Legion World Forums LEGION COMPANION Spaceopoly ULTIMATE LSH Survivor! LSH COSTUME Survivor game!

I'm too confused to shift gears. To be eliminated:

Chemical King (Adventure-era)
Chemical King (Cockrum re-design)
Dream Girl (Adventure-era)
Gates (Lee Moder)
Princess Projectra (Adventure-era)
Saturn Girl (Adventure-era)
Supergirl (Adventure-era)
Timber Wolf (Giffen, post-Great Darkness)
Triplicate Girl (Adventure-era)
Wildfire (Giffen slight re-design)

You can tell I'm not too attached to the Adventure era

How many costumes are going out or coming in? Are you ranking the alternatives in either direction as to their number of votes?

If you're keeping / dropping the top ten in both directions, I have to wonder if this isn't needlessly prolonging it all, really.

10 costumes going out, 10 going in. The 10 going out will rank according to vote, and then ties will be broken by cumulative previous voting. The 10 coming in will rank according to vote, and then ties will be broken first by the order in which they left the game in previous rounds, and then by total cumulative votes, if necessary. Basically, I'm doing exactly what you suggested in your last sentence.

This is a one-round thing. I wanted to give everyone one last chance to see any old favorites again and try to bring them back as we enter the top 50. And I figured that doing a 10-in, 10-out thing (once again, this round only) would shake things up a bit and just make this round a bit different. It's just a twist. It's entirely possible that everyone who comes back may just be eliminated again in the next round. Or, maybe not.

I agree that essentially I am prolonging the game by one round, but I do promise that this game is going to fly in the last rounds, probably faster than some will like. We're going to keep on eliminating in fairly large blocks all the way to the top 5.

For elimination -
Gates (Lee Moder)
Phantom Girl (Barry Kitson (current series))
Cosmic Boy (Legionnaires(Sprouse))
M’Onel (Jeff Moy)
Invisible Kid (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Saturn Girl (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Star Boy (Post-Zero Hour (Sprouse-style))
Ultra Boy (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Andromeda (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Live Wire (Legionnaires (Sprouse))

I LOVE the Adventure-Era (You thought I'd say Cockrum, huh)! The Original is always the best, IMHO.

So, please bring back -

Chameleon Boy (Adventure-era)
Colossal Boy (Adventure-era)
Cosmic Boy (Adventure-era)
Element Lad (Adventure-era)
Ferro Lad (Adventure-era)
Invisible Kid (Adventure-era)
Matter-Eater-Lad (Adventure-era)
Phantom Girl (Adventure-era)
Star Boy (Adventure-era)
Timber Wolf (Adventure-era)

Now it starts getting a little painful: almost all of the costumes I actually dislike have already been voted off, so it's time to separate the merely good from the great.

Voting Off:

Andromeda (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Cosmic Boy (Barry Kitson (current series))
Dreamer (Olivier Coipel)
Karate Kid (Cockrum)
Light Lass (Cockrum)
Phantom Girl (Barry Kitson (current series))
Saturn Girl (Giffen (Red-and-white jumpsuit))
Star Boy (Post-Zero Hour (Sprouse-style))
Supergirl (Adventure-era)
Ultra Boy (Pre-TMK (classic))

Nighty picked some good ones.

BRING BACK:

Chameleon Boy (Adventure-era)
Colossal Boy (Adventure-era)
Cosmic Boy (Adventure-era)
Element Lad (Adventure-era)
Ferro Lad (Adventure-era)
Invisible Kid (Adventure-era)
Matter-Eater-Lad (Adventure-era)
Phantom Girl (Adventure-era)
Star Boy (Adventure-era)
Timber Wolf (Adventure-era)

OOO. Voting blok!

2 days remaining, for all of the rest of you who've been waiting this round to see how things are shaping up.

My votes:

For elimination:

Dream Girl (Adventure)
Karate Kid (Post-Zero Hour (Moder))
Karate Kid (Kitson)
Kinetix (Green costume (Moy))
M'Onel (Moy)
Quislet (Lightle)
Shadow Lass (Baxter seroes)
Shadow Lass (Kitson)
Timber Wolf (Giffen, post Great Darkness)
Wildfire (Giffen slight redesign)

Bring back:

1. Apparition Sprouse
2. Dawnstar Magic Wars
3. Kid Quantum Jazmin
4. Princess Projectra Kitson
5. Sensor Girl Lightle
6. Sensor Girl Magic Wars
7. Violet Giffen (Yera)
8. Sun Boy Kitson
9. Triad Coipel
10. Umbra Lightle

Bring back:

Brainiac 5 (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Cosmic Boy (Legionnaires(Sprouse))
Dragonmage (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Dreamer (Olivier Coipel)
Star Boy (Legionnaires (Sprouse-style))
Superboy (Conner Kent, black T-shirt, jeans)
Thunder (Jeff Moy)
Triad (Olivier Coipel)
Wildfire (Olivier Coipel)
XS (Jeff Moy)

One day until the round closes!

To Go:

Cosmic Boy (Barry Kitson (current series))
Dream Girl (Barry Kitson (current series))
Karate Kid (Barry Kitson (current series))
Kinetix (Green costume) (Jeff Moy))
Light Lass (Barry Kitson (current series))
Lightning Lad (Barry Kitson (current series))
Phantom Girl (Barry Kitson (current series))
Shadow Lass (Barry Kitson (current series))
Star Boy (Post-Zero Hour (Sprouse-style))
Timber Wolf (Giffen, post-Great Darkness)

bring back:

#1 - Colossal Boy (Adventure - the one with red,green and yellow...
#2 - Cosmic Boy (grell - black swimsuit *grin* Sorry can't help it.)
#3 - Thunder (moy)
#4 - Dragonmage (Sprouse)
#5 - Dawnstar - Magic Era Giffen
#6 - Ferro Lad (Sprouse)
#7 - Kid Quantum - Oliver's
#8 - Princess Projectra - Kitson
#9 - Violet - 5year gap - white/black costume
#10 - Superboy (black/blue jeans)

Many of my favorite costumes come from the Legionnaires/post-ZH era, so it was tempting to bring many of them back. (And stop some of the Adventure era costumes I dislike more from coming back ) But I'd rather save some of my remaining faves from being eliminated instead, so...


Cosmic Boy (Kitson)
Live Wire (Sprouse)
Lightning Lad (Kitson)
Shadow Lass (Cockrum)
Princess Projectra (Cockrum)
Wildfire (Giffen redesign)
Princess Projectra (Adventure)
Karate Kid (Kitson)
Shadow Lass (Kitson)
Saturn Girl (Giffen red and white)

for elimination:

Andromeda (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Dream Girl (Adventure)
Karate Kid (Post-Zero Hour (Moder))
Karate Kid (Kitson)
Live Wire (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Shadow Lass (Cockrum)
Shadow Lass (Baxter seroes)
Saturn Girl (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Timber Wolf (Giffen, post Great Darkness)
Wildfire (Giffen slight redesign)

eliminate:

Andromeda (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Chemical King (Adventure-era)
Dream Girl (Adventure-era)
Dreamer (Olivier Coipel)
Princess Projectra (Adventure-era)
Princess Projectra (Cockrum)
Quislet (Steve Lightle)
Saturn Girl (Giffen (Red-and-white jumpsuit))
Supergirl (Adventure-era)
Supergirl (Great Darkness)

(Just call me last second lad...)

For elimination:
Cosmic Boy (80's Miniseries (Purple))
Dream Girl (Adventure-era)
Element Lad (Cockrum (Green, arrow))
Karate Kid (Cockrum)
Kinetix (Green costume) (Jeff Moy))
Light Lass (Cockrum)
Princess Projectra (Adventure-era)
Shadow Lass (Cockrum)
Superboy (Classic costume)
Supergirl (Adventure-era)

Cali: You have to vote for one or the other, either elimination or return, but not both. I'm actually working on the results now, but I'll hold off on posting them until you say which you want to go with.

Thanks!!!

Sorry, KP! I misread. ><

Personally, I blame finals. Should be all fixed now...

Kippers, since you haven't posted the results yet, I hope you don't mind if I change my votes from Dream Girl and Supergirl (both Adventure) to Sprouse Live Wire and Projectra Adventure.

Alright, I have all the results in. I'm going to have to ask for no more vote changes or entries, because this round is REALLY complex. I have to go out for Father's Day lunch now, but I'll be back with this rounds' results later this afternoon!

This round begins with Dream Girl (Adventure) leaving the game with 5 votes.

Next to leave, all tied with 4 votes, are Andromeda (Legionnaires (Sprouse)), Karate Kid (Kitson - current costume), Princess Projectra (Adventure), Timber Wolf (Giffen (Post-Great Darkness)), Wildfire (Slight Giffen re-design), and Supergirl (Adventure.)

Lots were tied with 3 votes, but voting in previous rounds determined that Live Wire (Legionnaires (Sprouse)), Phantom Girl (Kitson (Current costume)), and Saturn Girl (Giffen (Red-and-white jumpsuit)) be the ones to leave. I don't think I've ever run a Survivor game before where voting in previous rounds played such a huge part of the game!

And now for the second part of the round. There were a HUGE number of costumes all tied with the same number of votes for bringing back, but whittling the numbers down by time of previous elimination gave us these 10 to be brought back into the game:

Colossal Boy (Adventure)
Princess Projectra (Kitson (Current costume))
Chameleon Boy (Adventure)
Invisible Kid (Adventure)
Thunder (Moy)
Triad (Olivier Coipel)
Element Lad (Adventure)
Cosmic Boy (Adventure)
Ferro Lad (Adventure)
Dragonmage (Legionnaires (Sprouse))

So, here is the new TOP 50 LSH Costume Survivor list:

Chameleon Boy (Adventure)

Chemical King (Adventure-era)
Chemical King (Cockrum re-design)

Colossal Boy (Adventure)

Cosmic Boy (Adventure)
Cosmic Boy (80\'s Miniseries (Perez))
Cosmic Boy (Barry Kitson (current series))

Dawnstar (Classic) - IMMUNE until top 25

Dragonmage (Legionnaires (Sprouse))

Dream Girl (Barry Kitson (current series))
Dreamer (Olivier Coipel)

Element Lad (Adventure)
Element Lad (Cockrum (Green, arrow))

Ferro Lad (Adventure)

Gates (Lee Moder)

Invisible Kid (Adventure)
Invisible Kid (Legionnaires (Sprouse))

Karate Kid (Cockrum)
Karate Kid (Post-Zero Hour (Moder))

Kinetix (Green costume) (Jeff Moy))

Light Lass (Cockrum)
Light Lass (Barry Kitson (current series))

Lightning Lad (Cockrum (Classic))
Lightning Lad (Barry Kitson (current series))

M’Onel (Jeff Moy)
Mon-El (Pre-TMK (classic))

Phantom Girl (Cockrum)

Princess Projectra (Kitson (Current costume)
Princess Projectra (Cockrum)

Quislet (Steve Lightle)

Saturn Girl (Adventure-era)
Saturn Girl (Legionnaires (Sprouse))

Shadow Lass (Cockrum)
Shadow Lass (Baxter series)
Shadow Lass (Barry Kitson (current series))

Shrinking Violet (Cockrum (Green))

Star Boy (Cockrum)
Star Boy (Barry Kitson (current series))
Star Boy (Post-Zero Hour (Sprouse-style))

Sun Boy (Pre-TMK (classic))

Supergirl (Great Darkness)

Thunder (Moy)

Timber Wolf (Cockrum)
Timber Wolf (Lightle)

Triad (Olivier Coipel)
Triplicate Girl (Adventure-era)

Ultra Boy (Pre-TMK (classic))
Ultra Boy (Legionnaires (Sprouse))

White Witch (Giffen) - IMMUNE until top 25

Wildfire (Cockrum)


Rules for the next round: Once again, please vote for the 10 costumes you would most like to see leave the game this round.

Minigame: There are going to be two more immunity minigames for this Survivor game. This is the first of those two. Please vote for 3 costumes you would like to see given top 25 immunity. The top 3 votegetter costumes will join Dawnstar and White Witch in their immunity all the way to the top 25!

As always, any ties will be resolved by votes recieved from previous rounds. This round will end this Wednesday. Thanks so much for playing, gang!

Ultra Boy (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Saturn Girl (Legionnaires (Sprouse))
Karate Kid (Post-Zero Hour (Moder))
Shadow Lass (Cockrum)
Umbra (Post-Zero Hour (Lightle redesign))
Shadow Lass (Baxter)
Timber Wolf (Cockrum)
Timber Wolf (Lightle)
Triad (Olivier Coipel)
Dragonmage (Legionnaires (Sprouse))

Immunity: Colossal Boy (Adventure); Triplicate Girl (Adventure); Phantom Girl (Cockrum)

Oops! I made an error, the votes for Superboy were for Kon-El's blue jeans look, but that costume wes eliminated way early in the competition, so the actual winner was Thunder (Moy). I made the necessary changes in the post. Sorry about that!