The consensus on the DC board seemed to be that Phil was too verbose - and he did seem to use 5 speech bubbles when one would do.
The only other main complaint I seem to remember was his so-called "gay aesthetic" which had Circe doing 12 costume changes in the space of a fight, re-made Phillipus in the image of transsexual Eurovision winner Dana International and brought back "the twirl." All of which I thought was fine!
Phil did some great stuff - Silver Swan, Cheetah, Villainy Inc. I like some of Rucka's stuff so far - but again you can read the issues in 2 minutes - what was that tsunami all about? 4 pages of nothing but Diana shouting at it for cripe's sake!