Legion World Forums LEGION COMPANION Spaceopoly Bat-Villain Idol

^ Spoiler for a 20 year old comic...

It's been a while but that was my understanding too. I didn't remember there being an actual Calendar Man in that book, just the Holiday killer.

Soon to be reimagined as Calendar Man's psychotic, hammer wielding side kick Holly Day.

I hear Holly and Harley are set to get their own series in 2016!

Along with their friends, the indestructible Sally Forth and the Durlan assassin Polly Morph.

Here are the results of the last round:

Sterling Silversmith 7
Black Mask 6
Catman (Pre-New 52) 6
Catwoman (Golden Age) 6
Catwoman (Silver Age) 6
Crime Doctor 6
Dr. Phosphorous 6
Joe Chill 6
Man-Bat 6
Poison Ivy (Silver Age) 6
Talia Al Ghul 6
Tweedledee 6
Tweedledum (Dumfree) 6
Anarky 6
Black Spider 5
Cavalier 5
Clayface II (Hagen) (Silver Age) 5
Cluemaster 5
Copperhead 5
Crazy Quilt 5
Deadshot 5
Electrocutioner I 5
Firefly 5
Harley Quinn 5
Hugo Strange 5
Killer Croc (Bronze Age) 5
Killer Moth 5
Mad-Hatter 5
Magpie 5
Maxie Zeus 5
Mister Freeze (Silver Age) 5
Nocturna 5
Riddler (Silver Age) 5
Scarecrow 5
Shark (Terrible Trio) 5
Signalman 5
Spellbinder I 5
Two-Face (Golden Age) 5
Ubu 5
Ventriloquist I (Arnold) 5
Wrath 5
Bane 4
Blockbuster I 4
Calendar Man (Silver Age) 4
Captain Stingaree 4
Catman (Silver Age) 4
Clayface I (Karlo) (Golden Age) 4
Clayface I (Karlo) (Modern Age) 4
Clayface III (Payne) (Bronze Age) 4
Dr. Death 4
Dr. Double X 4
Dr. Tzin-Tzin 4
Fox (Terrible Trio) 4
KGBeast 4
King Snake 4
Mr. Zsasz 4
Nightslayer 4
Professor Pyg 4
Ra's Al-Ghul 4
Ratcatcher 4
Red Hood (Silver Age) 4
Spellbinder II 4
Spook 4
The Penguin (Silver Age) 4
Tweedledum II (Dumpson) 4
Two-Face (Modern Age) 4
Vulture (Terrible Trio) 4
Catwoman (Modern Age) 3
Clayface IV (Fuller) (Modern Age) 3
Film Freak 3
Holiday 3
Joker (Silver Age) 3
Killer Croc (Modern Age) 3
Kite-Man 3
Mister Freeze (Bronze Age) 3
Mister Freeze (Modern Age) 3
Monk 3
NKVDemon 3
Outsider 3
Penguin (Modern Age) 3
Poison Ivy (Modern Age) 3
Polka-Dot Man 3
Queen of Hearts 3
Reaper 3
Red Hood (Modern Age) 3
Riddler (Modern Age) 3
Tony Zucco 3
Werewolf 3
Blockbuster II 2
Calendar Man (Modern Age) 2
Carmine Falcone 2
Charaxes 2
Dr. Hurt 2
Electrocutioner II 2
Electrocutioner III 2
Eraser 2
Firebug 2
Lord Death Man 2
Orca 2
Professor Milo 2
Sal Maroni 2
Ten-Eyed Man 2
Ventriloquist II (Peyton) 2
Condiment King 1
Henri Ducard 1
Hush 1
Joker (Modern Age) 1
Mad-Hatter(Imposter) 1
Quakemaster 1
Rupert Thorne 1
Trigger Twins 1
Prometheus 0
Tally Man II 0

In order to not have another 1 or 0 round, I am going to eliminate all the candidates that got less than 3 points this round. I am going to start the next round in 24 hours. Please submit any last minute candidates before the next round starts. I can add names later, but it becomes more difficult as the pool gets smaller.

I suggest we hold off on adding villains to the list once we begin the ranking rounds. Adding villains too late may give them a big edge over those who have been part of the list since the first round

Obviously there have been a tonne of Bat-villains over the years, but I don't see any glaring omissions from the "main" rogues gallery. I'd humbly submit there isn't a need to add anyone else at this stage.

Wow! ten Eyed Man going, just when he's starring in Lash's Fondled or Murdered thread!

As of this round, we will be ranking characters from 1-10. A rank of 1 equals 10 points and 10 equals 1 point.

Anarky
Bane
Black Mask
Black Spider
Blockbuster I
Calendar Man (Silver Age)
Captain Stingaree
Catman (Pre-New 52)
Catman (Silver Age)
Catwoman (Golden Age)
Catwoman (Modern Age)
Catwoman (Silver Age)
Cavalier
Clayface I (Karlo) (Golden Age)
Clayface I (Karlo) (Modern Age)
Clayface II (Hagen) (Silver Age)
Clayface III (Payne) (Bronze Age)
Clayface IV (Fuller) (Modern Age)
Cluemaster
Copperhead
Crazy Quilt
Crime Doctor
Deadshot
Dr. Death
Dr. Double X
Dr. Phosphorous
Dr. Tzin-Tzin
Electrocutioner I
Film Freak
Firefly
Fox (Terrible Trio)
Harley Quinn
Holiday
Hugo Strange
Joe Chill
Joker (Silver Age)
KGBeast
Killer Croc (Bronze Age)
Killer Croc (Modern Age)
Killer Moth
King Snake
Kite-Man
Mad-Hatter
Magpie
Man-Bat
Maxie Zeus
Mister Freeze (Bronze Age)
Mister Freeze (Modern Age)
Mister Freeze (Silver Age)
Monk
Mr. Zsasz
Nightslayer
NKVDemon
Nocturna
Outsider
Penguin (Modern Age)
Penguin (Silver Age)
Poison Ivy (Modern Age)
Poison Ivy (Silver Age)
Polka-Dot Man
Professor Pyg
Queen of Hearts
Ra's Al-Ghul
Ratcatcher
Reaper
Red Hood (Modern Age)
Red Hood (Silver Age)
Riddler (Modern Age)
Riddler (Silver Age)
Scarecrow
Shark (Terrible Trio)
Signalman
Spellbinder I
Spellbinder II
Spook
Sterling Silversmith
Talia Al Ghul
Tony Zucco
Tweedledee
Tweedledum (Dumfree)
Tweedledum II (Dumpson)
Two-Face (Golden Age)
Two-Face (Modern Age)
Ubu
Ventriloquist I (Arnold)
Vulture (Terrible Trio)
Werewolf
Wrath

Anarky 6
Bane 1
Black Mask 7
Black Spider 8
Blockbuster I 4
Calendar Man (Silver Age) 8
Captain Stingaree 10
Catman (Pre-New 52) 1
Catman (Silver Age) 8
Catwoman (Golden Age) 1
Catwoman (Modern Age) 1
Catwoman (Silver Age) 4
Cavalier- 9
Clayface I (Karlo) (Golden Age)- 7
Clayface I (Karlo) (Modern Age)- 1
Clayface II (Hagen) (Silver Age)- 3
Clayface III (Payne) (Bronze Age)- 8
Clayface IV (Fuller) (Modern Age)- 9
Cluemaster 9
Copperhead 8
Crazy Quilt 9
Crime Doctor 2
Deadshot 1
Dr. Death 5
Dr. Double X 10
Dr. Phosphorous 4
Dr. Tzin-Tzin 6
Electrocutioner I 4
Film Freak 4
Firefly 4
Fox (Terrible Trio) 0
Harley Quinn 1
Holiday 3
Hugo Strange 4
Joe Chill 5
Joker (Silver Age) 1
KGBeast 8
Killer Croc (Bronze Age)
Killer Croc (Modern Age) 4
Killer Moth 7
King Snake 10
Kite-Man 6
Mad-Hatter 2
Magpie 7
Man-Bat 5
Maxie Zeus 9
Mister Freeze (Bronze Age) 5
Mister Freeze (Modern Age) 3
Mister Freeze (Silver Age) 8
Monk 1
Mr. Zsasz 8
Nightslayer 10
NKVDemon 10
Nocturna 6
Outsider 3
Penguin (Modern Age)
Penguin (Silver Age) 5
Poison Ivy (Modern Age) 1
Poison Ivy (Silver Age) 5
Polka-Dot Man 4
Professor Pyg 10
Queen of Hearts 10
Ra's Al-Ghul 1
Ratcatcher 8
Reaper 0
Red Hood (Modern Age) 6
Red Hood (Silver Age) 3
Riddler (Modern Age) 1
Riddler (Silver Age) 1
Scarecrow 1
Shark (Terrible Trio) 10
Signalman 10
Spellbinder I 1
Spellbinder II 3
Spook 10
Sterling Silversmith 10
Talia Al Ghul 1
Tony Zucco 4
Tweedledee 1
Tweedledum (Dumfree) 1
Tweedledum II (Dumpson) 9
Two-Face (Golden Age) 1
Two-Face (Modern Age) 3
Ubu 5
Ventriloquist I (Arnold) 5
Vulture (Terrible Trio) 10
Werewolf 10
Wrath 10

I regret not voting more for the Modern version of Joker.

Oh this is an interesting twist on the rules!



Having trouble voting using my phone so will be back when I can get to a laptop

Anarky 3
Bane 5
Black Mask 5
Black Spider 4
Blockbuster I 3
Calendar Man (Silver Age) 9
Captain Stingaree 10
Catman (Pre-New 52) 5
Catman (Silver Age) 4
Catwoman (Golden Age) 4
Catwoman (Modern Age) 6
Catwoman (Silver Age) 2
Cavalier 10
Clayface I (Karlo) (Golden Age) 4
Clayface I (Karlo) (Modern Age) 5
Clayface II (Hagen) (Silver Age) 2
Clayface III (Payne) (Bronze Age) 1
Clayface IV (Fuller) (Modern Age) 6
Cluemaster 6
Copperhead 3
Crazy Quilt 7
Crime Doctor 4
Deadshot 1
Dr. Death 10
Dr. Double X 9
Dr. Phosphorous 5
Dr. Tzin-Tzin 5
Electrocutioner I 5
Film Freak 6
Firefly 6
Fox (Terrible Trio) 10
Harley Quinn 3
Holiday 5
Hugo Strange 3
Joe Chill 3
Joker (Silver Age) 2
KGBeast 4
Killer Croc (Bronze Age) 1
Killer Croc (Modern Age) 4
Killer Moth 4
King Snake 4
Kite-Man 6
Mad-Hatter 3
Magpie 4
Man-Bat 1
Maxie Zeus 4
Mister Freeze (Bronze Age) 3
Mister Freeze (Modern Age) 3
Mister Freeze (Silver Age) 3
Monk 5
Mr. Zsasz 7
Nightslayer 6
NKVDemon 10
Nocturna 4
Outsider 4
Penguin (Modern Age) 4
Penguin (Silver Age) 3
Poison Ivy (Modern Age) 6
Poison Ivy (Silver Age) 3
Polka-Dot Man 10
Professor Pyg 2
Queen of Hearts 4
Ra's Al-Ghul 1
Ratcatcher 5
Reaper 4
Red Hood (Modern Age) 10
Red Hood (Silver Age) 7
Riddler (Modern Age) 6
Riddler (Silver Age) 3
Scarecrow 2
Shark (Terrible Trio) 10
Signalman 10
Spellbinder I 10
Spellbinder II 10
Spook 4
Sterling Silversmith 3
Talia Al Ghul 2
Tony Zucco 5
Tweedledee 3
Tweedledum (Dumfree) 3
Tweedledum II (Dumpson) 8
Two-Face (Golden Age) 6
Two-Face (Modern Age) 2
Ubu 4
Ventriloquist I (Arnold) 3
Vulture (Terrible Trio) 10
Werewolf 10
Wrath 4

Anarky -10
Bane -10
Black Mask -3
Black Spider -4
Blockbuster I -4
Calendar Man (Silver Age) -4
Captain Stingaree -9
Catman (Pre-New 52) -5
Catman (Silver Age) -5
Catwoman (Golden Age) -3
Catwoman (Modern Age) -9
Catwoman (Silver Age) -3
Cavalier -4
Clayface I (Karlo) (Golden Age) -3
Clayface I (Karlo) (Modern Age) -10
Clayface II (Hagen) (Silver Age) -3
Clayface III (Payne) (Bronze Age) -10
Clayface IV (Fuller) (Modern Age) -10
Cluemaster -4
Copperhead -4
Crazy Quilt -5
Crime Doctor -5
Deadshot -3
Dr. Death -5
Dr. Double X -4
Dr. Phosphorous –3
Dr. Tzin-Tzin -5
Electrocutioner I -4
Film Freak -8
Firefly -8
Fox (Terrible Trio) -5
Harley Quinn -9
Holiday -10
Hugo Strange -3
Joe Chill - 5
Joker (Silver Age) -3
KGBeast -5
Killer Croc (Bronze Age) -3
Killer Croc (Modern Age) -10
Killer Moth -4
King Snake -9
Kite-Man -5
Mad-Hatter -3
Magpie -6
Man-Bat - 3
Maxie Zeus -3
Mister Freeze (Bronze Age) -4
Mister Freeze (Modern Age) -10
Mister Freeze (Silver Age) -4
Monk -8
Mr. Zsasz -5
Nightslayer -4
NKVDemon -8
Nocturna -4
Outsider -3
Penguin (Modern Age) -10
Penguin (Silver Age) -3
Poison Ivy (Modern Age) -10
Poison Ivy (Silver Age) -3
Polka-Dot Man -9
Professor Pyg -7
Queen of Hearts -10
Ra's Al-Ghul -3
Ratcatcher -5
Reaper -8
Red Hood (Modern Age) -10
Red Hood (Silver Age) - 4
Riddler (Modern Age) -10
Riddler (Silver Age) -4
Scarecrow -3
Shark (Terrible Trio) -5
Signalman -4
Spellbinder I -5
Spellbinder II -10
Spook -5
Sterling Silversmith -5
Talia Al Ghul -4
Tony Zucco -5
Tweedledee -3
Tweedledum (Dumfree) -3
Tweedledum II (Dumpson) -10
Two-Face (Golden Age) -3
Two-Face (Modern Age) -10
Ubu -10
Ventriloquist I (Arnold) -3
Vulture (Terrible Trio) -5
Werewolf -4
Wrath - 3

Wow it's a trip to see who makes it through!

Anarky 3
Bane 5
Black Mask 2
Black Spider 3
Blockbuster I 7
Calendar Man (Silver Age) 6
Captain Stingaree 8
Catman (Pre-New 52) 2
Catman (Silver Age) 9
Catwoman (Golden Age) 3
Catwoman (Modern Age) 4
Catwoman (Silver Age) 1
Cavalier 5
Clayface I (Karlo) (Golden Age) 4
Clayface I (Karlo) (Modern Age) 8
Clayface II (Hagen) (Silver Age) 3
Clayface III (Payne) (Bronze Age) 7
Clayface IV (Fuller) (Modern Age) 9
Cluemaster 8
Copperhead 4
Crazy Quilt 6
Crime Doctor 3
Deadshot 1
Dr. Death 6
Dr. Double X 7
Dr. Phosphorous 8
Dr. Tzin-Tzin 9
Electrocutioner I 8
Film Freak 10
Firefly 5
Fox (Terrible Trio) 7
Harley Quinn 1
Holiday 5
Hugo Strange 3
Joe Chill 4
Joker (Silver Age) 1
KGBeast 4
Killer Croc (Bronze Age) 7
Killer Croc (Modern Age) 5
Killer Moth 3
King Snake 4
Kite-Man 3
Mad-Hatter 2
Magpie 5
Man-Bat 3
Maxie Zeus 4
Mister Freeze (Bronze Age) 3
Mister Freeze (Modern Age) 6
Mister Freeze (Silver Age) 2
Monk 7
Mr. Zsasz 6
Nightslayer 9
NKVDemon 8
Nocturna 7
Outsider 6
Penguin (Modern Age) 6
Penguin (Silver Age) 4
Poison Ivy (Modern Age) 3
Poison Ivy (Silver Age) 2
Polka-Dot Man 7
Professor Pyg 1
Queen of Hearts 10
Ra's Al-Ghul 1
Ratcatcher 7
Reaper 1
Red Hood (Modern Age) 2
Red Hood (Silver Age) 5
Riddler (Modern Age) 3
Riddler (Silver Age) 2
Scarecrow 3
Shark (Terrible Trio) 8
Signalman 5
Spellbinder I 4
Spellbinder II 7
Spook 8
Sterling Silversmith 7
Talia Al Ghul 1
Tony Zucco 6
Tweedledee 9
Tweedledum (Dumfree) 10
Tweedledum II (Dumpson) 10
Two-Face (Golden Age) 4
Two-Face (Modern Age) 2
Ubu 6
Ventriloquist I (Arnold) 3
Vulture (Terrible Trio) 9
Werewolf 10
Wrath 3

Hi Emily. I'm a bit confused about the scoring system (beyond the 1 = 10, 10 = 1 thing haha).

You mentioned that we're to give each character a score between 1 and 10, but you've given several characters a score of 0. Are those scores meant to be 10 or is 0 also an option?

I was thinking also that if this is not a forced ranking thing with a finite list (ie pick only 25 out of the available characters) we can reverse scoring such that a 10 is worth 10 points. But that might get confusing if we do shift to finite forced ranking

I had a second where I was going to put in 0s for the ones I didn't vote for last time, but I recalled the 1-10 range.

Happy with the way it for this round, rather than reversing the scores. Who knows what Emily has planned for the next rounds?

There's probably not much difference between a rank of 10 and a rank of 0 (points-wise) anyway, so I'm just going to go ahead and vote.

Anarky 4
Bane 10
Black Mask 4
Black Spider 1
Blockbuster I 1
Calendar Man (Silver Age) 1
Captain Stingaree 1
Catman (Pre-New 52) 10
Catman (Silver Age) 1
Catwoman (Golden Age) 10
Catwoman (Modern Age) 10
Catwoman (Silver Age) 10
Cavalier 1
Clayface I (Karlo) (Golden Age) 10
Clayface I (Karlo) (Modern Age) 10
Clayface II (Hagen) (Silver Age) 4
Clayface III (Payne) (Bronze Age) 4
Clayface IV (Fuller) (Modern Age) 10
Cluemaster 1
Copperhead 4
Crazy Quilt 1
Crime Doctor 4
Deadshot 10
Dr. Death 4
Dr. Double X 1
Dr. Phosphorous 1
Dr. Tzin-Tzin 1
Electrocutioner I 1
Film Freak 4
Firefly 1
Fox (Terrible Trio) 4
Harley Quinn 10
Holiday 10
Hugo Strange 10
Joe Chill 4
Joker (Silver Age) 10
KGBeast 1
Killer Croc (Bronze Age) 1
Killer Croc (Modern Age) 10
Killer Moth 1
King Snake 4
Kite-Man 1
Mad-Hatter 4
Magpie 1
Man-Bat 4
Maxie Zeus 1
Mister Freeze (Bronze Age) 10
Mister Freeze (Modern Age) 10
Mister Freeze (Silver Age) 10
Monk 1
Mr. Zsasz 4
Nightslayer 4
NKVDemon 1
Nocturna 1
Outsider 4
Penguin (Modern Age) 10
Penguin (Silver Age) 10
Poison Ivy (Modern Age) 10
Poison Ivy (Silver Age) 10
Polka-Dot Man 4
Professor Pyg 10
Queen of Hearts 1
Ra's Al-Ghul 10
Ratcatcher 1
Reaper 10
Red Hood (Modern Age) 10
Red Hood (Silver Age) 10
Riddler (Modern Age) 10
Riddler (Silver Age) 10
Scarecrow 4
Shark (Terrible Trio) 4
Signalman 1
Spellbinder I 1
Spellbinder II 10
Spook 1
Sterling Silversmith 1
Talia Al Ghul 10
Tony Zucco 4
Tweedledee 4
Tweedledum (Dumfree) 4
Tweedledum II (Dumpson) 4
Two-Face (Golden Age) 10
Two-Face (Modern Age) 10
Ubu 4
Ventriloquist I (Arnold) 1
Vulture (Terrible Trio) 4
Werewolf 1
Wrath 10

I don't understand the surprise, as I pretty-much copy and pasted IB's rules from the last Idol.

If you don't believe me, read this: http://www.legionworld.net/forums/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=859592&page=

I interpreted Rank 1 as most points, and Rank 10 being least points based on examples given in that post.

The 0s in my votes are just typos; I'll turn them into 1 pointers when I tally the votes.

As only 5 people have voted so far, I'm extending voting for 24 hours.

Anarky - 5
Bane - 5
Black Mask - 5
Black Spider - 3
Blockbuster I - 3
Calendar Man (Silver Age) - 1
Captain Stingaree - 1
Catman (Pre-New 52) - 5
Catman (Silver Age) - 1
Catwoman (Golden Age) - 1
Catwoman (Modern Age) - 7
Catwoman (Silver Age) - 1
Cavalier - 1
Clayface I (Karlo) (Golden Age) - 2
Clayface I (Karlo) (Modern Age) - 10
Clayface II (Hagen) (Silver Age) - 1
Clayface III (Payne) (Bronze Age) - 2
Clayface IV (Fuller) (Modern Age) - 10
Cluemaster - 5
Copperhead - 5
Crazy Quilt - 4
Crime Doctor - 4
Deadshot - 5
Dr. Death - 5
Dr. Double X - 3
Dr. Phosphorous - 3
Dr. Tzin-Tzin - 3
Electrocutioner I - 5
Film Freak - 7
Firefly - 3
Fox (Terrible Trio) - 1
Harley Quinn - 8
Holiday - 10
Hugo Strange - 5
Joe Chill - 7
Joker (Silver Age) - 1
KGBeast - 5
Killer Croc (Bronze Age) - 3
Killer Croc (Modern Age) - 8
Killer Moth - 5
King Snake - 9
Kite-Man - 1
Mad-Hatter - 1
Magpie - 7
Man-Bat - 2
Maxie Zeus - 2
Mister Freeze (Bronze Age) - 5
Mister Freeze (Modern Age) - 10
Mister Freeze (Silver Age) - 1
Monk - 1
Mr. Zsasz - 6
Nightslayer - 6
NKVDemon - 6
Nocturna - 6
Outsider - 5
Penguin (Modern Age) - 10
Penguin (Silver Age) - 1
Poison Ivy (Modern Age) - 9
Poison Ivy (Silver Age) - 1
Polka-Dot Man - 1
Professor Pyg - 10
Queen of Hearts - 10
Ra's Al-Ghul - 3
Ratcatcher - 5
Reaper - 5
Red Hood (Modern Age) - 10
Red Hood (Silver Age) - 3
Riddler (Modern Age) - 10
Riddler (Silver Age) - 1
Scarecrow - 1
Shark (Terrible Trio) - 1
Signalman - 1
Spellbinder I - 1
Spellbinder II - 3
Spook - 1
Sterling Silversmith - 4
Talia Al Ghul - 3
Tony Zucco - 10
Tweedledee - 2
Tweedledum (Dumfree) - 2
Tweedledum II (Dumpson) - 10
Two-Face (Golden Age) - 1
Two-Face (Modern Age) - 10
Ubu - 6
Ventriloquist I (Arnold) - 5
Vulture (Terrible Trio) - 1
Werewolf - 2
Wrath - 4

If past experience means anything, weekends are usually a rotten time to get people. I'd suggest extending rounds that end on weekends until the following Monday.

Request granted! I'll tally the votes on Monday. Hopefully, we get at least seven voters like last time.

Hi Emily, the reason for Rank 1 gettin most points etc. Is because in those rounds in my Idol games, the list is finite. That is, pick your Top 25 (out of 50 characters) and rank them in order, so that exactly one character gets 1 point, one gets 2 points, and so on. What has happened in this round in Bat Villain Idol is that we are ranking everyone remaining in the game, and not against each other. It is actually possible to give everyone 10 points in this round.

Hope this clarifies my rules.

I think your rules will give a similar effect except the voting will be a lot less predictable.

If you have any other questions on the rules, please feel free to ask Emily. All along I thought you made changes this round on purpose, which would have been fine as I always welcome twists and improvements in game mechanics. understanding the original rules will be very helpful for you in managing this game.