Roll Call
0 members (), 14 Murran Spies, and 4 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Time-Scope
Legion Trivia 6
by Invisible Brainiac - 03/28/24 06:23 AM
Share more completely random things!
by Invisible Brainiac - 03/28/24 06:23 AM
Inane one word posts XXXIV - inanity
by Invisible Brainiac - 03/28/24 06:22 AM
The Non-Legion Comics Trivia Thread Pt 5
by Invisible Brainiac - 03/28/24 06:22 AM
Legionnaire Mastermind
by Invisible Brainiac - 03/28/24 06:22 AM
Kill This Thread XLIX - We're Getting Old
by Invisible Brainiac - 03/28/24 06:21 AM
Postlo3w stories *LATEST UPDATE 28 MARCH*
by razsolo - 03/28/24 06:18 AM
Omnicom
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 1 of 12 1 2 3 11 12
Legion of Doom Idol Final!
#933468 07/10/17 05:20 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
This is the JLA Villains Idol. I have given them the name Legion of Doom due to it's popular use in cartoons, and it rolls nicely off the tongue. Due to events out of my control in real life, I kind of want to start planning the next game in order to get some escape. I also realized I am on vacation the first week of August so I might end up starting the game in about two weeks, unless of course we are in a heated debate over who to include. The planning for Villain Idols encounter one of two problems

1) We have too many villains and need to narrow it down to a reasonable number.

or

2) We have too few villains and need to raid encyclopedias to reach at least the hundreds.

The first scenario applies to the Legion of Doom Idol. Should we just include exclusive JLA villains or those that are combined teams? Should we try to include everyone that appeared more than twice or exclude some of more unusual Silver Age villains? Should we include the animated versions, some of which are very good, in this game? Such is the task that we must decide while chilling in our cool skull-shaped headquarters...

Last edited by Emily Sivana; 11/18/17 08:26 AM.

Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #933473 07/10/17 05:32 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
As was my position in previous Idols, I'm all for including as many villains as possible! We tend to eliminate a lot in the first few rounds anyway

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #933498 07/10/17 11:49 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Yeah I'm all about inclusion .. even though the list can be MAMMOTH

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #933548 07/11/17 01:48 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Has Mammoth fought the JLA too? Gosh, it is a big list. smile


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #933565 07/11/17 02:58 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Well, Mammoth did punch Superman in that one issue, so of course he must be included! tongue

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #933689 07/12/17 06:01 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I have started creating Draft One of our list. I have decided to start with the lists in the Lego games because they usually include everyone (even if it is just a skin). Please feel free to comment on any of the characters as it pertains to JLA continuity or lack thereof. Please note that since I am using video games first they might be including more characters than in the comics. I will split the characters up to multiple versions once we have the initial list set up.

Should I list all various Red/Yellow/etc Lanterns as JLA villains or save them for another game?

Off the bat, your host is biased towards Giganta.


The Riddler
Deadshot
Darkseid
Metallo
Trickster
Mr. Mxyzptlk
Composite Superman
Black Adam
Kalibak
Deathstroke
Scarecrow
King Shark
Professor Zoom
Cheshire
Bat-Mite
Cheetah
Black Manta
Star Sapphire III
Desaad
Manchester Black
Catwoman
Brainiac I
Doomsday
The Penguin
Bronze Tiger
Killer Croc
Giganta
Firefly
Frankenstein(no idea where Lego got this from)
Captain Cold
Cyborg Superman
Sinestro
Parasite
Merlyn
The Joker
Soloman Grundy
Gorilla Grodd
Toyman
Plastique
Heatwave
Killer Frost
Lex Luthor


My source list: http://lego.wikia.com/wiki/LEGO_Batman_3%3A_Beyond_Gotham

Upon review of my initial list, I will have to go to a JLA encyclopedia or Index to get the JLA specific villains. If anyone has one at hand, please feel free to make a separate list and I will merge them together.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #933697 07/12/17 11:03 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Maybe this is just me, but 90% of the characters on that list aren't JLA villains IMO.

They are villains associated with individual JLA members, yes, but very few of them have ever been considered a primary antagonist of the team itself as far as I know.

If this game is going to include every member's villains, then it should probably be more aptly called DCU Villains Idol, but then the list will be endless.

Wikipedia has a pretty well researched list of JLA villains that seems to be enough for an Idol game:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Justice_League_enemies

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #933750 07/13/17 05:03 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I will go through the general wiki over the next few days, as I have a funeral to attend. I am reluctant to copy-paste do to overlap.

I remember most of the characters the Lego games choose from the cartoons, to be honest, so that is why I didn't mind using at as my first source. I'm wondering if this game is warranting putting Super-Friends and JLU versions of the characters...you know me from previous games that I am reluctant to do so. I realize while typing this that majority of my JLA knowledge comes from cartoons and video games. That might be the same with some other members of the forum as well.

Edit: This is the initial merging of the two source lists. I filtered out a lot of the villains that seemed to be villains-as-plots, i.e a villain that consumes stars. There seems to be quite a few of them, so unless any of them are super significant I really don't want to include them. It would be like a game with multiple Galactuses.

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anansi
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Bat-Mite
Black Adam
Black Manta
Brain Storm
Brainiac I
Bronze Tiger
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheshire
Circe
Commander Blanx
Composite Superman
Crucifer
Cyborg Superman
Darkseid
David Graves
Deadshot
Deathstroke
Desaad
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doomsday
Doomsday
Felix Faust
Fernus
Firefly
Frankenstein
Garn Daanuth
Getaway Mastermind
Giganta
Gorilla Grodd
Grayman
Headmaster Mind
Heatwave
Hyathis
Imperiex
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Kid Amazo
Kilg%re
Killer Croc
Killer Frost
King Kull
King Shark
Kromm
Lex Luthor
Lord of Time
Magog (Kingdom Come)
Malefic
Manchester Black
Menagerie Man (Superfriends)
Merlyn
Metallo
Mr. Mxyzptlk
Nick Necro
Omega Man
Paragon
Parasite
Per Degaton
Peraxxus
Plastique
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen of Fables
Rama Khan
Saturna
Sayyar
Scarecrow
Shaggy Man
Simon Magus
Sinestro
Siren
Soloman Grundy
Sonar
Spaceman X
Star Sapphire III
Starro
T.O Morrow
The Construct
The General
The Joker
The Key
The Marshal
The Penguin
The Riddler
The Weapons Master
The Wizard
Toyman
Trickster
Troll King
Ultra-Humanite
Warlock of YS

Last edited by Emily Sivana; 07/16/17 11:52 AM.

Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934149 07/18/17 12:56 PM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Some notes

- Frankenstein is a hero in DC Continuity.

- It's spelt "Solomon Grundy"

- You have Doomsday twice

- I'll list off some more JL Villains later, but Royal Flush Gang is the most conspicuous absence at first glance. Would each member get an entry (there were a few Aces, but only one Jack as I recall)?

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934151 07/18/17 12:59 PM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934166 07/18/17 04:46 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I am going to have to go through the previous Idols and see what the precedent is for small teams. I feel like we reached a conclusion, but I don't remember which game it was.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934169 07/18/17 05:36 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Depending on whether or not small teams are allowed, the Appelaxians are another conspicuous absence, considering there would never have been a Justice League without them.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934170 07/18/17 05:52 PM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Abnegezar
Rath
Ghast
Neron
Asmodel
Alaric
Eclipso
Floronic Man
Libra
Manga Khan
Privateer/Star Tsar/Manhunter
Mister Nebula
Scarlet Skier
Overmaster (and the Cadre as individuals?)
Queen Bee II
Spirit King
Red Tornado/Tornado Tyrant
Vandal Savage

Groups who's individual members may count:
Cadre
Hyperclan
Royal Flush Gang
Various Injustice Gangs/Leagues
Crime Syndicates (Earth 3 & Anti-Matter)
Appelaxians
Secret Society of Super Villains
The Society
Manhunters

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934173 07/18/17 06:09 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
So I went through the Spider-Villain Idol, and it appears that I ended up listing the Enforcers as individuals but somehow the Circus of Crime got in as a group. shake On the bright side we don't have to worry about the rule/exceptions for belonging to multiple teams for this game. I will update the list later tonight in this post with some of Dave's suggestions.

On Alien Races: I remember not wanting to include entire races as enemies in the LSV Idol, but I might have let them in per Invisible Brainiac's arguments. This is another case where I will have to go back and check the precedent.

Abnegezar
Alaric
Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anansi
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Asmodel
Bat-Mite
Black Adam
Black Manta
Brain Storm
Brainiac I
Bronze Tiger
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheshire
Circe
Commander Blanx
Composite Superman
Crucifer
Cyborg Superman
Darkseid
David Graves
Deadshot
Deathstroke
Desaad
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doomsday
Eclipso
Felix Faust
Fernus
Firefly
Floronic Man
Garn Daanuth
Getaway Mastermind
Ghast
Giganta
Gorilla Grodd
Grayman
Headmaster Mind
Heatwave
Hyathis
Imperiex
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Kid Amazo
Kilg%re
Killer Croc
Killer Frost
King Kull
King Shark
Kromm
Lex Luthor
Libra
Lord of Time
Magog (Kingdom Come)
Malefic
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Menagerie Man (Superfriends)
Merlyn
Metallo
Mister Nebula
Mr. Mxyzptlk
Neron
Nick Necro
Omega Man
Paragon
Parasite
Per Degaton
Peraxxus
Plastique
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Queen of Fables
Rama Khan
Rath
Saturna
Sayyar
Scarecrow
Scarlet Skie
Shaggy Man
Simon Magus
Sinestro
Siren
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Spaceman X
Spirit King
Star Sapphire III
Starro
T.O Morrow
The Construct
The General
The Joker
The Key
The Marshal
The Penguin
The Riddler
The Weapons Master
The Wizard
Tornado Tyrant
Toyman
Trickster
Troll King
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Warlock of YS


Last edited by Emily Sivana; 07/18/17 06:43 PM. Reason: added list

Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934178 07/18/17 08:32 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
I think these 3 should be added:

- Aquarius (killed Larry Lance causing Black Canary to join the team).
- Starbreaker (one of their most powerful enemies and fought multiple versions of the team).
- Doctor Light (fought the team repeatedly, including in one of their most famous/infamous tales, Identity Crisis).

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934195 07/19/17 06:49 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
I'd argue to remove the following as they haven't fought the League that I'm aware of:


Bat-Mite
Black Adam
Bronze Tiger
Composite Superman
Heatwave
Killer Croc
King Shark
Manchester Black
Metallo
Mr. Mxyzptlk
Trickster

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934214 07/19/17 10:18 AM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
^ Seconded.

Was a decision made regarding the small groups of enemies? It seems very weird having a list of JLA enemies without these famous perennial foes:

Royal Flush Gang
Crime Syndicate
Cadre
Conglomerate
Extremists
Manhunters

Also, I think these foes who have opposed the team a few times should be added:

Overmaster
Hector Hammond
Tattooed Man
Blockbuster

These prominent one-offs could also be considered:

Nebula Man
Nekron

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934221 07/19/17 10:56 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Re teams/small groups, I can't remember if we ever had a decision. On one hand, some groups have certain members who stand out (Dreamslayer for example menaced the League solo and was responsible for Silver Sorceress' death).

For the Royal flush Gang, most incarnations don't have much individuality, but then we also have Amos Fortune... and one of the satellite Era versions got some good individual characterization I remember

This might have to be decided case to case.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934222 07/19/17 11:10 AM
Joined: Sep 2016
Posts: 5,070
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Sep 2016
Posts: 5,070
What about Calculator (their version of Oracle)?

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934229 07/19/17 12:23 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Re: groups.

I think a good rule of thumb would be that groups who don't have individual members represented (e.g. all of the groups I listed) should be included whereas groups that are comprised of characters who also fought the team individually (e.g. Injustice League, Crime Champions, SSoSV, etc.) should not. That way, important characters/teams are included without any doubling up.

Re: Amos Fortune/Royal Flush Gang and Overmaster/Cadre - I consider both of those "leaders" as sort of separate from their teams since the teams have acted independently of those characters many times since their introductory stories. For that reason, I think all four entities should be listed individually.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Dave Hackett #934256 07/19/17 05:15 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I will remove all of Dave's suggestions with the exception these two:

Originally Posted by Dave Hackett
I'd argue to remove the following as they haven't fought the League that I'm aware of:
Black Adam


I remember Black Adam being extremely prominent as a villain around the time of Infinite Crisis. Geoff Johns loves him so he was in a ton of books. Does that count as a Justice League villain? If not, I think I will start going through the cartoon lists as I feel like there are more well-known villains that should be included.

Quote
Manchester Black

He is cited as fighting them on the main wiki page so I want to keep him on the list for now.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934262 07/19/17 08:08 PM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Originally Posted by Emily Sivana
I will remove all of Dave's suggestions with the exception these two:

Originally Posted by Dave Hackett
I'd argue to remove the following as they haven't fought the League that I'm aware of:
Black Adam


I remember Black Adam being extremely prominent as a villain around the time of Infinite Crisis. Geoff Johns loves him so he was in a ton of books. Does that count as a Justice League villain? If not, I think I will start going through the cartoon lists as I feel like there are more well-known villains that should be included.

Quote
Manchester Black

He is cited as fighting them on the main wiki page so I want to keep him on the list for now.



Black Adam fought just about everyone (expect the big three) during the 52 series, but there was no Justice League at that time.

I've double checked Manchester Black's Wikipedia page and I don't see encounters with the JL. His sister lead the JL:Elite, but he only really fought with Superman. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manchester_Black

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934349 07/20/17 06:59 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I have come to realize I will have sporadic Internet access this weekend as I have to help my aunt. Would you all like to edit the list or wait until I get back? I am okay with adding all of Blacula and Jfposey's suggestions.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934355 07/20/17 09:56 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
I'll help you out Emily.

UPDATED LIST:

Alaric
Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anansi
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Aryan Brigade
Asmodel
Black Adam
Black Manta
Blockbuster
Brainstorm
Brainiac
Cadre
Calculator
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheshire
Chronos
Circe
Commander Blanx
Conglomerate
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Crucifer
Cyborg Superman
Darkseid
David Graves
Deadshot
Deathstroke
Demons Three
Desaad
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Light
Doomsday
Eclipso
Extremists
Felix Faust
Fernus
Firefly
Floronic Man
Garn Daanuth
General
Getaway Mastermind
Giganta
Gorilla Grodd
Gray Man
Headmaster Mind
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Imperiex
Joker
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
Kid Amazo
Kilg%re
Killer Frost
King Kull
Kromm
Lex Luthor
Libra
Lord of Time
Magog (Kingdom Come)
Malefic
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Marshal
Menagerie Man (Superfriends)
Merlyn
Mirror Master
Mister Nebula
Nebula Man
Nekron
Neron
Nick Necro
Omega Man
Overmaster
Paragon
Parasite
Penguin
Per Degaton
Peraxxus
Plastique
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Queen of Fables
Rama Khan
Riddler
Royal Flush Gang
Saturna
Sayyar
Scarecrow
Scarlet Skier
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Simon Magus
Sinestro
Siren
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Spaceman X
Spirit King
Starbreaker
Starro
Star Sapphire III
Tattooed Man
T.O. Morrow
Tornado Tyrant
Toyman
Troll King
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Wizard

ADDED:

Appelaxians (they were more like a villain team who happened to be aliens, rather than representatives of their race the way Khunds or Dominators might be)
Aquarius
Aryan Brigade
Blockbuster
Cadre
Calculator
Chronos
Conglomerate
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Doctor Light
Extremists
Hector Hammond
Hyperclan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Mirror Master
Nebula Man
Nekron
Overmaster
Poison Ivy
Royal Flush Gang
Shadow Thief
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Starbreaker
Tattooed Man

COMBINED:

Abnegezar
Rath
Ghast

into

Demons Three (since they only ever appeared as a unit)

REMOVED:

Bat-Mite
Bronze Tiger
Composite Superman
Heatwave
Killer Croc
King Shark
Metallo
Mr. Mxyzptlk
Trickster

Last edited by Blacula; 07/21/17 09:18 AM.
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934360 07/21/17 12:35 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Thanks Blacula!

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934368 07/21/17 05:59 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Good Work. I'd still argue that Mark Shaw/Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar is distinct enough from the Manhunters to get his own entry.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934386 07/21/17 09:10 AM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
^ I agree. Sorry I missed him. I'll add him now.

You've also made me realize that Snapper Carr should probably get his own entry too, since he was also the Star-Tsar.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934389 07/21/17 09:32 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
I agree with snapper getting his own entry. though he wasn't "evil" per se, he did still fight the League.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934495 07/23/17 02:51 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Great work so far everyone! Thank you for covering me when I was away.

Snapper Carr: Was he mind controlled or acting of his own free will? It is unclear from the encyclopedia entries as they mention something about the Joker tricking him.

Also, do the cartoon versions overlap with their respective ages (Silver Age and Post-Crisis) or would you be okay with me including them?


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934500 07/23/17 04:30 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Snapper began to begrudge his association with the team as it was affecting his wider life. He became a dupe of the Joker and fought the League. That's what my memory cell tells me anyway. Good enough to make the list.

I'd agree on the Mark Shaw/ Star Tsar entry too.


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934504 07/23/17 04:49 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Snapper was influenced to betray the team twice (first by the Joker and then by the Key and Mark Shaw) but that influence mainly extended to preying on his feelings of insecurity and inadequacy and turning that into a resentment of the team, rather than any sort of mind control.

Re: cartoon characters - I don't really mind but if I had to vote I would probably be against including any cartoon versions of characters already on the list because: a) I don't remember there being much of a difference between them, other than the cartoon versions suffering from reduced characterization; b) the list seems long enough; and c) I don't have any affinity for the cartoon versions so they'd probably be the first ones I'd vote off anyway.

On that note, is there a reason Menagerie Man is the only Superfriends character on the list or did he slip through an edit somewhere along the line?

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934511 07/23/17 08:36 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Menagerie Man is already listed on wikipedia's main Justice League villain list, so I guess at least one editor thought he was note-worthy for inclusion.

My main problem is the opposite Blacula, as by the time I was reading modern comics (around 2004) writers were already copying the cartoons in the comics. Before that, I primarily had access to my father's comics from the '80s, when the League was not as prominent as Teen Titans or Legion. I am unfamiliar with a lot of the JLA-specific villains.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934512 07/23/17 09:11 PM
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 146
E
Substitute
Offline
Substitute
E
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 146
Advanced Man
Agamemno
Amazoids/Men in Black
Antithesis
Brimstone
Cadre of the Immortal
Chair
Devastator
Devilfish
Doctor Impossible
Electrocutioner
Hunter
Jack O'Lantern III
Johnny Sorrow
Know Man
Konvikt
Krona/Epoch
Luck League
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fey
Packrat
Plura
Powderkeg
Solaris
Superboy-Prime
Tender Mercy
Time Commander
Ultraa
Unimaginable

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934547 07/24/17 05:28 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I have no immediate objection to adding any of these characters, but some of the newer ones might be questioned if there technically wasn't a JL active at the time of publishing (Super-Boy Prime being the one that stands outthe most). I will the floor open to comments before adding them to the list.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934553 07/25/17 01:26 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
I can vouch for a lot of Elvar's additions. The ones that I know of anyway - Mordru, Le Fey, the Cadre, Agamemno, Advanced Man, Electrocutioner, Solaris, Know Man, Johnny Sorrow, Jack O Lantern

I can't remember if Superboy Prime ever fought the League proper either...

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934558 07/25/17 07:49 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
other additions:

Triumph
Julian September
Qwisp

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Invisible Brainiac #934563 07/25/17 09:30 AM
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 146
E
Substitute
Offline
Substitute
E
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 146
Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac
I can vouch for a lot of Elvar's additions. The ones that I know of anyway - Mordru, Le Fey, the Cadre, Agamemno, Advanced Man, Electrocutioner, Solaris, Know Man, Johnny Sorrow, Jack O Lantern

I can't remember if Superboy Prime ever fought the League proper either...

Superboy-Prime destroyed the JLA Moom base watchtower.

Doctor Impossible, Chair, Tender Mercy and Hunter battle Donna Troy's League and all but Doctor Impossible was killed by the Omega Man.
Plura and Devilfish - Advanced Man worked for Plura and Devilfish defected from Aquaman's Justice League of Atlantis to the enemy during the Justice League: Justice LeagueS one-shots.
Brimstone took on the Justice League Detroit and Firestorm during the Legends mini-series.
Krona/Epoch along with Marvel's Grandmaster were the big baddies For the JLA/Avengers 4 issue limited.
Antithesis controled the League causing their sidekicks to take them down and form the Teen Titans.
Konvikt battled the League during the 52 issue Trinity series.
Unimaginable battle the League after trying to join when they were trying to recruit Metamorpho.
Luck League - Amos Forture group who battled the League during its original run.
Amazoids/Men in Black were sent out by Ivo to steal the powers of the most powerful individuals on the planet, Valor, Starman, Red Star, Geo-Force, Rebis and Power Girl in order to end his immortal life during Justice League Quarterly.
Devastator was responsible for severing Booster Gold's arm when he battled the League.
Packrat was revealed to havve battled the League in a past adventure in Legends of the DC Universe #12
Ultraa battled the League a few times in their original inception and after Crisis as a member of the League Busters.

Powderkeg and Time Commander was in ere and needs to be removed.

Last edited by Elvar; 07/25/17 06:36 PM. Reason: spelling
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934609 07/25/17 08:42 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
As I am going on vacation next week, I would like to try to get the list finalized by the end of Sunday. Please submit any addition or subtraction requests to the board for discussion prior to Sunday.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934771 07/27/17 05:24 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I have added the majority of the recent suggestions. I decided to omit Krona/Epoch for now as he is more of a general DCU villain. I also omitted Ultraa as I was under the impression he was a good guy? At least the original version seems to have been.

Advanced Man
Agamemno
Alaric
Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anansi
Antithesis
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Aryan Brigade
Asmodel
Black Adam
Black Manta
Blockbuster
Brainstorm
Brainiac
Brimstone
Cadre
Calculator
Captain Cold
Chair
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheshire
Chronos
Circe
Commander Blanx
Conglomerate
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Crucifer
Cyborg Superman
Darkseid
David Graves
Deadshot
Deathstroke
Demons Three
Desaad
Despero
Devastator
Devilfish
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Impossible
Doctor Light
Doomsday
Eclipso
Electocutioner
Extremists
Felix Faust
Fernus
Firefly
Floronic Man
Garn Daanuth
General
Getaway Mastermind
Giganta
Gorilla Grodd
Gray Man
Headmaster Mind
Hector Hammond
Hunter
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Imperiex
Jack O'Lantern III
Joker
Johnny Sorrow
Julian September
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
Kid Amazo
Kilg%re
Killer Frost
King Kull
Know Man
Konvikt
Kromm
Lex Luthor
Libra
Lord of Time
Luck League
Magog (Kingdom Come)
Malefic
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Marshal
Menagerie Man (Superfriends)
Merlyn
Mirror Master
Mister Nebula
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nebula Man
Nekron
Neron
Nick Necro
Omega Man
Overmaster
Packrat
Paragon
Parasite
Penguin
Per Degaton
Peraxxus
Plastique
Plura
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Queen of Fables
Qwisp
Rama Khan
Riddler
Royal Flush Gang
Saturna
Sayyar
Scarecrow
Scarlet Skier
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Simon Magus
Sinestro
Siren
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Spaceman X
Spirit King
Starbreaker
Starro
Star Sapphire III
Superboy-Prime
Tattooed Man
Tender Mercy
T.O. Morrow
Tornado Tyrant
Toyman
Troll King
Triumph
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Wizard


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934852 07/28/17 11:52 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Nice list - I love seeing totally unfamiliar names that I have to google

I agree with your logic about Krona and Ultraa

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934900 07/28/17 07:12 PM
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 146
E
Substitute
Offline
Substitute
E
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 146
A few more

Colonel Rumaan Harjavti
Eurocrime
Millenium Giants
Red King
Spore
Wally Tortollini
Wandjina
Xotar the Weapons Master (not to be confused with the later yellow clad Weapons Master)

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934902 07/28/17 07:20 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Should I separate the more well-known characters into Silver, Bronze, and Modern versions or leave them as is? I normally would include all versions, but our list is already getting long.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934903 07/28/17 07:55 PM
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 146
E
Substitute
Offline
Substitute
E
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 146
seems like a lot of extra work making the list even longer.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934908 07/28/17 11:35 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
I vote to leave as is.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934919 07/29/17 08:29 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Leave as is

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934922 07/29/17 09:44 AM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Ok, cool. Any comments on Elvar's latest suggestions? If there are no objections, I will add them to the final list. Unless anyone else has anymore suggestions, I might just go through the cartoon lists for anyone interesting (Galatea comes to mind) and post the final list tomorrow.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934924 07/29/17 10:12 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
hi Sounds good to me!

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #934961 07/30/17 07:08 AM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
This is intended to be the Final List for this game. If anyone has questions, please let me know ASAP. Otherwise, I will open voting tonight at 6:00 PM Central Time. I will be on vacation starting tomorrow and will be back on Thursday morning. I will leave it up to you guys whether you want to wait or get a Mod to count the votes while I am away.

The voting rules will be a simple one or zero per character for the first round.

The List
Advanced Man
Agamemno
Alaric
Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anansi
Antithesis
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Aryan Brigade
Asmodel
Atomic Skull (DCAU)
Bizarro (DCAU)
Bizarro (Superfriends)
Black Adam (Justice)
Black Manta
Blockbuster
Brainstorm
Brainiac
Brainiac 13
Brainiac (Superfriends)
Brimstone
Cadre
Calculator
Captain Cold
Chair
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheetah (DCAU)
Cheetah (Super-Friends)
Cheshire
Chronos
Circe
Clayface (DCAU)
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Commander Blanx
Conglomerate
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Crowbar (DCAU)
Crucifer
Cyborg Superman
Darkseid
David Graves
Deadshot
Deathstroke
Demons Three
Desaad
Despero
Devastator
Devilfish
Devilray (DCAU Black Manta)
Doctor Cyber (DCAU)
Doctor Destiny (DCAU)
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Impossible
Doctor Nataz (Superfriends)
Doctor Light
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends)
Doomsday
Eclipso
Electocutioner (DCAU)
Electocutioner
Eurocrime
Evil Star (DCAU)
Extremists
Fastball (DCAU)
Felix Faust
Fernus
Firefly
Floronic Man
Galatea (JLU)
Garn Daanuth
General
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU)
Gentleman Ghost (Superfriends)
Getaway Mastermind
Giganta
Giganta (DCAU)
Goldface (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd
Gray Man
Headmaster Mind
Hector Hammond
Hellgrammite (DCAU)
Hunter
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Imperiex
Jack O'Lantern III
Joker
Johnny Sorrow
Julian September
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
KGBeast (DCAU)
Kid Amazo
Kilg%re
Killer Frost (DCAU)
Killer Frost
King Kull
Know Man
Konvikt
Kromm
Lex Luthor
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends)
Libra
Livewire (DCAU)
Lord of Time
Luck League
Magog (Kingdom Come)
Malefic
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Marshal
Menagerie Man (Superfriends)
Merlyn
Metallo (DCAU)
Metallo (Justice)
Millenium Giants
Mirror Master (Superfriends)
Mister Nebula
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nebula Man
Nekron
Neron
Nick Necro
Omega Man
Overmaster
Packrat
Paragon
Parasite (DCAU)
Parasite
Penguin
Per Degaton
Peraxxus
Plastique
Plura
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Queen of Fables
Qwisp
Rama Khan
Rampage (DCAU)
Red King
Riddler
Royal Flush Gang
Saturna
Sayyar
Scarecrow
Scarecrow (Superfriends)
Scarlet Skier
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Silver Banshee (DCAU)
Simon Magus
Sinestro
Siren
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Spaceman X
Spirit King
Spore
Starbreaker
Starro
Steppenwolf
Star Sapphire III
Superboy-Prime
Tala (DCAU)
Tattooed Man
Tender Mercy
T.O. Morrow
Tornado Tyrant
Toyman
Troll King
Triumph
Toyman (DCAU)
Toyman (Superfriends)
Ultra-Humanite
Ulitmen (DCAU)
Vandal Savage
Wally Tortollini
Wandjina
Warlock of YS
Weather Wizard (Superfriends)
Weapons Master
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master

Last edited by Emily Sivana; 08/03/17 03:18 PM. Reason: Edited to remove typos

Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935120 08/01/17 08:10 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Advanced Man 0
Agamemno 1
Alaric 0
Amazo 1
Amos Fortune 1
Anansi 0
Antithesis 0
Anti-Matter Man 0
Anton Allegro 1
Appelaxians 1
Aquarius 0
Aryan Brigade 1
Asmodel 1
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 1
Bizarro (DCAU) 1
Bizarro (Superfriends) 1
Black Adam (Justice) 0
Black Manta 1
Blockbuster 1
Brainstorm 1
Brainiac 1
Brainiac 13 0
Brainiac (Superfriends) 1
Brimstone 1
Cadre 1
Calculator 1
Captain Cold 1
Chair 0
Catwoman 1
Cheetah 1
Cheetah (DCAU) 1
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 1
Cheshire 0
Chronos 1
Circe 1
Clayface (DCAU) 1
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 1
Commander Blanx 0
Conglomerate 1
Construct 1
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 1
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 1
Crowbar (DCAU) 1
Crucifer 0
Cyborg Superman 0
Darkseid 1
David Graves 0
Deadshot 1
Deathstroke 1
Demons Three 1
Desaad 1
Despero 1
Devastator 0
Devilfish 0
Devilray (DCAU Black Manta) 1
Doctober Cyber (DCAU) 0
Doctober Destiny (DCAU) 0
Doctor Destiny 1
Doctor Impossible 1
Doctor Nataz (Superfriends) 0
Doctor Light 1
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 1
Doomsday 1
Eclipso 1
Electocutioner (DCAU) 0
Electocutioner 1
Eurocrime 1
Evil Star (DCAU) 1
Extremists 1
Fastball (DCAU) 1
Felix Faust 1
Fernus 1
Firefly 1
Floronic Man 1
Galatea (JLU) 1
Garn Daanuth 0
General 1
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 1
Gentleman Ghost (Superfriends) 1
Getaway Mastermind 0
Giganta 1
Giganta (DCAU) 1
Goldface (DCAU) 0
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 1
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gray Man 1
Headmaster Mind 0
Hector Hammond 1
Hellgrammite (DCAU) 0
Hunter 0
Hyathis 1
Hyperclan 1
Imperiex 0
Jack O'Lantern III 1
Joker 1
Johnny Sorrow 0
Julian September 1
Kalibak 1
Kanjor Ro 1
Key 1
KGBeast (DCAU) 1
Kid Amazo 0
Kilg%re 1
Killer Frost (DCAU) 1
Killer Frost 1
King Kull 0
Know Man 0
Konvikt 0
Kromm 0
Lex Luthor 1
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 1
Libra 1
Livewire (DCAU) 0
Lord of Time 1
Luck League 0
Magog (Kingdom Come) 0
Malefic 1
Manchester Black 1
Manga Khan 1
Manhunters 1
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 1
Marshal 0
Menagerie Man (Superfriends) 0
Merlyn 0
Metallo (DCAU) 1
Metallo (Justice) 0
Millenium Giants 0
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 1
Mister Nebula 0
Mordru 1
Morgaine Le Fay 0
Nebula Man 1
Nekron 0
Neron 1
Nick Necro 0
Omega Man 0
Overmaster 1
Packrat 0
Paragon 0
Parasite (DCAU) 0
Parasite 1
Penguin 1
Per Degaton 0
Peraxxus 0
Plastique 1
Plura 0
Poison Ivy 1
Professor Ivo 1
Professor Zoom 0
Prometheus 1
Queen Bee 1
Queen Bee II 1
Queen of Fables 1
Qwisp 1
Rama Khan 1
Rampage (DCAU) 0
Red King 0
Riddler 1
Royal Flush Gang 1
Saturna 0
Sayyar 0
Scarecrow 1
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 1
Scarlet Skier 1
Shadow Thief 1
Shaggy Man 1
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 1
Simon Magus 0
Sinestro 1
Siren 0
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 0
Solaris 1
Solomon Grundy 1
Sonar 1
Spaceman X 0
Spirit King 1
Spore 0
Starbreaker 1
Starro 1
Steppenwolf 1
Star Sapphire III 1
Superboy-Prime 1
Tala (DCAU) 0
Tattooed Man 1
Tender Mercy 0
T.O. Morrow 1
Tornado Tyrant 1
Toyman 1
Troll King 0
Triumph 1
Toyman (DCAU) 0
Toyman (Superfriends) 1
Ultra-Humanite 1
Ulitmen (DCAU) 0
Vandal Savage 1
Wally Tortollini 0
Wandjina 0
Warlock of YS 1
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 1
Weapons Master 1
Wizard 1
Xotar the Weapons Master 1

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935131 08/01/17 09:59 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Advanced Man...0
Agamemno...0
Alaric...0
Amazo...1
Amos Fortune...1
Anansi...0
Antithesis...0
Anti-Matter Man...1
Anton Allegro...1
Appelaxians...1
Aquarius...1
Aryan Brigade...1
Asmodel...0
Atomic Skull (DCAU)...0
Bizarro (DCAU)...0
Bizarro (Superfriends)...0
Black Adam (Justice)...0
Black Manta...0
Blockbuster...0
Brainstorm...1
Brainiac...0
Brainiac 13...0
Brainiac (Superfriends)...0
Brimstone...0
Cadre...1
Calculator...0
Captain Cold...0
Chair...0
Catwoman...0
Cheetah...0
Cheetah (DCAU)...0
Cheetah (Super-Friends)...0
Cheshire...0
Chronos...0
Circe...0
Clayface (DCAU)...0
Colonel Rumann Harjavti...1
Commander Blanx...1
Conglomerate...1
Construct...1
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)...1
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)...1
Crowbar (DCAU)...0
Crucifer...0
Cyborg Superman...0
Darkseid...0
David Graves...0
Deadshot...0
Deathstroke...0
Demons Three...1
Desaad...0
Despero...1
Devastator...0
Devilfish...0
Devilray (DCAU Black Manta)...0
Doctober Cyber (DCAU)...0
Doctober Destiny (DCAU)...0
Doctor Destiny...1
Doctor Impossible...0
Doctor Nataz (Superfriends)...0
Doctor Light...1
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends)...0
Doomsday...0
Eclipso...1
Electocutioner (DCAU)...0
Electocutioner...1
Eurocrime...1
Evil Star (DCAU)...0
Extremists...1
Fastball (DCAU)...0
Felix Faust...1
Fernus...0
Firefly...0
Floronic Man...1
Galatea (JLU)...0
Garn Daanuth...1
General...0
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU)...0
Gentleman Ghost (Superfriends)...0
Getaway Mastermind...1
Giganta...0
Giganta (DCAU)...0
Goldface (DCAU)...0
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)...0
Gorilla Grodd...0
Gray Man...1
Headmaster Mind...0
Hector Hammond...1
Hellgrammite (DCAU)...0
Hunter...0
Hyathis...1
Hyperclan...0
Imperiex...0
Jack O'Lantern III...0
Joker...0
Johnny Sorrow...0
Julian September...0
Kalibak...0
Kanjor Ro...1
Key...1
KGBeast (DCAU)...0
Kid Amazo...0
Kilg%re...0
Killer Frost (DCAU)...0
Killer FrosT...0
King Kull...0
Know Man...0
Konvikt...0
Kromm...1
Lex Luthor...0
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends)...0
Libra...1
Livewire (DCAU)...0
Lord of Time...1
Luck League...0
Magog (Kingdom Come)...0
Malefic...0
Manchester Black...0
Manga Khan...0
Manhunters...1
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)...1
Marshal...0
Menagerie Man (Superfriends)...0
Merlyn...1
Metallo (DCAU)...0
Metallo (Justice)...0
Millenium Giants...0
Mirror Master (Superfriends)...0
Mister Nebula...0
Mordru...0
Morgaine Le Fay...0
Nebula Man...1
Nekron...1
Neron...0
Nick Necro...0
Omega Man...0
Overmaster...1
Packrat...0
Paragon...1
Parasite (DCAU)...0
Parasite...0
Penguin...0
Per Degaton...0
Peraxxus...0
Plastique...0
Plura...0
Poison Ivy...0
Professor Ivo...1
Professor Zoom...0
Prometheus...0
Queen Bee...1
Queen Bee II...1
Queen of Fables...0
Qwisp...0
Rama Khan...0
Rampage (DCAU)...0
Red King...0
Riddler...0
Royal Flush Gang...1
Saturna...1
Sayyar...1
Scarecrow...0
Scarecrow (Superfriends)...0
Scarlet Skier...0
Shadow Thief...1
Shaggy Man...1
Silver Banshee (DCAU)...0
Simon Magus...0
Sinestro...0
Siren...1
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)...1
Solaris...0
Solomon Grundy...0
Sonar...0
Spaceman X...1
Spirit King...1
Spore...0
Starbreaker...1
Starro...1
Steppenwolf...0
Star Sapphire III...1
Superboy-Prime...0
Tala (DCAU)...0
Tattooed Man...1
Tender Mercy...0
T.O. Morrow...1
Tornado Tyrant...1
Toyman...0
Troll King...1
Triumph...0
Toyman (DCAU)...0
Toyman (Superfriends)...0
Ultra-Humanite...0
Ulitmen (DCAU)...0
Vandal Savage...0
Wally Tortollini...0
Wandjina...1
Warlock of YS...1
Weather Wizard (Superfriends)...0
Weapons Master...1
Wizard...1
Xotar the Weapons Master...1

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935132 08/01/17 10:00 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
(Maybe someone with Mod privileges in this forum can change the thread title to show that the game has started?)

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935133 08/02/17 12:01 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Has it started? I was wondering if Emily was going to open the round formally by herself.... but then, nobody objected to the list AND it is past her intended "opening" time...

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935167 08/02/17 06:18 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
oops, forgot to make the edit. it's done now

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935176 08/02/17 07:35 PM
Joined: Sep 2016
Posts: 5,070
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Sep 2016
Posts: 5,070
This list is huge. I will need a little more time with it.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935226 08/03/17 12:25 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Thank you for changing the thread title, I was thinking about that when I was gone. I understand this list is long and has some extremely different versions of characters (JLAU is extremely different from Main DCU and Superfriends often represents the Silver Age versions for this game). I will keep this open until Saturday night at 6:00 PM Central Time. I may begin entering votes into the spreadsheet prior to that time due to the length, however, so if you edit your post please let me know.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935230 08/03/17 03:55 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Em, thanks for putting it together
I know the list is long but some of those folks brought a smile to my face as I remembered them!

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935234 08/03/17 04:47 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
1s for :-

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Brainstorm
Cadre
Calculator
Cheetah
Chronos
Circe
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Commander Blanx
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Darkseid
Demons Three
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Light
Eclipso
Extremists
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Garn Daanuth
General
Getaway Mastermind
Gorilla Grodd
Gray Man
Headmaster Mind
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Jack O'Lantern III
Joker
Kanjor Ro
Key
Killer Frost
Lex Luthor
Libra
Lord of Time
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Merlyn
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nebula Man
Nekron
Neron
Overmaster
Paragon
Parasite
Penguin
Per Degaton
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Queen of Fables
Qwisp
Royal Flush Gang
Saturna
Scarecrow
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Simon Magus
Sinestro
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Spaceman X
Spirit King
Starbreaker
Starro
Star Sapphire III
Tattooed Man
T.O. Morrow
Tornado Tyrant
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Wally Tortollini
Wandjina
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935241 08/04/17 05:03 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
I like long lists smile

Emily, if you want to, I can try to teach you how to automatically "look up" the votes in Excel. That's how I do it with my Idols, and it makes it easier and reduces error.

+1 for

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Appelaxians
Atomic Skull (DCAU)
Bizarro (DCAU)
Brainiac
Brainiac 13
Brimstone
Cadre
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheetah (DCAU)
Cheshire
Chronos
Circe
Clayface (DCAU)
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Cyborg Superman
Darkseid
Deadshot
Demons Three
Desaad
Despero
Doctor Destiny (DCAU)
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends)
Doomsday
Eclipso
Eurocrime
Extremists
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Galatea (JLU)
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU)
Giganta
Giganta (DCAU)
Goldface (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd
Hector Hammond
Imperiex
Johnny Sorrow
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
Kid Amazo
Kilg%re
Killer Frost (DCAU)
Killer Frost
Lex Luthor
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends)
Livewire (DCAU)
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Menagerie Man (Superfriends)
Metallo (DCAU)
Metallo (Justice)
Mirror Master (Superfriends)
Mister Nebula
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Neron
Overmaster
Parasite (DCAU)
Parasite
Penguin
Per Degaton
Plastique
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Queen of Fables
Qwisp
Rampage (DCAU)
Royal Flush Gang
Scarecrow
Scarecrow (Superfriends)
Scarlet Skier
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Silver Banshee (DCAU)
Sinestro
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Starbreaker
Starro
Steppenwolf
Star Sapphire III
Tala (DCAU)
Tattooed Man
Tender Mercy
T.O. Morrow
Tornado Tyrant
Toyman
Triumph
Toyman (DCAU)
Toyman (Superfriends)
Ultra-Humanite
Ulitmen (DCAU)
Vandal Savage
Wally Tortollini
Wandjina
Warlock of YS
Weather Wizard (Superfriends)
Weapons Master

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935304 08/04/17 06:26 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Thank you, Invisible Brainiac, I would like to learn how to use Excel better.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935319 08/05/17 09:42 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Same here! I had such a hard time with my Idol

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935322 08/05/17 10:12 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
I'll PM you guys - it will probably be easiest if I can email you an Excel file so you have the formulas ready smile

You will need VLOOKUP, and LEFT/MID/RIGHT (this last batch of formulas trims the text so you can match the lists smile

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935332 08/05/17 01:55 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I am going to delay the vote counts by at least 24 hours then so I can learn these new functions. Hopefully more people will also vote so I don't have to break ties. I will vote next round to ensure this won't be a problem in the future.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935348 08/06/17 02:19 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
emailed you both, Emily and Myg smile hope my sheet and explanations are clear!

thanks again for running this Emily. I realize now how much i missed Idol games

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 1)
Emily Sivana #935386 08/06/17 04:39 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
So, we have interesting results. I feel like if I put this in a graph it would be a bell curve. We might have time for a couple of Wild Card Rounds, as we have eliminated 29 characters. That is about 1/7th of the total number of characters.


The Results of Round One
Amazo 4
Amos Fortune 4
Appelaxians 4
Cadre 4
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 4
Construct 4
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 4
Demons Three 4
Despero 4
Doctor Destiny 4
Eclipso 4
Extremists 4
Felix Faust 4
Floronic Man 4
Hector Hammond 4
Kanjor Ro 4
Key 4
Manhunters 4
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 4
Overmaster 4
Professor Ivo 4
Queen Bee 4
Queen Bee II 4
Royal Flush Gang 4
Shadow Thief 4
Shaggy Man 4
Starbreaker 4
Starro 4
Star Sapphire III 4
Tattooed Man 4
T.O. Morrow 4
Tornado Tyrant 4
Warlock of YS 4
Weapons Master 4

Anton Allegro 3
Brainstorm 3
Cheetah 3
Chronos 3
Circe 3
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 3
Darkseid 3
Doctor Light 3
Eurocrime 3
Gorilla Grodd 3
Gray Man 3
Hyathis 3
Killer Frost 3
Lex Luthor 3
Libra 3
Lord of Time 3
Mordru 3
Nebula Man 3
Neron 3
Parasite 3
Penguin 3
Poison Ivy 3
Queen of Fables 3
Qwisp 3
Scarecrow 3
Sinestro 3
Solaris 3
Solomon Grundy 3
Sonar 3
Spirit King 3
Ultra-Humanite 3
Vandal Savage 3
Wandjina 3
Wizard 3
Xotar the Weapons Master 3

Anti-Matter Man 2
Aryan Brigade 2
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 2
Bizarro (DCAU) 2
Brainiac 2
Brimstone 2
Calculator 2
Captain Cold 2
Catwoman 2
Cheetah (DCAU) 2
Clayface (DCAU) 2
Commander Blanx 2
Conglomerate 2
Deadshot 2
Desaad 2
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 2
Doomsday 2
Electocutioner 2
Galatea (JLU) 2
Garn Daanuth 2
General 2
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 2
Getaway Mastermind 2
Giganta 2
Giganta (DCAU) 2
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 2
Hyperclan 2
Jack O'Lantern III 2
Joker 2
Kalibak 2
Kilg%re 2
Killer Frost (DCAU) 2
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 2
Manchester Black 2
Manga Khan 2
Merlyn 2
Metallo (DCAU) 2
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 2
Morgaine Le Fay 2
Nekron 2
Paragon 2
Per Degaton 2
Plastique 2
Professor Zoom 2
Prometheus 2
Saturna 2
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 2
Scarlet Skier 2
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 2
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 2
Spaceman X 2
Steppenwolf 2
Toyman 2
Triumph 2
Toyman (Superfriends) 2
Wally Tortollini 2
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 2

Agamemno 1
Aquarius 1
Asmodel 1
Bizarro (Superfriends) 1
Black Manta 1
Blockbuster 1
Brainiac 13 1
Brainiac (Superfriends) 1
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 1
Cheshire 1
Crowbar (DCAU) 1
Cyborg Superman 1
Deathstroke 1
Devilray (DCAU Black Manta) 1
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 1
Doctor Impossible 1
Electocutioner (DCAU) 1
Evil Star (DCAU) 1
Fastball (DCAU) 1
Fernus 1
Firefly 1
Gentleman Ghost (Superfriends) 1
Goldface (DCAU) 1
Headmaster Mind 1
Imperiex 1
Johnny Sorrow 1
Julian September 1
KGBeast (DCAU) 1
Kid Amazo 1
Kromm 1
Livewire (DCAU) 1
Malefic 1
Menagerie Man (Superfriends) 1
Metallo (Justice) 1
Mister Nebula 1
Parasite (DCAU) 1
Rama Khan 1
Rampage (DCAU) 1
Riddler 1
Sayyar 1
Siren 1
Superboy-Prime 1
Tala (DCAU) 1
Tender Mercy 1
Troll King 1
Toyman (DCAU) 1
Ulitmen (DCAU) 1


These are eliminated this round
Advanced Man 0
Alaric 0
Anansi 0
Antithesis 0
Black Adam (Justice) 0
Chair 0
Crucifer 0
David Graves 0
Devastator 0
Devilfish 0
Doctor Cyber (DCAU) 0 <-- Forgive me if my spelling error contributed in some way
Doctor Nataz (Superfriends) 0
Hellgrammite (DCAU) 0 <-- His existence and obscurity baffled me, which is why he made the list.
Hunter 0
King Kull 0
Know Man 0
Konvikt 0
Luck League 0
Magog (Kingdom Come) 0 <-- Kind of surprised nobody threw in a vote for being the villain of a memorable Elseworlds story
Marshal 0
Millenium Giants 0
Nick Necro 0
Omega Man 0
Packrat 0
Peraxxus 0
Plura 0
Red King 0
Simon Magus 0
Spore 0


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 1)
Emily Sivana #935406 08/07/17 01:26 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
About Magog, I think his JSA counterpart turned me off him.

mostly classic villains at the top of this round, but nice to see Colonel Harvarti (i know i spelled wrong but i'm in a hurry) and Queen Bee II

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 1)
Emily Sivana #935480 08/07/17 04:25 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
I agree about Magog - the JSA stories were abysmal and really turned the character from "meh" (in the way that I find all war god cyborgs - a little too Image-y circa 1990s) to UGH

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 1)
Emily Sivana #935535 08/08/17 01:43 PM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
The "New" Magog in JSA wasn't great, but he did have one good issue which was as a guest star in the SHEILD series, one of the better Impact/Red Circle attempts by DC. It made for a good soldier & marine butting heads partnership/rivalry.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 1)
Emily Sivana #935579 08/08/17 08:24 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I feel like we had more players in some of the other games. Other than Set (who I found via the shout box), who normally plays that did not post in the first round? I am thinking of sending a PM before starting the next round.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 1)
Emily Sivana #935580 08/08/17 09:13 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
I would recommend opening each round as soon as possible after a previous one has finished, and then keeping them open longer if necessary to attract more voters. Longer rounds = more opportunities for someone to notice the game and vote.

PMs or Shout Box comments always help too.

Re: Magog -

It's been ages since I read those JSA comics, but I think I remember thinking he was... OK. blush

I seem to remember thinking this was the first version of the character that I ever understood; the first 3 or 4 versions hadn't received much exploration of their motivations (as far as I was aware), whereas David was given some believable and sympathetic motivations for going down the darker path wasn't he?

I never read his solo series or the issues after Johns left though so I'm not sure if he got worse after then?

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 1)
Emily Sivana #935592 08/09/17 03:16 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
As Blacula suggested, I have found PMs to be very useful. I usually get 3-5 players who only find out about Idol because of PMs, sometimes even more. Facebook is also an option for those who do not check the Boards often.

once people are aware of the game, I found that they usually voted within the first 24 hours of a new Round. 48 is my usual round length though just to give a reasonable amount of time. 72 hours is probably okay too.

re Magog

I remember Magog being OK in JSA proper. He started going downhill in All-Stars, and he was such a horrible character - without nuance - by the time he left that I didn't even care when he died.

His evolution? Well-meaning in JSA, began to question the proactive stance of the team, eventually led to half the team splitting and forming the All-Stars (at that point Magog was still a balanced character IMO). In All-Stars he became more aggressive and ends-justify-the-means. finally, he blasted Cyclone in the middle of a prison riot, and when Power Girl called hin out he just said, "she came up on my blind side". That was such a bad moment that it ruined him completely, changing him from a multi-dimensional character to a caricature that we have seen so often before.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 1)
Emily Sivana #935600 08/09/17 06:08 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
It's also summer (in the Northern Hemisphere) and people have vacations and are outside doing stuff more. I missed the first round because I was away at a campsite for the whole duration.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935617 08/09/17 04:40 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Without further ado, I will start the next round. This is another 1 or 0 round. After this round, I will copy the basic rules from the Bat-villain Idol and we will begin ranking.

By the way, I have been thinking of an Idol for the minor villains or characters with small rogue rosters (Superman and Wonder Woman being the most obvious).

Agamemno
Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Aryan Brigade
Asmodel
Atomic Skull (DCAU)
Bizarro (DCAU)
Bizarro (Superfriends)
Black Manta
Blockbuster
Brainiac
Brainiac (Superfriends)
Brainiac 13
Brainstorm
Brimstone
Cadre
Calculator
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheetah (DCAU)
Cheetah (Super-Friends)
Cheshire
Chronos
Circe
Clayface (DCAU)
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Commander Blanx
Conglomerate
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Crowbar (DCAU)
Cyborg Superman
Darkseid
Deadshot
Deathstroke
Demons Three
Desaad
Despero
Devilray (DCAU Black Manta)
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Destiny (DCAU)
Doctor Impossible
Doctor Light
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends)
Doomsday
Eclipso
Electocutioner
Electocutioner (DCAU)
Eurocrime
Evil Star (DCAU)
Extremists
Fastball (DCAU)
Felix Faust
Fernus
Firefly
Floronic Man
Galatea (JLU)
Garn Daanuth
General
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU)
Gentleman Ghost (Superfriends)
Getaway Mastermind
Giganta
Giganta (DCAU)
Goldface (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Gray Man
Headmaster Mind
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Imperiex
Jack O'Lantern III
Johnny Sorrow
Joker
Julian September
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
KGBeast (DCAU)
Kid Amazo
Kilg%re
Killer Frost
Killer Frost (DCAU)
Kromm
Lex Luthor
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends)
Libra
Livewire (DCAU)
Lord of Time
Malefic
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Menagerie Man (Superfriends)
Merlyn
Metallo (DCAU)
Metallo (Justice)
Mirror Master (Superfriends)
Mister Nebula
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nebula Man
Nekron
Neron
Overmaster
Paragon
Parasite
Parasite (DCAU)
Penguin
Per Degaton
Plastique
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Queen of Fables
Qwisp
Rama Khan
Rampage (DCAU)
Riddler
Royal Flush Gang
Saturna
Sayyar
Scarecrow
Scarecrow (Superfriends)
Scarlet Skier
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Silver Banshee (DCAU)
Sinestro
Siren
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Spaceman X
Spirit King
Star Sapphire III
Starbreaker
Starro
Steppenwolf
Superboy-Prime
T.O. Morrow
Tala (DCAU)
Tattooed Man
Tender Mercy
Tornado Tyrant
Toyman
Toyman (DCAU)
Toyman (Superfriends)
Triumph
Troll King
Ulitmen (DCAU)
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Wally Tortollini
Wandjina
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Weather Wizard (Superfriends)
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935618 08/09/17 05:00 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
1s for:-

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Black Manta
Blockbuster
Brainstorm
Brimstone
Cadre
Calculator
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Chronos
Circe
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Conglomerate
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Darkseid
Demons Three
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Light
Eclipso
Extremists
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
General
Getaway Mastermind
Gorilla Grodd
Gray Man
Headmaster Mind
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Jack O'Lantern III
Joker
Kanjor Ro
Key
Killer Frost
Lex Luthor
Libra
Lord of Time
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Merlyn
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nebula Man
Nekron
Overmaster
Paragon
Per Degaton
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Royal Flush Gang
Saturna
Shaggy Man
Sinestro
Siren
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Spaceman X
Spirit King
Star Sapphire III
Starbreaker
Starro
T.O. Morrow
Tattooed Man
Tornado Tyrant
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Wally Tortollini
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935636 08/09/17 11:01 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
1 point for the following. 0 for the rest.

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Aryan Brigade
Brainstorm
Cadre
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Commander Blanx
Conglomerate
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Demons Three
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Light
Electocutioner
Eurocrime
Extremists
Felix Faust
Garn Daanuth
Getaway Mastermind
Gray Man
Headmaster Mind
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Kanjor Ro
Key
Kromm
Libra
Lord of Time
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Merlyn
Nebula Man
Nekron
Overmaster
Paragon
Professor Ivo
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Royal Flush Gang
Saturna
Sayyar
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Spaceman X
Spirit King
Star Sapphire III
Starbreaker
Starro
T.O. Morrow
Tattooed Man
Tornado Tyrant
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Invisible Brainiac #935637 08/09/17 11:07 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Originally Posted by Invisible Brainiac
re Magog

I remember Magog being OK in JSA proper. He started going downhill in All-Stars, and he was such a horrible character - without nuance - by the time he left that I didn't even care when he died.

His evolution? Well-meaning in JSA, began to question the proactive stance of the team, eventually led to half the team splitting and forming the All-Stars (at that point Magog was still a balanced character IMO). In All-Stars he became more aggressive and ends-justify-the-means. finally, he blasted Cyclone in the middle of a prison riot, and when Power Girl called hin out he just said, "she came up on my blind side". That was such a bad moment that it ruined him completely, changing him from a multi-dimensional character to a caricature that we have seen so often before.


Yeesh. Sounds like I got out of that series at the right time. What a character assassination.

To me, the JSA seems like it would be one of the easiest teams/properties to write/manage, but Willingham proved that he had no idea what he was doing with them, and these writers sound even worse.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935640 08/10/17 05:42 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Agamemno 0
Amazo 1
Amos Fortune 1
Anti-Matter Man 0
Anton Allegro 0
Appelaxians 0
Aquarius 0
Aryan Brigade 0
Asmodel 1
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 0
Bizarro (DCAU) 0
Bizarro (Superfriends) 0
Black Manta 1
Blockbuster 1
Brainiac 1
Brainiac (Superfriends) 0
Brainiac 13 0
Brainstorm 0
Brimstone 1
Cadre 1
Calculator 1
Captain Cold 1
Catwoman 0
Cheetah 1
Cheetah (DCAU) 0
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 0
Cheshire 1
Chronos 1
Circe 1
Clayface (DCAU) 0
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 1
Commander Blanx 0
Conglomerate 1
Construct 1
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 1
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 1
Crowbar (DCAU) 0
Cyborg Superman 1
Darkseid 1
Deadshot 1
Deathstroke 1
Demons Three 1
Desaad 1
Despero 1
Devilray (DCAU Black Manta) 0
Doctor Destiny 1
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 0
Doctor Impossible 0
Doctor Light 1
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 0
Doomsday 1
Eclipso 1
Electocutioner 0
Electocutioner (DCAU) 0
Eurocrime 0
Evil Star (DCAU) 0
Extremists 0
Fastball (DCAU) 0
Felix Faust 1
Fernus 0
Firefly 0
Floronic Man 1
Galatea (JLU) 0
Garn Daanuth 0
General 1
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 0
Gentleman Ghost (Superfriends) 0
Getaway Mastermind 0
Giganta 1
Giganta (DCAU) 0
Goldface (DCAU) 0
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 0
Gray Man 1
Headmaster Mind 0
Hector Hammond 1
Hyathis 0
Hyperclan 0
Imperiex 0
Jack O'Lantern III 1
Johnny Sorrow 1
Joker 1
Julian September 1
Kalibak 1
Kanjor Ro 1
Key 1
KGBeast (DCAU) 0
Kid Amazo 1
Kilg%re 0
Killer Frost 1
Killer Frost (DCAU) 0
Kromm 0
Lex Luthor 1
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 0
Libra 1
Livewire (DCAU) 0
Lord of Time 1
Malefic 0
Manchester Black 0
Manga Khan 1
Manhunters 1
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 1
Menagerie Man (Superfriends) 0
Merlyn 1
Metallo (DCAU) 0
Metallo (Justice) 0
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 0
Mister Nebula 0
Mordru 0
Morgaine Le Fay 0
Nebula Man 1
Nekron 1
Neron 1
Overmaster 1
Paragon 0
Parasite 1
Parasite (DCAU) 0
Penguin 1
Per Degaton 1
Plastique 1
Poison Ivy 1
Professor Ivo 1
Professor Zoom 1
Prometheus 1
Queen Bee 1
Queen Bee II 1
Queen of Fables 1
Qwisp 1
Rama Khan 0
Rampage (DCAU) 0
Riddler 1
Royal Flush Gang 1
Saturna 0
Sayyar 0
Scarecrow 1
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 1
Scarlet Skier 0
Shadow Thief 1
Shaggy Man 1
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 0
Sinestro 1
Siren 0
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 0
Solaris 1
Solomon Grundy 1
Sonar 0
Spaceman X 0
Spirit King 1
Star Sapphire III 0
Starbreaker 0
Starro 1
Steppenwolf 1
Superboy-Prime 0
T.O. Morrow 1
Tala (DCAU) 0
Tattooed Man 1
Tender Mercy 0
Tornado Tyrant 1
Toyman 1
Toyman (DCAU) 0
Toyman (Superfriends) 0
Triumph 1
Troll King 0
Ulitmen (DCAU) 0
Ultra-Humanite 1
Vandal Savage 1
Wally Tortollini 0
Wandjina 0
Warlock of YS 0
Weapons Master 0
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 0
Wizard 1
Xotar the Weapons Master 0

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935724 08/10/17 06:36 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Agamemno 0
Amazo 1
Amos Fortune 1
Anti-Matter Man 0
Anton Allegro 1
Appelaxians 1
Aquarius 0
Aryan Brigade 0
Asmodel 1
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 1
Bizarro (DCAU) 1
Bizarro (Superfriends) 0
Black Manta 1
Blockbuster 1
Brainiac 1
Brainiac (Superfriends) 1
Brainiac 13 0
Brainstorm 1
Brimstone 1
Cadre 1
Calculator 1
Captain Cold 1
Catwoman 1
Cheetah 1
Cheetah (DCAU) 1
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 1
Cheshire 1
Chronos 1
Circe 1
Clayface (DCAU) 1
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 1
Commander Blanx 0
Conglomerate 0
Construct 1
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 1
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 1
Crowbar (DCAU) 1
Cyborg Superman 0
Darkseid 1
Deadshot 1
Deathstroke 1
Demons Three 1
Desaad 1
Despero 1
Devilray (DCAU Black Manta) 0
Doctor Destiny 1
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 0
Doctor Impossible 0
Doctor Light 1
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 0
Doomsday 0
Eclipso 1
Electocutioner 0
Electocutioner (DCAU) 0
Eurocrime 0
Evil Star (DCAU) 1
Extremists 1
Fastball (DCAU) 1
Felix Faust 1
Fernus 0
Firefly 0
Floronic Man 0
Galatea (JLU) 0
Garn Daanuth 0
General 1
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 1
Gentleman Ghost (Superfriends) 0
Getaway Mastermind 0
Giganta 1
Giganta (DCAU) 1
Goldface (DCAU) 0
Gorilla Grodd 1
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 1
Gray Man 0
Headmaster Mind 0
Hector Hammond 1
Hyathis 1
Hyperclan 1
Imperiex 0
Jack O'Lantern III 1
Johnny Sorrow 0
Joker 1
Julian September 1
Kalibak 1
Kanjor Ro 1
Key 1
KGBeast (DCAU) 0
Kid Amazo 0
Kilg%re 0
Killer Frost 0
Killer Frost (DCAU) 1
Kromm 0
Lex Luthor 1
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 1
Libra 0
Livewire (DCAU) 0
Lord of Time 1
Malefic 0
Manchester Black 0
Manga Khan 1
Manhunters 1
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 0
Menagerie Man (Superfriends) 0
Merlyn 0
Metallo (DCAU) 0
Metallo (Justice) 0
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 0
Mister Nebula 0
Mordru 0
Morgaine Le Fay 0
Nebula Man 0
Nekron 0
Neron 1
Overmaster 0
Paragon 0
Parasite 1
Parasite (DCAU) 0
Penguin 0
Per Degaton 1
Plastique 1
Poison Ivy 1
Professor Ivo 1
Professor Zoom 1
Prometheus 1
Queen Bee 1
Queen Bee II 1
Queen of Fables 0
Qwisp 1
Rama Khan 1
Rampage (DCAU) 0
Riddler 0
Royal Flush Gang 1
Saturna 0
Sayyar 0
Scarecrow 0
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 1
Scarlet Skier 0
Shadow Thief 1
Shaggy Man 1
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 0
Sinestro 1
Siren 0
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 0
Solaris 1
Solomon Grundy 1
Sonar 1
Spaceman X 0
Spirit King 0
Star Sapphire III 1
Starbreaker 0
Starro 1
Steppenwolf 0
Superboy-Prime 0
T.O. Morrow 1
Tala (DCAU) 0
Tattooed Man 1
Tender Mercy 0
Tornado Tyrant 1
Toyman 0
Toyman (DCAU) 0
Toyman (Superfriends) 1
Triumph 0
Troll King 0
Ulitmen (DCAU) 0
Ultra-Humanite 1
Vandal Savage 1
Wally Tortollini 0
Wandjina 1
Warlock of YS 1
Weapons Master 1
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 0
Wizard 1
Xotar the Weapons Master 1

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935807 08/12/17 05:11 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
1 point for:

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Asmodel
Atomic Skull (DCAU)
Bizarro (DCAU)
Blockbuster
Brainiac
Brimstone
Cadre
Calculator
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheetah (DCAU)
Cheshire
Chronos
Circe
Clayface (DCAU)
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Cyborg Superman
Darkseid
Deadshot
Demons Three
Desaad
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Destiny (DCAU)
Doctor Light
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends)
Doomsday
Eclipso
Eurocrime
Extremists
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Galatea (JLU)
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU)
Giganta
Giganta (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Hector Hammond
Hyperclan
Imperiex
Jack O'Lantern III
Johnny Sorrow
Joker
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
Kid Amazo
Killer Frost
Killer Frost (DCAU)
Livewire (DCAU)
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Metallo (DCAU)
Metallo (Justice)
Mirror Master (Superfriends)
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nekron
Neron
Overmaster
Parasite
Parasite (DCAU)
Penguin
Plastique
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Rama Khan
Rampage (DCAU)
Riddler
Royal Flush Gang
Scarecrow (Superfriends)
Scarlet Skier
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Silver Banshee (DCAU)
Sinestro
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Star Sapphire III
Starbreaker
Starro
T.O. Morrow
Tala (DCAU)
Tattooed Man
Toyman (DCAU)
Triumph
Ulitmen (DCAU)
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Wally Tortollini
Wandjina
Warlock of YS
Weather Wizard (Superfriends)

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935881 08/13/17 09:29 AM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I will keep this round open at least 24 hours in case anyone else wants wants to vote. If I get no responses by tomorrow night, I will close the round.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #935885 08/13/17 11:41 AM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
1 point each for;
Amazo
Atomic Skull
Black Manta
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheshire
Chronos
Clayface
Deathstroke
Despero
Doctor Impossible
Electrocutioner
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Giganta
Gorilla Grodd
Kalibak
Kid Amazo
Killer Frost
Manhunter
Mark Shaw
Merlyn
Mirror Master
Parasite
Plastique
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Queen Bee
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Silver Banshee
Sonar
T.O. Morrow
Tattooed Man


Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Planning Stage)
Emily Sivana #936005 08/15/17 04:54 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Sorry guys, got preoccupied with a multiplayer game. I will close the round at midnight and post results around 9:00 PM Central US Time.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Emily Sivana #936075 08/16/17 08:34 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Wow, you guys have been busy! Another 17 villains got cut from the list. We will begin normal voting rounds tomorrow. I will copy and paste the rules from the Bat-Villain thread cause it has been awhile since the last game.

Amazo 6
Despero 6
Felix Faust 6
Manhunters 6
Professor Ivo 6
Queen Bee 6
Shaggy Man 6
T.O. Morrow 6
Tattooed Man 6

Amos Fortune 5
Cadre 5
Captain Cold 5
Cheetah 5
Chronos 5
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 5
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 5
Demons Three 5
Doctor Destiny 5
Doctor Light 5
Gorilla Grodd 5
Hector Hammond 5
Kanjor Ro 5
Key 5
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 5
Poison Ivy 5
Queen Bee II 5
Royal Flush Gang 5
Shadow Thief 5
Starro 5

Black Manta 4
Blockbuster 4
Brimstone 4
Calculator 4
Catwoman 4
Cheshire 4
Circe 4
Construct 4
Darkseid 4
Eclipso 4
Extremists 4
Floronic Man 4
Giganta 4
Jack O'Lantern III 4
Joker 4
Kalibak 4
Killer Frost 4
Lord of Time 4
Merlyn 4
Nekron 4
Overmaster 4
Parasite 4
Plastique 4
Sinestro 4
Solaris 4
Solomon Grundy 4
Sonar 4
Star Sapphire III 4
Tornado Tyrant 4
Ultra-Humanite 4
Vandal Savage 4
Warlock of YS 4
Wizard 4

Anton Allegro 3
Appelaxians 3
Asmodel 3
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 3
Brainiac 3
Brainstorm 3
Clayface (DCAU) 3
Conglomerate 3
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 3
Deadshot 3
Deathstroke 3
Desaad 3
General 3
Gray Man 3
Hyathis 3
Hyperclan 3
Kid Amazo 3
Lex Luthor 3
Libra 3
Manga Khan 3
Nebula Man 3
Neron 3
Per Degaton 3
Professor Zoom 3
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 3
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 3
Spirit King 3
Starbreaker 3
Weapons Master 3
Xotar the Weapons Master 3
Anti-Matter Man 2
Aquarius 2
Bizarro (DCAU) 2
Cheetah (DCAU) 2
Cyborg Superman 2
Doctor Impossible 2
Doomsday 2
Electocutioner 2
Eurocrime 2
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 2
Getaway Mastermind 2
Giganta (DCAU) 2
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 2
Headmaster Mind 2
Johnny Sorrow 2
Julian September 2
Killer Frost (DCAU) 2
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 2
Mordru 2
Morgaine Le Fay 2
Paragon 2
Penguin 2
Prometheus 2
Qwisp 2
Rama Khan 2
Riddler 2
Saturna 2
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 2
Spaceman X 2
Triumph 2
Wally Tortollini 2
Wandjina 2
Aryan Brigade 1
Brainiac (Superfriends) 1
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 1
Commander Blanx 1
Crowbar (DCAU) 1
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 1
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 1
Evil Star (DCAU) 1
Fastball (DCAU) 1
Galatea (JLU) 1
Garn Daanuth 1
Imperiex 1
Kromm 1
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 1
Livewire (DCAU) 1
Manchester Black 1
Metallo (DCAU) 1
Metallo (Justice) 1
Parasite (DCAU) 1
Queen of Fables 1
Rampage (DCAU) 1
Sayyar 1
Scarecrow 1
Scarlet Skier 1
Siren 1
Steppenwolf 1
Tala (DCAU) 1
Toyman 1
Toyman (DCAU) 1
Toyman (Superfriends) 1
Ulitmen (DCAU) 1
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 1


Eliminated this Round
Agamemno 0
Bizarro (Superfriends) 0 <-- I think he is funny in all carnations, makes for a good brick.
Brainiac 13 0
Devilray (DCAU Black Manta) 0 <-- The story is that Aquaman characters were in legal tangles regarding rights so they couldn't use the name Black Manta
Electocutioner (DCAU) 0
Fernus 0
Firefly 0
Gentleman Ghost (Superfriends) 0 <-- I love how his design.
Goldface (DCAU) 0
KGBeast (DCAU) 0
Kilg%re 0
Malefic 0
Menagerie Man (Superfriends) 0
Mister Nebula 0
Superboy-Prime 0
Tender Mercy 0
Troll King 0


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Emily Sivana #936137 08/17/17 04:37 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legion of Doom Headquarters Rules: Bottom of post reserved for editing.

1) Each round will last about 48 hours. I will try to end each round at the same time, but this won't always be possible because of other circumstances. I will push dates when there is a major holiday coming up.
2) I'll vote do my best to vote at the start of every round to minimize bias on my part.
3) I don't actively encourage editing of votes; it's a smart tactic but may be unfair for those who don't get to log on as often. However, I won't disallow them either. I'll only tally votes at the end of each round (to make it easier on myself!). I'll post on this thread the minute I start tallying to alert everyone; votes that come in after that will be ignored.
4) In case of errors in the results, I'll post a correction immediately. If anyone's vote was affected by the error, that poster will be notified by PM immediately. If the poster cannot correct his/her votes before the end of the round, he/she will get a makeup point next round - a +15 bonus. This only applies to instances where I made the error, and not where the poster made an error.
5) We will assign points based on an announced scale before each round. The more points you give a character, the higher the chance they will have for a high averaged percentage. I divide total scores for characters by the highest scored character to give a percentage. Characters below a specific rank will be sent home. The scale system will be set aside for simple adding during the Semi-Final Rounds.
6) Because several characters have multiple versions,please specify which character you are voting for.

Please define characters by Age or Common Universe Name (i.e Kingdom Come) if there is more than one known version.

The Current Scale is 5 (5, 15, 20...50)
Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Aryan Brigade
Asmodel
Atomic Skull (DCAU)
Bizarro (DCAU)
Black Manta
Blockbuster
Brainiac
Brainiac (Superfriends)
Brainstorm
Brimstone
Cadre
Calculator
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheetah (DCAU)
Cheetah (Super-Friends)
Cheshire
Chronos
Circe
Clayface (DCAU)
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Commander Blanx
Conglomerate
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Crowbar (DCAU)
Cyborg Superman
Darkseid
Deadshot
Deathstroke
Demons Three
Desaad
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Destiny (DCAU)
Doctor Impossible
Doctor Light
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends)
Doomsday
Eclipso
Electocutioner
Eurocrime
Evil Star (DCAU)
Extremists
Fastball (DCAU)
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Galatea (JLU)
Garn Daanuth
General
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU)
Getaway Mastermind
Giganta
Giganta (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Gray Man
Headmaster Mind
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Imperiex
Jack O'Lantern III
Johnny Sorrow
Joker
Julian September
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
Kid Amazo
Killer Frost
Killer Frost (DCAU)
Kromm
Lex Luthor
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends)
Libra
Livewire (DCAU)
Lord of Time
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Merlyn
Metallo (DCAU)
Metallo (Justice)
Mirror Master (Superfriends)
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nebula Man
Nekron
Neron
Overmaster
Paragon
Parasite
Parasite (DCAU)
Penguin
Per Degaton
Plastique
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Queen of Fables
Qwisp
Rama Khan
Rampage (DCAU)
Riddler
Royal Flush Gang
Saturna
Sayyar
Scarecrow
Scarecrow (Superfriends)
Scarlet Skier
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Silver Banshee (DCAU)
Sinestro
Siren
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Spaceman X
Spirit King
Star Sapphire III
Starbreaker
Starro
Steppenwolf
T.O. Morrow
Tala (DCAU)
Tattooed Man
Tornado Tyrant
Toyman
Toyman (DCAU)
Toyman (Superfriends)
Triumph
Ulitmen (DCAU)
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Wally Tortollini
Wandjina
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Weather Wizard (Superfriends)
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master


The Round begins now, but I expect to run this Round through the weekend I apologize for posting so late.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Emily Sivana #936147 08/17/17 09:19 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Amazo 30
Amos Fortune 25
Anti-Matter Man 15
Anton Allegro 15
Appelaxians 5
Aquarius 5
Aryan Brigade 15
Asmodel 20
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 25
Bizarro (DCAU) 30
Black Manta 50
Blockbuster 20
Brainiac 40
Brainiac (Superfriends) 50
Brainstorm 5
Brimstone 25
Cadre 5
Calculator 45
Captain Cold 40
Catwoman 40
Cheetah 50
Cheetah (DCAU) 25
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 50
Cheshire 30
Chronos 20
Circe 40
Clayface (DCAU) 50
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 15
Commander Blanx 15
Conglomerate 5
Construct 15
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 35
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 30
Crowbar (DCAU) 15
Cyborg Superman 25
Darkseid 40
Deadshot 35
Deathstroke 50
Demons Three 35
Desaad 30
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 40
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 35
Doctor Impossible 20
Doctor Light 15
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 50 (I'm obligated)
Doomsday 40
Eclipso 25
Electocutioner 50
Eurocrime 15
Evil Star (DCAU) 25
Extremists 10
Fastball (DCAU) 25
Felix Faust 40
Floronic Man 30
Galatea (JLU) 50
Garn Daanuth 5
General 15
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 50
Getaway Mastermind 15
Giganta 40
Giganta (DCAU) 50
Gorilla Grodd 40
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 50
Gray Man 10
Headmaster Mind 10
Hector Hammond 15
Hyathis 40
Hyperclan 5
Imperiex 5
Jack O'Lantern III 5
Johnny Sorrow 15
Joker 40
Julian September 5
Kalibak 20
Kanjor Ro 50
Key 35
Kid Amazo 15
Killer Frost 50
Killer Frost (DCAU) 25
Kromm 5
Lex Luthor 50
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 10
Livewire (DCAU) 50
Lord of Time 15
Manchester Black 30
Manga Khan 5
Manhunters 25
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 5
Merlyn 40
Metallo (DCAU) 40
Metallo (Justice) 50
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 50
Mordru 5
Morgaine Le Fay 15
Nebula Man 0
Nekron 0
Neron 15
Overmaster 25
Paragon 10
Parasite 40
Parasite (DCAU) 50
Penguin 30
Per Degaton 15
Plastique 30
Poison Ivy 30
Professor Ivo 40
Professor Zoom 50
Prometheus 30
Queen Bee 30
Queen Bee II 5
Queen of Fables 15
Qwisp 5
Rama Khan 5
Rampage (DCAU) 15
Riddler 40
Royal Flush Gang 35
Saturna 5
Sayyar 5
Scarecrow 50
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 5
Scarlet Skier 15
Shadow Thief 30
Shaggy Man 5
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 50
Sinestro 40
Siren 10
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 20
Solaris 5
Solomon Grundy 10
Sonar 5
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 5
Star Sapphire III 50
Starbreaker 5
Starro 50
Steppenwolf 25
T.O. Morrow 35
Tala (DCAU) 50
Tattooed Man 20
Tornado Tyrant 50
Toyman 15
Toyman (DCAU) 50
Toyman (Superfriends) 25
Triumph 25
Ulitmen (DCAU) 25
Ultra-Humanite 15
Vandal Savage 5
Wally Tortollini 5
Wandjina 10
Warlock of YS 5
Weapons Master 15
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 50
Wizard 40
Xotar the Weapons Master 40


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Emily Sivana #936151 08/18/17 02:55 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Reading those rules brought a smile to my face smile Thanks, Emily

re eliminations - not surprised Superboy-Prime went home. I heard he was intended to satirize whiny fans, but gosh he was annoying! And his killing of Kinetix, 3boot Sun Boy and 3boot Element Lad did NOT help. (As an aside, what is it with versions of Dirk often getting killed? 5YL, the horrible last Retroboot story that is not canon :p, and Threeboot? and Gim - Reboot and Superboy's Legion. some Legionnaires have all the un-luck!)

OK, lots of rambling there...

I agree Superfriends Bizarro was funny, but I prefer other versions.

Gentleman Ghost has an interesting concept, but I also prefer other versions.

I got curious about Tender Mercy. She has an interesting name...

Amazo 40
Amos Fortune 35
Anti-Matter Man 5
Anton Allegro 5
Appelaxians 20
Aquarius 5
Aryan Brigade 10
Asmodel 10
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 50
Bizarro (DCAU) 50
Black Manta 10
Blockbuster 10
Brainiac 50
Brainiac (Superfriends) 30
Brainstorm 5
Brimstone 50
Cadre 30
Calculator 15
Captain Cold 10
Catwoman 50
Cheetah 40
Cheetah (DCAU) 50
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 5
Cheshire 25
Chronos 20
Circe 50
Clayface (DCAU) 50
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 50
Commander Blanx 5
Conglomerate 5
Construct 5
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 30
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 50
Crowbar (DCAU) 5
Cyborg Superman 50
Darkseid 50
Deadshot 50
Deathstroke 5
Demons Three 50
Desaad 40
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 40
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 40
Doctor Impossible 5
Doctor Light 30
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 35
Doomsday 40
Eclipso 50
Electocutioner 10
Eurocrime 50
Evil Star (DCAU) 5
Extremists 5
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 20
Galatea (JLU) 50
Garn Daanuth 5
General 5
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 30
Getaway Mastermind 5
Giganta 50
Giganta (DCAU) 50
Gorilla Grodd 50
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 50
Gray Man 20
Headmaster Mind 5
Hector Hammond 30
Hyathis 5
Hyperclan 5
Imperiex 5
Jack O'Lantern III 10
Johnny Sorrow 5
Joker 5
Julian September 5
Kalibak 5
Kanjor Ro 15
Key 5
Kid Amazo 5
Killer Frost 50
Killer Frost (DCAU) 45
Kromm 5
Lex Luthor 5
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 5
Livewire (DCAU) 40
Lord of Time 5
Manchester Black 50
Manga Khan 50
Manhunters 5
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 5
Merlyn 5
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 5
Mordru 50
Morgaine Le Fay 50
Nebula Man 5
Nekron 5
Neron 45
Overmaster 5
Paragon 5
Parasite 50
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 15
Per Degaton 5
Plastique 50
Poison Ivy 50
Professor Ivo 30
Professor Zoom 15
Prometheus 5
Queen Bee 50
Queen Bee II 50
Queen of Fables 25
Qwisp 20
Rama Khan 5
Rampage (DCAU) 20
Riddler 5
Royal Flush Gang 50
Saturna 5
Sayyar 5
Scarecrow 5
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 5
Scarlet Skier 50
Shadow Thief 10
Shaggy Man 20
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 20
Sinestro 30
Siren 5
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 5
Solaris 5
Solomon Grundy 50
Sonar 50
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 5
Star Sapphire III 50
Starbreaker 50
Starro 50
Steppenwolf 5
T.O. Morrow 30
Tala (DCAU) 50
Tattooed Man 5
Tornado Tyrant 5
Toyman 5
Toyman (DCAU) 50
Toyman (Superfriends) 5
Triumph 50
Ulitmen (DCAU) 40
Ultra-Humanite 35
Vandal Savage 5
Wally Tortollini 5
Wandjina 50
Warlock of YS 5
Weapons Master 5
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 5
Xotar the Weapons Master 5

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Emily Sivana #936156 08/18/17 05:24 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 50
Anti-Matter Man 5
Anton Allegro 5
Appelaxians 5
Aquarius 5
Aryan Brigade 5
Asmodel 50
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 5
Bizarro (DCAU) 5
Black Manta 5
Blockbuster 50
Brainiac 5
Brainiac (Superfriends) 5
Brainstorm 5
Brimstone 50
Cadre 5
Calculator 5
Captain Cold 5
Catwoman 5
Cheetah 50
Cheetah (DCAU) 5
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 5
Cheshire 5
Chronos 50
Circe 50
Clayface (DCAU) 5
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 5
Commander Blanx 5
Conglomerate 5
Construct 5
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 50
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 50
Crowbar (DCAU) 5
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 5
Deadshot 5
Deathstroke 5
Demons Three 50
Desaad 5
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 50
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 5
Doctor Impossible 5
Doctor Light 5
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 50
Eclipso 50
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 5
Evil Star (DCAU) 5
Extremists 5
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 50
Galatea (JLU) 5
Garn Daanuth 5
General 50
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 5
Getaway Mastermind 5
Giganta 50
Giganta (DCAU) 5
Gorilla Grodd 50
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 5
Gray Man 5
Headmaster Mind 5
Hector Hammond 5
Hyathis 5
Hyperclan 5
Imperiex 5
Jack O'Lantern III 5
Johnny Sorrow 5
Joker 5
Julian September 5
Kalibak 5
Kanjor Ro 50
Key 50
Kid Amazo 50
Killer Frost 5
Killer Frost (DCAU) 5
Kromm 5
Lex Luthor 50
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 50
Livewire (DCAU) 5
Lord of Time 50
Manchester Black 5
Manga Khan 5
Manhunters 50
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 50
Merlyn 5
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 5
Mordru 5
Morgaine Le Fay 5
Nebula Man 50
Nekron 5
Neron 50
Overmaster 5
Paragon 5
Parasite 5
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 5
Per Degaton 50
Plastique 5
Poison Ivy 5
Professor Ivo 50
Professor Zoom 5
Prometheus 50
Queen Bee 50
Queen Bee II 5
Queen of Fables 5
Qwisp 5
Rama Khan 5
Rampage (DCAU) 5
Riddler 5
Royal Flush Gang 50
Saturna 5
Sayyar 5
Scarecrow 5
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 5
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 5
Shaggy Man 50
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 5
Sinestro 5
Siren 5
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 5
Solaris 50
Solomon Grundy 50
Sonar 5
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 5
Star Sapphire III 5
Starbreaker 5
Starro 50
Steppenwolf 5
T.O. Morrow 50
Tala (DCAU) 5
Tattooed Man 5
Tornado Tyrant 5
Toyman 5
Toyman (DCAU) 5
Toyman (Superfriends) 5
Triumph 5
Ulitmen (DCAU) 5
Ultra-Humanite 5
Vandal Savage 5
Wally Tortollini 5
Wandjina 5
Warlock of YS 5
Weapons Master 5
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 5
Xotar the Weapons Master 5

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Emily Sivana #936193 08/18/17 01:30 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 50
Anti-Matter Man 50
Anton Allegro 50
Appelaxians 50
Aquarius 50
Aryan Brigade 50
Asmodel 5
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 5
Bizarro (DCAU) 5
Black Manta 5
Blockbuster 5
Brainiac 5
Brainiac (Superfriends) 5
Brainstorm 50
Brimstone 5
Cadre 50
Calculator 5
Captain Cold 5
Catwoman 5
Cheetah 5
Cheetah (DCAU) 5
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 5
Cheshire 5
Chronos 5
Circe 5
Clayface (DCAU) 5
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 5
Commander Blanx 50
Conglomerate 50
Construct 50
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 5
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 50
Crowbar (DCAU) 5
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 5
Deadshot 5
Deathstroke 5
Demons Three 50
Desaad 5
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 50
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 5
Doctor Impossible 5
Doctor Light 50
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 5
Eclipso 5
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 50
Evil Star (DCAU) 5
Extremists 5
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 5
Galatea (JLU) 5
Garn Daanuth 5
General 5
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 5
Getaway Mastermind 5
Giganta 5
Giganta (DCAU) 5
Gorilla Grodd 5
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 5
Gray Man 5
Headmaster Mind 5
Hector Hammond 50
Hyathis 50
Hyperclan 5
Imperiex 5
Jack O'Lantern III 5
Johnny Sorrow 5
Joker 5
Julian September 5
Kalibak 5
Kanjor Ro 50
Key 50
Kid Amazo 5
Killer Frost 5
Killer Frost (DCAU) 5
Kromm 5
Lex Luthor 5
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 50
Livewire (DCAU) 5
Lord of Time 50
Manchester Black 5
Manga Khan 5
Manhunters 50
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 50
Merlyn 50
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 5
Mordru 5
Morgaine Le Fay 5
Nebula Man 5
Nekron 5
Neron 5
Overmaster 50
Paragon 50
Parasite 5
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 5
Per Degaton 5
Plastique 5
Poison Ivy 5
Professor Ivo 50
Professor Zoom 5
Prometheus 5
Queen Bee 50
Queen Bee II 50
Queen of Fables 5
Qwisp 5
Rama Khan 5
Rampage (DCAU) 5
Riddler 5
Royal Flush Gang 50
Saturna 5
Sayyar 5
Scarecrow 5
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 5
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 5
Shaggy Man 50
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 5
Sinestro 5
Siren 5
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 5
Solaris 5
Solomon Grundy 5
Sonar 50
Spaceman X 50
Spirit King 50
Star Sapphire III 5
Starbreaker 50
Starro 50
Steppenwolf 5
T.O. Morrow 50
Tala (DCAU) 5
Tattooed Man 5
Tornado Tyrant 50
Toyman 5
Toyman (DCAU) 5
Toyman (Superfriends) 5
Triumph 5
Ulitmen (DCAU) 5
Ultra-Humanite 5
Vandal Savage 5
Wally Tortollini 5
Wandjina 5
Warlock of YS 50
Weapons Master 50
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 50
Xotar the Weapons Master 50

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Blacula #936194 08/18/17 01:48 PM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 5
Anti-Matter Man 5
Anton Allegro 5
Appelaxians 5
Aquarius 5
Aryan Brigade 5
Asmodel 5
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 50
Bizarro (DCAU) 5
Black Manta 50
Blockbuster 5
Brainiac 5
Brainiac (Superfriends) 5
Brainstorm 50
Brimstone 5
Cadre 50
Calculator 5
Captain Cold 50
Catwoman 5
Cheetah 50
Cheetah (DCAU) 5
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 5
Cheshire 50
Chronos 50
Circe 5
Clayface (DCAU) 50
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 5
Commander Blanx 5
Conglomerate 50
Construct 5
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 5
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 50
Crowbar (DCAU) 5
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 5
Deadshot 5
Deathstroke 50
Demons Three 5
Desaad 5
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 5
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 5
Doctor Impossible 50
Doctor Light 50
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 5
Eclipso 5
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 5
Evil Star (DCAU) 5
Extremists 5
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 50
Galatea (JLU) 5
Garn Daanuth 5
General 5
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 50
Getaway Mastermind 5
Giganta 50
Giganta (DCAU) 50
Gorilla Grodd 50
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 50
Gray Man 5
Headmaster Mind 5
Hector Hammond 5
Hyathis 5
Hyperclan 5
Imperiex 5
Jack O'Lantern III 5
Johnny Sorrow 50
Joker 5
Julian September 5
Kalibak 50
Kanjor Ro 5
Key 5
Kid Amazo 50
Killer Frost 50
Killer Frost (DCAU) 50
Kromm 5
Lex Luthor 5
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 5
Livewire (DCAU) 50
Lord of Time 5
Manchester Black 5
Manga Khan 5
Manhunters 50
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 50
Merlyn 50
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 50
Mordru 5
Morgaine Le Fay 5
Nebula Man 5
Nekron 5
Neron 5
Overmaster 5
Paragon 5
Parasite 50
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 5
Per Degaton 5
Plastique 50
Poison Ivy 5
Professor Ivo 50
Professor Zoom 5
Prometheus 5
Queen Bee 50
Queen Bee II 50
Queen of Fables 5
Qwisp 5
Rama Khan 5
Rampage (DCAU) 5
Riddler 5
Royal Flush Gang 5
Saturna 5
Sayyar 5
Scarecrow 5
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 5
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 50
Shaggy Man 5
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 50
Sinestro 5
Siren 5
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 5
Solaris 5
Solomon Grundy 50
Sonar 50
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 5
Star Sapphire III 5
Starbreaker 5
Starro 5
Steppenwolf 5
T.O. Morrow 50
Tala (DCAU) 5
Tattooed Man 50
Tornado Tyrant 50
Toyman 5
Toyman (DCAU) 5
Toyman (Superfriends) 5
Triumph 5
Ulitmen (DCAU) 50
Ultra-Humanite 5
Vandal Savage 5
Wally Tortollini 5
Wandjina 5
Warlock of YS 5
Weapons Master 5
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 50
Xotar the Weapons Master 5


Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Emily Sivana #936322 08/21/17 10:54 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 35
Anti-Matter Man 5
Anton Allegro 30
Appelaxians 40
Aquarius 5
Aryan Brigade 5
Asmodel 35
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 5
Bizarro (DCAU) 25
Black Manta 25
Blockbuster 25
Brainiac 35
Brainiac (Superfriends) 45
Brainstorm 25
Brimstone 15
Cadre 2535
Calculator 25
Captain Cold 25
Catwoman 25
Cheetah 35
Cheetah (DCAU) 5
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 45
Cheshire 5
Chronos 25
Circe 25
Clayface (DCAU) 5
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 45
Commander Blanx 25
Conglomerate 10
Construct 45
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 50
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 50
Crowbar (DCAU) 35
Cyborg Superman 25
Darkseid 25
Deadshot 25
Deathstroke 25
Demons Three 40
Desaad 5
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 35
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 5
Doctor Impossible 5
Doctor Light 35
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 25
Eclipso 45
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 25
Evil Star (DCAU) 5
Extremists 25
Fastball (DCAU) 25
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 35
Galatea (JLU) 35
Garn Daanuth 5
General 50
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 35
Getaway Mastermind 10
Giganta 45
Giganta (DCAU) 45
Gorilla Grodd 40
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 45
Gray Man 45
Headmaster Mind 5
Hector Hammond 40
Hyathis 25
Hyperclan 40
Imperiex 5
Jack O'Lantern III 25
Johnny Sorrow 25
Joker 35
Julian September 35
Kalibak 25
Kanjor Ro 45
Key 45
Kid Amazo 5
Killer Frost 15
Killer Frost (DCAU) 5
Kromm 5
Lex Luthor 40
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 50
Libra 15
Livewire (DCAU) 5
Lord of Time 50
Manchester Black 15
Manga Khan 35
Manhunters 40
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 25
Merlyn 25
Metallo (DCAU) 25
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 15
Mordru 15
Morgaine Le Fay 15
Nebula Man 25
Nekron 15
Neron 35
Overmaster 35
Paragon 5
Parasite 25
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 15
Per Degaton 35
Plastique 25
Poison Ivy 25
Professor Ivo 50
Professor Zoom 25
Prometheus 40
Queen Bee 45
Queen Bee II 35
Queen of Fables 25
Qwisp 35
Rama Khan 25
Rampage (DCAU) 5
Riddler 25
Royal Flush Gang 50
Saturna 5
Sayyar 5
Scarecrow 25
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 25
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 25
Shaggy Man 40
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 5
Sinestro 25
Siren 5
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 15
Solaris 40
Solomon Grundy 35
Sonar 35
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 15
Star Sapphire III 25
Starbreaker 40
Starro 50
Steppenwolf 5
T.O. Morrow 45
Tala (DCAU) 15
Tattooed Man 25
Tornado Tyrant 40
Toyman 25
Toyman (DCAU) 5
Toyman (Superfriends) 35
Triumph 15
Ulitmen (DCAU) 15
Ultra-Humanite 35
Vandal Savage 35
Wally Tortollini 5
Wandjina 5
Warlock of YS 5
Weapons Master 30
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 25
Xotar the Weapons Master 40

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Emily Sivana #936389 08/22/17 12:14 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I will keep this open until tomorrow evening at 6:00 PM and post the results shortly later. I want to give a little more time in case thoth lad wants to vote.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Emily Sivana #936433 08/23/17 11:46 AM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Hold the Polling Booth Doors!

Whew!

Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 50
Anti-Matter Man 30
Anton Allegro 30
Appelaxians 40
Aquarius 15
Aryan Brigade 5
Asmodel 10
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 5
Bizarro (DCAU) 5
Black Manta 10
Blockbuster 15
Brainiac 10
Brainiac (Superfriends) 5
Brainstorm 25
Brimstone 15
Cadre 30
Calculator 10
Captain Cold 20
Catwoman 15
Cheetah 30
Cheetah (DCAU) 5
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 5
Cheshire 5
Chronos 20
Circe 20
Clayface (DCAU) 5
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 10
Commander Blanx 15
Conglomerate 10
Construct 35
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 5
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 5
Crowbar (DCAU) 5
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 40
Deadshot 5
Deathstroke 5
Demons Three 40
Desaad 5
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 40
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 5
Doctor Impossible 5
Doctor Light 40
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 5
Eclipso 15
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 5
Evil Star (DCAU) 5
Extremists 15
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 30
Galatea (JLU) 5
Garn Daanuth 10
General 15
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 5
Getaway Mastermind 10
Giganta 5
Giganta (DCAU) 5
Gorilla Grodd 20
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 5
Gray Man 30
Headmaster Mind 15
Hector Hammond 40
Hyathis 20
Hyperclan 15
Imperiex 5
Jack O'Lantern III 20
Johnny Sorrow 5
Joker 20
Julian September 5
Kalibak 5
Kanjor Ro 40
Key 50
Kid Amazo 5
Killer Frost 25
Killer Frost (DCAU) 5
Kromm 10
Lex Luthor 25
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 10
Livewire (DCAU) 5
Lord of Time 50
Manchester Black 5
Manga Khan 10
Manhunters 30
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 35
Merlyn 20
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 5
Mordru 25
Morgaine Le Fay 10
Nebula Man 15
Nekron 15
Neron 5
Overmaster 35
Paragon 40
Parasite 10
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 20
Per Degaton 35
Plastique 5
Poison Ivy 20
Professor Ivo 50
Professor Zoom 10
Prometheus 10
Queen Bee 40
Queen Bee II 30
Queen of Fables 10
Qwisp 10
Rama Khan 5
Rampage (DCAU) 5
Riddler 10
Royal Flush Gang 40
Saturna 15
Sayyar 5
Scarecrow 20
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 5
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 30
Shaggy Man 40
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 5
Sinestro 20
Siren 15
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 30
Solaris 20
Solomon Grundy 20
Sonar 15
Spaceman X 20
Spirit King 15
Star Sapphire III 25
Starbreaker 30
Starro 50
Steppenwolf 5
T.O. Morrow 50
Tala (DCAU) 5
Tattooed Man 30
Tornado Tyrant 30
Toyman 5
Toyman (DCAU) 5
Toyman (Superfriends) 5
Triumph 10
Ulitmen (DCAU) 5
Ultra-Humanite 50
Vandal Savage 10
Wally Tortollini 25
Wandjina 30
Warlock of YS 30
Weapons Master 50
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 50
Xotar the Weapons Master 50

Last edited by thoth lad; 08/24/17 11:22 AM. Reason: Gave points to Zoom

"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 2)
Emily Sivana #936449 08/23/17 08:20 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I am withholding the final tally as I had to send a few PMs due to ballot issues. I appreciate your patience during this time.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #936521 08/25/17 05:14 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Classic JLA villains from early runs dominate the top of the list this round, with a handful of cartoon stars filling out the B list. Amazo and Professor Ivo tied this round for the number 1 spot. All characters with less than 20% of the vote have been eliminated.


Amazo 320 100%
Professor Ivo 320 100%

Queen Bee 315 98%
Felix Faust 310 97%
T.O. Morrow 310 97%
Starro 305 95%
Despero 290 91%

Royal Flush Gang 280 88%
Demons Three 270 84%
Cheetah 260 81%
Doctor Destiny 260 81%
Gorilla Grodd 255 80%
Kanjor Ro 255 80%
Amos Fortune 250 78%
Manhunters 250 78%
Giganta 245 77%
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 240 75%
Key 240 75%
Tornado Tyrant 230 72%
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 225 70%
Doctor Light 225 70%
Lord of Time 225 70%
Queen Bee II 225 70%
Wizard 225 70%

Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 220 69%
Solomon Grundy 220 69%
Clayface (DCAU) 215 67%
Floronic Man 215 67%
Giganta (DCAU) 210 66%
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 210 66%
Shaggy Man 210 66%
Sonar 210 66%
Cadre 205 64%
Killer Frost 200 63%
Circe 195 61%
Eclipso 195 61%
Merlyn 195 61%
Xotar the Weapons Master 195 61%

Black Manta 185 58%
Hector Hammond 185 58%
Parasite 185 58%
Starbreaker 185 58%
General 180 56%
Lex Luthor 180 56%
Darkseid 170 53%
Doomsday 170 53%
Plastique 170 53%
Brainstorm 165 52%
Brimstone 165 52%
Commander Blanx 165 52%
Star Sapphire III 165 52%
Construct 160 50%
Livewire (DCAU) 160 50%
Neron 160 50%
Overmaster 160 50%
Weapons Master 160 50%

Captain Cold 155 48%
Eurocrime 155 48%
Shadow Thief 155 48%
Brainiac 150 47%
Hyathis 150 47%
Per Degaton 150 47%
Ultra-Humanite 150 47%
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 145 45%
Brainiac (Superfriends) 145 45%
Catwoman 145 45%
Chronos 145 45%
Deathstroke 145 45%
Galatea (JLU) 145 45%
Libra 145 45%
Prometheus 145 45%
Spirit King 145 45%
Ulitmen (DCAU) 145 45%
Anton Allegro 140 44%
Killer Frost (DCAU) 140 44%
Poison Ivy 140 44%
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 140 44%
Tattooed Man 140 44%
Appelaxians 135 42%
Asmodel 135 42%
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 135 42%
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 135 42%
Kid Amazo 135 42%
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 135 42%
Tala (DCAU) 135 42%
Blockbuster 130 41%
Deadshot 130 41%
Sinestro 130 41%
Solaris 130 41%

Bizarro (DCAU) 125 39%
Cheshire 125 39%
Toyman (DCAU) 125 39%
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 120 38%
Cyborg Superman 120 38%
Gray Man 120 38%
Paragon 120 38%
Anti-Matter Man 115 36%
Joker 115 36%
Kalibak 115 36%
Manchester Black 115 36%
Manga Khan 115 36%
Professor Zoom 115 36%
Scarecrow 115 36%
Triumph 115 36%
Calculator 110 34%
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 110 34%
Johnny Sorrow 110 34%
Mordru 110 34%
Nebula Man 110 34%
Wandjina 110 34%
Morgaine Le Fay 105 33%
Warlock of YS 105 33%
Cheetah (DCAU) 100 31%
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 100 31%
Aryan Brigade 95 30%
Desaad 95 30%
Doctor Impossible 95 30%
Penguin 95 30%
Riddler 95 30%
Spaceman X 95 30%

Aquarius 90 28%
Conglomerate 90 28%
Metallo (DCAU) 90 28%
Queen of Fables 90 28%
Scarlet Skier 90 28%
Electocutioner 85 27%
Qwisp 85 27%
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 85 27%
Toyman (Superfriends) 85 27%
Hyperclan 80 25%
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 80 25%
Metallo (Justice) 80 25%
Parasite (DCAU) 80 25%
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 80 25%
Crowbar (DCAU) 75 23%
Extremists 75 23%
Fastball (DCAU) 75 23%
Jack O'Lantern III 75 23%
Vandal Savage 70 22%
Garn Daanuth 65 20%
Julian September 65 20%
Toyman 65 20%


Eliminated This Round
Rampage (DCAU) 60 19% <-- I like all the obscure characters the DCAU got to fill the ranks of the Society
Evil Star (DCAU) 55 17%
Getaway Mastermind 55 17%
Nekron 55 17%
Rama Khan 55 17%
Scarecrow (Superfriends) 55 17%
Steppenwolf 55 17%
Wally Tortollini 55 17%
Headmaster Mind 50 16%
Siren 50 16%
Saturna 45 14%
Kromm 40 13%
Imperiex 35 11%
Sayyar 35 11%


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #936530 08/25/17 07:53 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Rama Khan!!!! Oh no!!!! How could that villain not score higher? Or Getaway Mastermind?

Yes these are the stuff of legends

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #936677 08/28/17 04:34 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Has anyone been absent from the board recently due to the hurricane? If not, I will start the next round soon.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #936751 08/30/17 05:05 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Round 4- We are keeping the same scale for now. If we begin to have diminishing numbers of eliminated characters, I will change the scale next round.

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Aryan Brigade
Asmodel
Atomic Skull (DCAU)
Bizarro (DCAU)
Black Manta
Blockbuster
Brainiac
Brainiac (Superfriends)
Brainstorm
Brimstone
Cadre
Calculator
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheetah (DCAU)
Cheetah (Super-Friends)
Cheshire
Chronos
Circe
Clayface (DCAU)
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Commander Blanx
Conglomerate
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Crowbar (DCAU)
Cyborg Superman
Darkseid
Deadshot
Deathstroke
Demons Three
Desaad
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Destiny (DCAU)
Doctor Impossible
Doctor Light
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends)
Doomsday
Eclipso
Electocutioner
Eurocrime
Extremists
Fastball (DCAU)
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Galatea (JLU)
Garn Daanuth
General
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU)
Giganta
Giganta (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Gray Man
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Jack O'Lantern III
Johnny Sorrow
Joker
Julian September
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
Kid Amazo
Killer Frost
Killer Frost (DCAU)
Lex Luthor
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends)
Libra
Livewire (DCAU)
Lord of Time
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Merlyn
Metallo (DCAU)
Metallo (Justice)
Mirror Master (Superfriends)
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nebula Man
Neron
Overmaster
Paragon
Parasite
Parasite (DCAU)
Penguin
Per Degaton
Plastique
Poison Ivy
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Queen of Fables
Qwisp
Riddler
Royal Flush Gang
Scarecrow
Scarlet Skier
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Silver Banshee (DCAU)
Sinestro
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Spaceman X
Spirit King
Star Sapphire III
Starbreaker
Starro
T.O. Morrow
Tala (DCAU)
Tattooed Man
Tornado Tyrant
Toyman
Toyman (DCAU)
Toyman (Superfriends)
Triumph
Ulitmen (DCAU)
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Wandjina
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Weather Wizard (Superfriends)
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #936752 08/30/17 05:15 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
My mind is leaning towards the villains that were on the B-List of rosters and got fleshed out in the cartoons.

Amazo 40
Amos Fortune 10
Anti-Matter Man 5
Anton Allegro 5
Appelaxians 10
Aquarius 10
Aryan Brigade 15
Asmodel 15
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 35
Bizarro (DCAU) 40
Black Manta 30
Blockbuster 20
Brainiac 30
Brainiac (Superfriends) 45
Brainstorm 10
Brimstone 15
Cadre 5
Calculator 25
Captain Cold 20
Catwoman 30
Cheetah 40
Cheetah (DCAU) 20
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 30
Cheshire 10
Chronos 25
Circe 35
Clayface (DCAU) 40
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 15
Commander Blanx 5
Conglomerate 15
Construct 20
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 45
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 35
Crowbar (DCAU) 10
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 25
Deadshot 30
Deathstroke 35
Demons Three 10
Desaad 5
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 35
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 10
Doctor Impossible 15
Doctor Light 5
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 15
Eclipso 25
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 5
Extremists 15
Fastball (DCAU) 10
Felix Faust 35
Floronic Man 10
Galatea (JLU) 50
Garn Daanuth 5
General 10
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 20
Giganta 20
Giganta (DCAU) 50
Gorilla Grodd 25
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 45
Gray Man 10
Hector Hammond 15
Hyathis 25
Hyperclan 20
Jack O'Lantern III 5
Johnny Sorrow 15
Joker 15
Julian September 5
Kalibak 15
Kanjor Ro 30
Key 20
Kid Amazo 15
Killer Frost 25
Killer Frost (DCAU) 35
Lex Luthor 35
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 40
Libra 5
Livewire (DCAU) 20
Lord of Time 5
Manchester Black 20
Manga Khan 5
Manhunters 5
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 10
Merlyn 15
Metallo (DCAU) 15
Metallo (Justice) 30
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 10
Mordru 5
Morgaine Le Fay 5
Nebula Man 5
Neron 15
Overmaster 5
Paragon 10
Parasite 20
Parasite (DCAU) 30
Penguin 15
Per Degaton 20
Plastique 15
Poison Ivy 10
Professor Ivo 35
Professor Zoom 25
Prometheus 15
Queen Bee 5
Queen Bee II 15
Queen of Fables 5
Qwisp 15
Riddler 30
Royal Flush Gang 35
Scarecrow 20
Scarlet Skier 10
Shadow Thief 15
Shaggy Man 20
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 30
Sinestro 25
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 10
Solaris 10
Solomon Grundy 25
Sonar 5
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 10
Star Sapphire III 45
Starbreaker 5
Starro 30
T.O. Morrow 25
Tala (DCAU) 30
Tattooed Man 10
Tornado Tyrant 25
Toyman 15
Toyman (DCAU) 30
Toyman (Superfriends) 25
Triumph 5
Ulitmen (DCAU) 15
Ultra-Humanite 10
Vandal Savage 5
Wandjina 10
Warlock of YS 5
Weapons Master 5
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 20
Wizard 5
Xotar the Weapons Master 5


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #936770 08/31/17 05:18 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 50
Anti-Matter Man 5
Anton Allegro 5
Appelaxians 5
Aquarius 5
Aryan Brigade 5
Asmodel 50
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 5
Bizarro (DCAU) 5
Black Manta 5
Blockbuster 50
Brainiac 5
Brainiac (Superfriends) 5
Brainstorm 5
Brimstone 50
Cadre 5
Calculator 5
Captain Cold 5
Catwoman 5
Cheetah 50
Cheetah (DCAU) 5
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 5
Cheshire 5
Chronos 50
Circe 50
Clayface (DCAU) 5
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 5
Commander Blanx 5
Conglomerate 5
Construct 5
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 50
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 50
Crowbar (DCAU) 5
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 5
Deadshot 5
Deathstroke 5
Demons Three 50
Desaad 5
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 50
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 5
Doctor Impossible 5
Doctor Light 5
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 50
Eclipso 50
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 5
Extremists 5
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 50
Galatea (JLU) 5
Garn Daanuth 5
General 50
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 5
Giganta 50
Giganta (DCAU) 5
Gorilla Grodd 50
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 5
Gray Man 5
Hector Hammond 5
Hyathis 5
Hyperclan 5
Jack O'Lantern III 5
Johnny Sorrow 5
Joker 5
Julian September 5
Kalibak 5
Kanjor Ro 50
Key 50
Kid Amazo 50
Killer Frost 5
Killer Frost (DCAU) 5
Lex Luthor 50
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 50
Livewire (DCAU) 5
Lord of Time 50
Manchester Black 5
Manga Khan 5
Manhunters 50
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 50
Merlyn 5
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 5
Mordru 5
Morgaine Le Fay 5
Nebula Man 50
Neron 50
Overmaster 5
Paragon 5
Parasite 5
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 5
Per Degaton 50
Plastique 5
Poison Ivy 5
Professor Ivo 50
Professor Zoom 5
Prometheus 50
Queen Bee 50
Queen Bee II 5
Queen of Fables 5
Qwisp 5
Riddler 5
Royal Flush Gang 50
Scarecrow 5
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 5
Shaggy Man 50
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 5
Sinestro 5
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 5
Solaris 50
Solomon Grundy 50
Sonar 5
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 5
Star Sapphire III 5
Starbreaker 5
Starro 50
T.O. Morrow 50
Tala (DCAU) 5
Tattooed Man 5
Tornado Tyrant 5
Toyman 5
Toyman (DCAU) 5
Toyman (Superfriends) 5
Triumph 5
Ulitmen (DCAU) 5
Ultra-Humanite 5
Vandal Savage 5
Wandjina 5
Warlock of YS 5
Weapons Master 5
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 5
Xotar the Weapons Master 5

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Dave Hackett #936776 08/31/17 11:59 AM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
Amazo 5
Amos Fortune 5
Anti-Matter Man 5
Anton Allegro 5
Appelaxians 5
Aquarius 5
Aryan Brigade 5
Asmodel 5
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 50
Bizarro (DCAU) 5
Black Manta 50
Blockbuster 50
Brainiac 5
Brainiac (Superfriends) 5
Brainstorm 50
Brimstone 5
Cadre 5
Calculator 5
Captain Cold 50
Catwoman 5
Cheetah 50
Cheetah (DCAU) 5
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 5
Cheshire 50
Chronos 50
Circe 5
Clayface (DCAU) 50
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 5
Commander Blanx 5
Conglomerate 5
Construct 5
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 50
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 50
Crowbar (DCAU) 5
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 5
Deadshot 5
Deathstroke 50
Demons Three 5
Desaad 5
Despero 5
Doctor Destiny 5
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 5
Doctor Impossible 50
Doctor Light 5
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 5
Eclipso 5
Electocutioner 50
Eurocrime 5
Extremists 5
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 50
Galatea (JLU) 5
Garn Daanuth 5
General 5
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 50
Giganta 50
Giganta (DCAU) 50
Gorilla Grodd 50
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 50
Gray Man 5
Hector Hammond 5
Hyathis 5
Hyperclan 5
Jack O'Lantern III 5
Johnny Sorrow 50
Joker 5
Julian September 5
Kalibak 50
Kanjor Ro 5
Key 5
Kid Amazo 50
Killer Frost 50
Killer Frost (DCAU) 50
Lex Luthor 5
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 5
Livewire (DCAU) 50
Lord of Time 5
Manchester Black 5
Manga Khan 5
Manhunters 50
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 50
Merlyn 5
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 50
Mordru 5
Morgaine Le Fay 5
Nebula Man 5
Neron 5
Overmaster 5
Paragon 5
Parasite 50
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 5
Per Degaton 5
Plastique 50
Poison Ivy 5
Professor Ivo 50
Professor Zoom 5
Prometheus 5
Queen Bee 50
Queen Bee II 50
Queen of Fables 5
Qwisp 5
Riddler 5
Royal Flush Gang 5
Scarecrow 5
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 50
Shaggy Man 50
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 50
Sinestro 5
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 5
Solaris 5
Solomon Grundy 50
Sonar 50
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 5
Star Sapphire III 5
Starbreaker 5
Starro 50
T.O. Morrow 50
Tala (DCAU) 5
Tattooed Man 50
Tornado Tyrant 50
Toyman 5
Toyman (DCAU) 5
Toyman (Superfriends) 5
Triumph 5
Ulitmen (DCAU) 50
Ultra-Humanite 5
Vandal Savage 5
Wandjina 5
Warlock of YS 5
Weapons Master 5
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 5
Xotar the Weapons Master 5


Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #936779 08/31/17 02:32 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 35
Anti-Matter Man 5
Anton Allegro 25
Appelaxians 45
Aquarius 5
Aryan Brigade 25
Asmodel 35
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 20
Bizarro (DCAU) 20
Black Manta 25
Blockbuster 25
Brainiac 35
Brainiac (Superfriends) 40
Brainstorm 40
Brimstone 35
Cadre 35
Calculator 20
Captain Cold 25
Catwoman 25
Cheetah 35
Cheetah (DCAU) 35
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 40
Cheshire 5
Chronos 25
Circe 25
Clayface (DCAU) 5
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 40
Commander Blanx 5
Conglomerate 5
Construct 35
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 45
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 45
Crowbar (DCAU) 25
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 35
Deadshot 5
Deathstroke 35
Demons Three 35
Desaad 5
Despero 40
Doctor Destiny 35
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 5
Doctor Impossible 5
Doctor Light 35
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 5
Eclipso 25
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 15
Extremists 15
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 40
Floronic Man 25
Galatea (JLU) 15
Garn Daanuth 5
General 40
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 15
Giganta 25
Giganta (DCAU) 35
Gorilla Grodd 25
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 35
Gray Man 35
Hector Hammond 25
Hyathis 35
Hyperclan 35
Jack O'Lantern III 5
Johnny Sorrow 15
Joker 25
Julian September 35
Kalibak 25
Kanjor Ro 35
Key 40
Kid Amazo 5
Killer Frost 5
Killer Frost (DCAU) 15
Lex Luthor 25
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 40
Libra 25
Livewire (DCAU) 5
Lord of Time 35
Manchester Black 25
Manga Khan 35
Manhunters 35
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 5
Merlyn 5
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 5
Mordru 25
Morgaine Le Fay 25
Nebula Man 25
Neron 5
Overmaster 35
Paragon 5
Parasite 5
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 5
Per Degaton 25
Plastique 5
Poison Ivy 5
Professor Ivo 50
Professor Zoom 25
Prometheus 45
Queen Bee 35
Queen Bee II 45
Queen of Fables 5
Qwisp 35
Riddler 25
Royal Flush Gang 45
Scarecrow 5
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 25
Shaggy Man 45
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 5
Sinestro 25
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 25
Solaris 40
Solomon Grundy 35
Sonar 25
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 25
Star Sapphire III 25
Starbreaker 35
Starro 45
T.O. Morrow 50
Tala (DCAU) 15
Tattooed Man 25
Tornado Tyrant 35
Toyman 25
Toyman (DCAU) 20
Toyman (Superfriends) 35
Triumph 15
Ulitmen (DCAU) 25
Ultra-Humanite 25
Vandal Savage 35
Wandjina 5
Warlock of YS 5
Weapons Master 35
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 25
Xotar the Weapons Master 40

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #936793 08/31/17 04:03 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 50
Anti-Matter Man 50
Anton Allegro 50
Appelaxians 50
Aquarius 50
Aryan Brigade 50
Asmodel 5
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 5
Bizarro (DCAU) 5
Black Manta 5
Blockbuster 5
Brainiac 5
Brainiac (Superfriends) 5
Brainstorm 50
Brimstone 5
Cadre 50
Calculator 5
Captain Cold 5
Catwoman 5
Cheetah 5
Cheetah (DCAU) 5
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 5
Cheshire 5
Chronos 5
Circe 5
Clayface (DCAU) 5
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 5
Commander Blanx 5
Conglomerate 5
Construct 50
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 5
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 50
Crowbar (DCAU) 5
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 5
Deadshot 5
Deathstroke 5
Demons Three 50
Desaad 5
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 50
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 5
Doctor Impossible 5
Doctor Light 50
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 5
Eclipso 5
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 50
Extremists 5
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 5
Galatea (JLU) 5
Garn Daanuth 5
General 5
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 5
Giganta 5
Giganta (DCAU) 5
Gorilla Grodd 5
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 5
Gray Man 5
Hector Hammond 50
Hyathis 50
Hyperclan 5
Jack O'Lantern III 5
Johnny Sorrow 5
Joker 5
Julian September 5
Kalibak 5
Kanjor Ro 50
Key 50
Kid Amazo 5
Killer Frost 5
Killer Frost (DCAU) 5
Lex Luthor 5
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 50
Livewire (DCAU) 5
Lord of Time 50
Manchester Black 5
Manga Khan 5
Manhunters 50
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 50
Merlyn 50
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 5
Mordru 5
Morgaine Le Fay 5
Nebula Man 5
Neron 5
Overmaster 5
Paragon 50
Parasite 5
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 5
Per Degaton 5
Plastique 5
Poison Ivy 5
Professor Ivo 50
Professor Zoom 5
Prometheus 5
Queen Bee 50
Queen Bee II 50
Queen of Fables 5
Qwisp 5
Riddler 5
Royal Flush Gang 50
Scarecrow 5
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 5
Shaggy Man 50
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 5
Sinestro 5
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 5
Solaris 5
Solomon Grundy 5
Sonar 5
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 5
Star Sapphire III 5
Starbreaker 50
Starro 50
T.O. Morrow 50
Tala (DCAU) 5
Tattooed Man 5
Tornado Tyrant 5
Toyman 5
Toyman (DCAU) 5
Toyman (Superfriends) 5
Triumph 5
Ulitmen (DCAU) 5
Ultra-Humanite 5
Vandal Savage 5
Wandjina 5
Warlock of YS 50
Weapons Master 50
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 5
Xotar the Weapons Master 50

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #936804 09/01/17 04:58 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 5
Anti-Matter Man 5
Anton Allegro 5
Appelaxians 5
Aquarius 5
Aryan Brigade 5
Asmodel 5
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 50
Bizarro (DCAU) 50
Black Manta 5
Blockbuster 5
Brainiac 50
Brainiac (Superfriends) 5
Brainstorm 5
Brimstone 50
Cadre 5
Calculator 5
Captain Cold 5
Catwoman 50
Cheetah 5
Cheetah (DCAU) 50
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 5
Cheshire 5
Chronos 5
Circe 5
Clayface (DCAU) 5
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 5
Commander Blanx 5
Conglomerate 5
Construct 5
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 5
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 5
Crowbar (DCAU) 5
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 5
Deadshot 5
Deathstroke 5
Demons Three 5
Desaad 5
Despero 5
Doctor Destiny 5
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 50
Doctor Impossible 5
Doctor Light 5
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 5
Eclipso 5
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 5
Extremists 5
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 5
Floronic Man 5
Galatea (JLU) 50
Garn Daanuth 5
General 5
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 5
Giganta 50
Giganta (DCAU) 50
Gorilla Grodd 50
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 50
Gray Man 5
Hector Hammond 5
Hyathis 5
Hyperclan 5
Jack O'Lantern III 5
Johnny Sorrow 5
Joker 5
Julian September 5
Kalibak 5
Kanjor Ro 50
Key 5
Kid Amazo 5
Killer Frost 50
Killer Frost (DCAU) 50
Lex Luthor 5
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 5
Livewire (DCAU) 5
Lord of Time 5
Manchester Black 30
Manga Khan 50
Manhunters 5
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 5
Merlyn 5
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 5
Mordru 50
Morgaine Le Fay 5
Nebula Man 5
Neron 5
Overmaster 5
Paragon 5
Parasite 5
Parasite (DCAU) 50
Penguin 5
Per Degaton 5
Plastique 5
Poison Ivy 5
Professor Ivo 5
Professor Zoom 5
Prometheus 5
Queen Bee 50
Queen Bee II 50
Queen of Fables 5
Qwisp 5
Riddler 5
Royal Flush Gang 50
Scarecrow 5
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 5
Shaggy Man 5
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 5
Sinestro 5
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 5
Solaris 5
Solomon Grundy 50
Sonar 50
Spaceman X 5
Spirit King 5
Star Sapphire III 50
Starbreaker 30
Starro 50
T.O. Morrow 5
Tala (DCAU) 30
Tattooed Man 30
Tornado Tyrant 5
Toyman 5
Toyman (DCAU) 50
Toyman (Superfriends) 5
Triumph 50
Ulitmen (DCAU) 50
Ultra-Humanite 50
Vandal Savage 5
Wandjina 50
Warlock of YS 5
Weapons Master 5
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 5
Xotar the Weapons Master 5

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #936909 09/03/17 02:20 AM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 40
Anti-Matter Man 35
Anton Allegro 30
Appelaxians 40
Aquarius 30
Aryan Brigade 5
Asmodel 10
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 5
Bizarro (DCAU) 5
Black Manta 20
Blockbuster 20
Brainiac 25
Brainiac (Superfriends) 5
Brainstorm 30
Brimstone 30
Cadre 40
Calculator 20
Captain Cold 35
Catwoman 30
Cheetah 25
Cheetah (DCAU) 5
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 5
Cheshire 5
Chronos 40
Circe 20
Clayface (DCAU) 5
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 30
Commander Blanx 25
Conglomerate 25
Construct 40
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 5
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 40
Crowbar (DCAU) 5
Cyborg Superman 5
Darkseid 35
Deadshot 20
Deathstroke 5
Demons Three 50
Desaad 20
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 50
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 5
Doctor Impossible 5
Doctor Light 40
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 5
Doomsday 5
Eclipso 20
Electocutioner 5
Eurocrime 5
Extremists 20
Fastball (DCAU) 5
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 35
Galatea (JLU) 5
Garn Daanuth 20
General 20
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 5
Giganta 5
Giganta (DCAU) 5
Gorilla Grodd 35
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 5
Gray Man 30
Hector Hammond 40
Hyathis 30
Hyperclan 20
Jack O'Lantern III 30
Johnny Sorrow 5
Joker 30
Julian September 5
Kalibak 5
Kanjor Ro 40
Key 50
Kid Amazo 5
Killer Frost 25
Killer Frost (DCAU) 5
Lex Luthor 30
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 5
Libra 20
Livewire (DCAU) 5
Lord of Time 40
Manchester Black 5
Manga Khan 10
Manhunters 30
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 35
Merlyn 30
Metallo (DCAU) 5
Metallo (Justice) 5
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 5
Mordru 35
Morgaine Le Fay 25
Nebula Man 25
Neron 5
Overmaster 5
Paragon 40
Parasite 15
Parasite (DCAU) 5
Penguin 20
Per Degaton 35
Plastique 5
Poison Ivy 25
Professor Ivo 50
Professor Zoom 5
Prometheus 10
Queen Bee 35
Queen Bee II 25
Queen of Fables 15
Qwisp 10
Riddler 20
Royal Flush Gang 40
Scarecrow 30
Scarlet Skier 5
Shadow Thief 20
Shaggy Man 40
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 5
Sinestro 30
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 40
Solaris 15
Solomon Grundy 30
Sonar 20
Spaceman X 20
Spirit King 10
Star Sapphire III 30
Starbreaker 30
Starro 50
T.O. Morrow 50
Tala (DCAU) 5
Tattooed Man 35
Tornado Tyrant 35
Toyman 10
Toyman (DCAU) 5
Toyman (Superfriends) 5
Triumph 10
Ulitmen (DCAU) 5
Ultra-Humanite 45
Vandal Savage 30
Wandjina 40
Warlock of YS 30
Weapons Master 40
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 5
Wizard 40
Xotar the Weapons Master 40


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 3)
Emily Sivana #937063 09/05/17 05:07 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Since the majority of players have voted, I will close the polls at midnight tonight. I plan to post the results tomorrow evening. I hope everyone had a nice Labor Day holiday.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 4)
Emily Sivana #937123 09/06/17 08:04 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
The winner this round by a large margin is Starro. It is so large in fact that I will look over the remaining characters and adjust the scale for the next round.


Starro 325 100%
Amazo 295 91%
Professor Ivo 290 89%
Felix Faust 280 86%
T.O. Morrow 280 86%
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 275 85%
Queen Bee 275 85%
Royal Flush Gang 275 85%
Kanjor Ro 260 80%
Shaggy Man 260 80%

Despero 250 77%
Solomon Grundy 245 75%
Gorilla Grodd 240 74%
Queen Bee II 240 74%
Doctor Destiny 230 71%

Manhunters 225 69%
Key 220 68%
Cheetah 210 65%
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 205 63%
Demons Three 205 63%
Giganta 205 63%
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 205 63%
Chronos 200 62%
Giganta (DCAU) 200 62%
Amos Fortune 195 60%
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 195 60%

Brainstorm 190 58%
Brimstone 190 58%
Lord of Time 190 58%
Floronic Man 180 55%
Blockbuster 175 54%
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 170 52%
Killer Frost 165 51%
Killer Frost (DCAU) 165 51%

Appelaxians 160 49%
Construct 160 49%
Libra 160 49%
Sonar 160 49%
Starbreaker 160 49%
Tattooed Man 160 49%
Tornado Tyrant 160 49%
Brainiac 155 48%
Hyathis 155 48%
Lex Luthor 155 48%
Ulitmen (DCAU) 155 48%
Catwoman 150 46%
Xotar the Weapons Master 150 46%
Cadre 145 45%
Captain Cold 145 45%
Circe 145 45%
Doctor Light 145 45%
Per Degaton 145 45%
Ultra-Humanite 145 45%
Weapons Master 145 45%
Black Manta 140 43%
Deathstroke 140 43%
Eclipso 135 42%
Galatea (JLU) 135 42%
General 135 42%
Hector Hammond 135 42%
Kid Amazo 135 42%
Prometheus 135 42%
Star Sapphire III 135 42%
Bizarro (DCAU) 130 40%
Mordru 130 40%
Solaris 130 40%

Anton Allegro 125 38%
Asmodel 125 38%
Cheetah (DCAU) 125 38%
Shadow Thief 125 38%
Nebula Man 120 37%
Paragon 120 37%
Toyman (DCAU) 120 37%
Wandjina 120 37%
Clayface (DCAU) 115 35%
Darkseid 115 35%
Manga Khan 115 35%
Merlyn 115 35%
Anti-Matter Man 110 34%
Aquarius 110 34%
Aryan Brigade 110 34%
Brainiac (Superfriends) 110 34%
Kalibak 110 34%
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 105 32%
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 105 32%
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 105 32%
Parasite 105 32%
Parasite (DCAU) 105 32%
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 105 32%
Warlock of YS 105 32%
Johnny Sorrow 100 31%
Sinestro 100 31%

Cheetah (Super-Friends) 95 29%
Gray Man 95 29%
Hyperclan 95 29%
Livewire (DCAU) 95 29%
Manchester Black 95 29%
Riddler 95 29%
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 95 29%
Tala (DCAU) 95 29%
Triumph 95 29%
Doctor Impossible 90 28%
Doomsday 90 28%
Eurocrime 90 28%
Joker 90 28%
Neron 90 28%
Plastique 90 28%
Vandal Savage 90 28%
Wizard 90 28%
Calculator 85 26%
Cheshire 85 26%
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 85 26%
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 85 26%
Toyman (Superfriends) 85 26%
Electocutioner 80 25%
Qwisp 80 25%
Deadshot 75 23%
Morgaine Le Fay 75 23%
Professor Zoom 75 23%
Scarecrow 75 23%
Extremists 70 22%
Toyman 70 22%
Conglomerate 65 20%
Julian September 65 20%
Overmaster 65 20%
Spirit King 65 20%


Eliminated This Round
Crowbar (DCAU) 60 18%
Jack O'Lantern III 60 18%
Metallo (Justice) 60 18%
Penguin 60 18%
Poison Ivy 60 18%
Commander Blanx 55 17%
Desaad 50 15%
Garn Daanuth 50 15%
Spaceman X 50 15%
Weather Wizard (Superfriends) 50 15%
Metallo (DCAU) 45 14%
Queen of Fables 45 14%
Fastball (DCAU) 40 12%
Scarlet Skier 40 12%
Cyborg Superman 35 11%
Doctor Sivana (Superfriends) 35 11%


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 4)
Emily Sivana #937249 09/09/17 03:27 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I am going to change the scale to by 12s (12, 24, 48, etc.) and see if that makes any difference to the scores. I apologize for the long delay in between rounds. I will try to post the redrawn list by the end of this weekend.

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Aryan Brigade
Asmodel
Atomic Skull (DCAU)
Bizarro (DCAU)
Black Manta
Blockbuster
Brainiac
Brainiac (Superfriends)
Brainstorm
Brimstone
Cadre
Calculator
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheetah (DCAU)
Cheetah (Super-Friends)
Cheshire
Chronos
Circe
Clayface (DCAU)
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Conglomerate
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Darkseid
Deadshot
Deathstroke
Demons Three
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Destiny (DCAU)
Doctor Impossible
Doctor Light
Doomsday
Eclipso
Electocutioner
Eurocrime
Extremists
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Galatea (JLU)
General
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU)
Giganta
Giganta (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Gray Man
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Johnny Sorrow
Joker
Julian September
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
Kid Amazo
Killer Frost
Killer Frost (DCAU)
Lex Luthor
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends)
Libra
Livewire (DCAU)
Lord of Time
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Merlyn
Mirror Master (Superfriends)
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nebula Man
Neron
Overmaster
Paragon
Parasite
Parasite (DCAU)
Per Degaton
Plastique
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Qwisp
Riddler
Royal Flush Gang
Scarecrow
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Silver Banshee (DCAU)
Sinestro
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Sonar
Spirit King
Star Sapphire III
Starbreaker
Starro
T.O. Morrow
Tala (DCAU)
Tattooed Man
Tornado Tyrant
Toyman
Toyman (DCAU)
Toyman (Superfriends)
Triumph
Ulitmen (DCAU)
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Wandjina
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master

Last edited by Emily Sivana; 09/10/17 08:02 AM. Reason: New Round

Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937273 09/10/17 08:14 AM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Amazo 60
Amos Fortune 48
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 24
Appelaxians 24
Aquarius 84
Aryan Brigade 12
Asmodel 24
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 84
Bizarro (DCAU) 120
Black Manta 120
Blockbuster 36
Brainiac 36
Brainiac (Superfriends) 60
Brainstorm 24
Brimstone 36
Cadre 60
Calculator 84
Captain Cold 48
Catwoman 36
Cheetah 60
Cheetah (DCAU) 36
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 72
Cheshire 12
Chronos 36
Circe 24
Clayface (DCAU) 96
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 24
Conglomerate 12
Construct 24
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 60
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 36
Darkseid 84
Deadshot 48
Deathstroke 108
Demons Three 36
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 132
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 48
Doctor Impossible 36
Doctor Light 24
Doomsday 12
Eclipso 84
Electocutioner 36
Eurocrime 12
Extremists 48
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 24
Galatea (JLU) 144
General 24
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 84
Giganta 72
Giganta (DCAU) 144
Gorilla Grodd 72
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 144
Gray Man 24
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis 108
Hyperclan 72
Johnny Sorrow 48
Joker 24
Julian September 12
Kalibak 48
Kanjor Ro 132
Key 120
Kid Amazo 72
Killer Frost 72
Killer Frost (DCAU) 36
Lex Luthor 84
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 36
Libra 48
Livewire (DCAU) 60
Lord of Time 24
Manchester Black 24
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 12
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 12
Merlyn 24
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 48
Mordru 36
Morgaine Le Fay 12
Nebula Man 12
Neron 60
Overmaster 12
Paragon 12
Parasite 36
Parasite (DCAU) 60
Per Degaton 36
Plastique 24
Professor Ivo 132
Professor Zoom 84
Prometheus 72
Queen Bee 120
Queen Bee II 60
Qwisp 12
Riddler 36
Royal Flush Gang 120
Scarecrow 12
Shadow Thief 24
Shaggy Man 12
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 84
Sinestro 108
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 36
Sonar 12
Spirit King 24
Star Sapphire III 144
Starbreaker 12
Starro 132
T.O. Morrow 144
Tala (DCAU) 60
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 84
Toyman 12
Toyman (DCAU) 132
Toyman (Superfriends) 60
Triumph 12
Ulitmen (DCAU) 36
Ultra-Humanite 12
Vandal Savage 24
Wandjina 12
Warlock of YS 12
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 36
Xotar the Weapons Master 12


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937274 09/10/17 08:18 AM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Hi Emily. What is the maximum score we can give?

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937275 09/10/17 08:19 AM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
The maximum score is 144, which is 12 times 12. I am trying a longer scale due to the results of the previous round.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937281 09/10/17 09:22 AM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Cool. Thanks.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937282 09/10/17 09:34 AM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 144
Anton Allegro 144
Appelaxians 144
Aquarius 144
Aryan Brigade 144
Asmodel 12
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 12
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Black Manta 12
Blockbuster 12
Brainiac 12
Brainiac (Superfriends) 12
Brainstorm 144
Brimstone 12
Cadre 144
Calculator 12
Captain Cold 12
Catwoman 12
Cheetah 12
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 12
Cheshire 12
Chronos 12
Circe 12
Clayface (DCAU) 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 12
Conglomerate 144
Construct 144
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 12
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 12
Deadshot 12
Deathstroke 12
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Impossible 12
Doctor Light 144
Doomsday 12
Eclipso 12
Electocutioner 12
Eurocrime 144
Extremists 12
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 12
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 12
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta 12
Giganta (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 12
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Gray Man 12
Hector Hammond 144
Hyathis 144
Hyperclan 12
Johnny Sorrow 12
Joker 12
Julian September 12
Kalibak 12
Kanjor Ro 144
Key 144
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost 12
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 12
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 12
Libra 144
Livewire (DCAU) 12
Lord of Time 144
Manchester Black 12
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Merlyn 144
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 12
Mordru 12
Morgaine Le Fay 12
Nebula Man 144
Neron 12
Overmaster 12
Paragon 144
Parasite 12
Parasite (DCAU) 12
Per Degaton 12
Plastique 12
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 12
Prometheus 12
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 144
Qwisp 12
Riddler 12
Royal Flush Gang 144
Scarecrow 12
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 144
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 12
Sinestro 12
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 144
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 12
Sonar 12
Spirit King 12
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 144
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tala (DCAU) 12
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 144
Toyman 12
Toyman (DCAU) 12
Toyman (Superfriends) 12
Triumph 12
Ulitmen (DCAU) 12
Ultra-Humanite 12
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 12
Warlock of YS 144
Weapons Master 144
Wizard 144
Xotar the Weapons Master 144

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937297 09/10/17 11:51 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Aquarius 12
Aryan Brigade 12
Asmodel 144
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 144
Bizarro (DCAU) 144
Black Manta 12
Blockbuster 12
Brainiac 144
Brainiac (Superfriends) 12
Brainstorm 12
Brimstone 144
Cadre 12
Calculator 12
Captain Cold 12
Catwoman 144
Cheetah 12
Cheetah (DCAU) 144
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 12
Cheshire 12
Chronos 144
Circe 144
Clayface (DCAU) 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 144
Conglomerate 12
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 12
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 144
Deadshot 12
Deathstroke 12
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 144
Doctor Impossible 12
Doctor Light 12
Doomsday 144
Eclipso 144
Electocutioner 12
Eurocrime 144
Extremists 144
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 12
Galatea (JLU) 144
General 12
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta 144
Giganta (DCAU) 144
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 144
Gray Man 12
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis 12
Hyperclan 12
Johnny Sorrow 12
Joker 12
Julian September 12
Kalibak 12
Kanjor Ro 144
Key 12
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost 144
Killer Frost (DCAU) 144
Lex Luthor 12
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 12
Libra 12
Livewire (DCAU) 12
Lord of Time 12
Manchester Black 144
Manga Khan 144
Manhunters 12
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 12
Merlyn 12
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 12
Mordru 144
Morgaine Le Fay 144
Nebula Man 12
Neron 144
Overmaster 12
Paragon 12
Parasite 144
Parasite (DCAU) 144
Per Degaton 12
Plastique 144
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 12
Prometheus 12
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 144
Qwisp 12
Riddler 12
Royal Flush Gang 144
Scarecrow 12
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 12
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 12
Sinestro 144
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 144
Sonar 12
Spirit King 12
Star Sapphire III 144
Starbreaker 144
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 12
Tala (DCAU) 12
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 12
Toyman 12
Toyman (DCAU) 144
Toyman (Superfriends) 12
Triumph 144
Ulitmen (DCAU) 144
Ultra-Humanite 144
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 144
Warlock of YS 12
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 12
Xotar the Weapons Master 12

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937316 09/10/17 04:58 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 132
Anti-Matter Man 108
Anton Allegro 96
Appelaxians 144
Aquarius 84
Aryan Brigade 12
Asmodel 60
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 12
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Black Manta 12
Blockbuster 48
Brainiac 60
Brainiac (Superfriends) 12
Brainstorm 96
Brimstone 72
Cadre 96
Calculator 48
Captain Cold 60
Catwoman 48
Cheetah 84
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 12
Cheshire 12
Chronos 72
Circe 72
Clayface (DCAU) 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 72
Conglomerate 60
Construct 120
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 24
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 132
Darkseid 96
Deadshot 48
Deathstroke 36
Demons Three 132
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 132
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Impossible 12
Doctor Light 132
Doomsday 12
Eclipso 72
Electocutioner 12
Eurocrime 12
Extremists 60
Felix Faust 132
Floronic Man 120
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 84
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta 12
Giganta (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 72
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Gray Man 96
Hector Hammond 108
Hyathis 84
Hyperclan 84
Johnny Sorrow 12
Joker 60
Julian September 12
Kalibak 36
Kanjor Ro 132
Key 144
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost 72
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 96
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 12
Libra 60
Livewire (DCAU) 12
Lord of Time 132
Manchester Black 12
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 84
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 96
Merlyn 72
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 12
Mordru 84
Morgaine Le Fay 72
Nebula Man 12
Neron 12
Overmaster 60
Paragon 120
Parasite 72
Parasite (DCAU) 12
Per Degaton 132
Plastique 36
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 48
Prometheus 60
Queen Bee 108
Queen Bee II 96
Qwisp 48
Riddler 60
Royal Flush Gang 120
Scarecrow 72
Shadow Thief 72
Shaggy Man 108
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 12
Sinestro 72
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 120
Solaris 108
Solomon Grundy 72
Sonar 60
Spirit King 36
Star Sapphire III 72
Starbreaker 72
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 132
Tala (DCAU) 12
Tattooed Man 96
Tornado Tyrant 108
Toyman 48
Toyman (DCAU) 12
Toyman (Superfriends) 12
Triumph 24
Ulitmen (DCAU) 12
Ultra-Humanite 132
Vandal Savage 84
Wandjina 72
Warlock of YS 60
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 120
Xotar the Weapons Master 120


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937317 09/10/17 05:34 PM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Aquarius 12
Aryan Brigade 12
Asmodel 144
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 12
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Black Manta 12
Blockbuster 144
Brainiac 12
Brainiac (Superfriends) 12
Brainstorm 12
Brimstone 144
Cadre 12
Calculator 12
Captain Cold 12
Catwoman 12
Cheetah 144
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 12
Cheshire 12
Chronos 144
Circe 144
Clayface (DCAU) 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 12
Conglomerate 12
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 144
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 12
Deadshot 12
Deathstroke 12
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Impossible 12
Doctor Light 12
Doomsday 144
Eclipso 144
Electocutioner 12
Eurocrime 12
Extremists 12
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 144
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 144
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta 144
Giganta (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Gray Man 12
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis 12
Hyperclan 12
Johnny Sorrow 12
Joker 12
Julian September 12
Kalibak 12
Kanjor Ro 144
Key 144
Kid Amazo 144
Killer Frost 12
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 144
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 12
Libra 144
Livewire (DCAU) 12
Lord of Time 144
Manchester Black 12
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Merlyn 12
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 12
Mordru 12
Morgaine Le Fay 12
Nebula Man 144
Neron 144
Overmaster 12
Paragon 12
Parasite 12
Parasite (DCAU) 12
Per Degaton 144
Plastique 12
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 12
Prometheus 144
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 12
Qwisp 12
Riddler 12
Royal Flush Gang 144
Scarecrow 12
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 144
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 12
Sinestro 12
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 144
Solomon Grundy 144
Sonar 12
Spirit King 12
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 12
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tala (DCAU) 12
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 12
Toyman 12
Toyman (DCAU) 12
Toyman (Superfriends) 12
Triumph 12
Ulitmen (DCAU) 12
Ultra-Humanite 12
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 12
Warlock of YS 12
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 12
Xotar the Weapons Master 12

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Dave Hackett #937322 09/10/17 07:57 PM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
Amazo 12
Amos Fortune 12
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Aquarius 12
Aryan Brigade 12
Asmodel 12
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 144
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Black Manta 144
Blockbuster 12
Brainiac 12
Brainiac (Superfriends) 12
Brainstorm 12
Brimstone 12
Cadre 12
Calculator 12
Captain Cold 144
Catwoman 12
Cheetah 144
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 12
Cheshire 144
Chronos 144
Circe 12
Clayface (DCAU) 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 12
Conglomerate 12
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 144
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 12
Deadshot 12
Deathstroke 12
Demons Three 144
Despero 12
Doctor Destiny 12
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Impossible 144
Doctor Light 12
Doomsday 12
Eclipso 12
Electocutioner 12
Eurocrime 12
Extremists 12
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 144
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 12
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 144
Giganta 144
Giganta (DCAU) 144
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Gray Man 12
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis 12
Hyperclan 12
Johnny Sorrow 12
Joker 12
Julian September 12
Kalibak 144
Kanjor Ro 12
Key 12
Kid Amazo 144
Killer Frost 144
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 12
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 12
Libra 12
Livewire (DCAU) 144
Lord of Time 12
Manchester Black 12
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Merlyn 12
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 144
Mordru 12
Morgaine Le Fay 12
Nebula Man 12
Neron 12
Overmaster 12
Paragon 12
Parasite 144
Parasite (DCAU) 12
Per Degaton 12
Plastique 144
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 12
Prometheus 12
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 144
Qwisp 12
Riddler 12
Royal Flush Gang 12
Scarecrow 12
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 12
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 12
Sinestro 12
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 12
Sonar 12
Spirit King 12
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 12
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tala (DCAU) 12
Tattooed Man 144
Tornado Tyrant 144
Toyman 12
Toyman (DCAU) 12
Toyman (Superfriends) 12
Triumph 12
Ulitmen (DCAU) 144
Ultra-Humanite 12
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 12
Warlock of YS 12
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 12
Xotar the Weapons Master 12


Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937353 09/11/17 10:05 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 120
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 72
Appelaxians 96
Aquarius 12
Aryan Brigade 24
Asmodel 96
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 24
Bizarro (DCAU) 48
Black Manta 60
Blockbuster 60
Brainiac 60
Brainiac (Superfriends) 96
Brainstorm 108
Brimstone 96
Cadre 108
Calculator 84
Captain Cold 60
Catwoman 60
Cheetah 72
Cheetah (DCAU) 84
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 84
Cheshire 48
Chronos 48
Circe 48
Clayface (DCAU) 60
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 108
Conglomerate 60
Construct 108
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 96
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 108
Darkseid 96
Deadshot 24
Deathstroke 84
Demons Three 120
Despero 120
Doctor Destiny 108
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 24
Doctor Impossible 72
Doctor Light 96
Doomsday 48
Eclipso 96
Electocutioner 24
Eurocrime 72
Extremists 72
Felix Faust 108
Floronic Man 84
Galatea (JLU) 60
General 120
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 60
Giganta 48
Giganta (DCAU) 24
Gorilla Grodd 60
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 96
Gray Man 48
Hector Hammond 60
Hyathis 96
Hyperclan 108
Johnny Sorrow 60
Joker 96
Julian September 108
Kalibak 48
Kanjor Ro 122
Key 144
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost 24
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 96
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 96
Libra 36
Livewire (DCAU) 12
Lord of Time 108
Manchester Black 12
Manga Khan 96
Manhunters 84
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 36
Merlyn 24
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 36
Mordru 24
Morgaine Le Fay 12
Nebula Man 84
Neron 48
Overmaster 12
Paragon 24
Parasite 36
Parasite (DCAU) 36
Per Degaton 84
Plastique 84
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 36
Prometheus 108
Queen Bee 96
Queen Bee II 108
Qwisp 84
Riddler 48
Royal Flush Gang 120
Scarecrow 48
Shadow Thief 96
Shaggy Man 120
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 24
Sinestro 48
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 36
Solaris 108
Solomon Grundy 84
Sonar 48
Spirit King 48
Star Sapphire III 96
Starbreaker 108
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tala (DCAU) 24
Tattooed Man 84
Tornado Tyrant 96
Toyman 36
Toyman (DCAU) 24
Toyman (Superfriends) 84
Triumph 12
Ulitmen (DCAU) 48
Ultra-Humanite 84
Vandal Savage 96
Wandjina 12
Warlock of YS 72
Weapons Master 96
Wizard 96
Xotar the Weapons Master 108

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937391 09/11/17 06:51 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
We normally have a total of seven players, right?


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937395 09/11/17 10:49 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
I believe so

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937431 09/12/17 04:44 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Cool, I will close the polls now then. I will post the results by tomorrow night. Edit: The experiment was a failure, as it only increased the difference between the highest and second highest amount of votes. I might have to choose a smaller scale next round. If anyone else has any ideas, I am willing to listen. I do not remember having such a high curve in previous Idol games. There is no percentages listed this round as the second highest amount of votes has only 76% of the vote/

Felix Faust 1304
Professor Ivo 996
Starro 996
Queen Bee 900
T.O. Morrow 864
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 852
Despero 852
Kanjor Ro 830
Demons Three 828
Doctor Destiny 816
Royal Flush Gang 804

Amazo 792
Key 720
Queen Bee II 708
Gorilla Grodd 648
Manhunters 624
Amos Fortune 612
Chronos 600
Tornado Tyrant 600
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 588
Giganta 576
Lord of Time 576
Eclipso 564
Shaggy Man 552
Floronic Man 540
Cheetah 528
Brimstone 516
Solomon Grundy 504
Starbreaker 504

Asmodel 492
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 492
Giganta (DCAU) 492
Star Sapphire III 492
Killer Frost 480
Hyathis 468
Circe 456
Darkseid 456
Libra 456
Parasite 456
Plastique 456
Lex Luthor 455
Appelaxians 444
Cadre 444
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 432
Construct 432
Doctor Light 432
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 432
Neron 432
Per Degaton 432
Wizard 432
Nebula Man 420
Prometheus 420
Xotar the Weapons Master 420
Brainstorm 408
Eurocrime 408
General 408
Kid Amazo 408
Sinestro 408
Solaris 408
Ulitmen (DCAU) 408
Ultra-Humanite 408
Wandjina 408

Galatea (JLU) 396
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 384
Doomsday 384
Anton Allegro 372
Black Manta 372
Tattooed Man 372
Aquarius 360
Bizarro (DCAU) 360
Extremists 360
Hector Hammond 360
Captain Cold 348
Cheetah (DCAU) 348
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 348
Toyman (DCAU) 348
Brainiac 336
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 336
Paragon 336
Blockbuster 324
Catwoman 324
Warlock of YS 324
Mordru 315
Anti-Matter Man 312
Conglomerate 312
Hyperclan 312
Kalibak 312
Doctor Impossible 300
Manga Khan 300
Merlyn 300
Weapons Master 300

Cheshire 288
Parasite (DCAU) 288
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 276
Morgaine Le Fay 276
Calculator 264
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 264
Livewire (DCAU) 264
Vandal Savage 252
Killer Frost (DCAU) 240
Shadow Thief 240
Aryan Brigade 228
Joker 228
Manchester Black 228
Triumph 228
Brainiac (Superfriends) 216
Clayface (DCAU) 216
Deathstroke 216
Professor Zoom 216
Gray Man 213
Toyman (Superfriends) 204


Eliminated this Round
Cheetah (Super-Friends) 192 <-- The lack of votes for these versions puzzles me as per the wikis and Justice series they are identical to the Silver Age versions, which normally get a lot of votes in the Idols.
Lex Luthor (Super-Friends) 192
Qwisp 192
Riddler 191
Julian September 180
Scarecrow 180
Deadshot 168
Johnny Sorrow 168
Silver Banshee (DCAU) 168
Sonar 168
Spirit King 156
Tala (DCAU) 144 <-- She was a really cool villain. She might get my Wild Card vote.
Toyman 144<--- I think the TV shows improved upon this character's concept.
Overmaster 132
Electocutioner 120

Last edited by Emily Sivana; 09/13/17 06:02 PM.

Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937497 09/14/17 05:44 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
I think you may need to recount. The highest any character could get was 7X144= 1008. Looks like Faust used his magic powers to grant himself an additional 300 points.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937508 09/14/17 08:16 AM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
Faust is shifty like that.

Not that I'd trust any of these people farther than I could throw them... smile


Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937515 09/14/17 09:32 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Faust cheated? I'm shocked

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937519 09/14/17 11:03 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
I hope he didn't sacrifice anyone's souls to get those 300 points.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937535 09/14/17 04:51 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I recounted the votes and the revised results are below. However, the bottom of the list remained unchanged so no changes to elimination will occur. I am still uncertain what scale to use next round.

Professor Ivo 996
Starro 996
Queen Bee 900
T.O. Morrow 864
Felix Faust 852
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 852
Despero 852
Kanjor Ro 830
Demons Three 828
Doctor Destiny 816
Royal Flush Gang 804
Amazo 792
Key 720
Queen Bee II 708
Gorilla Grodd 648
Manhunters 624
Amos Fortune 612
Chronos 600
Tornado Tyrant 600
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 588
Giganta 576
Lord of Time 576
Eclipso 564
Shaggy Man 552
Floronic Man 540
Cheetah 528
Brimstone 516
Solomon Grundy 504
Starbreaker 504
Asmodel 492
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 492
Giganta (DCAU) 492
Star Sapphire III 492
Killer Frost 480
Hyathis 468
Circe 456
Darkseid 456
Libra 456
Parasite 456
Plastique 456
Lex Luthor 455
Appelaxians 444
Cadre 444
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 432
Construct 432
Doctor Light 432
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 432
Neron 432
Per Degaton 432
Wizard 432
Nebula Man 420
Prometheus 420
Xotar the Weapons Master 420
Brainstorm 408
Eurocrime 408
General 408
Kid Amazo 408
Sinestro 408
Solaris 408
Ulitmen (DCAU) 408
Ultra-Humanite 408
Wandjina 408
Galatea (JLU) 396
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 384
Doomsday 384
Anton Allegro 372
Black Manta 372
Tattooed Man 372
Aquarius 360
Bizarro (DCAU) 360
Extremists 360
Hector Hammond 360
Captain Cold 348
Cheetah (DCAU) 348
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 348
Toyman (DCAU) 348
Brainiac 336
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 336
Paragon 336
Blockbuster 324
Catwoman 324
Warlock of YS 324
Mordru 315
Anti-Matter Man 312
Conglomerate 312
Hyperclan 312
Kalibak 312
Doctor Impossible 300
Manga Khan 300
Merlyn 300
Weapons Master 300
Cheshire 288
Parasite (DCAU) 288
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 276
Morgaine Le Fay 276
Calculator 264
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 264
Livewire (DCAU) 264
Vandal Savage 252
Killer Frost (DCAU) 240
Shadow Thief 240
Aryan Brigade 228
Joker 228
Manchester Black 228
Triumph 228
Brainiac (Superfriends) 216
Clayface (DCAU) 216
Deathstroke 216
Professor Zoom 216
Gray Man 213
Toyman (Superfriends) 204


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937578 09/16/17 08:32 AM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Round 6- We will keep the same scale for now.

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Aryan Brigade
Asmodel
Atomic Skull (DCAU)
Bizarro (DCAU)
Black Manta
Blockbuster
Brainiac
Brainiac (Superfriends)
Brainstorm
Brimstone
Cadre
Calculator
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheetah (DCAU)
Cheshire
Chronos
Circe
Clayface (DCAU)
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Conglomerate
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Darkseid
Deathstroke
Demons Three
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Destiny (DCAU)
Doctor Impossible
Doctor Light
Doomsday
Eclipso
Eurocrime
Extremists
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Galatea (JLU)
General
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU)
Giganta
Giganta (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Gray Man
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Joker
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
Kid Amazo
Killer Frost
Killer Frost (DCAU)
Lex Luthor
Libra
Livewire (DCAU)
Lord of Time
Manchester Black
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Merlyn
Mirror Master (Superfriends)
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nebula Man
Neron
Paragon
Parasite
Parasite (DCAU)
Per Degaton
Plastique
Professor Ivo
Professor Zoom
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Royal Flush Gang
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Sinestro
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Star Sapphire III
Starbreaker
Starro
T.O. Morrow
Tattooed Man
Tornado Tyrant
Toyman (DCAU)
Toyman (Superfriends)
Triumph
Ulitmen (DCAU)
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Wandjina
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937596 09/16/17 03:59 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 132
Anti-Matter Man 108
Anton Allegro 96
Appelaxians 144
Aquarius 84
Aryan Brigade 12
Asmodel 60
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 12
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Black Manta 12
Blockbuster 48
Brainiac (Superfriends) 12
Brainiac 60
Brainstorm 96
Brimstone 72
Cadre 96
Calculator 48
Captain Cold 60
Catwoman 48
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Cheetah 84
Cheshire 12
Chronos 72
Circe 72
Clayface (DCAU) 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 72
Conglomerate 60
Construct 120
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 24
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 132
Darkseid 96
Deathstroke 36
Demons Three 132
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Destiny 132
Doctor Impossible 12
Doctor Light 132
Doomsday 12
Eclipso 72
Eurocrime 12
Extremists 60
Felix Faust 132
Floronic Man 120
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 84
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta (DCAU) 12
Giganta 12
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 72
Gray Man 96
Hector Hammond 108
Hyathis 84
Hyperclan 84
Joker 60
Kalibak 36
Kanjor Ro 132
Key 144
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Killer Frost 72
Lex Luthor 96
Libra 60
Livewire (DCAU) 12
Lord of Time 132
Manchester Black 12
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 84
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 96
Merlyn 72
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 12
Mordru 84
Morgaine Le Fay 72
Nebula Man 12
Neron 12
Paragon 120
Parasite (DCAU) 12
Parasite 72
Per Degaton 132
Plastique 36
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 48
Prometheus 60
Queen Bee 108
Queen Bee II 96
Royal Flush Gang 120
Shadow Thief 72
Shaggy Man 108
Sinestro 72
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 120
Solaris 108
Solomon Grundy 72
Star Sapphire III 72
Starbreaker 72
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 132
Tattooed Man 96
Tornado Tyrant 108
Toyman (DCAU) 12
Toyman (Superfriends) 12
Triumph 24
Ulitmen (DCAU) 12
Ultra-Humanite 132
Vandal Savage 84
Wandjina 72
Warlock of YS 60
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 120
Xotar the Weapons Master 120


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937613 09/17/17 08:32 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Aquarius 12
Aryan Brigade 12
Asmodel 144
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 12
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Black Manta 12
Blockbuster 144
Brainiac 12
Brainiac (Superfriends) 12
Brainstorm 12
Brimstone 144
Cadre 12
Calculator 12
Captain Cold 12
Catwoman 12
Cheetah 144
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Cheshire 12
Chronos 144
Circe 144
Clayface (DCAU) 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 12
Conglomerate 12
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 144
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 12
Deathstroke 12
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Impossible 12
Doctor Light 12
Doomsday 144
Eclipso 144
Eurocrime 12
Extremists 12
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 144
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 144
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta 144
Giganta (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Gray Man 12
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis 12
Hyperclan 12
Joker 12
Kalibak 12
Kanjor Ro 144
Key 144
Kid Amazo 144
Killer Frost 12
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 144
Libra 144
Livewire (DCAU) 12
Lord of Time 144
Manchester Black 12
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Merlyn 12
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 12
Mordru 12
Morgaine Le Fay 12
Nebula Man 144
Neron 144
Paragon 12
Parasite 12
Parasite (DCAU) 12
Per Degaton 144
Plastique 12
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 12
Prometheus 144
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 12
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 144
Sinestro 12
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 144
Solomon Grundy 144
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 12
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 12
Toyman (DCAU) 12
Toyman (Superfriends) 12
Triumph 12
Ulitmen (DCAU) 12
Ultra-Humanite 12
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 12
Warlock of YS 12
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 12
Xotar the Weapons Master 12

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937639 09/17/17 07:27 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 144
Anton Allegro 144
Appelaxians 144
Aquarius 144
Aryan Brigade 144
Asmodel 12
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 12
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Black Manta 12
Blockbuster 12
Brainiac 12
Brainiac (Superfriends) 12
Brainstorm 144
Brimstone 12
Cadre 144
Calculator 12
Captain Cold 12
Catwoman 12
Cheetah 12
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Cheshire 12
Chronos 12
Circe 12
Clayface (DCAU) 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 12
Conglomerate 12
Construct 144
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 12
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 12
Deathstroke 12
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Impossible 12
Doctor Light 144
Doomsday 12
Eclipso 12
Eurocrime 144
Extremists 12
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 12
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 12
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta 12
Giganta (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 12
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Gray Man 12
Hector Hammond 144
Hyathis 144
Hyperclan 12
Joker 12
Kalibak 12
Kanjor Ro 144
Key 144
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost 12
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 12
Libra 144
Livewire (DCAU) 12
Lord of Time 144
Manchester Black 12
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Merlyn 144
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 12
Mordru 12
Morgaine Le Fay 12
Nebula Man 144
Neron 12
Paragon 144
Parasite 12
Parasite (DCAU) 12
Per Degaton 12
Plastique 12
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 12
Prometheus 12
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 144
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 144
Sinestro 12
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 144
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 12
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 144
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 144
Toyman (DCAU) 12
Toyman (Superfriends) 12
Triumph 12
Ultimen (DCAU) 12
Ultra-Humanite 12
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 144
Warlock of YS 144
Weapons Master 144
Wizard 144
Xotar the Weapons Master 144

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Blacula #937641 09/17/17 08:05 PM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
Amazo 12
Amos Fortune 12
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Aquarius 12
Aryan Brigade 12
Asmodel 12
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 144
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Black Manta 144
Blockbuster 12
Brainiac 12
Brainiac (Superfriends) 12
Brainstorm 144
Brimstone 12
Cadre 12
Calculator 12
Captain Cold 144
Catwoman 12
Cheetah 144
Cheetah (DCAU) 144
Cheshire 144
Chronos 144
Circe 12
Clayface (DCAU) 144
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 12
Conglomerate 12
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 144
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 12
Deathstroke 12
Demons Three 12
Despero 12
Doctor Destiny 12
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Impossible 144
Doctor Light 12
Doomsday 12
Eclipso 12
Eurocrime 12
Extremists 12
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 144
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 12
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 144
Giganta 144
Giganta (DCAU) 144
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 144
Gray Man 12
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis 12
Hyperclan 12
Joker 12
Kalibak 144
Kanjor Ro 12
Key 12
Kid Amazo 144
Killer Frost 144
Killer Frost (DCAU) 144
Lex Luthor 12
Libra 12
Livewire (DCAU) 144
Lord of Time 12
Manchester Black 12
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Merlyn 12
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 144
Mordru 12
Morgaine Le Fay 12
Nebula Man 12
Neron 12
Paragon 12
Parasite 144
Parasite (DCAU) 144
Per Degaton 12
Plastique 144
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 12
Prometheus 12
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 144
Royal Flush Gang 12
Shadow Thief 144
Shaggy Man 12
Sinestro 12
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 12
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 12
Starro 12
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 144
Tornado Tyrant 144
Toyman (DCAU) 12
Toyman (Superfriends) 12
Triumph 12
Ultimen (DCAU) 144
Ultra-Humanite 12
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 12
Warlock of YS 12
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 144
Xotar the Weapons Master 12


Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937656 09/18/17 09:17 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 12
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Aquarius 12
Aryan Brigade 12
Asmodel 12
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 144
Bizarro (DCAU) 144
Black Manta 12
Blockbuster 12
Brainiac 144
Brainiac (Superfriends) 12
Brainstorm 12
Brimstone 144
Cadre 12
Calculator 12
Captain Cold 12
Catwoman 144
Cheetah 12
Cheetah (DCAU) 144
Cheshire 12
Chronos 12
Circe 12
Clayface (DCAU) 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 144
Conglomerate 12
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 12
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 12
Deathstroke 12
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 14
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 144
Doctor Impossible 12
Doctor Light 12
Doomsday 12
Eclipso 12
Eurocrime 144
Extremists 12
Felix Faust 12
Floronic Man 12
Galatea (JLU) 144
General 12
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta 144
Giganta (DCAU) 144
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 144
Gray Man 12
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis 12
Hyperclan 12
Joker 12
Kalibak 12
Kanjor Ro 12
Key 12
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost 144
Killer Frost (DCAU) 144
Lex Luthor 12
Libra 12
Livewire (DCAU) 12
Lord of Time 12
Manchester Black 144
Manga Khan 144
Manhunters 12
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 12
Merlyn 12
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 12
Mordru 144
Morgaine Le Fay 144
Nebula Man 12
Neron 144
Paragon 12
Parasite 12
Parasite (DCAU) 12
Per Degaton 12
Plastique 144
Professor Ivo 12
Professor Zoom 12
Prometheus 12
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 144
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 12
Sinestro 12
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 144
Star Sapphire III 144
Starbreaker 144
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 12
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 12
Toyman (DCAU) 144
Toyman (Superfriends) 12
Triumph 144
Ulitmen (DCAU) 144
Ultra-Humanite 144
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 144
Warlock of YS 12
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 12
Xotar the Weapons Master 12

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937700 09/19/17 06:23 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 120
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 84
Appelaxians 84
Aquarius 12
Aryan Brigade 12
Asmodel 84
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 48
Bizarro (DCAU) 72
Black Manta 48
Blockbuster 84
Brainiac 96
Brainiac (Superfriends) 96
Brainstorm 120
Brimstone 48
Cadre 108
Calculator 84
Captain Cold 84
Catwoman 48
Cheetah 84
Cheetah (DCAU) 108
Cheshire 48
Chronos 48
Circe 84
Clayface (DCAU) 48
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 120
Conglomerate 60
Construct 120
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 108
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 120
Darkseid 120
Deathstroke 84
Demons Three 120
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 120
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 48
Doctor Impossible 48
Doctor Light 84
Doomsday 48
Eclipso 84
Eurocrime 48
Extremists 36
Felix Faust 120
Floronic Man 84
Galatea (JLU) 96
General 108
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 72
Giganta 84
Giganta (DCAU) 96
Gorilla Grodd 84
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 96
Gray Man 12
Hector Hammond 84
Hyathis 120
Hyperclan 120
Joker 84
Kalibak 36
Kanjor Ro 120
Key 144
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost 36
Killer Frost (DCAU) 48
Lex Luthor 96
Libra 24
Livewire (DCAU) 12
Lord of Time 144
Manchester Black 12
Manga Khan 120
Manhunters 120
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 24
Merlyn 24
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 36
Mordru 48
Morgaine Le Fay 48
Nebula Man 60
Neron 60
Paragon 12
Parasite 36
Parasite (DCAU) 48
Per Degaton 84
Plastique 60
Professor Ivo 144
Professor Zoom 24
Prometheus 108
Queen Bee 108
Queen Bee II 120
Royal Flush Gang 120
Shadow Thief 84
Shaggy Man 108
Sinestro 84
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 108
Solomon Grundy 48
Star Sapphire III 84
Starbreaker 108
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 96
Tornado Tyrant 108
Toyman (DCAU) 48
Toyman (Superfriends) 96
Triumph 12
Ulitmen (DCAU) 48
Ultra-Humanite 96
Vandal Savage 120
Wandjina 48
Warlock of YS 48
Weapons Master 108
Wizard 84
Xotar the Weapons Master 108

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937772 09/20/17 04:47 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I will end the round in 24 hours and post the results tomorrow night. I will sit out this round because I am exhausted from work related to the recent hurricanes.

Edit: Here are the results. The winner of this round is the Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) . I have decided to eliminate every character with less than 29% this round. Do not worry though, as I anticipate the Wild Card Round will be shortly. We will be eliminating characters at a higher rate if more of them cluster towards the end of the list.

Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 828 100%
Queen Bee 792 96%
Starro 765 92%
Amazo 732 88%
Despero 732 88%
Professor Ivo 732 88%
Demons Three 696 84%
Felix Faust 696 84%
Royal Flush Gang 684 83%
Queen Bee II 660 80%

Manhunters 648 78%
Gorilla Grodd 600 72%
Key 600 72%
Lord of Time 588 71%
T.O. Morrow 588 71%
Doctor Destiny 576 70%
Amos Fortune 564 68%
Kanjor Ro 564 68%
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 564 68%
Giganta 540 65%
Brainstorm 528 64%
Shaggy Man 528 64%
Floronic Man 516 62%
Wizard 516 62%
Cheetah (DCAU) 504 61%
Tattooed Man 504 61%

Starbreaker 492 59%
Star Sapphire III 468 57%
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 444 54%
Brimstone 432 52%
Chronos 432 52%
Solomon Grundy 432 52%
Wandjina 432 52%
Construct 420 51%
Giganta (DCAU) 420 51%
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 420 51%
Killer Frost 420 51%

Appelaxians 408 49%
Cheetah 408 49%
Plastique 408 49%
Ultra-Humanite 408 49%
Xotar the Weapons Master 408 49%
Doctor Light 396 47%
Libra 396 47%
Per Degaton 396 47%
Solaris 396 47%
Tornado Tyrant 396 47%
Cadre 384 46%
Hyathis 384 46%
Nebula Man 384 46%
Neron 384 46%
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 372 45%
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 372 45%
Eurocrime 372 45%
General 372 45%
Hector Hammond 372 45%
Killer Frost (DCAU) 372 45%
Lex Luthor 372 45%
Ulitmen (DCAU) 372 45%
Anton Allegro 360 43%
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 360 43%
Prometheus 348 42%
Brainiac 336 41%
Circe 336 41%
Eclipso 336 41%
Kid Amazo 336 41%
Shadow Thief 336 41%

Asmodel 324 39%
Captain Cold 324 39%
Blockbuster 312 38%
Manga Khan 312 38%
Mordru 312 38%
Paragon 312 38%
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 312 38%
Anti-Matter Man 300 36%
Morgaine Le Fay 300 36%
Weapons Master 300 36%

Galatea (JLU) 288 34%
Parasite 288 34%
Warlock of YS 288 34%
Aquarius 276 33%
Catwoman 276 33%
Merlyn 276 33%
Bizarro (DCAU) 264 32%
Darkseid 264 32%
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 264 32%
Hyperclan 252 30%
Kalibak 252 30%
Vandal Savage 252 30%


Eliminated This Round- So many decent characters bid farewell this round. Maybe some will return soon?
Black Manta 240 29%
Cheshire 240 29%
Clayface (DCAU) 240 29%
Doctor Impossible 240 29%
Doomsday 240 29%
Parasite (DCAU) 240 29%
Toyman (DCAU) 240 29%
Mirror Master (Superfriends) 230 28%
Triumph 216 26%
Aryan Brigade 204 25%
Livewire (DCAU) 204 25%
Manchester Black 204 25%
Sinestro 204 25%
Joker 192 23%
Calculator 180 22%
Conglomerate 168 20%
Deathstroke 168 20%
Brainiac (Superfriends) 156 19%
Gray Man 156 19%
Toyman (Superfriends) 156 19%
Professor Zoom 150 18%
Extremists 144 17%


Last edited by Emily Sivana; 09/21/17 08:36 PM. Reason: Added Results

Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937826 09/22/17 06:11 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Interesting that the DCAU outlasts the Superfriends versions, who originated the "LOD" moniker in the first place. Still 89 left, so lots of characters to cull.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937833 09/22/17 08:56 AM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Having never seen Superfriends or DCAU, these are always going to get few points from me.

On the other hand, I remember the Gray Man as a powerful early JL villian, and one at the center of a later big JLA/JLE crossover. The Extremists (the first incarnation of them anyway) were around in the JLE days too. I also thoguth the Joker would last a bit longer.


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937873 09/23/17 01:02 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
The next round starts now. I noticed a slight increase in eliminated characters, so we will keep the scale the same for now. This is taking longer than other games because there are lots of characters in the middle of the list.

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Aquarius
Asmodel
Atomic Skull (DCAU)
Bizarro (DCAU)
Blockbuster
Brainiac
Brainstorm
Brimstone
Cadre
Captain Cold
Catwoman
Cheetah
Cheetah (DCAU)
Chronos
Circe
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Construct
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter)
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Darkseid
Demons Three
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Destiny (DCAU)
Doctor Light
Eclipso
Eurocrime
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Galatea (JLU)
General
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU)
Giganta
Giganta (DCAU)
Gorilla Grodd
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Hyperclan
Kalibak
Kanjor Ro
Key
Kid Amazo
Killer Frost
Killer Frost (DCAU)
Lex Luthor
Libra
Lord of Time
Manga Khan
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Merlyn
Mordru
Morgaine Le Fay
Nebula Man
Neron
Paragon
Parasite
Per Degaton
Plastique
Professor Ivo
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Royal Flush Gang
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Star Sapphire III
Starbreaker
Starro
T.O. Morrow
Tattooed Man
Tornado Tyrant
Ulitmen (DCAU)
Ultra-Humanite
Vandal Savage
Wandjina
Warlock of YS
Weapons Master
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937876 09/23/17 03:05 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 132
Anti-Matter Man 108
Anton Allegro 96
Appelaxians 144
Aquarius 84
Asmodel 60
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 12
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Blockbuster 48
Brainiac 60
Brainstorm 96
Brimstone 72
Cadre 96
Captain Cold 60
Catwoman 48
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Cheetah 84
Chronos 72
Circe 72
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 72
Construct 120
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 24
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 132
Darkseid 96
Demons Three 132
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Destiny 132
Doctor Light 132
Eclipso 72
Eurocrime 12
Felix Faust 132
Floronic Man 120
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 84
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta (DCAU) 12
Giganta 12
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 72
Hector Hammond 108
Hyathis 84
Hyperclan 84
Kalibak 36
Kanjor Ro 132
Key 144
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Killer Frost 72
Lex Luthor 96
Libra 60
Lord of Time 132
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 84
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 96
Merlyn 72
Mordru 84
Morgaine Le Fay 72
Nebula Man 12
Neron 12
Paragon 120
Parasite 72
Per Degaton 132
Plastique 36
Professor Ivo 144
Prometheus 60
Queen Bee 108
Queen Bee II 96
Royal Flush Gang 120
Shadow Thief 72
Shaggy Man 108
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 120
Solaris 108
Solomon Grundy 72
Star Sapphire III 72
Starbreaker 72
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 132
Tattooed Man 96
Tornado Tyrant 108
Ulitmen (DCAU) 12
Ultra-Humanite 132
Vandal Savage 84
Wandjina 72
Warlock of YS 60
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 120
Xotar the Weapons Master 120


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937886 09/24/17 09:57 AM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 144
Anton Allegro 144
Appelaxians 144
Aquarius 144
Asmodel 12
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 12
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Blockbuster 144
Brainiac 12
Brainstorm 144
Brimstone 12
Cadre 144
Captain Cold 12
Catwoman 12
Cheetah 12
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Chronos 144
Circe 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 144
Construct 144
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 12
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 12
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Light 144
Eclipso 12
Eurocrime 144
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 144
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 12
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta 12
Giganta (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 12
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Hector Hammond 144
Hyathis144
Hyperclan 12
Kalibak 12
Kanjor Ro 144
Key 144
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost 12
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 12
Libra 144
Lord of Time 144
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Merlyn 144
Mordru 12
Morgaine Le Fay 12
Nebula Man 144
Neron 12
Paragon 144
Parasite 12
Per Degaton 12
Plastique 12
Professor Ivo 144
Prometheus 12
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 144
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shadow Thief 144
Shaggy Man 144
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 144
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 12
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 144
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 144
Tornado Tyrant 144
Ulitmen (DCAU) 12
Ultra-Humanite 12
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 144
Warlock of YS 144
Weapons Master 144
Wizard 144
Xotar the Weapons Master 144

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937887 09/24/17 10:25 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
I don't think the scale makes too much difference right now because most voters are min/maxing their votes, presumably until the list size shrinks down a bit.

Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Aquarius 12
Asmodel 144
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 12
Bizarro (DCAU) 12
Blockbuster 144
Brainiac 12
Brainstorm 12
Brimstone 144
Cadre 12
Captain Cold 12
Catwoman 12
Cheetah 144
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Chronos 144
Circe 144
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 12
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 144
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 12
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Light 12
Eclipso 144
Eurocrime 12
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 144
Galatea (JLU) 12
General 144
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta 144
Giganta (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis 12
Hyperclan 12
Kalibak 12
Kanjor Ro 144
Key 144
Kid Amazo 144
Killer Frost 12
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 144
Libra 144
Lord of Time 144
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Merlyn 12
Mordru 12
Morgaine Le Fay 12
Nebula Man 144
Neron 144
Paragon 12
Parasite 12
Per Degaton 144
Plastique 12
Professor Ivo 144
Prometheus 144
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 12
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 144
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 144
Solomon Grundy 144
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 12
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 12
Ulitmen (DCAU) 12
Ultra-Humanite 12
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 12
Warlock of YS 12
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 12
Xotar the Weapons Master 12

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937896 09/24/17 03:30 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Originally Posted by Emily Sivana
The next round starts now. I noticed a slight increase in eliminated characters, so we will keep the scale the same for now. This is taking longer than other games because there are lots of characters in the middle of the list.



I agree with Dave, the scale probably does not affect the results so much. It's more the minimizing/maximizing of the players.

I would not be averse to eliminating more characters every round in order to speed up the game.

Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 12
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Aquarius 12
Asmodel 12
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 144
Bizarro (DCAU) 144
Blockbuster 12
Brainiac 144
Brainstorm 12
Brimstone 144
Cadre 12
Captain Cold 12
Catwoman 144
Cheetah 12
Cheetah (DCAU) 12
Chronos 12
Circe 144
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 144
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 12
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Darkseid 12
Demons Three 144
Despero 12
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 12
Doctor Light 12
Eclipso 144
Eurocrime 144
Felix Faust 12
Floronic Man 12
Galatea (JLU) 144
General 12
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 12
Giganta 144
Giganta (DCAU) 144
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 144
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis12
Hyperclan 12
Kalibak 12
Kanjor Ro 12
Key 12
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost 144
Killer Frost (DCAU) 144
Lex Luthor 12
Libra 12
Lord of Time 12
Manga Khan 12
Manhunters 12
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 12
Merlyn 12
Mordru 144
Morgaine Le Fay 144
Nebula Man 12
Neron 144
Paragon 12
Parasite 12
Per Degaton 12
Plastique 144
Professor Ivo 12
Prometheus 12
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 144
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 12
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 144
Star Sapphire III 144
Starbreaker 144
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 12
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 12
Ulitmen (DCAU) 12
Ultra-Humanite 144
Vandal Savage 12
Wandjina 144
Warlock of YS 12
Weapons Master 12
Wizard 12
Xotar the Weapons Master 12

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #937898 09/24/17 04:54 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Amazo 132
Amos Fortune 121
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 84
Appelaxians 72
Aquarius 12
Asmodel 96
Atomic Skull (DCAU) 48
Bizarro (DCAU) 60
Blockbuster 48
Brainiac 60
Brainstorm 84
Brimstone 48
Cadre 96
Captain Cold 36
Catwoman 36
Cheetah 84
Cheetah (DCAU) 48
Chronos 60
Circe 48
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 108
Construct 108
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter) 60
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 120
Darkseid 84
Demons Three 108
Despero 108
Doctor Destiny 96
Doctor Destiny (DCAU) 36
Doctor Light 60
Eclipso 48
Eurocrime 60
Felix Faust 96
Floronic Man 72
Galatea (JLU) 48
General 120
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU) 84
Giganta 72
Giganta (DCAU) 84
Gorilla Grodd 72
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 84
Hector Hammond 72
Hyathis 96
Hyperclan 96
Kalibak 36
Kanjor Ro 120
Key 132
Kid Amazo 12
Killer Frost 36
Killer Frost (DCAU) 48
Lex Luthor 108
Libra 12
Lord of Time 120
Manga Khan 96
Manhunters 84
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 24
Merlyn 24
Mordru 24
Morgaine Le Fay 24
Nebula Man 60
Neron 48
Paragon 12
Parasite 48
Per Degaton 60
Plastique 48
Professor Ivo 144
Prometheus 108
Queen Bee 108
Queen Bee II 120
Royal Flush Gang 108
Shadow Thief 48
Shaggy Man 108
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 36
Solaris 96
Solomon Grundy 60
Star Sapphire III 60
Starbreaker 84
Starro 132
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 96
Tornado Tyrant 108
Ulitmen (DCAU) 60
Ultra-Humanite 48
Vandal Savage 96
Wandjina 36
Warlock of YS 48
Weapons Master 84
Wizard 72
Xotar the Weapons Master 96

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #938045 09/27/17 04:30 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
This round ends in 24 hours. I will post the results tomorrow evening.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #938139 09/29/17 03:25 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
BWAH HA HA HA HA! It wouldn't be a Villainous Idol without a Villainous Takeover of the Scoring! BWAH HA HA ... cough ...cough... wheeze... jeepers... that's tough to keep going... cough...

Right do-gooders! Watch helplessly as my Trained Cyborg Attack Ocelots deliver the scores!

Amazo, 708, 100%
Starro, 708, 100%
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3), 684, 97%
Demons Three, 672, 95%
Royal Flush Gang, 660, 93%
Queen Bee, 648, 92%
Professor Ivo, 588, 83%
Key, 576, 81%
T.O. Morrow, 576, 81%
Amos Fortune, 553, 78%
Despero, 552, 78%
Kanjor Ro, 552, 78%
Lord of Time, 552, 78%
Doctor Destiny, 540, 76%
Felix Faust, 528, 75%
Queen Bee II, 516, 73%
Shaggy Man, 516, 73%
Floronic Man, 492, 69%
Colonel Rumann Harjavti, 480, 68%
Manhunters, 468, 66%
Starbreaker, 456, 64%
Chronos, 432, 61%
Solomon Grundy, 432, 61%
Brimstone, 420, 59%
Circe, 420, 59%
Eclipso, 420, 59%
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar), 420, 59%
Wandjina, 408, 58%
Blockbuster, 396, 56%
Construct, 396, 56%
Appelaxians, 384, 54%
Giganta, 384, 54%
Gorilla Grodd, 384, 54%
Tornado Tyrant, 384, 54%
Xotar the Weapons Master, 384, 54%
Eurocrime, 372, 53%
General, 372, 53%
Lex Luthor, 372, 53%
Libra, 372, 53%
Nebula Man, 372, 53%
Solaris, 372, 53%
Cadre, 360, 51%
Doctor Light, 360, 51%
Neron, 360, 51%
Per Degaton, 360, 51%
Tattooed Man, 360, 51%
Wizard, 360, 51%
Anton Allegro, 348, 49%
Brainstorm, 348, 49%
Hector Hammond, 348, 49%
Hyathis, 348, 49%
Ultra-Humanite, 348, 49%
Prometheus, 336, 47%
Asmodel, 324, 46%
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU), 324, 46%
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar), 324, 46%
Paragon, 300, 42%
Star Sapphire III, 300, 42%
Anti-Matter Man, 288, 41%
Brainiac, 288, 41%
Killer Frost (DCAU), 288, 41%
Shadow Thief, 288, 41%
Mordru, 276, 39%
Warlock of YS, 276, 39%
Aquarius, 264, 37%
Cheetah, 264, 37%
Giganta (DCAU), 264, 37%
Merlyn, 264, 37%
Morgaine Le Fay, 264, 37%
Weapons Master, 264, 37%
Catwoman, 252, 36%
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter), 252, 36%
Plastique, 252, 36%
Bizarro (DCAU), 240, 34%
Atomic Skull (DCAU), 228, 32%
Galatea (JLU), 228, 32%
Darkseid, 216, 31%
Hyperclan, 216, 31%
Killer Frost, 216, 31%
Vandal Savage, 216, 31%
Doctor Destiny (DCAU), 204, 29%
Kid Amazo, 192, 27%
Cheetah (DCAU), 168, 24%
Parasite, 156, 22%
Manga Khan, 144, 20%
Captain Cold, 132, 19%
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU), 132, 19%
Kalibak, 108, 15%
Ulitmen (DCAU), 108, 15%

And those to be eliminated are .....Curses! Emily Sivana has escaped my fiendish death trap labyrinth! Blast the government for forcing me to put a Customer Help Desk in it! Emily will tell you who's gone, but I...I will return! BWAH HA HA HA .... >WHEEZE< Has anyone seen my inhaler?...


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #938142 09/29/17 04:41 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
In an act of revenge, I may just cut all characters beneath 50%. If anyone has any objections (and not siding with the wretched traitor in his revolt) speak now.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #938146 09/29/17 06:15 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
8-O Four of my favorites are on 49%! :'(

But, lthe way the votes are going, they'd probably be out next round anyway, so saving them would just be delaying the inevitable.

Happy with whichever decision.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #938168 09/30/17 08:05 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Happy with any decision. I'm cackling with glee at the villainous infighting!

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #938173 09/30/17 10:21 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Kick them out of the skull ship!
Make space for the REAL Justice League foes!

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #938189 09/30/17 08:17 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I will cut all villains under 40% of the vote. You can see from thoth lad's list that cut eliminates a huge swath of characters. I anticipate running the Wild Card very shortly at the rate we are going. We might finish the entire game by the end of October. I will remix the remaining characters and start the voting tomorrow.

Mordru, 276, 39%
Warlock of YS, 276, 39%
Aquarius, 264, 37%
Cheetah, 264, 37%
Giganta (DCAU), 264, 37% <-- Opps, I should have voted. I feel this version is more fleshed out than the comic book one. I also think the awesome Giganta/Atom ship is the result of her popularity in the cartoon.
Merlyn, 264, 37%
Morgaine Le Fay, 264, 37%
Weapons Master, 264, 37%
Catwoman, 252, 36%
Crime Syndicate (Anti-Matter), 252, 36%
Plastique, 252, 36%
Bizarro (DCAU), 240, 34%
Atomic Skull (DCAU), 228, 32% <-- While there are many better villains, I can think of few who are cooler looking. Your frightening face will be greatly missed.
Galatea (JLU), 228, 32% <-- One of the more interesting takes on Power Girl that I have seen,
Darkseid, 216, 31%
Hyperclan, 216, 31%
Killer Frost, 216, 31% <-- Slightly surprised given that variations of this character have appeared in recent TV shows.
Vandal Savage, 216, 31%
Doctor Destiny (DCAU), 204, 29% <-- I find it odd that voters wouldn't give both versions high points in order to stack the deck in the early rounds. I have been doing that with Gorilla Grodd and Giganta in case one of them gets eliminated.
Kid Amazo, 192, 27%
Cheetah (DCAU), 168, 24%
Parasite, 156, 22%
Manga Khan, 144, 20%
Captain Cold, 132, 19%
Gentleman Ghost (DCAU), 132, 19%
Kalibak, 108, 15%
Ulitmen (DCAU), 108, 15%

Last edited by Emily Sivana; 09/30/17 08:20 PM.

Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #938193 09/30/17 10:31 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Poor Ultimen. Lasted something like 10 rounds but never had their name spelled correctly. frown wink

I think last round was the first time I lost a character/group that I'd been giving more than minimum points to, but this round saw the loss of a handful of faves.

Warlock of YS - I don't get why this character never appeared more. He had a great look, and a formidable (if generic) power set and would have been perfect as an arch-nemesis for Zatanna.
Merlyn - Cool character. After a slow start (I don't think he appeared for like a decade after his first introduction) his profile began to rise after Crisis and the Arrow TV show has now obviously firmly cemented him as one of GA's top foes.
Weapons Master - GREAT power set! And one that seems completely original to me; is there anyone else out there with a similar one? I guess Dial-H-for-Hero might be distantly similar but their results are random (I think)? Probably, one of the better characters introduced during an otherwise forgettable era too.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 5)
Emily Sivana #938204 10/01/17 01:46 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
The next round beings immediately. Please feel free to continue commenting on the departed, as we may see them soon enough. We are down to 62 characters remaining. On a programming note, let me know if anyone is interested in doing an Idol after this one is over. Otherwise, I will probably wait two weeks and then try to test this Legion-themed RPG I have been working on.

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Anton Allegro
Appelaxians
Asmodel
Blockbuster
Brainiac
Brainstorm
Brimstone
Cadre
Chronos
Circe
Colonel Rumann Harjavti
Construct
Crime Syndicate
Demons Three
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Doctor Light
Eclipso
Eurocrime
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
General
Giganta
Gorilla Grodd
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Hector Hammond
Hyathis
Kanjor Ro
Key
Killer Frost (DCAU)
Lex Luthor
Libra
Lord of Time
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Nebula Man
Neron
Paragon
Per Degaton,
Professor Ivo
Prometheus
Queen Bee
Queen Bee II
Royal Flush Gang
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar)
Solaris
Solomon Grundy
Star Sapphire III
Starbreaker
Starro
T.O. Morrow
Tattooed Man
Tornado Tyrant
Ultra-Humanite
Wandjina
Wizard
Xotar the Weapons Master


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Emily Sivana #938205 10/01/17 01:52 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Amazo 60
Amos Fortune 60
Anti-Matter Man 60
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Asmodel 36
Blockbuster 48
Brainiac 48
Brainstorm 112
Brimstone 120
Cadre 24
Chronos 36
Circe 24
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 24
Construct 24
Crime Syndicate 48
Demons Three 48
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 120
Doctor Light 12
Eclipso 24
Eurocrime 12
Felix Faust 120
Floronic Man 36
General 24
Giganta 144
Gorilla Grodd 60
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 144
Hector Hammond 48
Hyathis 60
Kanjor Ro 84
Key 84
Killer Frost (DCAU) 120
Lex Luthor 84
Libra 12
Lord of Time 48
Manhunters 48
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 60
Nebula Man 12
Neron 60
Paragon 12
Per Degaton 36
Professor Ivo 120
Prometheus 84
Queen Bee 84
Queen Bee II 48
Royal Flush Gang 96
Shadow Thief
Shaggy Man
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 36
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 60
Star Sapphire III 96
Starbreaker 12
Starro 120
T.O. Morrow 120
Tattooed Man 60
Tornado Tyrant 60
Ultra-Humanite 24
Wandjina 12
Wizard 36
Xotar the Weapons Master 12


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Emily Sivana #938212 10/01/17 02:27 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
My name is Blacula and I am an Idol addict.

Of course I will play another game straight after this one. smile

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Emily Sivana #938214 10/01/17 03:47 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Of those we lost last round...

Mordru - Big ticket crossover villain, but not the best of stories.
Aquarius - Another villain who doesn't understand that you become part of the cosmos when you tap into it. Groovy man.
Cheetah - Part of a great JLA/JSA crossover.
Merlyn - I liked him more from his Who's Who entry than when I actually got to read him.
Darkseid - Tsk. The moment you finish a Darkseid reread, he's gone. It's like he means nothing to you >sob< smile
Hyperclan - It took an issue or two to get used to Porter's art and they seemed to have generic powers. But a good twist.
Killer Frost - I like her from early Firestorm as well as for that JLA/JSA crossover.
Manga Khan - Fitting that he should go out at the same time as Darkseid, whose power levels he so closely matches. Bwah ha ha ha !


Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 72
Anton Allegro 60
Appelaxians 144
Asmodel 36
Blockbuster 48
Brainiac 48
Brainstorm 96
Brimstone 72
Cadre 144
Chronos 120
Circe 36
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 24
Construct 120
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 132
Demons Three 132
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Light 144
Eclipso 72
Eurocrime 12
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 144
General 48
Giganta 12
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 48
Hector Hammond 108
Hyathis 108
Kanjor Ro 132
Key 144
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 96
Libra 36
Lord of Time 144
Manhunters 108
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Nebula Man 12
Neron 12
Paragon 144
Per Degaton 72
Professor Ivo 144
Prometheus 36
Queen Bee 108
Queen Bee II 72
Royal Flush Gang 120
Shadow Thief 60
Shaggy Man 144
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 144
Solaris 72
Solomon Grundy 72
Star Sapphire III 72
Starbreaker 24
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 72
Tornado Tyrant 144
Ultra-Humanite 144
Wandjina 60
Wizard 144
Xotar the Weapons Master 144


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
thoth lad #938215 10/01/17 04:03 PM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
Amazo 12
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 144
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Asmodel 12
Blockbuster 12
Brainiac 12
Brainstorm 144
Brimstone 12
Cadre 12
Chronos 144
Circe 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 12
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Demons Three 12
Despero 12
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Light 12
Eclipso 12
Eurocrime 12
Felix Faust 12
Floronic Man 144
General 12
Giganta 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 144
Gorilla Grodd 144
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis 12
Kanjor Ro 12
Key 12
Killer Frost (DCAU) 144
Lex Luthor 12
Libra 12
Lord of Time 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Nebula Man 12
Neron 12
Paragon 12
Per Degaton 12
Professor Ivo 144
Prometheus 12
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 144
Royal Flush Gang 12
Shadow Thief 144
Shaggy Man 12
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 144
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 12
Starro 12
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 144
Tornado Tyrant 144
Ultra-Humanite 12
Wandjina 12
Wizard 12
Xotar the Weapons Master 12

On those departed;
Cheetah, Giganta, Plastique and Killer Frost were always good choices for me, because I love the team having multiple ladies, and for them to not be pallete-swaps of heroes (like Superwoman or Star Sapphire). I'm also a fan of there being more adversaries of characters like Wonder Woman and Firestorm (and Aquaman and the Hawks, etc.) on the team, and not just a checklist of Superman and Batman rogues.

Atomic Skull had a great visual, and, while powerful, wasn't 'too big for the room,' like some others, who are, IMO, better as solo villains than part of a team (like Darkseid or Mordru or Neron).

Kid Amazo always interested me more than adult Amazo. He had so much more character.

Oh, those poor Ultimen. Losers gotta lose. smile



Last edited by Set; 10/01/17 04:26 PM. Reason: Looked up Dr. Destiny and Amos Fortune, decided I liked them.

Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Emily Sivana #938217 10/01/17 04:32 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Oh Noes! Not the Ultimen. I didn't care about the Ulitmen but... actually I don't care about this lot either. Were they the ones that became the new Global Guardians? Google tells me I'm thinking of the Ultramarine Corps. Nope, never heard of them. Or Kid Amazo for that matter. Bye Bye! smile


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
thoth lad #938218 10/01/17 04:55 PM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
Originally Posted by thoth lad
Or Kid Amazo for that matter. Bye Bye! smile


Oh! I would slap the taste out of your mouth, if you had any!

Not really. I don't actually like Kid Amazo that much anyway.

Now you come at Queen Bee and IT"S ON!

smile


Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
thoth lad #938219 10/01/17 05:09 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Originally Posted by thoth lad
Oh Noes! Not the Ultimen. I didn't care about the Ulitmen but... actually I don't care about this lot either. Were they the ones that became the new Global Guardians? Google tells me I'm thinking of the Ultramarine Corps. Nope, never heard of them. Or Kid Amazo for that matter. Bye Bye! smile


The Ultimen were an evil parody the the characters added to the Superfriends series. The '90s-00s Animated Universe often created inversions of earlier concepts; Galatea is another example of that.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Emily Sivana #938231 10/01/17 10:07 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 132
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 96
Appelaxians 108
Asmodel 108
Blockbuster 48
Brainiac 72
Brainstorm 96
Brimstone 48
Cadre 96
Chronos 48
Circe 48
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 108
Construct 96
Crime Syndicate 96
Demons Three 84
Despero 96
Doctor Destiny 72
Doctor Light 36
Eclipso 48
Eurocrime 84
Felix Faust 108
Floronic Man 72
General 120
Giganta 72
Gorilla Grodd 72
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 84
Hector Hammond 72
Hyathis 96
Kanjor Ro 108
Key 120
Killer Frost (DCAU) 48
Lex Luthor 84
Libra 12
Lord of Time 108
Manhunters 48
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 36
Nebula Man 12
Neron 12
Paragon 12
Per Degaton 36
Professor Ivo 120
Prometheus 96
Queen Bee 108
Queen Bee II 108
Royal Flush Gang 108
Shadow Thief 48
Shaggy Man 108
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 96
Solomon Grundy 64
Star Sapphire III 48
Starbreaker 96
Starro 108
T.O. Morrow 132
Tattooed Man 108
Tornado Tyrant 96
Ultra-Humanite 48
Wandjina 12
Wizard 72
Xotar the Weapons Master 72

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Emily Sivana #938232 10/01/17 11:48 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 144
Anton Allegro 144
Appelaxians 144
Asmodel 12
Blockbuster 12
Brainiac 12
Brainstorm 144
Brimstone 12
Cadre 144
Chronos 12
Circe 12
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 12
Construct 144
Crime Syndicate 144
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Light 144
Eclipso 12
Eurocrime 144
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 12
General 12
Giganta 12
Gorilla Grodd 12
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Hector Hammond 144
Hyathis 144
Kanjor Ro 144
Key 144
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 12
Libra 144
Lord of Time 144
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Nebula Man 144
Neron 12
Paragon 144
Per Degaton 12
Professor Ivo 144
Prometheus 12
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 12
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 144
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 144
Solaris 12
Solomon Grundy 12
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 144
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 12
Ultra-Humanite 12
Wandjina 12
Wizard 12
Xotar the Weapons Master 12

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Emily Sivana #938244 10/02/17 05:42 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Surprised to see Morrison's Anti-Matter Crime Syndicate go home. In many respects they were more interesting than the originals, and the introductory GN (Earth-2), is all kinds of cool.

Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 12
Anton Allegro 12
Appelaxians 12
Asmodel 144
Blockbuster 144
Brainiac 12
Brainstorm 12
Brimstone 144
Cadre 12
Chronos 144
Circe 144
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 12
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Doctor Light 12
Eclipso 12
Eurocrime 12
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 144
General 144
Giganta 144
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Hector Hammond 12
Hyathis 12
Kanjor Ro 144
Key 144
Killer Frost (DCAU) 12
Lex Luthor 144
Libra 12
Lord of Time 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Nebula Man 144
Neron 144
Paragon 12
Per Degaton 144
Professor Ivo 144
Prometheus 144
Queen Bee 144
Queen Bee II 12
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shadow Thief 12
Shaggy Man 144
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 12
Solaris 144
Solomon Grundy 144
Star Sapphire III 12
Starbreaker 12
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 12
Ultra-Humanite 12
Wandjina 12
Wizard 12
Xotar the Weapons Master 12

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Blacula #938262 10/02/17 10:45 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Originally Posted by Blacula
My name is Blacula and I am an Idol addict.

Of course I will play another game straight after this one. smile


I would also be up for an Idol
Not sure I have the bandwidth to run it though (and can't think of one off the top of my head)

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Emily Sivana #938276 10/02/17 04:29 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Like I said in the earlier post, if nobody else is interested in running an Idol I want to try a text-based RPG. It would be a sort of make our adventure with Legion of Super-Heroes or Villains depending on the choices the players make. My working title is the Nal Bros RPG (and yes that is a reference to Mario).


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Emily Sivana #938305 10/03/17 01:26 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
I predict great things for this RPG

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 7)
Emily Sivana #938306 10/03/17 01:32 PM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
It's like you're already a Nal Brother!

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938335 10/03/17 04:33 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
faint I love this forum. I probably will post the RPG thread shortly before we finish the Legion of Doom Idol so I can get a head-count. It is set up for multiple possibilities so in case one plot does not end well we can try another one. Anyways, I will leave this open one more day to allow for IB to vote if he so chooses.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938343 10/04/17 02:04 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
I've never played such an RPG before, so I'm excited to try it out

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938379 10/04/17 04:35 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Do you intend to submit votes this round or is it okay to close the polls?


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938424 10/05/17 02:44 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Thanks for asking Emily. I won’t be able to vote until tomorrow so go ahead and close

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938432 10/05/17 04:36 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I am going to close the polls now. I will post the results later this evening. Please bear with me as I still feel sick (I feel kind of dizzy). I will start the next round immediately because I will be out of town this weekend and without the Excel spreadsheets used to to run this game. I decided to eliminate everyone under 50% because otherwise we wouldn't be eliminating as many characters as I would like.

T.O. Morrow 828 100%
Professor Ivo 816 99%
Amos Fortune 768 93%
Doctor Destiny 768 93%

Queen Bee 732 88%
Crime Syndicate 708 86%
Despero 684 83%
Felix Faust 672 82%
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 672 82%
Starro 672 82%

Amazo 648 78%
Key 648 78%
Manhunters 636 76%
Kanjor Ro 624 75%
Royal Flush Gang 624 75%
Brainstorm 604 73%

Demons Three 564 68%
Shaggy Man 564 68%
Floronic Man 552 67%
Giganta 528 64%
Chronos 504 61%

Solomon Grundy 496 59%
Lord of Time 468 57%
Tornado Tyrant 468 57%
Anti-Matter Man 444 53%
Gorilla Grodd 444 53%
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 444 53%
Appelaxians 432 51%
Cadre 432 51%
Hyathis 432 51%
Lex Luthor 432 51%
Brimstone 408 50%
Construct 408 50%
Tattooed Man 408 50%


Eliminated this Round
Hector Hammond 396 48%
Queen Bee II 396 48%
Prometheus 384 46%
Doctor Light 360 43%
General 360 43%
Snapper Carr (Star-Tsar) 360 43%
Asmodel 348 42%
Killer Frost (DCAU) 348 42%
Solaris 348 42%
Anton Allegro 336 41%
Nebula Man 336 41%
Paragon 336 41%
Blockbuster 312 38%
Per Degaton 312 38%
Starbreaker 300 36%
Shadow Thief 288 35%
Wizard 288 35%
Circe 276 33%
Eurocrime 276 33%
Xotar the Weapons Master 264 32%
Neron 252 30%
Star Sapphire III 252 30%
Ultra-Humanite 252 30%
Libra 228 28%
Brainiac 204 25%
Colonel Rumann Harjavti 192 23%
Eclipso 180 22%
Wandjina 120 14%


Last edited by Emily Sivana; 10/05/17 05:59 PM.

Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938434 10/05/17 06:03 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
And then there were 34...

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Anti-Matter Man
Appelaxians
Brainstorm
Brimstone
Cadre
Chronos
Construct
Crime Syndicate
Demons Three
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Giganta
Gorilla Grodd
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU)
Hyathis
Kanjor Ro
Key
Lex Luthor
Lord of Time
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Professor Ivo
Queen Bee
Royal Flush Gang
Shaggy Man
Solomon Grundy
Starro
T.O. Morrow
Tattooed Man
Tornado Tyrant


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938442 10/06/17 05:34 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Yikes, not a great round for the Morrison era (General, Prometheus & Solaris), or the JLI years (Queen Bee II, the Colonel, and others). Surprised to see an animated character stick around so long, they traditionally don't fare well in these. Of characters that were in the original LoD, only 4 remain: Giganta, Grodd, Luthor & Grundy.

Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 12
Anti-Matter Man 12
Appelaxians 12
Brainstorm 12
Brimstone 12
Cadre 12
Chronos 12
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Demons Three 144
Despero 12
Doctor Destiny 144
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 144
Giganta 144
Gorilla Grodd 12
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Hyathis 12
Kanjor Ro 144
Key 144
Lex Luthor 144
Lord of Time 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Professor Ivo 12
Queen Bee 12
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shaggy Man 144
Solomon Grundy 144
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 12



Last edited by Dave Hackett; 10/06/17 05:36 AM.
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938451 10/06/17 10:04 AM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Bloodbath! Lots of big characters gone this round; characters who might have won if this game were being played anywhere else. And I think we possibly lost our first major foe of the classic era in Dr Light.

I can't help but wonder how different the results would have been if IB had voted. Eurocrime fans will never forgive you, IB! wink

Dave's mention of the last 4 remaining original LoD members brings up an interesting point that didn't occur to me until Set (I think) made mention of a "team" a few posts ago. I read that post and was like "What team?". And then I remembered that this game was called "Legion of Doom Idol". Although in practice it has played more like "Exhaustive List of Justice League Villains Idol". And for people like me who like to vote for characters to match the theme of the game, that's a pretty major disconnect. Giganta might be one of the most notable members of the LoD for example, but I can't think of one instance where she's fought the actual Justice League. Similarly, Starro might be one of the most iconic JL villains, but I couldn't imagine any story that might believably make him a member of the LoD. I don't think any other Idol games have had this disconnect, in my mind anyway.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938452 10/06/17 10:11 AM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Amazo 12
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 12
Appelaxians 144
Brainstorm 144
Brimstone 12
Cadre 144
Chronos 12
Construct 144
Crime Syndicate 144
Demons Three 12
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 12
Giganta 12
Gorilla Grodd 12
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Hyathis 144
Kanjor Ro 12
Key 144
Lex Luthor 12
Lord of Time 144
Manhunters 12
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Professor Ivo 12
Queen Bee 144
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shaggy Man 144
Solomon Grundy 12
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 12

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938462 10/06/17 01:59 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
>sigh<
Anton Allegro who became a lot scarier after I'd read the Lovecraft story. A modern take on the Fiddler.
Co Harjavti who would have been more of a parallel into modern politics if it wasn't being played for laughs.
Arthur Light, whose promise of great villainy ended up with him being destroyed as a character.
The General - An updated Shaggy Man.
Hammond, the GL Villain who Professor Stein had to fight!
Paragon, the supremacist update on Amazo
Degaton, whose back to sweeping that lab floor with dreams of conquest flitting across the shadows of his mind.
Snapper, who turned away form his idols in the most treacherous of ways
Ultra Humanite, the brains and brawn behind one of the best JLA/JSA crossovers
The Wizard, another classic JSA villain making a mark on the JLA and whose crossover would inspire the dreadful Identity Crisis.

>/sigh<

Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 12
Appelaxians 144
Brainstorm 36
Brimstone 72
Cadre 72
Chronos 96
Construct 120
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 144
Demons Three 144
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 144
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 144
Giganta 12
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 12
Gorilla Grodd 36
Hyathis 60
Kanjor Ro 120
Key 144
Lex Luthor 96
Lord of Time 144
Manhunters 96
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 72
Professor Ivo 144
Queen Bee 96
Royal Flush Gang 120
Shaggy Man 120
Solomon Grundy 60
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 72
Tornado Tyrant 120


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Blacula #938470 10/06/17 05:31 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Originally Posted by Blacula
Bloodbath! Lots of big characters gone this round; characters who might have won if this game were being played anywhere else. And I think we possibly lost our first major foe of the classic era in Dr Light.

I can't help but wonder how different the results would have been if IB had voted. Eurocrime fans will never forgive you, IB! wink

Dave's mention of the last 4 remaining original LoD members brings up an interesting point that didn't occur to me until Set (I think) made mention of a "team" a few posts ago. I read that post and was like "What team?". And then I remembered that this game was called "Legion of Doom Idol". Although in practice it has played more like "Exhaustive List of Justice League Villains Idol". And for people like me who like to vote for characters to match the theme of the game, that's a pretty major disconnect. Giganta might be one of the most notable members of the LoD for example, but I can't think of one instance where she's fought the actual Justice League. Similarly, Starro might be one of the most iconic JL villains, but I couldn't imagine any story that might believably make him a member of the LoD. I don't think any other Idol games have had this disconnect, in my mind anyway.


I think for teams like Justice League and Avengers (and X-Men and Teen Titans to a lesser extent) one's perspective is based on when they started reading. I got a big reading gap between my Dad's 80s comics and Morrison's JLA run. By the mid-2000s when I was caught up on modern comics, there were tons of Crises where every villain seemed to be fighting everyone. I also freely admit the JLA cartoons and DC video games define the JLA to me more than the comics, because that is where I learned about Shadow Thief, Starro, etc. Part of my decision is also based on what is called "Rule of Cool", whereas I think Legion of Doom sounds cooler than JLA Villains. It is the main reason I was throwing votes at Atomic Skull.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Blacula #938482 10/07/17 04:56 AM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
Amazo 12
Amos Fortune 144
Anti-Matter Man 12
Appelaxians 12
Brainstorm 144
Brimstone 12
Cadre 12
Chronos 144
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate 144
Demons Three 12
Despero 12
Doctor Destiny 144
Felix Faust 12
Floronic Man 144
Giganta 144
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 144
Hyathis 12
Kanjor Ro 12
Key 12
Lex Luthor 12
Lord of Time 12
Manhunters 144
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 144
Professor Ivo 144
Queen Bee 144
Royal Flush Gang 12
Shaggy Man 144
Solomon Grundy 12
Starro 12
T.O. Morrow 144
Tattooed Man 144
Tornado Tyrant 144

Of those who left us this round, Shadow Thief was my favorite. Many of my quirky favorites are still hanging on, but I'm sure many more upsets remain!

How many will be on the final team? Seven is the typical hero team size, but this is a *Legion* of Doom, after all, so ten or a dozen would not be out of line.


Last edited by Set; 10/07/17 05:00 AM.

Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Blacula #938506 10/07/17 07:31 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Originally Posted by Blacula

I can't help but wonder how different the results would have been if IB had voted. Eurocrime fans will never forgive you, IB! wink



Eurocrime, Starbreaker, Queen Bee II and Wandjina would probably have gotten votes from me!

Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 12
Anti-Matter Man 12
Appelaxians 12
Brainstorm 12
Brimstone 144
Cadre 12
Chronos 144
Construct 12
Crime Syndicate 144
Demons Three 144
Despero 12
Doctor Destiny 144
Felix Faust 144
Floronic Man 12
Giganta 144
Gorilla Grodd 144
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 144
Hyathis 12
Kanjor Ro 12
Key 12
Lex Luthor 12
Lord of Time 12
Manhunters 12
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 12
Professor Ivo 12
Queen Bee 144
Royal Flush Gang 144
Shaggy Man 12
Solomon Grundy 144
Starro 144
T.O. Morrow 12
Tattooed Man 12
Tornado Tyrant 12

Last edited by Invisible Brainiac; 10/07/17 07:32 PM.
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938509 10/07/17 09:37 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Ahhhh Solaris eliminated so soon? Solaris will have it's revenge! SUNBURN!!!!

Amazo 144
Amos Fortune 120
Anti-Matter Man 12
Appelaxians 60
Brainstorm 72
Brimstone 36
Cadre 108
Chronos 48
Construct 36
Crime Syndicate 132
Demons Three 108
Despero 144
Doctor Destiny 72
Felix Faust 96
Floronic Man 72
Giganta 108
Gorilla Grodd 48
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 96
Hyathis 72
Kanjor Ro 108
Key 120
Lex Luthor 60
Lord of Time 72
Manhunters 72
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 12
Professor Ivo 120
Queen Bee 120
Royal Flush Gang 108
Shaggy Man 108
Solomon Grundy 36
Starro 108
T.O. Morrow 120
Tattooed Man 48
Tornado Tyrant 36

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938536 10/08/17 12:25 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I am going to keep this open until tomorrow evening. I want to announce in chat that we are nearing completion because we sometimes get people who only vote in the later rounds.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Myg - Andy S #938543 10/08/17 12:42 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Originally Posted by Myg - Andy S
Ahhhh Solaris eliminated so soon? Solaris will have it's revenge! SUNBURN!!!!


But Morrison's Solaris is met by the 1972 Russian film where he pinched its name from! It's pseudo sci-fi utterings are no match for the real thing!


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938593 10/09/17 06:24 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Now it is time for the results. The Crime Syndicate has won a victory. I am please to say we have a top 20! We will be switching to a slightly smaller scale of by 5s until we reach the Semi-Finals. The Wild Card Round will be after one more regular round.

Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 852 100%
Doctor Destiny 792 93%
T.O. Morrow 708 83%
Starro 696 82%
Felix Faust 684 81%

Royal Flush Gang 672 78%
Shaggy Man 672 78%
Queen Bee 660 77%

Amazo 600 70%
Amos Fortune 576 67%
Key 576 67%
Demons Three 564 66%
Giganta 563 66%

Floronic Man 528 62%
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 528 62%
Manhunters 480 56%
Despero 468 55%

Chronos 456 54%
Professor Ivo 444 52%
Tattooed Man 432 51%


Eliminated this Round
Brainstorm 420 49%
Gorilla Grodd (DCAU) 420 49% <-- I feel the TV version was better developed as a character.
Kanjor Ro 408 48%
Solomon Grundy 408 48% <-- Somebody more intelligent than me can make a joke a about Grundy and pants.
Gorilla Grodd 396 46%
Lord of Time 396 46%
Appelaxians 384 45%
Cadre 360 42%
Construct 336 39%
Lex Luthor 336 39% <-- He lasted pretty long.
Tornado Tyrant 336 39%
Hyathis 312 37% <-- I thought her design was a lot better than Kanjor Ro.
Brimstone 288 33%
Anti-Matter Man 72 8%


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938594 10/09/17 06:33 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
I guess Grundy has to go buy new pants... Maybe Grodd went with him

Among the villains left, I see Giganta and Tattooed Man more as villains who would work well in a team, but not really as solo acts.

Mark Shaw is an interesting case. he doesn’t work well as a team player. and the appearances of his I read had him more as a problematic ally rather than an out and out villain

Last edited by Invisible Brainiac; 10/09/17 06:35 PM.
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938598 10/09/17 09:16 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Sad to see Brainstorm go (and by only 1%! <cry>) but pleasantly surprised to see an obscure favorite like him last this long! Take that Joker!

Kanjar Ro will be pleased to see that that cheap imitator who stole his spot on the list, Kanjor Ro, has finally gone.

Lord of Time is another slightly obscure character whose status as a fave of mine is 95% based upon his choice of headgear. He should have appeared more.

What can I say about the Appelaxians? They are the antagonists in the greatest single issue story of all time - Justice League of America #200. For that reason alone they are the default winners of this game, regardless of the result.

The Cadre are probably the only decent villains introduced during the Detroit era. I have a special place in my heart for Black Mass for some reason.

Construct is another great villain. He/it seemed so menacing in the Red Tornado mini. I feel like writers must have forgotten about him over the years because it seems like there were about a dozen similar characters introduced after Crisis.

Hyathis - I agree with you Emily. She had a great look. I don't know why Kanjar Ro was the only one of those villains to become a major player. All of them looked interesting (and easily updateable) to me.

Brimstone - Very surprised to see him last this long. Did he appear anywhere other than Legends? I found that to be a really boring mini and him to be a really boring opponent in it.

Well done to Giganta for being the last remaining LoD member on the list.

I like pretty much everyone left now so the rounds are going to start getting much harder for me.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938599 10/10/17 02:14 AM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
I remember Brimstone appearing in an issue of the Ray (Ray, not Happy), and Superboy (Kon) showing up to help. he was kind of funny there. after thrashing the two, Brimstone goes... “I need a beer”

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938603 10/10/17 06:23 AM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
Of those who have departed this round, I'll miss Gorilla Grodd and the Tornado Tyrant most.

I like how many of those remaining are good team options.


Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938623 10/10/17 11:18 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
I'm surprised Anti-Matter Man and Hyathis made it so far
I'm not sure I've ever read an actual issue with Hyathis in it - I remember her (fondly) from the original Who's Who series

Gorilla Grodd has been surpassed (barely) by the DCAU version - which I completely understand.

Surprised that Brainstorm, Lord of Time, Kanjar Ro, Cadre and Appelaxians are out. They are (to me) quintessential Justice League villains.

Happy to see Luthor go. While he's constantly used as a leader/villain, he doesn't ring "JLA foe" to me

Last edited by Myg - Andy S; 10/10/17 11:20 AM.
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938628 10/10/17 11:27 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Brimstone was also used as a Firestorm villain during the "elemental" years.

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938658 10/10/17 03:58 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
On those who have been sent to the DCU revolving door jails...

Brainstorm - Great helmet, shame about the neck injury!
Kanjor Ro - ruined by a writer getting him to call Wondy something not code approved.
Solomon Grundy - sorry, no pants jokes. I've a christening to get arranged today.
Gorilla Grodd - he went all cannibal at some point, taking away his silver age fun a bit.
Lord of Time - If only he understood what he could do with his powers. Great villain though.
Appelaxians - A super cover for their first retcon appearance and that #200! Wow!
Cadre - Often mocked, before DC realised that they hadn't created anything better in years. I've a soft spot for a lot of these guys.
Construct - Appeared as a puppet in the early JL issues, but the bronze age showed him at his best.
Lex Luthor - The villainous counterpoint to so many hero teams.
Tornado Tyrant - Like so many of the others, he had a great cover appearance. There's a lot of Adam Strange sci-fi in this list. Gets all nostalgic...
Hyathis - Did really well to get this far. A striking visual and loads of potential.
Brimstone - Looked cool when Byrne drew him... Like so many big villains, he didn't move around a lot.
Anti-Matter Man - Surprised he's gone. I thought no one would touch him smile


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938755 10/12/17 04:45 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Sorry for the delay in between rounds. Too many new video games are coming out next year and I have been distracted by the hype. Here is the top 20. Please vote by 5's: 5, 10, 15, 20, etc. the highest number you can use is 50.

Amazo
Amos Fortune
Chronos
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3)
Demons Three
Despero
Doctor Destiny
Felix Faust
Floronic Man
Giganta
Key
Manhunters
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar)
Professor Ivo
Queen Bee
Royal Flush Gang
Shaggy Man
Starro
T.O. Morrow
Tattooed Man

Emily's Votes:

Amazo 15
Amos Fortune 5
Chronos 20
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 20
Demons Three 5
Despero 45
Doctor Destiny 30
Felix Faust 25
Floronic Man 10
Giganta 50
Key 25
Manhunters 5
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 5
Professor Ivo 40
Queen Bee 30
Royal Flush Gang 15
Shaggy Man 5
Starro 35
T.O. Morrow 30
Tattooed Man 20


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938778 10/13/17 07:16 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Amazo 30
Amos Fortune 5
Chronos 5
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 40
Demons Three 40
Despero 5
Doctor Destiny 30
Felix Faust 40
Floronic Man 50
Giganta 30
Key 20
Manhunters 30
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 50
Professor Ivo 10
Queen Bee 10
Royal Flush Gang 40
Shaggy Man 30
Starro 50
T.O. Morrow 20
Tattooed Man 5

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Dave Hackett #938781 10/13/17 07:56 AM
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
S
Set Offline
Long live the Legion!
Offline
Long live the Legion!
S
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 9,036
Amazo 5
Amos Fortune 50
Chronos 50
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 50
Demons Three 5
Despero 5
Doctor Destiny 50
Felix Faust 5
Floronic Man 50
Giganta 50
Key 5
Manhunters 50
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 50
Professor Ivo 50
Queen Bee 50
Royal Flush Gang 5
Shaggy Man 50
Starro 5
T.O. Morrow 50
Tattooed Man 50

Huh, only Giganta and Queen Bee left for super-villainesses! (Plus any female members of the Crime Syndicate and Royal Flush Gang...).


Wrapped Around Your Finger now complete in BITS!
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938787 10/13/17 09:19 AM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
^ The Justice League have always been pretty terrible at attracting female villains. Heck, Queen Bee is probably their most prominent one and she's only appeared something like 3 times in 50 years!

Amazo 5
Amos Fortune 5
Chronos 5
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 5
Demons Three 5
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 50
Felix Faust 50
Floronic Man 5
Giganta 5
Key 50
Manhunters 5
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 5
Professor Ivo 5
Queen Bee 50
Royal Flush Gang 50
Shaggy Man 50
Starro 50
T.O. Morrow 50
Tattooed Man 5

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938823 10/14/17 06:34 AM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 30
Chronos 25
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 35
Demons Three 35
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 50
Felix Faust 45
Floronic Man 40
Giganta 5
Key 45
Manhunters 40
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 5
Professor Ivo 50
Queen Bee 35
Royal Flush Gang 30
Shaggy Man 30
Starro 50
T.O. Morrow 45
Tattooed Man 25


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938841 10/14/17 10:28 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wow the top 20!

Amazo 45
Amos Fortune 35
Chronos 10
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 40
Demons Three 30
Despero 50
Doctor Destiny 35
Felix Faust 40
Floronic Man 25
Giganta 35
Key 50
Manhunters 25
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 10
Professor Ivo 50
Queen Bee 35
Royal Flush Gang 45
Shaggy Man 45
Starro 50
T.O. Morrow 50
Tattooed Man 25

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938885 10/15/17 08:51 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
I will end the round tomorrow night around this time (9:50 PM Central) in order to give time for IB to vote if he so chooses.


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 8)
Emily Sivana #938920 10/16/17 05:47 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Thanks Emily! Sorry for holding up the game. Just got back from a busy conference in Boston.

Amazo 50
Amos Fortune 5
Chronos 5
Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 50
Demons Three 50
Despero 5
Doctor Destiny 5
Felix Faust 5
Floronic Man 5
Giganta 50
Key 5
Manhunters 5
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 5
Professor Ivo 5
Queen Bee 50
Royal Flush Gang 50
Shaggy Man 5
Starro 50
T.O. Morrow 5
Tattooed Man 5

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 9)
Emily Sivana #938984 10/17/17 04:56 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
We have finished Round 9! The winner of this round is Starro again. We will be starting the Wild Card Round shortly. I have to dig up the rules from the last Idol because I don't remember what the established procedure was. In the meantime, please feel free to discuss the results. It may also be a good idea to start thinking of picks for the Wild Card Round.

Starro 290 100%
Queen Bee 260 90%
Doctor Destiny 250 86%
T.O. Morrow 250 86%

Crime Syndicate (Earth 3) 240 83%
Royal Flush Gang 235 81%
Giganta 225 78%

Shaggy Man 215 74%
Despero 210 72%
Felix Faust 210 72%
Professor Ivo 210 72%
Amazo 200 70%
Key 200 70%

Floronic Man 185 64%
Manhunters 160 55%

Eliminated This Round
Amos Fortune 135 47%
Tattooed Man 135 47%
Mark Shaw (Manhunter/Privateer/Star-Tsar) 130 45%
Demons Three 125 43%
Chronos 120 41%


Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 9)
Emily Sivana #938985 10/17/17 05:17 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Unseen, not unheard
Offline
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 83,192
Will Starro coast to the end? Or will a challenger rise up???

Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 9)
Emily Sivana #938987 10/17/17 05:51 PM
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
Tempus Fugitive
Offline
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,394
I tried telling him it was a promotional typo for the Idol contest. But he took "One villain will become a big starro" as a sign...

Mark Shaw was more anti hero than villain, so he probably got quite far considering. Chronos and the Tattooed Man were villains of single heroes more than just league heroes. Amos Fortune could be a little abstract - Luck Glands? I liked the Demons Three more after I'd read some horror novels, but they initially didn't do much for me. Giganta is the surprise for me to be still on the list. I've not read any of those.


"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 9)
Emily Sivana #939043 10/18/17 06:42 PM
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
OP Offline
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
The Wild Card Round Starts Now.

Rules for this Round

1) Please Choose One Character (See Page 1 for help) that has already been eliminated from the game.
2) One Character not included in the game
3) Write it in a Post; Check all posts above you to make sure your suggestion was not previously taken
4) I will create a list of all the suggestions and we vote for one character to re-enter the game.

My vote goes to Star Sapphire III due to her brilliant performance during the Identity Crisis era.

Last edited by Emily Sivana; 10/19/17 04:52 PM. Reason: tense changes

Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
Re: Legion of Doom Idol (Round 9)
Emily Sivana #939052 10/19/17 01:54 AM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
Offline
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Just checking Emily:

The rules sort of make it sound like we pick two characters (one who was eliminated [1] and one who was not included in the game [2]) but you've only picked one character. Am I misreading the rules?

Page 1 of 12 1 2 3 11 12

Link Copied to Clipboard
ShoutChat
Forum Statistics
Forums14
Topics21,012
Posts1,044,277
Legionnaires1,729
Most Online53,886
Jan 7th, 2024
Newest Legionnaires
Mimi, max kord, Duke, CBSutherland2000, Arumidden
1,729 Registered Legionnaires
Today's Birthdays
Joe Kalicki
Random Holo-Vids
Who's Who in the LMBP
Posts: 312
Joined: July 2003
ShanghallaLegion of Super-Heroes & all related proper names & images are ™ & © material of DC Comics, Inc. & are used herein without its permission.
This site is intended solely to celebrate & publicize these characters & their creators.
No commercial benefit, nor any use beyond the “fair use” review & commentary provisions of United States copyright law, is either intended or implied.
Posts made on this message board must not be reproduced without the author's consent.
The Legion World Star
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5