating his trauma was a good idea but it seemed like that was all they did with his character. He was defined by the 1000 years and his heroic ideals and nothing else. I guess that's why he drops down lower for me.
White Witch was a wonderful character and I really enjoyed any adventure where she had a focus. I just enjoyed some others a bit more.
Krypto - fun bit he was never going to be a "top dog" for me.
Tyroc - I remember PL writing about the trouble with using a visual medium to tell stories about a vocal powered character. Still I enjoyed his few moments and think some one else might have been able to do more than just shove him to the side.

Originally Posted by thoth lad

(Pre-5YL) White Witch - Her takedown of the Khund warrior stands out as someone who Levitz put rules around, but who could still be made to be unexpectedly powerful. Points for her friendship with Blok, interesting complexity in her quitting over Brainy's use of the Infinite Man
(Pre-5YL) Krypto - A little sad to see the last of the Super Pets go. A nod to a more whimsical era, while also being played completely straight and therefore being a very effective unit.

Mysa quitting like that is one of the reasons I like her so much - she was genuinely angered at how everyone acted so blase about the Infinite Man's life.

and Krypto... such a good boy.

definitely would not have minded having these two last longer in the game (though not at the expense of my faves of course)

Originally Posted by stile86

With the 5YL era now in some limbo of continuity it makes sense to have both groups of legionnaires listed in the polls but to me they are much the same character, whom I like and appreciate so they both get points.

makes sense, and thanks for explaining your thinking, stile!

I think I did this right:

(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II 300
(Reboot) Kinetix 250
(Reboot) XS 200
(Reboot) Spark 150
(Reboot) Monstress 50
(Threeboot) Theena 50

Definitely the right concept, GL! And the math adds up to 1000!

Hi. I'm away from where I scribbled my picks. Will post after work tomorrow.

Assuming the high winds don't sweep me off into Oz again. I hate picking sides in their endless war against Wonderland.

Maybe a Mary Poppins umbrella will keep you safe, thothy!

(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - 30
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 30
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy - 40
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar - 30
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl - 30
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - 40
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass - 30
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - 40
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - 40
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl - 30
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - 30
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass - 30
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet - 30
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy - 40
(Pre-5YL) Superboy - 40
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - 40
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - 30
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - 30
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 30
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy - 40
(Reboot) Andromeda - 30
(Reboot) Gates - 30
(Reboot) Gear - 40
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - 40
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - 30
(Reboot) Kinetix - 30
(Reboot) Monstress - 30
(Reboot) Shikari - 30
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el) - 30
(Reboot) XS - 30

I missed this thread so far (and lost some of my tops choices) but hopefully can still join this round:

(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - 300
(Reboot) XS - 150
(Threeboot) Theena - 150
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 100
(Pre-5YL) Tellus -100
(Reboot) Kinetix - 100
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - 50
(Reboot) Gates - 45
(Reboot) Gear - 5

IDLE

Yay! Another Theena voter!

Kind of funny that the only threeboot character to keep making it through is a side character and no "actual" Legionnaires.

Threeboot was strange. I liked some things and didn't like others, but Theena was a very interesting character and one of the best additions in my mind.

Idle, glad to have you! Better late than never!

Also a big wow at Nighty’s votes

lots of love spread around!

edit: gang, it's 10pm here, I'll leave it open a bit longer as Thoth and Reboot haven't been able to vote yet - and we know both very well intend to

Just about to post. Sorry about that Ibby. Just one of those evenings where it was taking me ages to get to the PC. Then I realised, I'd just marked the ones I thought I'd vote for, rather than allocating points.

no worries thothy, I'm still letting my brain relax after a tough day at work, and a long meeting with the neighbors in a warm, not well-ventilated room

As the storm eases off outside (I would live in The House of the Unlikely at the top of a hill)...

(5YL) Brainiac 5 - 154
(5YL) Laurel Gand - 251
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 132
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - 291
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 172

oh thoth you romantic you! Brainy and Kara, Brainy and Laurel... sitting in a tree...

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

no worries thothy, I'm still letting my brain relax after a tough day at work, and a long meeting with the neighbors in a warm, not well-ventilated room

Thanks buddy. Between re-tying everyitng that got blown away and doing some quick repairs, famiy and not being 100% today, the time just scooted past.

How was your home owners meeting?

Originally Posted by idle

I missed this thread so far (and lost some of my tops choices) but hopefully can still join this round:

Resurrection round to come! It'll be interesting to find out who some of your top choices were Idle. Good to have you onboard.

It's really interesting seeing who people give points to. From Dead Earth Wildfire to Tellus, I'm looking forward to finding out more about the choices.

EDIT:

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

oh thoth you romantic you! Brainy and Kara, Brainy and Laurel... sitting in a tree...

I think you'll find they are flying above the tree.

That's the tough thing about having, not only multiples, but very close multiples. Pre-Crisis Brainy and Kara were very interesting in the period just before and when DC decided to bump her off. 5YG Braining and Laurel had a different dynamic, freed from the Super-Offices. I thought TMK did really well, showing us the difference in the personalities due to this versions time in the 30th century (although I think it was orgininally intended to involve some time travelling too)

DOUBLE EDIT:

Chuck and Lu and Ayla and Vi aren;t far from my thought either, now you come to point that out.

hope you feel 100% soon thothy! or 300%, then you can also gain two Carggite-thothies who can help you with tying things down...

the meeting went well, lots of business got done, and I got to nod along and pretend I understood everything in Dutch, while trusting hubby to fill me in after... Got the core but some of the details went over my head alas. Where's Cypher when you need him

totally agree, curious to learn more about why folks find so-and-so fascinating. and TMK did very well in making Laurel her own character, based on but different from Kara

TBH, Zoe and Vi are (in many ways for me) also up there: though in my headcanon they're only best friends, but what BFFs they are (GL has a different take of course

and Reboot Brainy/Gates make such a good pair of BFFs too!

not coincidentally, these are in my top 4... their friendships really up their appeal for me

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

hope you feel 100% soon thothy! or 300%, then you can also gain two Carggite-thothies who can help you with tying things down...

the meeting went well, lots of business got done, and I got to nod along and pretend I understood everything in Dutch, while trusting hubby to fill me in after... Got the core but some of the details went over my head alas. Where's Cypher when you need him

totally agree, curious to learn more about why folks find so-and-so fascinating. and TMK did very well in making Laurel her own character, based on but different from Kara

Thanks. Just a mild thing I picked up at the weekend. I'm not used to getting anything, so no doubt get extra mopey about it.

Didn't Cypher get dedded because the readers didn't like him/ writers didn't know what to do with him? Count your blessings. I prefer "Where's Laurel with an Telepathic Earplug," for extra safety myself.

Sorry, saw some shiny objects

(Reboot) Invisible Kid - 342
(Reboot) Gates - 326
(Reboot) Spark - 302
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - 30

Given the whole "continuing point totals are a bonus for those who get through this round", I *was* tempted just to boost Spark & Gates as high as I could, but I decided to save Lyle, and eh, throw a few points at Vi to make sure she stays in too.

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Thanks. Just a mild thing I picked up at the weekend. I'm not used to getting anything, so no doubt get extra mopey about it.

Didn't Cypher get dedded because the readers didn't like him/ writers didn't know what to do with him? Count your blessings. I prefer "Where's Laurel with an Telepathic Earplug," for extra safety myself.

should hopefully be fine soon, then

Cypher is one of those superheroes whose power isn't very flashy, and tends to be overlooked in the comics universe... but in real life, boy, would that power be among the best

Originally Posted by Reboot

Given the whole "continuing point totals are a bonus for those who get through this round", I *was* tempted just to boost Spark & Gates as high as I could, but I decided to save Lyle, and eh, throw a few points at Vi to make sure she stays in too.

those bonus points ARE very shiny

and I do think that that +10% every round is gonna be a surprisingly big boost... I'm been mulling over how to structure the points so that the +10% doesn't become too big an advantage!

RESULTS TIME!!! End of Round 5!!

We shook things up by doing away with rankings, and moving to a free-for-all distribution system with a nice shiny prize of bonus points for the next few rounds! so... who made it to become the first 10 entering our Top 30? Voters could pick among 50, but only 10 make it...

cue the suspense, and this time I'm posting the results from the bottom up.

Lots of points sprinkled around, and a few getting zero votes - from the list, I'm fairly certain some of these zero points are strategic choices...

(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare) - 0
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan) - 0
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy - 0
(Reboot) M'Onel - 0
(Reboot) Saturn Girl - 0
(Reboot) Sensor - 0
(Reboot) Triad - 0
(Reboot) Umbra - 0
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar - 30
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl - 30
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass - 30
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet - 30
(Reboot) Andromeda - 30
(Reboot) Shikari - 30
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el) - 30
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy - 40
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy - 40
(Reboot) Gear - 45
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - 80
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - 90
(5YL) Shrinking Violet - 100
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - 100
(Reboot) Live Wire - 100
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - 130
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl - 130
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - 140
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - 140
(Pre-5YL) Superboy - 140
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy - 140
(5YL) Infectious Lass - 150
(Reboot) Monstress - 180
(Reboot) Chameleon - 200
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass - 230
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - 230
(Dead Earth) Wildfire - 300
(Threeboot) Theena - 300
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - 330
(5YL) Laurel Gand - 351
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 352
(5YL) Brainiac 5 - 354

And the Top 10, walking away with some bonus points AND a spot in the Top 30:

(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 362
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - 380
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - 380
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - 381
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - 382
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 450
(Reboot) Gates - 451
(Reboot) Spark - 452
(Reboot) XS - 480
(Reboot) Kinetix - 680

including this round's points, also sharing the total cumulative points these folks have! and remember, they start the next few rounds with a +10% bonus: this is going to shake things up or sure!

(Reboot) Kinetix - 3113
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - 2140
(Reboot) Gates - 2038
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 2013
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 1704
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - 1617
(Reboot) XS - 1387
(Reboot) Spark - 1378
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - 1370
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - 798

Reboot Lyle is far behind, while Zoe has skyrocketed ahead...
Nice mix too: 6 Rebooters, 3 pre-%YL, and a 5YL-er. And each of the 10 represents a "unique" character. Though we were vey close to having two versions of Brainy scoot through.

this 10 would make an interesting team...

Round 6 will be up shortly!

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

including this round's points, also sharing the total cumulative points these folks have! and remember, they start the next few rounds with a +10% bonus: this is going to shake things up or sure!

These guys aren't even IN the next two rounds

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Thanks. Just a mild thing I picked up at the weekend. I'm not used to getting anything, so no doubt get extra mopey about it.

Didn't Cypher get dedded because the readers didn't like him/ writers didn't know what to do with him? Count your blessings. I prefer "Where's Laurel with an Telepathic Earplug," for extra safety myself.

should hopefully be fine soon, then

Cypher is one of those superheroes whose power isn't very flashy, and tends to be overlooked in the comics universe... but in real life, boy, would that power be among the best

Cypher is alive again (though partly techno from his pal Warlock) and playing a crucial role in the current Krakoa era (though that should probably be the recent now almost gone Krakoa era)

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

oh thoth you romantic you! Brainy and Kara, Brainy and Laurel... sitting in a tree...

I think you'll find they are flying above the tree.

That's the tough thing about having, not only multiples, but very close multiples. Pre-Crisis Brainy and Kara were very interesting in the period just before and when DC decided to bump her off. 5YG Braining and Laurel had a different dynamic, freed from the Super-Offices. I thought TMK did really well, showing us the difference in the personalities due to this versions time in the 30th century (although I think it was orgininally intended to involve some time travelling too)

DOUBLE EDIT:

Chuck and Lu and Ayla and Vi aren;t far from my thought either, now you come to point that out.

Totally agree.

Round 6 begins!

Phase 2/Round 6 - From our Top 40, only 15 will advance to the next round. Joining the 10 who made it last round, we will have 25 of our Top 30.

That also means that 25 Legionnaires will be eliminated!

(don't worry though: Round 7 will be a resurrection round, where 5 lucky Legionnaires get a second chance by joining our top 30!)

We go back to "traditional" voting patterns: Rank your Top 15. Points will be awarded as follows:

Rank and Points

1 - 500
2 - 400
3 - 330
4 - 270
5 - 220
6 - 180
7 - 140
8 - 100
9 - 70
10 - 50
11 - 35
12 - 20
13 - 10
14 - 6
15 - 1

One request when voting - please still copy-paste the list/wording exactly as below, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours (so, around this time on January 25th Thursday - though probably a bit earlier in my evening

)
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Dead Earth
Pre-5YL
Reboot
Threeboot

Round 6 list!

Realities are listed alphabetically; then Legionnaires are listed alphabetically within reality.

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra
(Threeboot) Theena

(Round ends, around this time on January 25th Thursday, though a bit earlier in the evening)

Originally Posted by Reboot

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

including this round's points, also sharing the total cumulative points these folks have! and remember, they start the next few rounds with a +10% bonus: this is going to shake things up or sure!

These guys aren't even IN the next two rounds

you know what I mean

Originally Posted by stile86

Cypher is alive again (though partly techno from his pal Warlock) and playing a crucial role in the current Krakoa era (though that should probably be the recent now almost gone Krakoa era)

thanks stile, I had heard about that - Cypher and Krakoa are now buddy buddy, eh?

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

RESULTS TIME!!! End of Round 5!!

(5YL) Brainiac 5 - 354

And the Top 10, walking away with some bonus points AND a spot in the Top 30:

(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 362
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - 380
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - 380
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - 381
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - 382
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 450
(Reboot) Gates - 451
(Reboot) Spark - 452
(Reboot) XS - 480
(Reboot) Kinetix - 680

Nice mix too: 6 Rebooters, 3 pre-%YL, and a 5YL-er. And each of the 10 represents a "unique" character. Though we were vey close to having two versions of Brainy scoot through.

Aargh! So close! 8/9 points would have posted 5YL Brainy but at the expense of Pre-5YL Brainy, so really 5YL needed 27 and Pre needed 19 to slip past Tellus. Oh well. Almost, but as the saying goes, almost only counts in horseshoes and nuclear weapons.

(It only just occurred to me that those late posters with their very exact points could have been calculating exactly how much they needed to get their favourites in based on those who had already voted. Sneaky. Although not much good for encouraging voting in time to make life easier for Ibby.)
EDIT (Not meant as a criticism. More admiration.)

well, here goes nothing... the ranking was tough, and again a mix between "which ones are my top faves" versus "which ones are likely to get a few other votes, too?"

1 - (Reboot) Live Wire
2 - (Reboot) Chameleon
3 - (Reboot) Brainiac 5
4 - (Reboot) Monstress
5 - (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
6 - (Reboot) Shikari
7 - (Reboot) Umbra
8 - (Reboot) Triad
9 - (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
10 - (Reboot) Saturn Girl
11 - (Reboot) Gear
12 - (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
13 - (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
14 - (5YL) Infectious Lass
15 - (5YL) Laurel Gand

Originally Posted by stile86

(It only just occurred to me that those late posters with their very exact points could have been calculating exactly how much they needed to get their favourites in based on those who had already voted. Sneaky. Although not much good for encouraging voting in time to make life easier for Ibby.)
EDIT (Not meant as a criticism. More admiration.)

those exact points certainly point to something, heh

this is also why I vote first - as the one running the game, it's a bit suspect if I do all the vote-counting and then vote last

Late voters one round, not being last voters in the next, might be an option to consider. Not a rule, but something to bear in mind to keep within the spirit of things.

Hmm. 5 of my choicess made the top ten. (I guess the characters I like aren't as unpopular as I thought.)

1. (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
2. (Threeboot) Theena
3. (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
4. (Reboot) Gear
5. (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
6. (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
7. (Reboot) Monstress
8. (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
9. (5YL) Shrinking Violet
10. (Pre-5YL) Superboy
11. (Reboot) Brainiac 5
12. (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
13. (Reboot) Andromeda
14. (5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
15. (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

TBH, Zoe and Vi are (in many ways for me) also up there: though in my headcanon they're only best friends, but what BFFs they are (GL has a different take of course

I believe the technical term is 'gal pals.'

Okay, my list, in order:

(Threeboot) Theena
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Umbra
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) M'Onel

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Late voters one round, not being last voters in the next, might be an option to consider. Not a rule, but something to bear in mind to keep within the spirit of things.

If we're really concerned about it as a problem, I'd suggest considering secret ballots by pm, posted to the thread once everyone has voted, for future games. I don't really have the time/energy for that level of strategic voting myself, but I'm not really that fussed one way or the other.

1 - (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
2 - (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
3 - (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
4 - (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
5 - (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
6 - (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
7 - (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
8 - (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
9 - (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
10 - (Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
11 - (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
12 - (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
13 - (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
14 - (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
15 - (Reboot) Gear

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Late voters one round, not being last voters in the next, might be an option to consider. Not a rule, but something to bear in mind to keep within the spirit of things.

If we're really concerned about it as a problem, I'd suggest considering secret ballots by pm, posted to the thread once everyone has voted, for future games. I don't really have the time/energy for that level of strategic voting myself, but I'm not really that fussed one way or the other.

I considered this, TBH. but it's a but of extra work.

I've also considered that, although late voters do have an advantage in being more "secure" of the results, early voters have the advantage in "setting the tone" so to speak - their early votes are the groundwork for others. for a late voter, if nobody else votes for their top faves, they may just have to abandon them...

re when people vote, I can't think of an effective way to make that a rule. so voluntary would work best

Originally Posted by Gaseous Lad

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

TBH, Zoe and Vi are (in many ways for me) also up there: though in my headcanon they're only best friends, but what BFFs they are (GL has a different take of course

I believe the technical term is 'gal pals.'

oh yes, like those sweet older neighbors of mine... I had to explain the truth to my parents gently

1 – (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
2 – (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
3 – (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
4 – (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
5 – (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
6 – (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
7 – (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
8 – (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
9 – (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
10 – (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
11 – (Reboot) Monstress
12 – (Threeboot) Theena
13 – (Reboot) Umbra
14 – (Reboot) Shikari
15 – (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl

(5YL) Laurel Gand 500
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel 400
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy 330
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet 270
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass 220
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl 180
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl 140
(5YL) Infectious Lass 100
(5YL) Shrinking Violet 70
(5YL) Brainiac 5 50
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar 35
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl 20
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare) 10
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass 6
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy 1

(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Shrinking Violet
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Threeboot) Theena
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl

1 - (Reboot) Shikari
2 - (Reboot) Triad
3 - (Reboot) Brainiac 5
4 - (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
5 - (Reboot) Live Wire
6 - (Reboot) Umbra
7 - (Dead Earth) Wildfire
8 - (Reboot) Gear
9 - (Reboot) Saturn Girl
10 - (Reboot) Chameleon
11 - (Reboot) Sensor
12 - (Reboot) Monstress
13 - (Reboot) Andromeda
14 - (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
15 - (Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)

that's 8 votes - looks like our 9th may be biding time?

Oh, that's me, isn't it? I just haven't taken the time to do it. I'll get to it in a bit.

no worries EDE! you have almost a full day , after all, the round doesn't close until evening Netherlands time Jan 25

no rush!

I was just being cheeky re our recent discussion about waiting until the end to vote

1. (5YL) Infectious Lass
2. (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
3. (Pre-5YL) Superboy
4. (Threeboot) Theena
5. (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
6. (5YL) Laurel Gand
7. (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
8. (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
9. (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
10. (5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
11. (Dead Earth) Wildfire
12. (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
13. (5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
14. (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
15. (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy

Nice mix there, EDE

I literally just took my Top 25 list, eliminated everyone who wasn't on the list for the current round, which gave me 9, and then I went through the rest of the list and grabbed six other characters who kind of appealed to me.

Pretty much what I did for the past few rounds, although I did a little shuffling in the order.

thanks all, will try to get through this if I have a break at work - it's been hectic recently though, so most likely I won't get to it until after dinner

closing the round now, folks!!

RESULTS TIME!!! End of Round 5!!

We went back to the rankings, but with high stakes - from 40, only 15 will pass to the Top 30. So 25 get sent home.

from the top:

(Threeboot) Theena - 1210
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - 950
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - 906
(5YL) Laurel Gand - 901
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - 890
(Reboot) Live Wire - 860
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - 835
(Reboot) Triad - 820
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - 800
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - 730
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - 717
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - 716
(Reboot) Shikari - 686
(Dead Earth) Wildfire - 675
(Reboot) Monstress - 645

Theena dominates this round, flying the Threeboot flag high! and we got a nice mix of realities, with pre-5YL and Reboot both well-represented... plus Dead Earth Wildfire and 5yl Laurel Gand!

And the cut off for elimination!

(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl - 640
(5YL) Infectious Lass - 606
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass - 576
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 556
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy - 542
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy - 501
(Reboot) Chameleon - 485
(5YL) Brainiac 5 - 450
(Reboot) Saturn Girl - 450
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet - 420
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass - 410
(Reboot) Gear - 406
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare) - 390
(Pre-5YL) Superboy - 390
(Reboot) Umbra - 350
(5YL) Shrinking Violet - 320
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy - 320
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan) - 286
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy - 236
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar - 170
(Reboot) Andromeda - 55
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl - 51
(Reboot) Sensor - 35
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el) - 1
(Reboot) M'Onel - 1

Jeckie narrowly misses safety by 5 points! heavy losses for pre-5YL and Reboot as well.

to refresh, the top 15 making it through this round, will join our earlier 10 winners of Round 5:

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) XS

and... next round, Round 7, we will resurrect 5 Legionnaires to return to the game! Round 7 wil be up shortly!

gotta say, we do have some of our "niche" Legionnaires making it through, but otherwise no real surprises. with only 15/40 to make it through, we were bound to lose some long-serving, popular Legionnaires.

We do - for now - lose our last versions of

Tasmia Mallor
Rokk Krinn
Jeckie/Sensor
Dirk Morgna
Nura Nal
Lar Gand
Jo Nah
Reep Daggle

plus Infectious Lass, Devlin, Kent Shakespeare, Gear, Dawnstar, Kon-El

and as of now, the only Legionnaires with 2 versions still in the game is... Brainiac 5!

Round 7 begins!

what kind of comic book-related game would this be, without some character resurrections?

This round, we're bringing 5 Legionnaires back to the list, to form our Top 30!

just like two rounds ago:

Everyone has up to 1000 points to distribute however they wish. I will count votes less than 1000, but will not allow votes greater than 1000.

you may vote for anyone on the list below... you may also write-in a character, with the rule that this character must be a Legionnaire in a reality, with sufficient proof that this character was a full Legionnaire. (Urk or Blockade Boy wouldn't count, for example!)

Example allowable votes (using non-Legion characters):

Example 1:

1000 points - Scarlet Witch

Example 2:

500 points - Jean Grey
250 points - Monica Rambeau
250 points - Jubilee

Example 3:

100 points - Kimiyo Hoshi
100 points - Power Girl
200 points - Wonder Woman
200 points - Hal Jordan
300 points - Ted Kord
100 points - Maya

you get the drift. someone can even give 1 point each to 1000 Legionnaires (not that we have that many). as long as the total is max of 1000.

One request when voting - please still copy-paste the list/wording exactly as below, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours (so, around this time on January 28th Sunday).
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Dead Earth
Pre-5YL
Reboot
Threeboot

Round 7 list - Realities are listed alphabetically; then Legionnaires are listed alphabetically within reality. I've also noted the round in which each was eliminated, as that might be useful information.

(5YL) Atmos ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Bloodclaw ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Bouncing Boy ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Bounty entity ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Brainiac 5 ( Round 5 )
(5YL) Calamity King ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Chameleon Boy ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid ( Round 3 )
(5YL) Color Kid ( Round 3 )
(5YL) Colossal Boy ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Cosmic Boy ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Crystal Kid ( Round 3 )
(5YL) Dawnstar ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Dream Girl ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Duo Damsel ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Echo ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Element Lad ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Fire Lad ( Round 3 )
(5YL) Firefist ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Flederweb ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare) ( Round 5 )
(5YL) Infectious Lass ( Round 5 )
(5YL) Invisible Kid II ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Karate Kid II ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Kono ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty) ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Lightning Lass ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Mon-el ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish) ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Nightwind ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Polar Boy ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Porcupine Pete ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Queen Projectra ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Reflecto ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan) ( Round 5 )
(5YL) Rond Vidar ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Shadow Lass ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Shrinking Violet ( Round 5 )
(5YL) Spider-Girl ( Round 3 )
(5YL) Star Boy ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Stone Boy ( Round 3 )
(5YL) Storm Boy ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Sun Boy ( Round 1 )
(5YL) Timber Wolf ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Tyroc ( Round 3 )
(5YL) Ultra Boy ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Valor ( Round 2 )
(5YL) Veilmist ( Round 4 )
(5YL) Visi-Lad ( Round 2 )
(5YL) White Witch ( Round 3 )
(5YL) Wildfire ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Bouncing Boy ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Chameleon ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Colossal Boy ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Cosmic Man ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Lightning Man ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Saturn Woman ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Sensor ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Shrinking Violet ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Superman ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Ultra Boy ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Umbra ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Wildfire ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Batman ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Bouncing Man ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5 ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chameleon Man ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chemical King ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Color King ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Colossal Man ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Cosmic Man ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Dream Woman ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duo Damsel ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Element Man ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Karate King ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Light Lady ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Matter-Eater Man ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Night Woman ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Phantom Woman ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Polar Man ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shrinking Violet ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Star Man ( Round 2 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman ( Round 3 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Timber Wolf ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ultra Man ( Round 1 )
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) White Witch ( Round 1 )
(Arrowverse) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 )
(Arrowverse) Chameleon ( Round 1 )
(Arrowverse) Dream Girl ( Round 1 )
(Arrowverse) Karate Kid ( Round 1 )
(Arrowverse) Lightning Lass ( Round 1 )
(Arrowverse) Mon-El ( Round 1 )
(Arrowverse) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 )
(Arrowverse) Toyman ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Alchemist ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Andromeda ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Chameleon ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Computo ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy ( Round 3 )
(Arthurian Legion) Dragonmage ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Dream Girl ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Ferro ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Infectious Lass ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Inferno ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Invisible Kid I ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Invisible Kid II ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Karate Kid I ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Leviathan ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire ( Round 3 )
(Arthurian Legion) Matter-Eater Lad ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Nemesis Kid ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Polar Boy ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl ( Round 3 )
(Arthurian Legion) Shrinking Violet ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Spark ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Triad ( Round 2 )
(Arthurian Legion) Ultra Boy ( Round 1 )
(Arthurian Legion) Umbra ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Blok ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Bouncing Boy ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5 ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Chameleon Boy ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Colossal Boy ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Computo ( Round 3 )
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Dawnstar ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Dream Girl ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Element Lad ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Entropy Kid ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Ferro Lad ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Invisible Kid ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Karate Kid ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Matter-Eater Lad ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Mon-el ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Phantom Girl ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Princess Projectra ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Shadow Lass ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Shrinking Violet ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Star Boy ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Sun Boy ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon) ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Timber Wolf ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Triplicate Girl ( Round 2 )
(Bendisboot) Ultra Boy ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) White Witch ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) Wildfire ( Round 1 )
(Bendisboot) X-Ray Girl ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Andromeda ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Blok ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Bouncing Boy ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Chameleon Boy ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Colossal Boy ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Cosmic Boy ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Douglas Nolan ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Dream Girl ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Ferro Lad ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Green Arrow ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Green Lantern (John Stewart) ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Kid Quantum ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Light Lass ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Lightning Lad ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Phantom Girl ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Shadow Lass ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl ( Round 2 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Timber Wolf ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Triad ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Ultra Boy ( Round 1 )
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Wildfire ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Argent ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Graft ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Lodestone ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Magno Boy ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Membrain ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Metrox ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Nervosa ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Phase ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Shape ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Shift ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Silverwing ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Triad III ( Round 1 )
(Dead Earth) Triplicate ( Round 1 )
(JLA Trapped in Time) Dawnstar ( Round 1 )
(JLA Trapped in Time) Karate Kid ( Round 1 )
(Legion 1 Million) Brainiac 417 ( Round 1 )
(Legion 1 Million) Cosmicbot ( Round 1 )
(Legion 1 Million) Implicate Girl ( Round 1 )
(Legion 1 Million) Superboy ( Round 1 )
(Legion 1 Million) The Chameleon ( Round 1 )
(Legion 1 Million) The Dreamer ( Round 1 )
(Legion 1 Million) The M'Onelves ( Round 1 )
(Legion 1 Million) The Umbra ( Round 1 )
(Legion 1 Million) Titangirl ( Round 1 )
(Legion 1 Million) Wildflame ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Andromeda ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Arm-Fall-Off-Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Atmos ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Blok ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Bouncing Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Catspaw ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Chameleon Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Chemical King ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Color Kid ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Comet Queen ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Cosmic Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Dawnstar ( Round 2 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Dream Girl ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Element Lad ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Ferro Lad ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Gates ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Gold Lantern ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Invisible Kid ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Karate Kid ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Kid Quantum II ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix ( Round 2 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Lightning Lad ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Mon-El ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Monstress ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Phantom Girl ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Polar Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Power Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Quislet ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Sensor Girl ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Shadow Lass ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Star Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Stone Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Supergirl ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Superman ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Tellus ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Timber Wolf ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Tyroc ( Round 1 )
(Legion Animated Movie) Wildfire ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Blok ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy ( Round 3 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5 ( Round 4 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chameleon Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chemical King ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chlorophyll Kid ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Color Kid ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Colossal Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Cosmic Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dawnstar ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dream Girl ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Element Lad ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Ferro Lad ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Infectious Lass ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Invisible Kid ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Karate Kid ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad ( Round 2 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Matter-Eater Lad ( Round 2 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid ( Round 2 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Night Girl ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Phantom Girl ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Polar Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Porcupine Pete ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet ( Round 2 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Star Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Stone Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Sun Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman X ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Timber Wolf ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Tyroc ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Ultra Boy ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) White Witch ( Round 1 )
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) XS ( Round 1 )
(Pre-5YL) Anti-Lad ( Round 1 )
(Pre-5YL) Beppo ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Blok ( Round 3 )
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy ( Round 3 )
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King ( Round 3 )
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy ( Round 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Comet ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Command Kid ( Round 1 )
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Dynamo Boy ( Round 1 )
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen) ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad ( Round 3 )
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad ( Round 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang) ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II ( Round 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Krypto ( Round 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad ( Round 3 )
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el ( Round 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Pete Ross ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Proty II ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Quislet ( Round 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar ( Round 3 )
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy ( Round 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Streaky ( Round 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Superboy ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc ( Round 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy ( Round 5 )
(Pre-5YL) White Witch ( Round 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire ( Round 3 )
(Reboot) Andromeda ( Round 5 )
(Reboot) Apparition ( Round 4 )
(Reboot) Chameleon ( Round 5 )
(Reboot) Chuck Taine ( Round 4 )
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy ( Round 5 )
(Reboot) Dreamer ( Round 4 )
(Reboot) Element Lad ( Round 2 )
(Reboot) Ferro ( Round 4 )
(Reboot) Gear ( Round 5 )
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson) ( Round 4 )
(Reboot) Karate Kid ( Round 4 )
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I ( Round 2 )
(Reboot) Leviathan ( Round 2 )
(Reboot) Magno ( Round 2 )
(Reboot) M'Onel ( Round 5 )
(Reboot) Saturn Girl ( Round 5 )
(Reboot) Sensor ( Round 5 )
(Reboot) Star Boy ( Round 4 )
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el) ( Round 5 )
(Reboot) Thunder ( Round 4 )
(Reboot) Timber Wolf ( Round 2 )
(Reboot) Ultra Boy ( Round 4 )
(Reboot) Umbra ( Round 5 )
(Reboot) Wildfire ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Black Witch ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Blok ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Bouncing Boy ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Chameleon Boy ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl ( Round 3 )
(Retroboot) Chemical Kid ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Colossal Boy ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Comet Queen ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Cosmic Boy ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Dawnstar ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Dragonwing ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Dream Girl ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel ( Round 3 )
(Retroboot) Earth-Man ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Element Lad ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Gates ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Glorith ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Invisible Kid II ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Karate Kid ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Lightning Lad ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Lightning Lass ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Matter-Eater Lad ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Mon-el ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Night Girl ( Round 3 )
(Retroboot) Phantom Girl ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Polar Boy ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Quislet ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Rond Vidar ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Saturn Girl ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Sensor Girl ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Shadow Lass ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Shrinking Violet ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Star Boy ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Sun Boy ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Superman ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Tellus ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Timber Wolf ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Tyroc ( Round 1 )
(Retroboot) Ultra Boy ( Round 2 )
(Retroboot) Wildfire ( Round 1 )
(Smallville) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 )
(Smallville) Clark Kent ( Round 1 )
(Smallville) Cosmic Boy ( Round 1 )
(Smallville) Lightning Lad ( Round 1 )
(Smallville) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Bouncing Boy ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Chameleon Boy ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Colossal Boy ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Cosmic Boy ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Element Lad ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Ferro Lad ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Invisible Kid ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Karate Kid ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass ( Round 4 )
(Superboy's Legion) Lightning Lad ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Phantom Girl ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Sensor ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Shadow Lass ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Shrinking Violet ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Star Boy ( Round 2 )
(Superboy's Legion) Sun Boy ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Superboy ( Round 1 )
(Superboy's Legion) Ultra Boy ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Alchemist ( Round 3 )
(SW6) Andromeda ( Round 3 )
(SW6) Apparition ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Bouncing Boy ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Catspaw ( Round 4 )
(SW6) Chameleon Boy ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Computo ( Round 4 )
(SW6) Cosmic Boy ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Dragonmage ( Round 4 )
(SW6) Dream Girl ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Ferro ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Gossamer ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Inferno ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Invisible Kid ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Karate Kid ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Kid Quantum ( Round 4 )
(SW6) Leviathan ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Live Wire ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad ( Round 2 )
(SW6) Princess Projectra ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Shrinking Violet ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Star Boy ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Triad ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Ultra Boy ( Round 1 )
(SW6) Valor ( Round 2 )
(Threeboot) Atom Girl ( Round 2 )
(Threeboot) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Chameleon ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Colossal Boy/ Micro Lad ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Cosmic Boy ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Dream Boy ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Dream Girl ( Round 2 )
(Threeboot) Element Lad ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Gazelle ( Round 2 )
(Threeboot) Invisible Kid ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Karate Kid ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Light Lass ( Round 2 )
(Threeboot) Lightning Lad ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Mon-el ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Night Girl ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Phantom Girl ( Round 2 )
(Threeboot) Princess Projectra ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Shadow Lass ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Sizzle ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Star Boy ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Sun Boy ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Supergirl ( Round 2 )
(Threeboot) Timber Wolf ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Triplicate Girl ( Round 2 )
(Threeboot) Turtle ( Round 1 )
(Threeboot) Ultra Boy ( Round 1 )
(Young Justice) Chameleon Boy ( Round 1 )
(Young Justice) Phantom Girl ( Round 1 )
(Young Justice) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 )

Round ends around this time on January 28th Sunday!

this is tough... if I had to rank the eliminated, Reboot Tinya and Cham top my fave list. But they haven't been getting a lot of support in past rounds. I also like Reboot Imra, Reboot Cos and Gear, but same issue.

I'm a little shocked that pre-5YL Nura isn't more popular, TBH. though maybe that is just in relation to others on the list. She's one of my faves from pre-5YL because of her unique personality, and how she was sassy but still kind.

while I don't dislike many of the pre-5YL Legionnaires, many of them don't strongly appeal to me for various reasons. for pre-5YL Tasmia, it was that one annual where COMPUTO attacks Legion HQ, and I found it annoying how she spent so much time stamping her foot and crying while running around with Jan and Shvaughn

I would have ranked Reboot Andromeda higher, if not for her Sister Andy phase and her Anomaly transformation that went nowhere. I did like her earlier about-face and redemption arc re the White Triangle.

Drura is cool and fun with a great unique power, but I wonder if she can actually last very long. I like her, but not to the point of being willing to risk many of my faves for her.

ditto Krypto... and Veilmist... and Sussa...

I'm gonna need some more time to think!

(Pre-5YL) Element Lad ( Round 3 ) - 500
(Reboot) Gear ( Round 5 ) - 150
(Pre-5YL) Proty II ( Round 2 ) - 100
(SW6) Computo ( Round 4 ) - 100
(5YL) Flederweb ( Round 2 ) - 50
(5YL) Spider-Girl ( Round 3 ) - 50
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate ( Round 2 ) - 50

Element Lad and Proty II were the favorites I mentioned that had been voted off (not voted on?) before I found the thread. I realize that most of these will probably be eliminated soon if they come back buy I have to try and Jan is my second favorite legionnaire and the pre 5YL version was such a big part of the legion when I started reading.

(5YL) Calamity King ( Round 2 ) - 6
(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid ( Round 3 ) - 6
(5YL) Color Kid ( Round 3 ) - 6
(5YL) Crystal Kid ( Round 3 ) - 6
(5YL) Echo ( Round 2 ) - 6
(5YL) Fire Lad ( Round 3 ) - 6
(5YL) Flederweb ( Round 2 ) - 7
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare) ( Round 5 ) - 6
(5YL) Infectious Lass ( Round 5 ) - 6
(5YL) Karate Kid II ( Round 2 ) - 6
(5YL) Kono ( Round 2 ) - 6
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish) ( Round 2 ) - 6
(5YL) Nightwind ( Round 2 ) - 6
(5YL) Porcupine Pete ( Round 2 ) - 6
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan) ( Round 5 ) - 6
(5YL) Spider-Girl ( Round 3 ) - 6
(5YL) Stone Boy ( Round 3 ) - 6
(5YL) Storm Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(5YL) Tyroc ( Round 3 ) - 6
(5YL) Veilmist ( Round 4 ) - 6
(5YL) Visi-Lad ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Blok ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Bouncing Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5 ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Chameleon Boy ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Colossal Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Computo ( Round 3 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Dawnstar ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Dream Girl ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Element Lad ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Entropy Kid ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Ferro Lad ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Invisible Kid ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Karate Kid ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Matter-Eater Lad ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Mon-el ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy ( Round 2 ) - 20
(Bendisboot) Phantom Girl ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Princess Projectra ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Shadow Lass ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Shrinking Violet ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Star Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Sun Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon) ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Timber Wolf ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Triplicate Girl ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Ultra Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) White Witch ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) Wildfire ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Bendisboot) X-Ray Girl ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Blok ( Round 3 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy ( Round 3 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Chemical King ( Round 3 ) - 7
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen) ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad ( Round 3 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang) ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I ( Round 2 ) - 11
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad ( Round 3 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Quislet ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar ( Round 3 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Superboy ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) White Witch ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire ( Round 3 ) - 6
(Reboot) Andromeda ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Reboot) Apparition ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Reboot) Chameleon ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Reboot) Dreamer ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Reboot) Element Lad ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Reboot) Ferro ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Reboot) Gear ( Round 5 ) - 7
(Reboot) Karate Kid ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Reboot) Leviathan ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Reboot) Magno ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Reboot) M'Onel ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Reboot) Saturn Girl ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Reboot) Sensor ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Reboot) Star Boy ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el) ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Reboot) Thunder ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Reboot) Timber Wolf ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Reboot) Ultra Boy ( Round 4 ) - 6
(Reboot) Umbra ( Round 5 ) - 6
(Reboot) Wildfire ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Retroboot) Black Witch ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl ( Round 3 ) - 6
(Retroboot) Chemical Kid ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Retroboot) Comet Queen ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Retroboot) Dragonwing ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Retroboot) Glorith ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Retroboot) Night Girl ( Round 3 ) - 6
(Retroboot) Rond Vidar ( Round 1 ) - 7
(Retroboot) Tyroc ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Alchemist ( Round 3 ) - 6
(SW6) Andromeda ( Round 3 ) - 6
(SW6) Apparition ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Bouncing Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Brainiac 5 ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Catspaw ( Round 4 ) - 6
(SW6) Chameleon Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Computo ( Round 4 ) - 6
(SW6) Cosmic Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Dragonmage ( Round 4 ) - 6
(SW6) Dream Girl ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Ferro ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Gossamer ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Inferno ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Invisible Kid ( Round 1 ) - 10
(SW6) Karate Kid ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Kid Quantum ( Round 4 ) - 6
(SW6) Leviathan ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Live Wire ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad ( Round 2 ) - 6
(SW6) Princess Projectra ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Saturn Girl ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Shrinking Violet ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Star Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Triad ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Ultra Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(SW6) Valor ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Threeboot) Dream Boy ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Threeboot) Dream Girl ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Threeboot) Gazelle ( Round 2 ) - 6
(Threeboot) Sizzle ( Round 1 ) - 6
(Threeboot) Turtle ( Round 1 ) - 7

wow, love how you're spreading so many points around, Nighty!

and interesting to see your faves, Idle! we were commenting a few rounds back that Jan was eliminated fairly early, but who knows if he will get new life now that you're voting on him!

and thanks again to whomever has updated the thread title for me

and now with my own votes: decided to stick with a small group, and focusing on (some of) those I've seen others vote for - therefore bigger chance of actually making it through a few more rounds

(Reboot) Cosmic Boy 100
(Reboot) Gear 300
(Reboot) Saturn Girl 100
(Reboot) Umbra 400
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl 50
(Pre-5YL) Krypto 50

I AM CHAOS!!!!!

(Bendisboot) X-Ray Girl ( Round 1 ) - 100
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad ( Round 2 ) - 100
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy ( Round 2 ) - 100
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern ( Round 2 ) - 500
(Bendisboot) Entropy Kid ( Round 1 ) - 100
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate ( Round 2 ) - 100

Gold Lantern's origin alone, deserves all those points and more. It will be awesome!

Got mine picked, but feline overlord demanded attention, so just have to assign points. I found myself sticking to recent rounds. With so many good characters, I was leaning to those who nearly made it this far.

I see Nighty has Monster Boy points, while idle has Doctor Fate. Bendisboot resurgence...is on!

Gold Lantern should have just won this entire game from round 1!!!!

didn't know you were such a Retroboot fan, GL

or is this strategic voting to protect your actual faves still in the game?

(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass 275
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet 325
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel 400

There were another half dozen I'd have happily given points to as well, but wanted to give these more of a fighting chance.

Not quite in that group, there's Nura. Embodiment of fan power in the Legion election, and a character who developed superbly under Levitz as a result. One of the earliest scenes in the Baxter series was her taking out a driod with her powere being used for combat.
Drura is the rejected applicant whose powers, once controllable, was ptobably the most feared character in the galaxy. No one, not Darkseid, not Mordru, not the LSV would want to mess with Drura. Or get her on a bad day. Which she doens;t seem to have many of, with the sense of mischief she has.
I didn't even go back to look at Mon-El again. Another influential character, who if he won this I'd have been nodding my head in agreement.

It IS interesting how, among the current op 25/30, we barely have any couples.

There's Brainy and Kara, and now Laurel

Imra and Garth, but Imra's pre-5YL and Garth is Reboot

we have Chuck without Lu,

we have Tinya without Jo...

Gosh, if only a later voter would add to the 400 points a certain other poster gave Lu, and she could be reunited with Chuck.

(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass ( Round 5 ) - 100
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl ( Round 5 ) - 150
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass ( Round 5 ) - 150
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy ( Round 5 ) - 100
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy ( Round 5 ) - 100
(Retroboot) Dragonwing ( Round 2 ) - 50
(Retroboot) Glorith ( Round 2 ) - 50
(Retroboot) Tyroc ( Round 1 ) - 50
(Threeboot) Turtle ( Round 1 ) - 50
(Threeboot) Gazelle ( Round 2 ) - 50
(SW6) Dragonmage ( Round 4 ) - 100
(Threeboot) Sizzle ( Round 1 ) - 50

As usual, I didn't look at others votes, because I don't have the attention span to vote strategically. I just splash my points around in a drunken spending spree, like the Luck Lords teach us.

Nice to see Dragonwing get some points.

(5YL) Brainiac 5 ( Round 5 ) - 700
(5YL) Cosmic Boy ( Round 2 ) - 100
(5YL) Invisible Kid II ( Round 2 ) - 70
(5YL) Shrinking Violet ( Round 5 ) - 100
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II ( Round 4 ) - 5
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl ( Round 5 ) - 5
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel ( Round 5 ) - 5
(Pre-5YL) White Witch ( Round 4 ) - 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy ( Round 5 - 5
(SW6) Computo ( Round 4 ) - 5

This was really hard. Picking those that "might" get a second chance.

In the end I had to hope that putting most of it on Brainy would be enough to get him back in. Then possible boosts for a few other outstanding 5YL characters. Cos really did pull the team back together, and the dynamic between him and Vi was amazing. Would we even have a free Earth without Jacques?

After that the rest is really just token votes to show them some love. I don't expect any of those points to really help but maybe it will prompt someone else to use their budget of points.
Those 4 Pre-5YL are probably the standouts to me (that have been dropped). Again Jacques, Jeckie, Luornu and Mysa had some of the most interesting storylines and character development.
I thought Reboot Cos's leadership was terrific.
And Danielle showed so much potential. Such a pity it was cut short.

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Gold Lantern should have just won this entire game from round 1!!!!

didn't know you were such a Retroboot fan, GL

or is this strategic voting to protect your actual faves still in the game?

There is a Klingon saying - "Only Nixon can go to China."

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Gosh, if only a later voter would add to the 400 points a certain other poster gave Lu, and she could be reunited with Chuck.

Originally Posted by Set

As usual, I didn't look at others votes, because I don't have the attention span to vote strategically. I just splash my points around in a drunken spending spree, like the Luck Lords teach us.

alas, thoth's plea fell on deaf ears! (nice to know how you vote, Set! am sure others will use that tidbit strategically :p)

Originally Posted by stile86

Would we even have a free Earth without Jacques?

After that the rest is really just token votes to show them some love. I don't expect any of those points to really help but maybe it will prompt someone else to use their budget of points.
Those 4 Pre-5YL are probably the standouts to me (that have been dropped). Again Jacques, Jeckie, Luornu and Mysa had some of the most interesting storylines and character development.
I thought Reboot Cos's leadership was terrific.
And Danielle showed so much potential. Such a pity it was cut short.

5YL really upped my respect and appreciation for Jacques... and Tyroc! and Drura...

and indeed, a pity for Danielle. TBH, if Gear didn't exist, I'd be rooting harder for Danielle to come back as a Legionnaire in the comics canon

(Reboot) Cosmic Boy - 405
(Reboot) Saturn Girl - 405
(Reboot) Umbra - 120
(Reboot) Gear - 70

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel 900 pts
(5YL) Calamity King 100 pts

ok gang, closing the round and tallying the votes now!

RESULTS TIME!!! End of Round 7!!

Hundreds of Legionnaire hopefuls competed for a second chance... but only 5 will make it through! Who are our lucky ones?

Posting results from the bottom up...

First we have the massive wall of zeroes... Mainly Legionnaires who have counterparts in other realities, but also a few "duds". Take that Atmos, Firefist, Bloodclaw, you horrible Bounty entity! and also poor one-shot Dead Earthers!

(5YL) Atmos
(5YL) Bloodclaw
(5YL) Bouncing Boy
(5YL) Bounty entity
(5YL) Chameleon Boy
(5YL) Colossal Boy
(5YL) Dawnstar
(5YL) Dream Girl
(5YL) Duo Damsel
(5YL) Element Lad
(5YL) Firefist
(5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty)
(5YL) Lightning Lass
(5YL) Mon-el
(5YL) Polar Boy
(5YL) Queen Projectra
(5YL) Reflecto
(5YL) Rond Vidar
(5YL) Saturn Girl
(5YL) Shadow Lass
(5YL) Star Boy
(5YL) Sun Boy
(5YL) Timber Wolf
(5YL) Ultra Boy
(5YL) Valor
(5YL) White Witch
(5YL) Wildfire
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Bouncing Boy
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Brainiac 5
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Chameleon
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Colossal Boy
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Cosmic Man
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Lightning Man
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Saturn Woman
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Sensor
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Shrinking Violet
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Superman
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Ultra Boy
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Umbra
(Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Wildfire
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Batman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Bouncing Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chameleon Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chemical King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Color King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Colossal Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Cosmic Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Dream Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duo Damsel
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Element Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Karate King
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Light Lady
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Matter-Eater Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Night Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Phantom Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Polar Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shrinking Violet
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Star Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Timber Wolf
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ultra Man
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) White Witch
(Arrowverse) Brainiac 5
(Arrowverse) Chameleon
(Arrowverse) Dream Girl
(Arrowverse) Karate Kid
(Arrowverse) Lightning Lass
(Arrowverse) Mon-El
(Arrowverse) Saturn Girl
(Arrowverse) Toyman
(Arthurian Legion) Alchemist
(Arthurian Legion) Andromeda
(Arthurian Legion) Brainiac 5
(Arthurian Legion) Chameleon
(Arthurian Legion) Computo
(Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Dragonmage
(Arthurian Legion) Dream Girl
(Arthurian Legion) Ferro
(Arthurian Legion) Infectious Lass
(Arthurian Legion) Inferno
(Arthurian Legion) Invisible Kid I
(Arthurian Legion) Invisible Kid II
(Arthurian Legion) Karate Kid I
(Arthurian Legion) Leviathan
(Arthurian Legion) Live Wire
(Arthurian Legion) Matter-Eater Lad
(Arthurian Legion) Nemesis Kid
(Arthurian Legion) Polar Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl
(Arthurian Legion) Shrinking Violet
(Arthurian Legion) Spark
(Arthurian Legion) Triad
(Arthurian Legion) Ultra Boy
(Arthurian Legion) Umbra
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Andromeda
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Blok
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Bouncing Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Brainiac 5
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Chameleon Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Colossal Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Cosmic Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Douglas Nolan
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Dream Girl
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Ferro Lad
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Green Arrow
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Green Lantern (John Stewart)
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Kid Quantum
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Light Lass
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Lightning Lad
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Phantom Girl
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Saturn Girl
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Shadow Lass
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Timber Wolf
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Triad
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Ultra Boy
(DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Wildfire
(Dead Earth) Argent
(Dead Earth) Graft
(Dead Earth) Lodestone
(Dead Earth) Magno Boy
(Dead Earth) Membrain
(Dead Earth) Metrox
(Dead Earth) Nervosa
(Dead Earth) Phase
(Dead Earth) Shape
(Dead Earth) Shift
(Dead Earth) Silverwing
(Dead Earth) Triad III
(Dead Earth) Triplicate
(JLA Trapped in Time) Dawnstar
(JLA Trapped in Time) Karate Kid
(Legion 1 Million) Brainiac 417
(Legion 1 Million) Cosmicbot
(Legion 1 Million) Implicate Girl
(Legion 1 Million) Superboy
(Legion 1 Million) The Chameleon
(Legion 1 Million) The Dreamer
(Legion 1 Million) The M'Onelves
(Legion 1 Million) The Umbra
(Legion 1 Million) Titangirl
(Legion 1 Million) Wildflame
(Legion Animated Movie) Andromeda
(Legion Animated Movie) Arm-Fall-Off-Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Atmos
(Legion Animated Movie) Blok
(Legion Animated Movie) Bouncing Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Brainiac 5
(Legion Animated Movie) Catspaw
(Legion Animated Movie) Chameleon Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Chemical King
(Legion Animated Movie) Color Kid
(Legion Animated Movie) Comet Queen
(Legion Animated Movie) Cosmic Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Dawnstar
(Legion Animated Movie) Dream Girl
(Legion Animated Movie) Element Lad
(Legion Animated Movie) Ferro Lad
(Legion Animated Movie) Gates
(Legion Animated Movie) Gold Lantern
(Legion Animated Movie) Invisible Kid
(Legion Animated Movie) Karate Kid
(Legion Animated Movie) Kid Quantum II
(Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix
(Legion Animated Movie) Lightning Lad
(Legion Animated Movie) Mon-El
(Legion Animated Movie) Monstress
(Legion Animated Movie) Phantom Girl
(Legion Animated Movie) Polar Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Power Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Quislet
(Legion Animated Movie) Saturn Girl
(Legion Animated Movie) Sensor Girl
(Legion Animated Movie) Shadow Lass
(Legion Animated Movie) Star Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Stone Boy
(Legion Animated Movie) Supergirl
(Legion Animated Movie) Superman
(Legion Animated Movie) Tellus
(Legion Animated Movie) Timber Wolf
(Legion Animated Movie) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Legion Animated Movie) Tyroc
(Legion Animated Movie) Wildfire
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Blok
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chameleon Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chemical King
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chlorophyll Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Color Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Colossal Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Cosmic Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dawnstar
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dream Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Element Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Ferro Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Infectious Lass
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Invisible Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Karate Kid
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Matter-Eater Lad
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Night Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Phantom Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Polar Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Porcupine Pete
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Saturn Girl
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Star Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Stone Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Sun Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman X
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Timber Wolf
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Tyroc
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Ultra Boy
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) White Witch
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) XS
(Pre-5YL) Anti-Lad
(Pre-5YL) Beppo
(Pre-5YL) Comet
(Pre-5YL) Command Kid
(Pre-5YL) Dynamo Boy
(Pre-5YL) Pete Ross
(Pre-5YL) Streaky
(Reboot) Chuck Taine
(Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
(Retroboot) Blok
(Retroboot) Bouncing Boy
(Retroboot) Brainiac 5
(Retroboot) Chameleon Boy
(Retroboot) Colossal Boy
(Retroboot) Cosmic Boy
(Retroboot) Dawnstar
(Retroboot) Dream Girl
(Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
(Retroboot) Earth-Man
(Retroboot) Element Lad
(Retroboot) Gates
(Retroboot) Invisible Kid II
(Retroboot) Karate Kid
(Retroboot) Lightning Lad
(Retroboot) Lightning Lass
(Retroboot) Matter-Eater Lad
(Retroboot) Mon-el
(Retroboot) Phantom Girl
(Retroboot) Polar Boy
(Retroboot) Quislet
(Retroboot) Saturn Girl
(Retroboot) Sensor Girl
(Retroboot) Shadow Lass
(Retroboot) Shrinking Violet
(Retroboot) Star Boy
(Retroboot) Sun Boy
(Retroboot) Superman
(Retroboot) Tellus
(Retroboot) Timber Wolf
(Retroboot) Ultra Boy
(Retroboot) Wildfire
(Smallville) Brainiac 5
(Smallville) Clark Kent
(Smallville) Cosmic Boy
(Smallville) Lightning Lad
(Smallville) Saturn Girl
(Superboy's Legion) Bouncing Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Brainiac 5
(Superboy's Legion) Chameleon Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Colossal Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Cosmic Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Element Lad
(Superboy's Legion) Ferro Lad
(Superboy's Legion) Invisible Kid
(Superboy's Legion) Karate Kid
(Superboy's Legion) Light Lass
(Superboy's Legion) Lightning Lad
(Superboy's Legion) Phantom Girl
(Superboy's Legion) Saturn Girl
(Superboy's Legion) Sensor
(Superboy's Legion) Shadow Lass
(Superboy's Legion) Shrinking Violet
(Superboy's Legion) Star Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Sun Boy
(Superboy's Legion) Superboy
(Superboy's Legion) Ultra Boy
(Threeboot) Atom Girl
(Threeboot) Brainiac 5
(Threeboot) Chameleon
(Threeboot) Colossal Boy/ Micro Lad
(Threeboot) Cosmic Boy
(Threeboot) Element Lad
(Threeboot) Invisible Kid
(Threeboot) Karate Kid
(Threeboot) Light Lass
(Threeboot) Lightning Lad
(Threeboot) Mon-el
(Threeboot) Night Girl
(Threeboot) Phantom Girl
(Threeboot) Princess Projectra
(Threeboot) Saturn Girl
(Threeboot) Shadow Lass
(Threeboot) Star Boy
(Threeboot) Sun Boy
(Threeboot) Supergirl
(Threeboot) Timber Wolf
(Threeboot) Triplicate Girl
(Threeboot) Ultra Boy
(Young Justice) Chameleon Boy
(Young Justice) Phantom Girl
(Young Justice) Saturn Girl

Next: a lot of love spread around, these Legionnaires got 6 points each

(5YL) Chlorophyll Kid
(5YL) Color Kid
(5YL) Crystal Kid
(5YL) Echo
(5YL) Fire Lad
(5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
(5YL) Infectious Lass
(5YL) Karate Kid II
(5YL) Kono
(5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish)
(5YL) Nightwind
(5YL) Porcupine Pete
(5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
(5YL) Stone Boy
(5YL) Storm Boy
(5YL) Tyroc
(5YL) Veilmist
(5YL) Visi-Lad
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen
(Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto
(Bendisboot) Blok
(Bendisboot) Bouncing Boy
(Bendisboot) Brainiac 5
(Bendisboot) Chameleon Boy
(Bendisboot) Colossal Boy
(Bendisboot) Computo
(Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy
(Bendisboot) Dawnstar
(Bendisboot) Dream Girl
(Bendisboot) Element Lad
(Bendisboot) Ferro Lad
(Bendisboot) Invisible Kid
(Bendisboot) Karate Kid
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lad
(Bendisboot) Lightning Lass
(Bendisboot) Matter-Eater Lad
(Bendisboot) Mon-el
(Bendisboot) Phantom Girl
(Bendisboot) Princess Projectra
(Bendisboot) Saturn Girl
(Bendisboot) Shadow Lass
(Bendisboot) Shrinking Violet
(Bendisboot) Star Boy
(Bendisboot) Sun Boy
(Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon)
(Bendisboot) Timber Wolf
(Bendisboot) Triplicate Girl
(Bendisboot) Ultra Boy
(Bendisboot) White Witch
(Bendisboot) Wildfire
(Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid
(Pre-5YL) Blok
(Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
(Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
(Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen)
(Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
(Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang)
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
(Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho
(Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
(Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid
(Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Mon-el
(Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid
(Pre-5YL) Quislet
(Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
(Pre-5YL) Star Boy
(Pre-5YL) Superboy
(Pre-5YL) Tyroc
(Pre-5YL) Wildfire
(Reboot) Andromeda
(Reboot) Apparition
(Reboot) Chameleon
(Reboot) Dreamer
(Reboot) Element Lad
(Reboot) Ferro
(Reboot) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum I
(Reboot) Leviathan
(Reboot) Magno
(Reboot) M'Onel
(Reboot) Sensor
(Reboot) Star Boy
(Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
(Reboot) Thunder
(Reboot) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Ultra Boy
(Reboot) Wildfire
(Retroboot) Black Witch
(Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
(Retroboot) Chemical Kid
(Retroboot) Comet Queen
(Retroboot) Harmonia Li
(Retroboot) Night Girl
(SW6) Alchemist
(SW6) Andromeda
(SW6) Apparition
(SW6) Bouncing Boy
(SW6) Brainiac 5
(SW6) Catspaw
(SW6) Chameleon Boy
(SW6) Cosmic Boy
(SW6) Dream Girl
(SW6) Ferro
(SW6) Gossamer
(SW6) Inferno
(SW6) Karate Kid
(SW6) Kid Quantum
(SW6) Leviathan
(SW6) Live Wire
(SW6) Matter-Eater Lad
(SW6) Princess Projectra
(SW6) Saturn Girl
(SW6) Shrinking Violet
(SW6) Star Boy
(SW6) Triad
(SW6) Ultra Boy
(SW6) Valor
(Threeboot) Dream Boy
(Threeboot) Dream Girl

and starting from 7 points and up, these Legionnaires advanced a bit from the pack... but not enough to make it to the magic 5 this round...

(Pre-5YL) Chemical King - 7
(Retroboot) Rond Vidar - 7
(SW6) Invisible Kid - 10
(Pre-5YL) White Witch - 11
(Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I - 16
(Pre-5YL) Krypto - 50
(5YL) Spider-Girl - 56
(Pre-5YL) Dream Girl - 56
(Retroboot) Dragonwing - 56
(Retroboot) Glorith - 56
(Retroboot) Tyroc - 56
(Threeboot) Gazelle - 56
(Threeboot) Sizzle - 56
(5YL) Flederweb - 57
(Threeboot) Turtle - 57
(5YL) Invisible Kid II - 70
(5YL) Cosmic Boy - 100
(5YL) Shrinking Violet - 100
(Pre-5YL) Proty II - 100
(5YL) Calamity King - 106
(Bendisboot) Entropy Kid - 106
(Bendisboot) Radius Lad - 106
(Bendisboot) X-Ray Girl - 106
(Pre-5YL) Sun Boy - 106
(Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy - 106
(SW6) Dragonmage - 106
(SW6) Computo - 111
(Bendisboot) Monster Boy - 120
(Bendisboot) Doctor Fate - 156
(Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass - 156
(Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl - 161
(Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet - 331
(Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass - 381
(Bendisboot) Gold Lantern - 506
(Pre-5YL) Element Lad - 506
(Reboot) Saturn Girl - 511

Reboot Imra misses the cut off by 6 points... and Gold Lantern and pre-5YL Jan by 11 points...

and the 5 lucky ones coming back to life:

(Reboot) Cosmic Boy - 516
(Reboot) Umbra - 526
(Reboot) Gear - 527
(5YL) Brainiac 5 - 700
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 1311

Three from the Reboot, one 5YL, one pre-5YL!

This makes 3 versions of Brainiac 5 in the top 30, two versions of Lu, and the top 30 welcomes a version each for Gear, Rokk and Tasmia!
These 5 come back to the game, and I will restore their total cumulative points including this round - these points will be used to break any ties that come up in the future rounds.

(note: if they had tied, Imra would have gone through over Cos; Imra had 945 previous round points, to Cos' 736! Jan and Gold Lantern had far fewer points, so Cos would still have won over them!)

thanks all for voting - round 8 will be up soon!

Also, perhaps not surprisingly, all 5 of the resurrected were eliminated just one round ago! I was wondering if we'd see any earlier eliminations return to the game...

Round 8 begins!

ok gang, things are getting serious now. We're down to 30... let's go down to 20!

Please vote for your Top10!

now, as 10 of our contestants get a fairly sizable bonus due to winning it big in Round 5, I've also tweaked the point system so that higher ranks can earn a fair big number of points - where in Round 6, rank 1 could earn 500, here Rank 1 can earn 450. not a big jump down. The reason for this: while I wanted the Round 5 winners to get a boost, without making that boost insurmountable - else where would the fun be?

So, a word of caution, this game is prone to surprises... think carefully about how complacent you want to be with your faves!

1 - 450
2 - 350
3 - 270
4 - 200
5 - 150
6 - 100
7 - 50
8 - 20
9 - 5
10 - 1

I will post the list of 30 contestants twice - the first is to list the Legionnaires, their bonus points if any, and a reminder re which Round they made it back in -

the second list only has the Legionnaires' names, please use that one to copy-paste the list/wording exactly, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

List with round information and starting bonus points, for decision-making reference!

(5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 7 winner - 0
(5YL) Laurel Gand - Round 6 winner - 0
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 202
(Dead Earth) Wildfire - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 171
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 162
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 137
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 winner - 0
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy - Round 7 winner - 0
(Reboot) Gates - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 204
(Reboot) Gear - Round 7 winner - 0
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 80
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 312
(Reboot) Live Wire - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Monstress - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Shikari - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 214
(Reboot) Spark - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 138
(Reboot) Triad - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Umbra - Round 7 winner - 0
(Reboot) XS - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 139
(Threeboot) Theena - Round 6 winner - 0

Hope that's not too hard to read... don't worry, there is an easier list below!!!

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours (so, around this time on January 31st Wednesday - around dinner time for me

)
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Dead Earth
Pre-5YL
Reboot
Threeboot

Please use this list for copy-pasting your voting! Round 8 list!

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) XS
(Threeboot) Theena

(Round ends, around this time on January 31st Wednesday, round my dinner time

)

interesting top 30 we got - 15 from the Reboot, 10 from pre-5YL, 3 5YL, and 1 each from Dead Earth and Threeboot, still going strong.

Duplicates on the list: 3 Brainiac 5s, 2 Luornu Durgos, and we have both Laurel Gand and Supergirl represented - though they definitely are different characters, I would say. that means we have 27 "unique" characters represented on the list of 30, sweet.

all 3 founders are still on, though Cos and Garth are Reboot versions, and Imra pre5YL.

and a large portion of the list includes Legionnaires who don't have multiple counterparts in the "main" canon 'Boots - besides Laurel and Kara, we also have Polar Bpy, Tellus, Gates, Gear, Kid Q II, Kinetix, Monstress, Shikari, XS and Theena.

among the "usual suspects" of Adventure Era ++ Legionnaires (you know, the ones who typically show up in every canon "Boot

) - we have Imra, Garth, Rokk, Tinya, Lu, Brainy, Lyle, Vi, Chuck, Tenzil, Ayla, Val, Tasmia, Brin, and Wildfire.

and yes, I'm stalling because I'm struggling with my list, only 10 and they need to be ranked, too ...

I was able to trim my list down to the 15 Reboot characters (I grew up with them, after all; and they got me through some very tough times), and one Pre-5YL one: Polar Boy.

(I do like many of the others on the list, but Polar Boy rises above the likes of Tenzil, Supergirl, Chuck, Theena, pre 5YL Tinya, Laurel, pre-5YL Luornu, pre5YL Val...) Even Dead Earth Wildfire, I don't quite want to see eliminated!

after thinking long and hard, I've decided on my top 10... though there are many others on the list whom I'd vote for, if there were more slots. But these 10 are the ones I'd feel most badly about not voting for.

also playing it a bit safe here - some of my picks have the +10% bonus, but this game has thrown us surprises before... I'm putting some of my +10% bonus picks a bit lower, in the hopes that others who've voted for them will still vote for them and keep them safe. the exception is Kinetix, who is my #1 absolute fave, and so I don't wanna take any chances with her!

(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Umbra
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) XS

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Threeboot) Theena
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Reboot) XS

On Round 7:

Thrilled to see Lu get through!

Sad to see Vi and Ayla go. One of my favourite Legion couples, making them one of my favourite comics couples. Levitz put Salu through the wringer with the sens-tank/ impersonation plot. Yes, her change in personality was a direct response to that. But then we got to see that settle as the series developed, into the 5YG and into the TMK series. Salu faced so many difficult momnets during all of that. Having to deal with pretty much everything about her own life, her relationships, and how she felt about everyone around her. People who were essentially an extended family.
Ayla too, had come a long way from impersonating her deceased brother, through Light Lass days, through her romance with Brin, and through her own sense of loss and sense of attachement to the others. The two together really helped each other through some tough times.

Jeckie is another one, I'd not have minded winning. A lot of that is, like Nura, Levitz having to work his way out of a corner. With his boss vetoing Supergirl's return, we saw a a lot of strength, and capability in Sensor Girl before the Jeckie reveal. Revealed, we then had an arc from the LSV invasion of her planet, the faith of her people and death of her consort, through to being Leader and her confrontation with the Emerald Empress and the Archmage. Jeckie was central in a lot of the big moments in the Baxter series.

While not at that level for me, Monster Boy was fun; Doctor Fate had long standing (Giffeny) Legion connections; Computo was the SW6 stand out. Always nice to see other pre-5YG points too.

pre5YL and 5YL Ayla, Vi and Jeckie were all definitely outstanding, thothy, I agree. I like how Vi became a much more settled character 5YL, and so did Ayla. Both women grew wonderfully during that time, working out a lot of trauma and issues.

TBH, with Ayla, I preferred her 5YL version vastly over her pre-5YL one. Ayla blasting Polar Boy's Legion leader campaign ice sculpture to smithereens is one moment that made me not like her so much... conversely, I became a much bigger fan of Pre-5YL Garth after seeing his even-tempered reaction.

Jeckie, I also appreciated a lot 5YL. I did feel a lot for her, during the invasion of Orando, and I loved how she took down Nemesis Kid. pre-5YL, her horror at accidentally causing the death of the Emerald Empress was palpable, too. And I always felt she got a bit shafted after Adventure and before v3; in Adventure, she had a lot of great moments, like standing against Persuader and such. But I also remember her passively whining a lot... and when Pharoxx and Hegga made a play for the throne, I remember others, like Nura, shining more than Jeckie herself did! I also didn't quite appreciate her reaction to Brainy apologizing (after obsessively trying to figure out who she was). She "accepted" the apology... then subtly threatens Brainy by hurting his hand. Tch! come on, Jeckie, give Brainy a break.

Agree with a lot of your points too Ibby. I was just thinking about favourite iterations a minute ago.

There are some simply lovely relationship moments in TMK's run between Saul and Ayla. Some of my favourite in comics. Ayla's mechanical nature was also in the background. We saw her interest in keeping the Legion ships going, her friendship with Loomis. There were indications of some of this during the Baxter run. She had been only to happy to leave, befroe Baxter. We then saw her reclaim her old powers and idnetity. She saved a lot of her colleagues. Then she became more of a powerhouse as the series progressed. During that time, she had to reassess relationships, because Salu had certainly figured out what she wanted. I think the impact of that led to a distraction with Pol too. All the cmplex- read-between-the-panels stuff we all like to do with the Legion.

I quite like the Garth-Proty arc. As much for the sheer fun of thinking out the box (or ceremonial casket). It connected Garth's adventurous status through the leadership issues to the quieter retired Garth. It also allowed TMK to give us the SW6 livewire persoanlity. While, for effect, that may have gone too far in the other direction, it certainly laid the gorundwork for events to come.

I think Jeckies' shining moments were at the start and end of the Baxter run. I liked her gentle reminder to Brainy. It added another dynamic to the team. While there was no suggestion of really harming Brainy, we remembered the fate of Nemesis Kid. It reminded us of Jeckie's heritage. And the responsibilities that brings may supercede the goals of the Legion and certain members of it. That was an occassion where I felt TMK didn;t follow through, In that run, her world was the victim of the Khundish mist, and that was that.

Originally Posted by thoth lad

On Round 7:

Thrilled to see Lu get through!

Yeah, so apparently I accidentally deleted Lu from my list in the previous round. If I'd done things correctly, she should've been by #1 that round, so I had to make sure she was brought back.

1. (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
2. (Reboot) Kinetix
3. (Reboot) Gates
4. (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
5. (Threeboot) Theena
6. (Reboot) Gear
7. (Reboot) XS
8. (Pre-5YL) Tellus
9. (Reboot) Brainiac 5
10. (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy

Well whaddye know? My 5 points for Reboot Cos actually made a difference. His longer term chances aren't great but still ...

And yes I too am glad to see Lu back.

(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Reboot) XS
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Threeboot) Theena
(Reboot) XS
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy

(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Reboot) Gear
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy

1 - (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
2 - (Pre-5YL) Tellus
3 - (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
4 - (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
5 - (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
6 - (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
7 - (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
8 - (Reboot) Invisible Kid
9 - (Reboot) Monstress
10 - (Reboot) Gates

wow, votes are coming in hard and fast! did you all have an easier time choosing this round?

Originally Posted by Eryk Davis Ester

Originally Posted by thoth lad

On Round 7:

Thrilled to see Lu get through!

Yeah, so apparently I accidentally deleted Lu from my list in the previous round. If I'd done things correctly, she should've been by #1 that round, so I had to make sure she was brought back.

glad you succeeded, EDE!

Originally Posted by thoth lad

It reminded us of Jeckie's heritage. And the responsibilities that brings may supercede the goals of the Legion and certain members of it. .

fair one, thothy. after all, a Queen's duty is first and foremost to her people... even if, at the time, she may not be a reigning queen

Originally Posted by stile86

Well whaddye know? My 5 points for Reboot Cos actually made a difference. His longer term chances aren't great but still ...

.

yeah, even 1 point can make a difference - in past editions, Legionnaires have won/lost a round by breaking a tie

(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf

1 - (Reboot) Triad
2 - (Reboot) Spark
3 - (Reboot) Gates
4 - (Reboot) Gear
5 - (Reboot) Brainiac 5
6 - (Reboot) XS
7 - (Reboot) Invisible Kid
8 - (Dead Earth) Wildfire
9 - (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
10 - (Reboot) Shikari

closing the round now! results up shortly

Round 8 Results!

from 30, we're going down to 20... who made the cut?

(Reboot) Kinetix - 1112 ( Round 5 winner with +10% bonus )
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 891 ( Round 7 winner )
(Reboot) Spark - 838 ( Round 5 winner with +10% bonus )
(Reboot) Gates - 815 ( Round 5 winner with +10% bonus )
(Threeboot) Theena - 770 ( Round 6 winner )
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - 752 ( Round 6 winner )
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 722 ( Round 5 winner with +10% bonus )
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - 712 ( Round 5 winner with +10% bonus )
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - 674 ( Round 5 winner with +10% bonus )
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - 655 ( Round 6 winner )
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 641 ( Round 5 winner with +10% bonus )
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - 601 ( Round 6 winner )
(Reboot) Triad - 550 ( Round 6 winner )
(Reboot) XS - 511 ( Round 5 winner with +10% bonus )
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - 507 ( Round 5 winner with +10% bonus )
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - 505 ( Round 6 winner )
(Reboot) Gear - 500 ( Round 7 winner )
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - 500 ( Round 5 winner with +10% bonus )
(Dead Earth) Wildfire - 475 ( Round 6 winner )
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - 475 ( Round 6 winner )

and 4 points separated the highest-eliminated from safety...

(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - 471 ( Round 6 winner )
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - 470 ( Round 6 winner )
(5YL) Brainiac 5 - 450 ( Round 7 winner )
(5YL) Laurel Gand - 450 ( Round 6 winner )
(Reboot) Monstress - 305 ( Round 6 winner )
(Reboot) Live Wire - 270 ( Round 6 winner )
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy - 220 ( Round 7 winner )
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - 130 ( Round 6 winner )
(Reboot) Umbra - 100 ( Round 7 winner )
(Reboot) Shikari - 51 ( Round 6 winner )

we didn't lose anybody from the Round 5 winners list, though of course we can't really say if that was because of the +10% bonus or not. Folks just voted differently, after all.

We lose 3 of the Round 7 returnees;

5 Reboot, 3 pre-5YL, 2 5YL;

the last versions of Brek Bannin, Val Armorr, Laurel Gand, Monstress, Garth, Cos, Imra, Tasmia and Shikari...

... and all versions of the original 3 founders!

thanks all for voting... round 9 will be up soon!

Round 9 begins!

Let's slow things down a bit - I bet most, if not all, of us are reeling from last round. I know I am!

From 20, let's get down to 15.

Please vote for your top 8!

Again, because of the bonus points for our Round 5 winners, I've also tweaked the point system so that higher ranks can earn a fair big number of points. The reason for this: while I wanted the Round 5 winners to get a boost, without making that boost insurmountable - else where would the fun be?

where last round, Rank 1 earns 450, this round, Rank 1 earns 400.

1 - 400
2 - 280
3 - 180
4 - 120
5 - 80
6 - 30
7 - 10
8 - 1

I will post the list of 30 contestants twice - the first is to list the Legionnaires, their bonus points if any, and a reminder re which Round they made it back in -

the second list only has the Legionnaires' names, please use that one to copy-paste the list/wording exactly, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

List with round information and starting bonus points, for decision-making reference!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 274
(Dead Earth) Wildfire - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 235
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 233
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 188
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 winner - 0
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Gates - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 286
(Reboot) Gear - Round 7 winner - 0
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 130
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 423
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 282
(Reboot) Spark - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 222
(Reboot) Triad - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) XS - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 190
(Threeboot) Theena - Round 6 winner - 0

Hope that's not too hard to read... don't worry, there is an easier list below!!!

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours (so, around this time on February 3rd, Saturday - around dinner time for me

)
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Dead Earth
Pre-5YL
Reboot
Threeboot

Please use this list for copy-pasting your voting! Round 9 list!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) XS
(Threeboot) Theena

Round ends around this time on February 3rd, Saturday - around dinner time for me

random thoughts will I let myself absorb what has happened:

So we still have 10 Reboot, 7 Pre-5YL, and one each Dead Earth, 5YL, Threeboot.

Theena looks to be the dark horse of this race - I do like her, but also find it interesting that she's outlasted the likes of other "niche", relatively "unique" characters like Infectious Lass, Shikari, Spider-Girl, Veilmist...

in one stroke, we lose all versions of the founders, yow!

I miss Live Wire, but the writing was on the wall, not many others were giving him points. I miss Monstress too, though am pleased she got this far - she's certainly come a long way from the Legionnaire that many fans wanted dead!

While I do like Umbra's growth under the DNA era, I have to admit she was quite something before - even her LSH Secret Files 2 entry says that her teammates thought of her as an "arrogant snot". She was cruel to Monstress in Legion Lost 7, but she was also telepathically influenced then, so I can excuse that.

pre 5YL Imra. I really liked her in Adventure, and even up to Universo Project. I have big issues with her during, and after, Conspiracy. I can excuse her secrecy during the Conspiracy build-up (though I love that Tellus of all Legionnaires called her out on her "un-Legion-like answers"!). My qualms with her - even more so than Brainiac 5- come from what I see as her hypocrisy after. From pulling rank on Polar Boy during Brainy's trial ("Don't quote the constitution at me, I helped write it!"). to her being, well, in my mind unfairly critical of Brek (when fighting the Emerald Empress: "We did fine, despite Polar Boy seriously misbalancing the teams.") eh? didn't see any evidence of that...

But also, I found her full-throated defense of Brainy interesting, versus her rather strict Legion Constitution interpretation before that got Star Boy kicked off the team.

(for that matter, pre-5YL Brainiac 5 loses points from me for that too - he was the prosecutor versus Star Boy, was he not?)

I regret losing Polar Boy a bit, to be honest. he was not always the wisest Legionnaire, but he had spirit. (5YG: his pizza parlor protest, that got him locked up - brave, but not effective. Jacques and the other Subs made smarter choices then!)

Karate Kid, I found a much more competent :Legionnaire in the Adventure Era. in v2, he acted kinda dumb a lot ("Astound this, Stone Face!" and promptly crashes into Darkseid...); then he went out in a blaze of glory at the start of v3.

as for Reboot Cos, I should rank him higher, he was an excellent first leader. he did have his flaws though, sometimes he lost his temper...

well, everyone who made the top 30 is a big winner in my book!

again, voting based on a mix of my faves + considering how others have voted in earlier rounds...

(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) XS
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Gear

1 - (Pre-5YL) Tellus
2 - (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
3 - (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
4 - (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
5 - (Reboot) Gates
6 - (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
7 - (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
8 - (Threeboot) Theena

that was fast, Set

I just remembered: both Pre-5YL Imra and Val made it to the Top 3 last time we ran this game... but the voters have changed so much from last time, too!

also, a little reflection on why I like Reboot Garth so much - yeah, he had his immature moments, but he really grew into a mature, seasoned Legionnaire towards the end. especially under DNA. I cried when he sacrificed himself in Legion Lost, and was shocked when he returned as Jarth.... and dang it, he and Imra deserved their happy ending. which has happened in my fanfic land, at least

Sigh. Goodbye 5YL Brainy. It felt like this portrayal extended and completed Pre-5YL Brainy. In contrast the Retroboot took him in a direction I didn't like.
Also sad to see Laurel go. A wonderfully unique character, very different from both Kara that she replaced and the later Reboot version.

Looking back I am sorry I didn't vote more for Imra earlier. She was a backbone of the team in many stories, and an effective leader.

Your comments on Livewire, Ibby, are well made. He did experience a lot of growth over the series and showed a lot of strength and leadership and sacrifice.

(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Reboot) XS
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Threeboot) Theena
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Reboot) XS

Originally Posted by stile86

Sigh. Goodbye 5YL Brainy. It felt like this portrayal extended and completed Pre-5YL Brainy. In contrast the Retroboot took him in a direction I didn't like.
Also sad to see Laurel go. A wonderfully unique character, very different from both Kara that she replaced and the later Reboot version.

Looking back I am sorry I didn't vote more for Imra earlier. She was a backbone of the team in many stories, and an effective leader.

Your comments on Livewire, Ibby, are well made. He did experience a lot of growth over the series and showed a lot of strength and leadership and sacrifice.

thanks, stile.

and agree about Imra - for most incarnations of Imra, I would follow her willingly, as a Legionnaire!

and Laurel, indeed, a great character for sure. certainly, the 5YL and SW6 ones are ones I prefer over the Reboot version - and that's not often the case for me

Hey, guys--I'm chaos, aka previous non-participant who just discovered this game existed and therefore may mess up voting patterns unmaliciously but sincerely because of his very presence!

(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Triad

We'll see how/if my presene makes any real difference.......

Lardy! good to see you again! just like old times eh

(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Gear
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Gates

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel 400
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad 280
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy 180
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl 120
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 80
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf 30
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl 10
(Pre-5YL) Tellus 1

Little bump up - interesting that we still miss 3 of our regular voters !

Sorry! It's been a busy last few days! Will have something up shortly!

Sorry I'm so late!!!!

(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) XS
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Threeboot) Theena

Didn't want to lose Triad, but she's getting so few votes that, well...

1 - (Reboot) Spark
2 - (Reboot) XS
3 - (Reboot) Gates
4 - (Reboot) Brainiac 5
5 - (Dead Earth) Wildfire
6 - (Reboot) Invisible Kid
7 - (Reboot) Gear
8 - (Reboot) Kinetix

only 1 left, let's see if IDLE is gonna vote soon

I'm gonna leave the game open overnight, it's late and I've had a tough workweek too. see you all in the morning!

'Night!

Sorry guys. I thought I had voted. (Probably forgot to hit post)

1. (pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
2. (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
3. (Threeboot) Theena
4. (Reboot) Kinetix
5. (Reboot) Gates
6. (Pre-5YL) Tellus
7. (Reboot) XS
8. (Reboot) Gear

Just in case Ibby's look ups doesn't spot it. Idle's Telly's should be Tellus.

Telly Savalas would have been a great Legionnaire - or Legion Villain!

"Who loves ya, baby?" as he opens up with a barrage of las-gun fire.
The villain who leaves a lollipop for his foes.

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Just in case Ibby's look ups doesn't spot it. Idle's Telly's should be Tellus.

thanks for the sharp spot, thothy! you can be an editor! (do a better job than most of the editors today!)

thanks for editing, IDLE!

just woke up, gettnig my morning coffee, and will get to my laptop and excel soon

closing the round now - had my coffee, breakfast, and done at the gym and all. results up shortly!

Round 8 Results!

from 20, down to 15... who made the cut?

for below - Legionnaires are ranked by points this round. I've annotated which round got them into the top 30, and for the Round 5 winners you can see their bonus points at the end. For full transparency, and to see/gauge who would be gone without those points. (Keeping in mind, this is a chicken-and-egg thing - did they get fewer points because their voters knew they had a safety cushion?)

making it to safety are:

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad 1014 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 274
(Reboot) Gates 937 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 286
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel 890 - Round 7 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 875 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 235
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl 873 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 233
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II 861 - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf 850 - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II 842 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 282
(Reboot) Spark 752 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 222
(Reboot) Kinetix 724 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 423
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy 710 - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) XS 661 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 190
(Pre-5YL) Tellus 619 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 188
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 600 - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Invisible Kid 590 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 130

and missing the cut off and going home are:

(Dead Earth) Wildfire 500 - Round 6 winner - 0
(Threeboot) Theena 462 - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl 340 - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Gear 292 - Round 7 winner - 0
(Reboot) Triad 81 - Round 6 winner - 0

although we didn't lose anyone from Round 5, I would say that Reboot Lyle, Tellus, and XS were all in striking distance! if, say, one of the eliminated had gotten an extra 1st rank (worth 400 pts) or 2nd rank (worth 280 points) vote ...

The Threeboot and Dead Earth realities exit the game completely, leaving us with 1 5YL, 8 Reboot and 6 pre-5YL in our top 15.

and we still have one Round 7 returnee (pre-5YL Luornu) going very strong!

with Reboot Lu's exit, that leaves Brainiac 5 as the only Legionnaire with more than 1 version on the list.

thanks for voting all, Round 10 is coming up after the break (pretty much immediately)!

Ooooh... Two more boots come to an end. Shame about Theena. That was a character I saw myself supporting a little later.
Nice to see Tenzil dying the flag, and later eating it, for 5YG. TMK did such a good job there.
No doubt folks would have tweaked votes accordingly, but those bonus points gave a nice cushion.

Round 10 begins!

From 15, let's get down to 10, so 5 will go home.

Please vote for your top 5!

Again, because of the bonus points for our Round 5 winners, I've also tweaked the point system so that higher ranks can earn a fair big number of points. The reason for this: while I wanted the Round 5 winners to get a boost, without making that boost insurmountable - else where would the fun be?

Among the round 5 winners, the average "previous round bonus" is 325. So I've considered that in setting the points for this round - where rank 1 gets 350 points. (last round, Rank 1 earned 400).

I've also, for the first time, awarded more than 1 point for Rank 5 - just to make rank 5 a bit more meaningful. This will be the last time I do this, once we stop giving bonus points at the start of the round, 1 point can be more meaningful by forcing a tie

1 - 350
2 - 200
3 - 100
4 - 50
5 - 10

I will post the list of contestants twice - the first is to list the Legionnaires, their bonus points if any, and a reminder re which Round they made it back in -

the second list only has the Legionnaires' names, please use that one to copy-paste the list/wording exactly, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

List with round information and starting bonus points, for decision-making reference!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 375
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 322
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 321
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 250
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 winner - 0
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Gates - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 379
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 189
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 495
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 366
(Reboot) Spark - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 297
(Reboot) XS - Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 256

Hope that's not too hard to read... don't worry, there is an easier list below!!!

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Pre-5YL
Reboot

Please use this list for copy-pasting your voting! Round 10 list!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) XS

Round ends around this time on February 7th, Wednesday- I will try to end it during lunch as I'm working from home, but might slide to dinner depending on how busy I am with work.

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Ooooh... Two more boots come to an end. Shame about Theena. That was a character I saw myself supporting a little later.
Nice to see Tenzil dying the flag, and later eating it, for 5YG. TMK did such a good job there.
No doubt folks would have tweaked votes accordingly, but those bonus points gave a nice cushion.

yeah, shame about Theena - if I had space I would have voted for her. Also Dead Earth Wildfire, IMO. And I'm also of course a bit sad to see pre5YL Tinya, Reboot Lu, and Gear go - I liked all of them, just not more than many remaining on the list.

It IS a big thing that they made it so far, esp. Theena (who wasn't an "active" active Legionnaire going on missions), and Dead Earth Wildfire (who appeared in exactly one issue!)

A bit of a preview ahead, folks:

Round 10: drop from 15 to 10

Round 11: a special last resurrection round

Round 12: down to 7; starting here on, no more bonus points, just a level playing field for all

Round 13; down to 5

Round 14: down to 3

Round 15: final round - choose one winner

I'm down to 6 on my list...

he hasn't been getting a lot of votes, so I'm not sure how high I want to rank Reboot Brainy. And I also don't want to take a chance with my #1 fave...

Kid Q II does not have a cushion, but a lot have been voting for her, so she seems reasonably safe.

XS, Gates and Violet all have a cushion, but... based on points, Gates seems safest of the 3... while Vi and XS are about the same safety level.

well, I'll feel bad not voting for Reboot Brainy, so... taking a chance that others will vote for my other faves....

(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) XS
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II

Well, I'm glad Theena lasted as long as she did, and at least it wouldn't have mattered if I'd ranked her as #1 rather than #2 last time.

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus

Always nice not to regret how one voted

(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) XS
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Gates

I knew DE Wildfire would drop off at some point but it was fun to see how far he would go. Same for Theena.
Pity about Triad. She had a wonderful story in Reboot. At least her other version is still around (thanks to resurrection).

(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Reboot) XS
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

Originally Posted by stile86

I knew DE Wildfire would drop off at some point but it was fun to see how far he would go. Same for Theena.
Pity about Triad. She had a wonderful story in Reboot. At least her other version is still around (thanks to resurrection).

l

same, always fun to see underdogs make it far!

also same re Triad, I definitely was sad to see her go - wish I had more spots on my list, but...

my general rule is, we only vote for about half the new list. that is, if we're going for our top 10, can only vote for 5 max. if we're going for top 50, can only vote 25.

1. (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
2. (Reboot) Kinetix
3. (Reboot) Gates
4. (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
5. (Pre-5YL) Tellus

Kind of interesting to note that I have all three realities represented (and would have had a fourth if Theena had made it). Having been a Legion fan since about 1983 or 4, If I had to pick a legion overall if would be Pre5YL, but individually, I tend to like the more unique characters (i.e. the ones usually only found in a single iteration. Of course my two faves are from Pre5YL. One should be obvious if you look at my voting and number two is Jan.

so Brin and Jan, that's a cool couple of faves, Idle! I like how different they are too - Brin is a straight up acrobatic brawler/fighter type, and Jan's powers are very versatile and more ranged (though he can definitely fight short-range if needed)

and yeah, can see the uniqueness from your list!

do you tend to like telekinetics too? thinking of Kinetix and Tellus. or do they just happen to be telekinetics, and they're you're faves for other reasons?

Brin also has the plus of that top Lightle drawn issue.

Thanks for putting up the next rounds, Ibby.
I'm looking forward again to seeing who people would like to bring back next round.
There could well be a few favs going out this round, receiving some impassioned pleas.

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy

happy to, thothy! we're getting close to the end, so a bit of a preview sounds like just the thing

and indeed, as we go on I find folks get more emotionally invested (probably a combination of: top faves going home, plus the act of actually voting for Legionnaires...) so... it's definitely getting tougher and tougher for me to vote, too!

so we have 7 votes in, out of 10 past voters.

I wonder if Lardy is gonna be a regular voter, too?

Sorry, my first attempt to answer seems to have not posted. I don't have any particular like or dislike of telekinetics. I like tellus because of his alien-ness and that Levitz did seem to play up his different way of thinking about the world. As for Kinetix, I like that fact that she was actively searching for things to help her gain powers rather than being born with them or getting them in an accident. I generally liked her personality and enjoyed her time as a catperson.

thanks, idle! always interesting to hear why others like characters.

I like Tellus' starting out as a fish out of water, but quickly showing some backbone (heh) - like him being brave against the Empress' new Fatal Five, and him calling Saturn Girl out for her "un-Legion-like" evasiveness during Conspiracy

and Kinetix, I did like that she wanted to use power to help others (though there was probably a bit of selfishness too, re it made her feel good and useful). but she was also always looking out for her friends

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

so we have 7 votes in, out of 10 past voters.

I've sent PMs out - I'll extend the round by a day, considering we're "missing" 3 voters.

I'll close the round at around this time tomorrow, no matter what.

(Reboot) Gates - 350
(Reboot) Spark - 200
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - 100
(Reboot) XS - 50
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - 10

ok, it's been a day, no replies from our other 2 "lost" voters Set and Lardy, so I will close the round now!

Round 10 Results!

from 15, down to 10... who made the cut?

for below - Legionnaires are ranked by points this round. I've annotated which round got them into the top 30, and for the Round 5 winners you can see their bonus points at the end. For full transparency, and to see/gauge who would be gone without those points. (Keeping in mind, this is a chicken-and-egg thing - did they get fewer points because their voters knew they had a safety cushion?)

making it to safety are:

(Reboot) Kinetix - 1045 Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 495
(Reboot) Gates - 839 Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 379
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - 821 Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 321
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - 776 Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 366
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - 725 Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 375
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - 722 Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 322
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - 720 Round 7 winner - 0
(Reboot) Spark - 697 Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 297
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - 639 Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 189
(Reboot) XS - 556 Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 256

and missing the cut off and going home are:

(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - 550 Round 6 winner - 0
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - 270 Round 5 winner with +10% bonus - 250
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - 210 Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - 210 Round 6 winner - 0
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - 150 Round 6 winner - 0

we lose our first Round 5 winner...

TBH, this is making me doubt whether that 10% bonus was too generous. although, I did try to scale the points so that the 10% bonus would not be insurmountable. maybe I should have made the Rank 2 points equal to the average bonus, rather than the Rank 1 points...

and also wondering if this is a chicken-and-egg thing. Some of us did seem to alter our votes in consideration of this 10% bonus, but not everyone did...

maybe next time we play this, the bonus should only be +5%?

anyway... too late for that, for now... though it was also fairly close, another vote for e.g., Brin would have eliminated XS...

with Reboot Brainy also leaving, there are no more Legionnaires with doppelgangers/versions on the list!

thanks for voting all, Round 11 is coming up after the break (pretty much immediately)!

Round 11 begins!

I promised a second chance, so here we go...

For the 20 Legionnaires we eliminated in the last 3 rounds, they do have one last chance to progress in this game...

Simply vote YES or NO for each of them!

If any Legionnaire gets 75% YES votes, they will make it back into the game! (that would be 6 of 8 voters, 7 of 9 voters, or 8 of 10).

I will post the list of contestants twice - the first is to list the Legionnaires, and a reminder re which Round they were eliminated --

the second list only has the Legionnaires' names, please use that one to copy-paste the list/wording exactly, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work smile

List with round information and round eliminated, for decision-making reference!

(5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 8
(5YL) Laurel Gand - Round 8
(Dead Earth) Wildfire - Round 9
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - Round 10
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - Round 8
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - Round 9
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - Round 8
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - Round 8
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - Round 10
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - Round 10
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - Round 10
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy - Round 8
(Reboot) Gear - Round 9
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 10
(Reboot) Live Wire - Round 8
(Reboot) Monstress - Round 8
(Reboot) Shikari - Round 8
(Reboot) Triad - Round 9
(Reboot) Umbra - Round 8
(Threeboot) Theena - Round 9

Hope that's not too hard to read... don't worry, there is an easier list below!!!

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Please use this list for copy-pasting your voting! Round 10 list!

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra
(Threeboot) Theena

Round ends on February 11th, Sunday - I will try to end it before my lunch, but if not possible it will have to be late in the evening.

Some insight into how resurrection rounds played out in previous Idol games:

Postboot Legion Idol: (only one resurrection round)

Leviathan returned, placing 13th
Element Lad, placing 16th

Preboot Legion Idol: (only one resurrection round)

Chemical King, finished 4th
Nightwind, 7th
Colossal Boy, 8th
Matter-Eater Lad, 9th
Spider-Girl, 11th
and Triplicate Girl/Duo Damsel (Again?!), 18th

First Multiverse Legion Idol: (also two resurrection rounds)

Retroboot Tyroc returned in the final resurrection round, and ended up placing 7th.

For the 1st Resurrection Round, the following returned:

(Preboot) Saturn Girl, placing 2nd
Reboot Gates, placing 4th
(SW6) Dragonmage, placing 8th
Reboot Lyle, placing 9th
Reboot Live Wire, 10th
Reboot Umbra, 12th
(Preboot) Shadow Lass, placing 16th
SW6 Andromeda, 19th
Reboot Saturn Girl, placing 23rd

Titans Idol: (also two resurrection rounds)

Flamebird made it back in the final resurrection round, and went on to win 2nd place: rising like the phoenix, indeed!

For the 1st Resurrection Round, the following returned:

Blue Beetle (Jaime Reyes), finished 9th
Miss Martian, finished 14th
Golden Eagle, finished 17th
Animated Beast Boy, finished 22nd

JLA Idol:

nobody returned in the 2nd resurrection round.

For the 1st Resurrection Round, the following returned:

Elongated Man, 5th
Wonder Woman (Diana), 16th
Blue Beetle (Ted), 17th
Doctor Light (Kimiyo), 24th

JSA Idol: (also two resurrection rounds)

nobody returned in the 2nd resurrection round.

For the 1st Resurrection Round, the following returned:

Earth-2 Robin, finished 6th
Spectre (Jim Corrigan), finished 12th
Stargirl, finished 14th

as we can see, characters coming back can place quite highly (just look at Mutliverse Legion Idol with Preboot Imra, and Titans Idol with Flamebird!)

maybe that's why, in JLA and JSA Idol, nobody came back in the final res. round?

as I said above - returning characters can place quite highly, and at the expense of other characters. So I'll be picky-ish with my list...

YES

(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra

NO

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Threeboot) Theena

YES!:
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf

other yeses:
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Reboot) Gear
(Threeboot) Theena

No:
(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra

And what do you have against my faves IBBY?

aw shucks IDLE! nothing against your faves... I just don't want them to win over my faves on the list

(which I think is the case with your faves versus mine, too!

)

YES:
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra

NO:
(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Threeboot) Theena

YES

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra
(Threeboot) Theena

NO

Earth-Man (I know he's not on the list, but I'm voting against him in principle, to make sure he definitely stays gone!)

I'm feeling the love from Nighty

(for certain realities, anyway!)

and I wish I could just purge Earth-Man's Legion membership from everywhere, EDE!

YES

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Triad
(Threeboot) Theena

NO

(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Umbra

With already three No votes for the 5YL couple it seems their fate is doomed (unless we suddenly get a few more 5YL fans joining the game).
Both Wildfire and Theena are still possible - just.

Bouncing Boy and Karate Kid also have 3 Nos so far

TBH I'm pleasantly surprised by all the YESes flying around!

Yes

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Threeboot) Theena

No

(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra

a very clean divide among the realities there, thothy

Sheer coincidence.

Right now we're 6 votes in... I see Gaseous Lad and Reboot have checked in recently, but Set hasn't been online since Jan.31, and Lardy since Feb.1, so...

I expect we'll get 8 voters this round. there's a fairly good chance we'll get multiple Legionnaires coming back to the game, if so!

PS I have Lardy on Facebook and he seems fine. I hope Set is too!

Was traveling this week - vote coming up shortly!

YES

(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra
(Threeboot) Theena

NO
(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Reboot) Shikari
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf

YES
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra
(Threeboot) Theena

NO
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Live Wire
(5YL) Brainiac 5

Feels weird to vote NO to any Legionnaire, but hey, gardeners gotta prune even the roses...

Nice! So we’re 8 voters in now!

Assuming only Reboot votes too, I think we will get 5 returning Legionnaires…

YES

(Dead Earth) Wildfire
(Reboot) Brainiac 5
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Live Wire
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shikari
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) Umbra

NO

(5YL) Brainiac 5
(5YL) Laurel Gand
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Tellus
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
(Threeboot) Theena

I’m off to visit grandma and the in-laws, so round will end tonight my time

ending the round now!

Bah. Just off to bed. One day I'll be an early voter. Hope you enjoyed your visit, Ibby.

Round 11 Results!

20 Legionnaires went through a gauntlet of 9 voters... 75% (or 6.75 rounded up to 7) had to say YES for a Legionnaire to return to the game!

So who made it?

listing the Legionnaire, the round they were originally eliminated in, and their results...

(5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 8 - 3 ( 33% )
(5YL) Laurel Gand - Round 8 - 3 ( 33% )
(Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy - Round 10 - 4 ( 44% )
(Pre-5YL) Karate Kid - Round 8 - 4 ( 44% )
(Dead Earth) Wildfire - Round 9 - 5 ( 56% )
(Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl - Round 9 - 5 ( 56% )
(Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf - Round 10 - 5 ( 56% )
(Reboot) Shikari - Round 8 - 5 ( 56% )
(Pre-5YL) Polar Boy - Round 8 - 6 ( 67% )
(Pre-5YL) Tellus - Round 10 - 6 ( 67% )
(Reboot) Brainiac 5 - Round 10 - 6 ( 67% )
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy - Round 8 - 6 ( 67% )
(Reboot) Live Wire - Round 8 - 6 ( 67% )
(Reboot) Umbra - Round 8 - 6 ( 67% )
(Threeboot) Theena - Round 9 - 6 ( 67% )

and these 5 Legionnaires are making it back to the game!

(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - Round 8 - 7 ( 78% )
(Reboot) Gear - Round 9 - 7 ( 78% )
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 10 - 7 ( 78% )
(Reboot) Monstress - Round 8 - 7 ( 78% )
(Reboot) Triad - Round 9 - 7 ( 78% )

This sure is unprecedented! As I recapped here, we've had 4 Idol games with such a resurrection round before (the Yes/No voting). and we've only had, at most, 1 making it back in (2 games had 1, 2 games had none!) and now we have 5!

4 from the Reboot, one from pre-5YL.

Thanks all for voting - Round 12 will kick off soon!

Round 12 begins!

From 15, let's get down to 10 once again, so 5 will go home.

Please vote for your top 5!

With no more bonus points for Round 5 winners, I've tweaked the points system a bit to give fewer points for Ranks 1-5.

1 - 100
2 - 50
3 - 30
4 - 15
5 - 5

I will post the list of contestants twice - the first is to list the Legionnaires, and a reminder re which Round they made it back in -

the second list only has the Legionnaires' names, please use that one to copy-paste the list/wording exactly, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

List with round information, for decision-making reference!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - Round 8 eliminated (Round 11 returnee)
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 resurrection winner
(Reboot) Gates - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Reboot) Gear - Round 9 eliminated (Round 11 returnee)
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 10 eliminated (Round 11 returnee)
(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Reboot) Monstress - Round 8 eliminated (Round 11 returnee)
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Reboot) Spark - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Reboot) Triad - Round 9 eliminated (Round 11 returnee)
(Reboot) XS - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus

Hope that's not too hard to read... don't worry, there is an easier list below!!!

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Pre-5YL
Reboot

Please use this list for copy-pasting your voting! Round 12 list!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Triad
(Reboot) XS

Round ends around this time on February 14th, Wednesday - luckily, Mr. Ibby and I don't really celebrate Valentines' Day, so...

what's coming up:

This Round: from 15 to 10.
Round 13: from 10 to 7.
Round 14: from 7 to 5.
Round 15: from 5 to 3
Round 16: choosing a winner!

Some observations while I'm thinking about my votes...

Luornu is the only Legionnaire with more than 1 version left on the list!

Brainy and Kara are the only romantic couple represented...

while Vi/Zoe is the only best friend pair!

the list is heavily weighted towards the Reboot, which was boosted by last round's resurrections! 2/3 of the list are Reboot Legionnaires! will that come back to bite their fans though, considering they might split the votes?

2/3 of the list are females!

6/15 (2/5 or 40%) of the list are "single-reality" Legionnaires with no/few counterparts: Gates, Gear, Kid Q II, Kinetix, Monstress and XS!

Imra is the only founder on the list!

voting time: I've narrowed my list down to 6, and I'm really torn.

First 4 slots go to Legionnaires I can really relate to -

Kinetix, feeling useless and wanting power
Gates, with his opinions and thoughts ignored
Monstress, shunned for being different, and trying so hard not to show it
Vi, feeling ignored and overshadowed

so does my 5th go to XS, who worked through her fear to become a brave hero? or Kid Q II, the angry upstart who grew to become a leader?

well..

(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Monstress
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) XS

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5

(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

Also forgot to remark: Gear has returned to the game twice now! In round 7 and in round 11

Well, only one of my top faves still in so
1. (Reboot) Kinetix
and for the rest
2. (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
3. (Reboot) Gates
4. (Reboot) Gear
5. (Reboot) XS

Wow! I'm surprised Theena didn't make it back in!

(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Monstress
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl

Tough cuts this round for me. I think I would have cut Tenz, but I keep him in honor of our dearly departed MLLASH. 5YL Tenz is the character I most associate with him, so cutting him would be like cutting Lash. All were difficult, but the first three out were Gear, Gates & LeVIathon. Last and hardest cut was Imra.

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Triad

Originally Posted by idle

Well, only one of my top faves still in so

I sympathize, Idle, sorry there aren't more.

Originally Posted by Gaseous Lad

Wow! I'm surprised Theena didn't make it back in!

she was very close... TBH I voted NO to Theena not because I don't like her exactly, I just wasn't willing to have her win over someone else I liked more

Originally Posted by Lard Lad

Tough cuts this round for me. I think I would have cut Tenz, but I keep him in honor of our dearly departed MLLASH. 5YL Tenz is the character I most associate with him, so cutting him would be like cutting Lash. All were difficult, but the first three out were Gear, Gates & LeVIathon. Last and hardest cut was Imra.

d

great reason to vote for Tenz, Lardy! and thanks for sharing some of your other faves that didn't make the cut!

(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Gear
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl

1 - (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
2 - (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
3 - (Reboot) Monstress
4 - (Reboot) Gates
5 - (Reboot) Invisible Kid

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
A story of sacrifice, and of unrequited love. Better still was Luornu's decision to not let those feelings dominate the rest of her life (and story), moving on to find a stronger love and sense of purpose. Also cool powers and an example of a team with early, strong female characters.

(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
No wonder Levitz wanted Supergirl to be Sensor Girl. He was writing her really well in that run, in the GDS (nabbed for Crisis) and in a little run of issues than ended in her final return to our time. If you go with the Brainy colouring continuity, she was there before Superboy. The romance with Brainy has twists and turns and she's just a more proactive, fun Kryptonian.

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
An example of a character who was really boosted by the TMK run. A humorous counterpoint to the dark galaxy he travelled around. I think I first saw him in a team poster and probably wondered what on Earth they were thinking. But Tenz is a mover and shaker. A politician with connections and a great sense of how to live the fullest of lives. And, of course, Lash (as Lardy pointed out)

(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
Key to so many Legion stories and the team. The epitome of intelligence and application. But written so that this comes with flaws and cautionary tales from Omega to Supergirl robots. All this gave a lot of depth to Querl, the longer the series went on, from his reaction to Universo's mind tampering to his reasons for the Conspiracy that led to a number of departures.

(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
Arguably the team's best leader, whose powers made her every bit as powerful as any Daxamite or Kryptonian. A founder who was every bit as active as the others, which wasn’t common at all in those days. Her willingness to sacrifice herself for Garth and her victory over Universo two of many fine moments for Imra.

A little sad that Bouncing Boy didn;t make it back in. He's a character I grew to appreciate more and more with each reread and access to the older issues. I think he meant a lot to readers for a lot of reasons. Everything from self identity, through unrequited love, finding a place and better yet, building on that to find happiness and a good life. Oh, and he was a bit of a tactical genius on the sly, and then there's that Hunter issue.

Beautiful tributes, thothy

re Chuck, I like all iterations. though my fave would be taking the Reboot Chuck's personality and giving him the Pre-5YL powers!

Thanks Ibby. I liked your views on your picks too.
What was Reboot Chuck's personality?

(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Gear
(Reboot) Triad

Originally Posted by thoth lad

Thanks Ibby. I liked your views on your picks too.
What was Reboot Chuck's personality?

thanks, thothy!

Reboot Chuck's very first appearance, some Legionnaires were complaining about how their lives reeked. And Gates was going on about them being a teenage death squad. Chuck flat out said nobody on Earth would even be alive without the Legion, and how proud he was to be there.

Not dissimilar from pre5YL Chuck, just - in my opinion - a bit more earnest. And I'm a sucker for the underdog-types generally; Reboot Chuck not having powers, but standing by the team anyway, endeared him to me.

also, we have all the usual voters in, so I'm closing round 12 now!

Round 12 Results!

From 15, we're going down to 10... who made it?

spoiler: no ties this time, and a pretty big gap separates the top 10 from the bottom 5!

Results are in this format: Legionnaire - how they made it to Round 12 - Round 12 points (number of voters this round). I thought these two bits would be interesting info.

Moving on as our Top 10:

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 280 ( 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 returnee - 220 ( 5 )
(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 200 ( 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 170 ( 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 170 ( 4 )
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 10 eliminated (Round 11 returnee) 150 ( 2 )
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 150 ( 4 )
(Reboot) Gates - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 145 ( 4 )
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 130 ( 3 )
(Reboot) Spark - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 130 ( 2 )

and going home this round...

(Reboot) Gear - Round 9 eliminated (Round 7, Round 11 returnee) 80 ( 3)
(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl - Round 8 eliminated (Round 11 returnee) 80 ( 5)
(Reboot) Monstress - Round 8 eliminated (Round 11 returnee) 75 ( 3)
(Reboot) XS - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 10 ( 2)
(Reboot) Triad - Round 9 eliminated (Round 11 returnee) 10 ( 2)

We lose 4/5 of the Legionnaires who came back Round 11... perhaps a sign that that +10% bonus mechanic may not have changed things around so much, in the long run?

We lose our first Round 5 winner as well, in XS!
so basically, we lose everyone who made it back in Round 11, except Kid Q II stays while XS goes!

Our Top 10 is made up of 8 Legionnaires from Round 5, a Round 7 returnee, and a Round 11 returnee!

Interestingly, Imra was on 5 different lists, but still didn't make it to safety - her highest place was a Rank 2 vote, and on 3/5 of lists she was rank 5th. Not enough to cover lost ground.

Conversely, Kinetix was on only 2 lists, but was Rank 1 on both, letting her make it to 3rd place.

and of course, Tenzil looks to be the juggernaut of this round - on 4 lists (has the numbers), with two of those being Rank 1 and another as Rank 2.

Our top 10 composition is now:

6 Reboot, 3 pre 5YL, 1 5YL (basically same a in Round 5, except we drop Tellus and XS, for pre5YL Luornu and Kid Q II)

We have 6 females, 3 males (4 if you count Gates as male)

and with Triad gone, nobody has more than 1 version.

thanks all for voting - Round 13 will be up soon!

I also thought I'd go back and share the Legionnaire, per round, who was on the most number of lists. We started the rankings in Round 3.

Round 3 - appearing on 5/8 lists:

(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) XS

(all are gone now!)

Round 4 - appearing on 5/8 lists:

(Pre-5YL) Dawnstar (again!)

Round 5 - appearing on 5/9 lists:

(Reboot) XS

Round 6 - appearing on 6/9 lists

(Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl

Round 7 - first resurrection Round - appearing on 4/9 lists

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Cosmic Boy
(Reboot) Gear

Round 8 - appearing on 6/9 lists

(Reboot) XS

Round 9 - appearing on 7/10 lists (!)

(Reboot) Gates

Round 10 - appearing on 4/10 lists

(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) XS

Round 11 was our second resurrection Round

as the lists get shorter, in some ways our tastes are beginning to diverge! the peak was appearing on 7/10 lists... what will happen next?

Round 13 begins!

From 10, let's get down to 7, so 3 will go home.

Please vote for your top 4!

With no more bonus points for Round 5 winners, I've tweaked the points system a bit to give fewer points overall.

1 - 90
2 - 45
3 - 20
4 - 5

I will post the list of contestants twice - the first is to list the Legionnaires, and a reminder re which Round they made it back in -

the second list only has the Legionnaires' names, please use that one to copy-paste the list/wording exactly, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

List with round information, for decision-making reference!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 returnee
(Reboot) Gates - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 10 eliminated (Round 11 returnee)
(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus
(Reboot) Spark - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus

Hope that's not too hard to read... don't worry, there is an easier list below!!!

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list - you can use this to search (Ctrl+F) the list of Legionnaires, too! (and if you have questions on the realities, please let me know!)

5YL
Pre-5YL
Reboot

Please use this list for copy-pasting your voting! Round 13 list!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark

Round ends around this time on February 17th, Saturday - I will aim to end it in the afternoon, as I have evening plans.

what's coming up:

This Round: from 10 to 7.
Round 14: from 7 to 5.
Round 15: from 5 to 3
Round 16: choosing a winner!

(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II

(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Gates

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5

1. (Reboot) Kinetix
2. (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
3. (Reboot) Gates
4. (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5

(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Gates

(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5

votes coming in hard and fast! are you all finding it easier, now that we have a shorter list?

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

votes coming in hard and fast! are you all finding it easier, now that we have a shorter list?

Nah, they were just trying to get in ahead of the PHPocalypse

Actually, with that in mind...

(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Gates
(Reboot) Invisible Kid
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II

always wise to get the votes in "in time"

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

votes coming in hard and fast! are you all finding it easier, now that we have a shorter list?

Pretty easy when one person from your list is cut, and then you have one less vote!

a good problem to have

(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II

(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad

and we are now 9 voters in, of our usual 10! as of now, the points are quite close...

I'll leave this open until tomorrow, this time, to give Lardy a chance to vote.

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Reboot) Invisible Kid

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

I'll leave this open until tomorrow, this time, to give Lardy a chance to vote.

Thanks!!!

sure

closing the round now!

Round 13 Results!

From 10, we're going down to 7... who made it?

Spoiler: this time, we're going to break a tie!!!

Results are in this format: Legionnaire - how they made it to Round 12 - Round 12 points - past round points (for the tie-breaker) - and (number of voters this round)

Moving on as our Top 7: the Pre-5YL and 5YL are dominating!

The first 5 of our Top 7:

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 230 - 4754 ( 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 220 - 4193 ( 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 195 - 4112 ( 6 )
(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 180 - 6194 ( 2 )
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 returnee - 150 - 6375 ( 5 )

gotta say, I'm slightly surprised Luornu is not dominating as usual! she's still got the numbers re voters, though.

then we have a 3-way tie for the last two slots, meaning one of these must go home.

(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 10 eliminated (Round 11 returnee) - 135 - 4401 ( 4 )
(Reboot) Spark - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 135 - 3795 ( 2 )
(Reboot) Invisible Kid - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 135 - 2677 ( 4 )

Lyle has the fewest previous round votes, so he gets the boot. Jazmin and Ayla live to fight another round.

and finally, bringing up the rear...

(Reboot) Gates - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 120 - 4774 ( 5 )
(Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 100 - 4562 ( 3 )

A dark day for the Reboot contingent, as we lose 3 more... leaving 3 on the list. not bad though, with 1 5YL, 3 Pre-5YL, and 3 Reboot Legionnaires left in our top 7.

This round also shows again, how fewer voters giving more points, is better than more voters giving fewer points (compre Kinetix and Spark with 2 voters each, vs. Gates with 5 voters or Lyle with 4)

We still have 2 Wild Cards in the game as well: Luornu and Jazmin, both of whom returned in resurrection rounds!

With most voters losing 1-2 of the picks on their list, I think we'll be seeing a lot of vote convergence next round! it's gonna be interesting!

Round 14 begins!

From 7, let's get down to 5 - bottom 2 go home.

Please vote for your top 3!

With no more bonus points for Round 5 winners, I've tweaked the points system a bit to give fewer points overall.

1 - 50
2 - 20
3 - 5

I will post the list of contestants twice - the first is to list the Legionnaires, a reminder re which Round they made it back in - and now, increasingly relevant info, the cumulative points they have (which will be used to break ties).

the second list only has the Legionnaires' names, please use that one to copy-paste the list/wording exactly, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

List with round information, for decision-making reference!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 4984
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 4307
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 4413
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 returnee - 6525
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 10 eliminated (Round 11 returnee) - 4536
(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 6374
(Reboot) Spark - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 3930

Hope that's not too hard to read... don't worry, there is an easier list below!!!

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list

5YL
Pre-5YL
Reboot

Please use this list for copy-pasting your voting! Round 14 list!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Spark

Round ends towards the end of my day on Wednesday, February 21st - I will aim to end it in the evening, after dinner.

what's coming up:

This Round: from 7 to 5.
Round 15: from 5 to 3
Round 16: choosing a winner!

I liked all the Legionnaires eliminated last round, and Vi and Gates hit the hardest. Top 10 is a great finish, though.

Gates was so opinionated, had so many one-liners, but was so naive in so many ways... he often genuinely didn't realize how upsetting he could be. Which was funny, as he was often quick to call others out on their behavior.

And dear sweet Vi, who grew from a painfully shy (yet fiery, awesome fighter!) to a confident leader-type, becoming a great foil for the blustery Kinetix.

with only 7 Legionnaires left, it's getting tight - and I think we're all going to have to think really carefully about which ones we really want to keep in the game!

I like all 3 below, but I have one clear fave...

(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II

Glad that all 3 ladies made it so far, though. Fingers crossed they can continue on...

I like how Ayla had a temper, but could admit she was wrong.
Jaz was a good leader, and I like her powers.
And of course, Zoe. She was generally kind and nice, but cross her and you'd get a tongue-lashing! And definitely one of the power-sets I'd most love to have in real life!

(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5

I was leery of voting for Brainy, but then remembered that pre-5YL Brainy, apart from Superboy's Legion and Legion cartoon Brainy, is pretty much 'peak Brainy' for me, not the Vril Dox wannabe he turned into in the Threeboot, a Machiavellian short-fused jerk characterization he's been kind of pushed into, in later years. He still had some likable qualities back before 5YL and was a character I admired, for having the 'super-power' of *being really smart,* in a genre where 'super-powers' generally meant shoot zaps and punch through walls.

One thing that always appealed to me about the Legion as a kid and teen is that they had a lot of positive role models, IMO. A dude whose super-power is 'really smart' (Brainy), a super-hero who is overweight (Bouncing Boy) and someone who got onto a team limited to those with powers only despite having no powers at all *because he tried really hard* (Karate Kid). All cool positive role-models, to me.

A+, totally agree, Set.

Early Brainy was great - smart, but still good-natured and chummy. you could tell he was smart, but he didn't lord it over others.

late Reboot/DNA Brainy had this again (where early Reboot Brainy was rather arrogant). but late Reboot Brainy also got that internalized forcefield - didn't take away from his intelligence, but it is a bit different from "just" being super-smart.

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl

1. (Reboot) Kinetix
2. (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
3. (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5

This is easy now.

(Reboot) Kinetix
(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

And of course, Zoe. She was generally kind and nice, but cross her and you'd get a tongue-lashing!

Which Vi especially liked.

Yeah. That just happened.

(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

Originally Posted by Gaseous Lad

This is easy now.

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

And of course, Zoe. She was generally kind and nice, but cross her and you'd get a tongue-lashing!

Which Vi especially liked.

Yeah. That just happened.

having fewer faves left DOES help with the choosing and ranking, eh

behave, you

but yeah, go Zoe and Ayla (and Jaz)! keep going, for Vi!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl

I think it's amazing that Querl and Kara, the star-crossed couple, have made it so far! I think of that Crisis Crossover issue with Brainy mourning Kara's death, and it just makes me feel they should have been together. Very platonic and doomed from the start..but aren't those the best ones in literature?.

And depending on future results, there may come a time that I have to leave Tenzil off--but not TODAY, y'all!!!

Hey, we're just picking three and not putting them in first, second and third, are we?

(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5

Originally Posted by Lard Lad

Hey, we're just picking three and not putting them in first, second and third, are we?

we're ranking them, Lardy! First place gets more points! so as of now, I would assume you're ranking Tenzil first, Brainy 2nd, Kara 3rd! and they get points accordingly!

Originally Posted by Lard Lad

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl

!

points will be given as follows

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Round 14 begins!

From 7, let's get down to 5 - bottom 2 go home.

Please vote for your top 3!

With no more bonus points for Round 5 winners, I've tweaked the points system a bit to give fewer points overall.

1 - 50
2 - 20
3 - 5

Originally Posted by Lard Lad

I think it's amazing that Querl and Kara, the star-crossed couple, have made it so far! I think of that Crisis Crossover issue with Brainy mourning Kara's death, and it just makes me feel they should have been together. Very platonic and doomed from the start..but aren't those the best ones in literature?.

quite the romance there! loved the dynamic, with Brainy being the brains, Kara being super powerful, but both being very competent AND respecting each other

in some realities at least, they get their happy ending...

(Reboot) Spark
(Reboot) Kid Quantum II
(Reboot) Kinetix

votes coming in early! we have 9/10 now. as soon as Thoth votes, I can close the round

(no pressure, thoth!

)

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5

with all votes in, let's close the round - I have a busy couple of weeks coming up, so it will help if I can end the game earlier.

I do acknowledge that Lardy may not have understood the ranking & points, but if I were Lardy, I also would not be changing my votes now...

for that matter, I think any changing of votes from now on would be controversial at best, as we're almost at the end!

Round 14 Results!

From 7, we lose 2 to get to 5. Who made it?

Spoiler: again, we're going to break a tie!!!

Results are in this format: Legionnaire - how they made it to Round 14 - Round 14 points - past round points (for the tie-breaker) - and (number of voters this round)

The first 4 of our Top 5 are:

(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 155 - 6374 ( 4 )
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 120 - 4984 ( 3 )
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 returnee - 115 - 6525 ( 5 )
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 100 - 4413 ( 5 )

Zoe was buoyed by 3 first place votes this round! Tenzil also had 2 first place votes, while Kara and Luornu only had one each.

And we need to break the tie for 5th place. Taking past round votes into account:

(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 90 - 4307 ( 6 )
(Reboot) Spark - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 90 - 3930 ( 3 )

Querl beats Ayla by 300+ points... so Querl stays in the game!

Bringing up the rear is:

(Reboot) Kid Quantum II - Round 10 eliminated (Round 11 returnee) - 80 - 4536 ( 4 )

Querl, Jaz and Ayla each had one 1st place vote each, but Querl's larger number of voters allowed him to beat Jaz and tie with Ayla.

We lose two more from the Reboot, leaving Zoe as the sole Reboot rep.

We also lose another Wild Card in Jaz, leaving Luornu as the sole remaining resurrected Legionnaire on the list.

and 6 of 10 voters did not lose any of the Legionnaires on their list - so I'm curious to see how things will shuffle next round!

Round 15 begins!

From 5, let's get down to 3 - bottom 2 go home, top 3 head to the finals!

Please vote for your top 2! Points are given as follows:

Rank

1 - 10
2 - 5

I will post the list of contestants twice - the first is to list the Legionnaires, a reminder re which Round they made it back in - and now, increasingly relevant info, the cumulative points they have (which will be used to break ties).

the second list only has the Legionnaires' names, please use that one to copy-paste the list/wording exactly, parentheses and spaces and all, this will make it a) easier to identify which version, b) it will make my Excel lookups work

List with round information, for decision-making reference!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 5104
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 4397
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 4513
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 returnee - 6640
(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 6529

Hope that's not too hard to read... don't worry, there is an easier list below!!!

House Rules

1) Each round will last about 72 hours (unless everyone votes earlier than that!)
2) I'll vote at or near the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) While I don't encourage changing of votes, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, he or she will get a makeup vote next round - +15 points to give a Legionnaire of their choosing (only applicable once we do ranking; for rounds before, will do something else).
5) In case of a tie, I will look at cumulative points through past rounds to break the tie.

Realities remaining on the list

5YL
Pre-5YL
Reboot

Please use this list for copy-pasting your voting! Round 15 list!

(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Kinetix

Round ends towards the end of my day on Thursday, February 22nd - I will aim to end it in the evening, after dinner. But if everyone votes sooner... I'll end it sooner!

what's coming up:

This Round: from 5 to 3
Round 16: choosing a winner!

Ok, with all my top faves except Zoe gone, I have to pick someone else to vote. If either Ayla or Jazmin had made it, they'd be getting my 2nd place votes. But...

all are worthy, IMO. they've all had their great moments.

in terms of sheer contribution to the Legion though, it has to be between pre-5YL Brainy (enough said), but Supergirl is part of the Legend that started it all, so...

(Reboot) Kinetix
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl

1. (Reboot) Kinetix
2. (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad

(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

Querl, Jaz and Ayla each had one 1st place vote each, but Querl's larger number of voters allowed him to beat Jaz and tie with Ayla.

We lose two more from the Reboot, leaving Zoe as the sole Reboot rep.

Aw, not Ayla! Now we only have Zoe to deliver the tongue lashings!

1. (Reboot) Kinetix
2. (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

Wow. Querl only just pulled through by the green skin of his teeth (not his teeth that are green but his skin - you know what I mean - who has skin on their teeth anyway?).
Judging by the votes so far his chances for the finals are not great. Still ...

(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl

(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5

Okay, I understand they are ranked, now. Lucky all my picks went through last time! I'll stick with the star-crossed lovers and leave Tenz's fate to others.

Originally Posted by Gaseous Lad

Aw, not Ayla! Now we only have Zoe to deliver the tongue lashings!

I'm looking at a pic of her with her tongue out! Jeff Moy always drew such an awesome Ayla!

Originally Posted by Lard Lad

Okay, I understand they are ranked, now. Lucky all my picks went through last time! I'll stick with the star-crossed lovers and leave Tenz's fate to others.

yeah, I figured you wouldn't have an incentive to change your vote last round, anyhow

Originally Posted by stile86

Wow. Querl only just pulled through by the green skin of his teeth (not his teeth that are green but his skin - you know what I mean - who has skin on their teeth anyway?).
Judging by the votes so far his chances for the finals are not great. Still ...

we could always get surprised

Still 4 voters haven't checked in! Oh, the suspense!!

I wonder if everyone else is still thinking of their votes... we're so close to the end, after all

Well, my top two favorite Legionnaires have made it this far, but do I keep them in the same order?

Another day I might reverse them, but today I'm sticking with:

1. (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
2. (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

votes are spread super evenly so far! I'm on the edge of my seat!

it's been - and is being - an incredibly busy and exhausting week at work, so I'll plan to close this round tomorrow, Friday, instead (to give everyone else a chance to vote - we're only 7 of 10 regular voters so far)

just a heads up, I've been working until almost midnight the last two days, so I'm looking to go to bed early tonight. I will close this round, whatever happens, around my dinner time.

(Reboot) Kinetix

thanks Reboot - I will count that as a Rank 1 vote, and assume you don't have a Rank 2 vote (unless you change your vote before I begin tallying)

Not far from home. Will vote as soon as I'm in.

In and looking...

Oh crumbs, this is a tough one...

Nope, I'm going to stick with my original thought on this round. I could have picked any combination.

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5

and... tallying now!

Just peeking back. This could be interesting.

Round 15 Results!

Our Top 5 becomes a Top 3. Who makes it to the finals?

Spoiler: no ties this time!!!

Results are in this format: Legionnaire - how they made it to Round 15 - Round 15 points - and (number of voters this round)

That's a very smooth progression of votes there...

(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 40 ( 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 30 ( 4 )
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel - Round 7 returnee - 25 ( 4 )

We have an all-female finale, folks! And each of the 3 had numbers too, with 4/9 voters each!

We say goodbye to:

(Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5 - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 20 ( 3 )
(5YL) Matter-Eater Lad - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 15 ( 2 )

I actually thought for a while that Tenzil would make it to the finale - though even if he had gotten another rank 1 vote, he would merely have tied with Luornu - and she would have beat him with previous round points.

The 5YL makes a graceful exit, in our second to the last round.

Final Round begins in a minute!

FINAL ROUND!

no more ranking, just vote. There can only be one winner.

Pick one from the top 3 to be our ultimate Legion Idol!

(Pre-5YL) Supergirl
(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
(Reboot) Kinetix

This round closes some time on SUNDAY (so I can start the week fresh, it's gonna be a tough work week for me!)

Well, Luornu definitely did not waste her second chance - she's been scoring high ever since coming back to the game!

as for Zoe, she's holding the Reboot flag up high - with other Reboot Legionnaires all gone, she's the last rep of her era.

And Kara, what can we say... she's part of the legend (I like to think that she and Kal together inspired the Legion, and not just Kal)

Well, I've only been consistently ranking her #1 (except for one round) this game, so...

(Pre-5YL) Supergirl

I'd have loved Tenzil to make it to the final. He was key to the tone of a portion of the TMK run.

I'm suprised that Brainy didn't make it. Another one I'd have happily thought about voting for in the final. Such a key member of the team going all the way back, sharing in their triumphs and tragedies (sometimes caused by him)

At the very start of this, I wondered which character would be meeting Kinetix in the final. And here we are. In my head I thought it was going to go down to 2 (not remembering/ looking at previous versions). It could be that Zoe does well with the reboot era vote, with others split between Kara and Lu.

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

We have an all-female finale, folks! And each of the 3 had numbers too, with 4/9 voters each!

That is so cool!!

And my vote - (no surprise)

Kinetix!

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

Originally Posted by thoth lad

I'm suprised that Brainy didn't make it. Another one I'd have happily thought about voting for in the final. Such a key member of the team going all the way back, sharing in their triumphs and tragedies (sometimes caused by him).

I thought Brainy and Kara would be battling it out for the 3rd spot, but Kara leapfrogged over Lu, even. (Well, partly because of me)

Originally Posted by thoth lad

I
At the very start of this, I wondered which character would be meeting Kinetix in the final.

was it so pre-ordained?

TBH, without Idle also voting for Zoe for a lot of the middle rounds, I don't know if Zoe would be here today. (though maybe GL would have voted for Zoe instead)

Kara!

(Reboot) Kinetix

Hi.

(Reboot) Kinetix

Ah well. Bye Brainy. To be honest I hadn't expected him to last this long. Interesting seeing Tenzil go as well with the huge support he has had in previous rounds.

Now who to vote for? Really tricky. I'll be happy with any of these winning. Kinetix is great. There is a reason she has done so well. Great to see Lu make sych a great comeback as well. But ...

(Pre-5YL) Supergirl

Originally Posted by KryptonKid

Hi.

KryptonKid! Just in time for the finale! Long time no see! what a pleasant surprise!

Originally Posted by stile86

Ah well. Bye Brainy. To be honest I hadn't expected him to last this long. Interesting seeing Tenzil go as well with the huge support he has had in previous rounds.

Now who to vote for? Really tricky. I'll be happy with any of these winning. Kinetix is great. There is a reason she has done so well. Great to see Lu make sych a great comeback as well. But ...

Brainy was a bit of a dark horse, well-deserved! I think Tenzil had a lot of lower-rank votes, plus Lardy changed up last round too

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

This shouldn't come as a surprise, but

(Reboot) Kinetix

we are now 10 votes in - missing thoth from our usual voters, but adding KryptonKid.

however, unless we get another surprise voter, it looks like the winner is decided...

our top 3 are now duking it out at 5-3-2, so even thoth's vote won't force a tie for first! thoth's vote can still decide 2nd vs. 3rd place, though.

Nearly finished working for the day. Then I shall put on my Jimmy Olsen thinking cap, from his box of hats.

I'd like to thank everyone for giving me the responsibility and honour of having a vote that's worth 5

you will be the queen-maker... for 2nd place over 3rd

(and you can also be the vote auditor, checking to see if my counting has been correct :p)

vote counting...

Zoe: Ibby, GL, Reboot, KryptonKid, idle - 5
Kara: Nighty, Lardy, stile - 3
Lu: Set, EDE, thoth - 3

I went with Lu.

KryptonKid was the dark horse vote-swinger! My preference would have been Lu. But had I tallied it up before voting, I'd have gone with Kara to have a tie.

Well, that was an interesting Finale. Not unexpected that Kinetix would retain her strong postboot following, seen throughout, while others would be split across the remaining votes. Closer than I thought it was going to be though.

Thanks for all your hard work on this Ibby. I leave it to you to officially declare....Da Winna!

thanks for counting, thothy

if we had had a tie for winner, I'd have declared a run-off round with just the top two duking it out. Assuming that were Kara, I think we'd see Kara winning over Zoe if it were 1-1...

and happy to, I had lots of fun running this game and participating it it.

but... let's officially close now...

FINALE Results:

with two Legionnaires getting 3 votes each, we have to pull in past round votes to break the tie for 2nd vs. 3rd place.

With 3 votes this round, and 4543 points from previous round, 3rd place goes to:

(Pre-5YL) Supergirl - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 3 - 4543

With 3 votes also this round, but a whopping 6665 previous-round votes, jumping into 2nd place is:

(using the DD graemlin here to fit the placing!)

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel

and finally, with 5 votes crowning her the winner, we have - our first two-time Idol Champion (yes, she also won the crown 13 years ago!)

(Reboot) Kinetix - Round 5 winner with no more +10% bonus - 5 - 6569

!!!!

a big thank you to you all, for participating - I had fun running the game, and I was genuinely surprised a couple of times! Major thanks to, in alphabetical order:

Eryk Davis Ester
Gaseous Lad
IDLE
KryptonKid
Lard Lad
Nightcrawler
Reboot
Set
stile86
Thoth Lad

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

a big thank you to you all, for participating - I had fun running the game, and I was genuinely surprised a couple of times! Major thanks to, in alphabetical order:

Eryk Davis Ester
Gaseous Lad
IDLE
KryptonKid
Lard Lad
Nightcrawler
Reboot
Set
stile86
Thoth Lad

I echo Ibby's thanks, and I thank Ibby himself for making this all possible, for drumming up awareness and enthusiasm, and for seeing it through no matter what work-related or other obstacles arose.

Sorry I was too busy to participate, but being part of the excited audience was, in its own way, almost as thrilling!

Long Live the Legion!

And here are some other special awards. After digging up some stats:

1) Most Popular: the Legionnaire who was on the most lists overall (basically: was picked by the most voters) -

XS was most voted 5 times!

Rounds 1, 2, 3, 5, and 10.

(Tying as most voted 4 times? Gates, and Pre-5YL Lu)

2) Top-Ranked: the Legionnaire who was #1 in terms of points for the most rounds -

Kinetix, who dominated in 10 rounds (including the finale). Though 2 of those were Rounds 1-2, where we just made our picks without ranking them.

5YL Tenzil had top points in 3 rounds... and Theena had top points in 1.

3) Point Hoarder: the Legionnaire who collected the most points in the game -

(Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel, who had 6668 points overall in this game. (Note: this does include points she earned in the first resurrection round, Round 7; but even if I take those points away, she's left with 5354 - still putting her ahead of Supergirl for the tie-breaker this finale).

4) The Mister Miracle award - who was our best escape artist?

Gear - the only Legionnaire to return to the game in both resurrection rounds!

5) Most Meaningful Second Chance - again, Luornu - she was eliminated in Round 6, returned in Round 7, and made it all the way to 2nd place!

Kid Quantum II didn't do too badly either, returning in Round 11 and making it to 7th place - beating 4 Legionnaires who had not been eliminated at all.

6) Doppelganger Award -

Luornu Durgo was the only Legionnaires with two versions in the top 15 - Reboot Triad also placed 15th.

While Querl Dox had no fewer than 3 versions making it to the top 30 - with the 5YL Querl placing 26th, Reboot Querl making it to 19th, and pre-5YL Querl finishing 4th.

7) Last Survivors -

From Round 9 to Round 15, Tenzil was the only representative of the 5YL era;

From Round 2 to Round 9, Wildfire was the only Dead Earth Legionnaire on the list;

and From Round 3 to Round 9, Theena was the sole Threebooter.

Originally Posted by Ann Hebistand

Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac

a big thank you to you all, for participating - I had fun running the game, and I was genuinely surprised a couple of times! Major thanks to, in alphabetical order:

Eryk Davis Ester
Gaseous Lad
IDLE
KryptonKid
Lard Lad
Nightcrawler
Reboot
Set
stile86
Thoth Lad

I echo Ibby's thanks, and I thank Ibby himself for making this all possible, for drumming up awareness and enthusiasm, and for seeing it through no matter what work-related or other obstacles arose.

Sorry I was too busy to participate, but being part of the excited audience was, in its own way, almost as thrilling!

Long Live the Legion!

what a pleasant message, Annfie, thank you! Pleased that you had fun spectating throughout!

And now, every Legionnaire in this game ever, with their final ranking!

an (*) indicates that this Legionnaire was then originally eliminated, but returned to the game later. Ranking is decided by: a) which round was the Legionnaire eliminated? b) how many points did they get that round? c) if there was a tie for points during the round, who had more previous-round points?

1 ) (Reboot) Kinetix
2 ) (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
3 ) (Pre-5YL) Supergirl
4 ) (Pre-5YL) Brainiac 5
5 ) (5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
6 ) (Reboot) Spark
7 ) (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
8 ) (Reboot) Invisible Kid
9 ) (Reboot) Gates
10 ) (Reboot) Shrinking Violet/ LeViathan II
11 ) (Reboot) Gear
12 ) (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
13 ) (Reboot) Monstress
14 ) (Reboot) XS
15 ) (Reboot) Triad

Round 11: Resurrection Round

16 ) (Pre-5YL) Timber Wolf
17 ) (Pre-5YL) Tellus
18 ) (Pre-5YL) Bouncing Boy
19 ) (Reboot) Brainiac 5
* ) (Reboot) Kid Quantum II
20 ) (Dead Earth) Wildfire
21 ) (Threeboot) Theena
22 ) (Pre-5YL) Phantom Girl
* ) (Reboot) Gear
* ) (Reboot) Triad
23 ) (Pre-5YL) Polar Boy
24 ) (Pre-5YL) Karate Kid
25 ) (5YL) Laurel Gand
26 ) (5YL) Brainiac 5
* ) (Reboot) Monstress
27 ) (Reboot) Live Wire
28 ) (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
* ) (Pre-5YL) Saturn Girl
29 ) (Reboot) Umbra
30 ) (Reboot) Shikari

Round 7: Resurrection Round

31 ) (Pre-5YL) Princess Projectra/ Sensor Girl
32 ) (5YL) Infectious Lass
33 ) (Pre-5YL) Shadow Lass
* ) (Pre-5YL) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
34 ) (Pre-5YL) Ultra Boy
35 ) (Pre-5YL) Sun Boy
36 ) (Reboot) Chameleon
* ) (5YL) Brainiac 5
37 ) (Reboot) Saturn Girl
38 ) (Pre-5YL) Shrinking Violet
39 ) (Pre-5YL) Light(ning) Lass
* ) (Reboot) Gear
40 ) (5YL) Impulse (Kent Shakespeare)
41 ) (Pre-5YL) Superboy
* ) (Reboot) Umbra
42 ) (5YL) Shrinking Violet
43 ) (Pre-5YL) Cosmic Boy
44 ) (5YL) Reflex (Devlin O'Ryan)
* ) (Reboot) Cosmic Boy
45 ) (Pre-5YL) Dawnstar
46 ) (Reboot) Andromeda
47 ) (Pre-5YL) Dream Girl
48 ) (Reboot) Sensor
49 ) (Reboot) Superboy (Kon-el)
50 ) (Reboot) M'Onel

Eliminated - Round 4

51 ) (Pre-5YL) Mon-el
52 ) (Pre-5YL) White Witch
53 ) (Pre-5YL) Krypto
54 ) (Pre-5YL) Star Boy
55 ) (Reboot) Apparition
56 ) (Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid II
57 ) (Pre-5YL) Quislet
58 ) (Pre-5YL) Tyroc
59 ) (Pre-5YL) Ferro Lad
60 ) (5YL) Veilmist
61 ) (Reboot) Ferro
62 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Brainiac 5
63 ) (Pre-5YL) Colossal Boy
64 ) (Reboot) Karate Kid
65 ) (SW6) Computo
66 ) (Reboot) Dreamer
67 ) (Reboot) Star Boy
68 ) (Reboot) Ultra Boy
69 ) (SW6) Catspaw
70 ) (Reboot) Thunder
71 ) (Reboot) Chuck Taine
72 ) (Reboot) Inferno (Sandy Anderson)
73 ) (SW6) Kid Quantum
74 ) (SW6) Dragonmage
75 ) (Superboy's Legion) Light Lass

Eliminated - Round 3

76 ) (Retroboot) Duplicate Damsel
77 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Superman
78 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Bouncing Boy
79 ) (Pre-5YL) Wildfire
80 ) (Pre-5YL) Blok
81 ) (Pre-5YL) Chameleon Boy
82 ) (Pre-5YL) Chemical King
83 ) (Pre-5YL) Element Lad
84 ) (Retroboot) Night Girl
85 ) (Pre-5YL) Lightning Lad
86 ) (Pre-5YL) Rond Vidar
87 ) (5YL) Crystal Kid
88 ) (5YL) Spider-Girl
89 ) (SW6) Andromeda
90 ) (5YL) Stone Boy
91 ) (5YL) Fire Lad
92 ) (5YL) Color Kid
92 ) (Bendisboot) Computo
92 ) (Retroboot) Chameleon Girl
93 ) (5YL) Chlorophyll Kid
93 ) (5YL) Tyroc
93 ) (5YL) White Witch
93 ) (Arthurian Legion) Cosmic Boy
93 ) (Arthurian Legion) Live Wire
93 ) (Arthurian Legion) Saturn Girl
93 ) (SW6) Alchemist

The following were eliminated in Round 2:

Getting 2 votes:

94 ) (5YL) Kono
94 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad II
94 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Nemesis Kid
94 ) (Reboot) Element Lad
94 ) (Reboot) Leviathan
94 ) (Reboot) Magno
94 ) (Reboot) Timber Wolf
94 ) (Reboot) Wildfire
95 ) (5YL) Echo
95 ) (5YL) Neon (Celeste Rockfish)
95 ) (5YL) Nightwind
95 ) (5YL) Reflecto
95 ) (5YL) Visi-Lad
95 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Brainiac 5
95 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Mxyzptlk V
95 ) (Bendisboot) Monster Boy
95 ) (Bendisboot) Saturn Girl
95 ) (Pre-5YL) Elastic Lad (Jimmy Olsen)
95 ) (Pre-5YL) Insect Queen (Lana Lang)
95 ) (Pre-5YL) Invisible Kid I
95 ) (Pre-5YL) Kid Psycho
95 ) (Pre-5YL) Matter-Eater Lad
95 ) (Pre-5YL) Proty II
95 ) (Reboot) Kid Quantum I
95 ) (Retroboot) Dragonwing
95 ) (Retroboot) Glorith
96 ) (5YL) Calamity King
96 ) (5YL) Cosmic Boy
96 ) (5YL) Karate Kid II
96 ) (5YL) Lightning Lad (Proty)
96 ) (5YL) Timber Wolf
96 ) (5YL) Ultra Boy
96 ) (5YL) Valor
96 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shadow Woman
96 ) (Arthurian Legion) Triad
96 ) (Bendisboot) Brainiac 5
96 ) (Bendisboot) Cosmic Boy
96 ) (Bendisboot) Gold Lantern
96 ) (Bendisboot) Radius Lad
96 ) (Bendisboot) Superboy (Jon)
96 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Supergirl
96 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Kinetix
96 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Lightning Lad
96 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Shrinking Violet
96 ) (Pre-5YL) Beppo
96 ) (Pre-5YL) Comet
96 ) (Pre-5YL) Nemesis Kid
96 ) (Pre-5YL) Streaky
96 ) (Retroboot) Gates
96 ) (Retroboot) Harmonia Li
96 ) (Retroboot) Lightning Lass
96 ) (Retroboot) Saturn Girl
96 ) (Retroboot) Shrinking Violet
96 ) (SW6) Valor
96 ) (Threeboot) Dream Girl
96 ) (Threeboot) Light Lass
96 ) (Threeboot) Supergirl
96 ) (Threeboot) Triplicate Girl

Getting 1 vote:

97 ) (Pre-5YL) Magnetic Kid
98 ) (5YL) Flederweb
98 ) (5YL) Invisible Kid II
98 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lex Luthor V
98 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Lightning Man
98 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Quantum Queen
98 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Saturn Woman
98 ) (Bendisboot) Lightning Lad
98 ) (Bendisboot) Lightning Lass
98 ) (SW6) Matter-Eater Lad
99 ) (5YL) Chameleon Boy
99 ) (5YL) Polar Boy
99 ) (5YL) Porcupine Pete
99 ) (5YL) Wildfire
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Cosmic Man
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Dream Woman
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duo Damsel
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Duplicate Boy
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Element Man
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ferro Lad
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Karate King
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Light Lady
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Night Woman
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Phantom Woman
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Polar Man
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Power Boy
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Reflecto
99 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Star Man
99 ) (Bendisboot) Blok
99 ) (Bendisboot) Dawnstar
99 ) (Bendisboot) Doctor Fate
99 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Dawnstar
99 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Matter-Eater Lad
99 ) (Pre-5YL) Pete Ross
99 ) (Retroboot) Comet Queen
99 ) (Retroboot) Lightning Lad
99 ) (Retroboot) Ultra Boy
99 ) (Superboy's Legion) Star Boy
99 ) (Threeboot) Atom Girl
99 ) (Threeboot) Gazelle

Getting 0 votes:

100 ) (Bendisboot) Chameleon Boy
100 ) (Bendisboot) Mon-el
100 ) (Bendisboot) Timber Wolf
100 ) (Bendisboot) Triplicate Girl
100 ) (Threeboot) Phantom Girl

And these were eliminated in Round 1:

getting 1 vote that round:

101 ) (5YL) Atmos
101 ) (5YL) Bloodclaw
101 ) (5YL) Bouncing Boy
101 ) (5YL) Bounty entity
101 ) (5YL) Colossal Boy
101 ) (5YL) Dawnstar
101 ) (5YL) Duo Damsel
101 ) (5YL) Element Lad
101 ) (5YL) Firefist
101 ) (5YL) Lightning Lass
101 ) (5YL) Mon-el
101 ) (5YL) Queen Projectra
101 ) (5YL) Rond Vidar
101 ) (5YL) Shadow Lass
101 ) (5YL) Sun Boy
101 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Cosmic Man
101 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Lightning Man
101 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Saturn Woman
101 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Sensor
101 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Umbra
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Batman
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Bouncing Man
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chameleon Man
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Chemical King
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Color King
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Colossal Man
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Matter-Eater Man
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Shrinking Violet
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Timber Wolf
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) Ultra Man
101 ) (Adult Legion (Adventure Era)) White Witch
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Alchemist
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Brainiac 5
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Chameleon
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Dragonmage
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Ferro
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Inferno
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Leviathan
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Matter-Eater Lad
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Polar Boy
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Shrinking Violet
101 ) (Arthurian Legion) Ultra Boy
101 ) (Bendisboot) Bouncing Boy
101 ) (Bendisboot) Colossal Boy
101 ) (Bendisboot) Dream Girl
101 ) (Bendisboot) Element Lad
101 ) (Bendisboot) Entropy Kid
101 ) (Bendisboot) Ferro Lad
101 ) (Bendisboot) Invisible Kid
101 ) (Bendisboot) Karate Kid
101 ) (Bendisboot) Matter-Eater Lad
101 ) (Bendisboot) Phantom Girl
101 ) (Bendisboot) Princess Projectra
101 ) (Bendisboot) Shadow Lass
101 ) (Bendisboot) Shrinking Violet
101 ) (Bendisboot) Star Boy
101 ) (Bendisboot) Sun Boy
101 ) (Bendisboot) Ultra Boy
101 ) (Bendisboot) White Witch
101 ) (Bendisboot) Wildfire
101 ) (Bendisboot) X-Ray Girl
101 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Bouncing Boy
101 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Chameleon Boy
101 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Cosmic Boy
101 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Kid Quantum
101 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Saturn Girl
101 ) (Dead Earth) Argent
101 ) (Dead Earth) Lodestone
101 ) (Dead Earth) Magno Boy
101 ) (Dead Earth) Membrain
101 ) (Dead Earth) Silverwing
101 ) (Dead Earth) Triad III
101 ) (Dead Earth) Triplicate
101 ) (Legion 1 Million) Brainiac 417
101 ) (Legion 1 Million) Cosmicbot
101 ) (Legion 1 Million) Implicate Girl
101 ) (Legion 1 Million) Superboy
101 ) (Legion 1 Million) The Chameleon
101 ) (Legion 1 Million) The Dreamer
101 ) (Legion 1 Million) The M'Onelves
101 ) (Legion 1 Million) The Umbra
101 ) (Legion 1 Million) Wildflame
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Arm-Fall-Off-Boy
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Brainiac 5
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Chemical King
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Comet Queen
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Gates
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Invisible Kid
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Kid Quantum II
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Mon-El
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Monstress
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Phantom Girl
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Shadow Lass
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Supergirl
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Superman
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Timber Wolf
101 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chameleon Boy
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chlorophyll Kid
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Colossal Boy
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dream Girl
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Infectious Lass
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Karate Kid
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Night Girl
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Phantom Girl
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Saturn Girl
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Star Boy
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Stone Boy
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Sun Boy
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Superman X
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Timber Wolf
101 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Triplicate Girl / Duo Damsel
101 ) (Pre-5YL) Dynamo Boy
101 ) (Retroboot) Black Witch
101 ) (Retroboot) Blok
101 ) (Retroboot) Bouncing Boy
101 ) (Retroboot) Brainiac 5
101 ) (Retroboot) Chameleon Boy
101 ) (Retroboot) Chemical Kid
101 ) (Retroboot) Dawnstar
101 ) (Retroboot) Earth-Man
101 ) (Retroboot) Mon-el
101 ) (Retroboot) Phantom Girl
101 ) (Retroboot) Star Boy
101 ) (Retroboot) Superman
101 ) (Retroboot) Tellus
101 ) (Retroboot) Timber Wolf
101 ) (Retroboot) Tyroc
101 ) (Retroboot) Wildfire
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Bouncing Boy
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Brainiac 5
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Chameleon Boy
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Colossal Boy
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Cosmic Boy
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Element Lad
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Ferro Lad
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Invisible Kid
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Karate Kid
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Lightning Lad
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Phantom Girl
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Saturn Girl
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Sensor
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Shadow Lass
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Shrinking Violet
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Sun Boy
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Superboy
101 ) (Superboy's Legion) Ultra Boy
101 ) (SW6) Apparition
101 ) (SW6) Brainiac 5
101 ) (SW6) Cosmic Boy
101 ) (SW6) Ferro
101 ) (SW6) Invisible Kid
101 ) (SW6) Live Wire
101 ) (SW6) Saturn Girl
101 ) (SW6) Shrinking Violet
101 ) (SW6) Triad
101 ) (SW6) Ultra Boy
101 ) (Threeboot) Chameleon
101 ) (Threeboot) Invisible Kid
101 ) (Threeboot) Karate Kid
101 ) (Threeboot) Lightning Lad
101 ) (Threeboot) Mon-el
101 ) (Threeboot) Saturn Girl
101 ) (Threeboot) Shadow Lass
101 ) (Threeboot) Sizzle
101 ) (Threeboot) Sun Boy
101 ) (Threeboot) Turtle
101 ) (Young Justice) Chameleon Boy
101 ) (Young Justice) Phantom Girl
101 ) (Young Justice) Saturn Girl

Getting zero votes:

102 ) (5YL) Dream Girl
102 ) (5YL) Saturn Girl
102 ) (5YL) Star Boy
102 ) (5YL) Storm Boy
102 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Bouncing Boy
102 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Brainiac 5
102 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Chameleon
102 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Colossal Boy
102 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Shrinking Violet
102 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Superman
102 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Ultra Boy
102 ) (Adult Legion (Action/Morrison)) Wildfire
102 ) (Arrowverse) Brainiac 5
102 ) (Arrowverse) Chameleon
102 ) (Arrowverse) Dream Girl
102 ) (Arrowverse) Karate Kid
102 ) (Arrowverse) Lightning Lass
102 ) (Arrowverse) Mon-El
102 ) (Arrowverse) Saturn Girl
102 ) (Arrowverse) Toyman
102 ) (Arthurian Legion) Andromeda
102 ) (Arthurian Legion) Computo
102 ) (Arthurian Legion) Dream Girl
102 ) (Arthurian Legion) Infectious Lass
102 ) (Arthurian Legion) Invisible Kid I
102 ) (Arthurian Legion) Invisible Kid II
102 ) (Arthurian Legion) Karate Kid I
102 ) (Arthurian Legion) Nemesis Kid
102 ) (Arthurian Legion) Spark
102 ) (Arthurian Legion) Umbra
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Andromeda
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Blok
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Brainiac 5
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Colossal Boy
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Douglas Nolan
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Dream Girl
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Ferro Lad
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Green Arrow
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Green Lantern (John Stewart)
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Light Lass
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Lightning Lad
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Phantom Girl
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Shadow Lass
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Timber Wolf
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Triad
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Ultra Boy
102 ) (DC Animated (JLU-verse)) Wildfire
102 ) (Dead Earth) Graft
102 ) (Dead Earth) Metrox
102 ) (Dead Earth) Nervosa
102 ) (Dead Earth) Phase
102 ) (Dead Earth) Shape
102 ) (Dead Earth) Shift
102 ) (JLA Trapped in Time) Dawnstar
102 ) (JLA Trapped in Time) Karate Kid
102 ) (Legion 1 Million) Titangirl
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Andromeda
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Atmos
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Blok
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Bouncing Boy
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Catspaw
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Chameleon Boy
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Color Kid
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Cosmic Boy
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Dream Girl
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Element Lad
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Ferro Lad
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Gold Lantern
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Karate Kid
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Lightning Lad
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Polar Boy
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Power Boy
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Quislet
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Saturn Girl
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Sensor Girl
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Star Boy
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Stone Boy
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Tellus
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Tyroc
102 ) (Legion Animated Movie) Wildfire
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Blok
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Chemical King
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Color Kid
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Cosmic Boy
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Dawnstar
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Element Lad
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Ferro Lad
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Invisible Kid
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Polar Boy
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Porcupine Pete
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Tyroc
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) Ultra Boy
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) White Witch
102 ) (Legion Toon (and Comic)) XS
102 ) (Pre-5YL) Anti-Lad
102 ) (Pre-5YL) Command Kid
102 ) (Retroboot) Colossal Boy
102 ) (Retroboot) Cosmic Boy
102 ) (Retroboot) Dream Girl
102 ) (Retroboot) Element Lad
102 ) (Retroboot) Invisible Kid II
102 ) (Retroboot) Karate Kid
102 ) (Retroboot) Matter-Eater Lad
102 ) (Retroboot) Polar Boy
102 ) (Retroboot) Quislet
102 ) (Retroboot) Rond Vidar
102 ) (Retroboot) Sensor Girl
102 ) (Retroboot) Shadow Lass
102 ) (Retroboot) Sun Boy
102 ) (Smallville) Brainiac 5
102 ) (Smallville) Clark Kent
102 ) (Smallville) Cosmic Boy
102 ) (Smallville) Lightning Lad
102 ) (Smallville) Saturn Girl
102 ) (SW6) Bouncing Boy
102 ) (SW6) Chameleon Boy
102 ) (SW6) Dream Girl
102 ) (SW6) Gossamer
102 ) (SW6) Inferno
102 ) (SW6) Karate Kid
102 ) (SW6) Leviathan
102 ) (SW6) Princess Projectra
102 ) (SW6) Star Boy
102 ) (Threeboot) Brainiac 5
102 ) (Threeboot) Colossal Boy/ Micro Lad
102 ) (Threeboot) Cosmic Boy
102 ) (Threeboot) Dream Boy
102 ) (Threeboot) Element Lad
102 ) (Threeboot) Night Girl
102 ) (Threeboot) Princess Projectra
102 ) (Threeboot) Star Boy
102 ) (Threeboot) Timber Wolf
102 ) (Threeboot) Ultra Boy

As for the future:

I'm thinking of making Mutliverse Legion Idol an annual thing - though I will probably shift it to start in April, when I'm much less busy at work.

As Kinetix is now a two-time winner, I'll consider having her retire as a contestant - if the set of players remains roughly the same, that might make sense? She can be the host instead

I'll write the announcements using her "voice". (to be discussed next time we actually have this game!)

Or, if there is enough interest, we could instead have Multiverse Legion Idol be every x years (2? 3?) And in the meantime, we can do Idol games for other teams: we've had Justice League, Teen Titans and Justice Society Idol. I'd be open to even doing other DC Super-teams... and even. say Avengers or X-Men, though I don't nearly have as much emotional investment in those

And for a Legion theme: I'm thinking of a mid-year (start in June?) "Legion Tryout Idol". We'd use that to choose our 25-member Legion - and the fun part is, the pool of candidates would include -

a) pretty much every eligible super-powered good guy in any Legion reality ever - think the Wanderers, Heroes of Lallor, Workforce, Mekt's Threeboot gang, the Threeboot UP Young Heroes...

b) to balance it out, each character will only have "one" entry on the list. Only one entry for Luornu Durgo, one for Querl Dox...

thoughts? requests? lemme know!

Thanks for doing this Ibby. It was fun and I wish I could have been in at the start. All of the ideas sound fun but the Tryout Idol sounds especially fun.

thanks idle, and glad you enjoyed it

as the next Idol won't be too far off, I'll be sure to PM you and all the other players of this one, when I do start it!

I'm already building the list for Tryout Idol

394 so far...

Wow! It's hard to believe it's over! This was a lot of fun! Thanks to Ibby for doing all the hard work!

Thanks heaps Ibby. This was great fun! I am amazed at the amount of work and effort you put in and look forward to future contests.

That was quite a finale, if you think about it! Not only an all-female group but, arguably, three who were deemed expendable Legionnaires.

Kara was never featured in the Legion to the extent of her super-cousin. She's ultimately sacrificed as the big, emotional death (along with Barry) Allen of COIE.

Lu's third body was killed in a rather emotionless manner. She was later married off into semi-retirement with Chuck because their powers weren't terribly useful. She did have a huge moment in the Conspiracy story, but again at the expense of her second body.

Zoe....ugh. Turned into a, iirc, speechless terrorform and later part of the body count in Lo3W. And she never got the story I feel she was made for.

So in some ways, these ladies were abused by Legion creators and DC, but they all obviously mean something to Legion fandom. They won't be forgotten or thrown away by us!

Long Live Kara, Luornu and Zoe!!!!!

thanks for the kind words, GL, stile! and thanks for playing, glad you had fun!

Lardy, what a lovely tribute - and you're right! all 3 could have, and should have, been treated better - sometimes I wonder if anyone at DC will see this thread, and realize how beloved so many of these "niche" Legionnaires are!

at least they all live on in our memories... and in our fics!

(still hoping we will, one day, in canon, see Zoe force her way out of Mordru and give him what for! both razsolo and I have written that in our fics - I found it very cathartic!)

I'm already building the list for Tryout Idol tongue 394 so far..

Don't forget Blazerr from the Flash. (whatever the Cobalt Blue storyline was. Around 147 I think)

I just reread that issue.

Blazerr with two Rs is already on the list, thanks